[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: [ANCP] ANCP Multicast Admission Control



Hi again Sven,

I support introduction of the text you propose below for section 3.4.2.1 (related to our earlier agreement on being able to do CAC on some flows and not on others).

Minor suggestions:
- could change title into something like "By-passing admission control for some flows" or "When not to perform admission control for a subset of flows". The idea being that the title makes it clear that we don't do CAC on some flows BUT still do CAC on others.
- s/"so that other streams are not impacted"/"so that other streams (that are subject to admission control) are not impacted"/


Thanks

Francois



3.4.2.1. When not to perform Admission Control

In general, the Access Node and NAS may not be aware of all possible
multicast groups that will be streamed in the access network. For
instance, it is likely that there will be multicast streams offered
across the Internet. For these unknown streams, performing bandwidth
admission control may be challenging.


   To solve this, these requests could be accepted without performing
   Admission Control.  This solution works, provided that the network
   handles the streams as best effort, so that other streams are not
   impacted at times of congestion.

Disabling Admission Control for unknown stream can be achieved by
adding a "catch-all statement" in the Access Node white list or grey
list. In case the Access Node queries the NAS, the NAS on his turn
will have to accept the request. That way, the unknown streams are
not blocked by default.


Next, in order to ensure that the streams are handled as best effort,
the flow must be marked as such when entering the service provider
network. This way, whenever congestion occurs somewhere in the
access/aggregation network, this stream will be kicked out before the
access provider's own premium content.


The above concept is applicable beyond the notion of "Internet
streams" or other unknown streams; it can applied to known multicast
streams as well. In this case, the Access Node or NAS will accept
the stream even when bandwidth may not be sufficient to support the
stream. This again requires that the stream is marked as best effort
traffic before entering the access/aggregation network.





_______________________________________________ ANCP mailing list ANCP at ietf.org https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ancp