|
Dear authors, Thanks for submitting your document on "Framework for GMPLS and
PCE Control of G.709 Optical Transport Networks". We have reviewed the document and we are a little bit concerned to find
out that some significant items described in the document are not aligned with
what is defined in G.709. Especially the mappings into ODU3e1 and ODU3e2 are
only defined in G.Sup43 which is not a standard. In addition G.Sup43 does not define mappings of
ODU0, ODU1, ODU2 and ODUflex into ODU3e2. The only mappings that are
defined in G.Sup43 are 4x ODU2e. We are afraid that this is not inline with the view of the majority of
participants in SG15/Q11. Except of the extensions that are already described in two draft
(draft-ceccarellifuxh-ccamp-gmpls-ext-for-evol-otn,
draft-zhang-ccamp-gmpls-evolving-g709), all other content of section 3, 4 is
copied from ITU standards. Would not it be better to just refer to the ITU-T
document? Best regards, Nurit
|