[dccp] DCCP design review in Vienna

[Aaron Falk <falk@isi.edu>]

Folks-

We are scheduled to hold a design review at the Vienna IETF.

This working group is following an agressive schedule of about 18
months, hoping to publish the spec this November.  The three
specification documents are fairly stable and we are near completion
of an expert review of the spec documents.  The purpose of holding a
design review at this time is to surface any remaining issues which
may reveal themselves to the larger IETF community.

To prepare for this there are two important things which should be
done:

  1. We should try to converge on the reviewer comments (& author
     responses) as much as possible to see which issues we can close
     quickly and which require further discussion in Vienna.

  2. Folks should make an effort to read the current version of the
     spec (a new rev will come out before the IETF).

Here's the draft agenda:

AGENDA

  10 min - intro, ground rules, charter review

  40 min - spec walkthrough

	   - questions only by reviewers
	   - focus on clarification and identification of issues, not
	     resolving  them

  10 min - summary of provocative/significant comments from written
	   reviews  

	   - intent is to frame open discussion -- reviews have
             already been posted to list (2 of 3 anyways, expecting
             the third this week)

  45 min -  open discussion

           - strong encouragement that significant issues/comments be
	     written up by commenter to list (in real time would be
	     good)

  10 min -  reviewer feedback

	   - want quick rundown from reviewers: What must be done
	     before spec can progress?  (followup with written note to
	     list)

  5  min - wrapup next steps

Many thanks & hope to see you there...

--aaron  (dccp wg chair)

[1] http://www.ietf.org/html.charters/dccp-charter.html

_______________________________________________
dccp IETF mailing list: dccp@ietf.org
list info:  https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dccp
wg charter: http://www.ietf.org/html.charters/dccp-charter.html