Re: [Enum] ENUM WG document status

[Bernie Hoeneisen <bernie at ietf.hoeneisen.ch>]

Hi Rich

Thanks for the summary. My comments/updates inline.

On Wed, 9 Sep 2009, Richard Shockey wrote:

> draft-ietf-enum-enumservices-guide
> ----------------------------------
>
> Current Status: Waiting for AD Go-Ahead
>
> Open issues: There's a problem with the IETF's Expert Review Process in 
> general, and the Enumservices draft is the document that brought those 
> problems up :-/

That is unfortunately true....:-(

> Bernie has agreed with IANA (Michelle) to add a bit to the text that
> closes the loophole in the process. He will submit a new version, and that
> will hopefully close that issue.
>
> ToDo: Wait for new revision (-17)

Update:
We could close all the open issues and published -17 three weeks ago. 
http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-enum-enumservices-guide-17


> draft-ietf-enum-calendar-service
> --------------------------------
>
> Current Status: RFC Editor (AUTH48)
>
> Open Issues: Unfortunately, this draft was submitted to the RFC Editor 
> before work on the Enumservices document was finished - the Enumservice 
> does not fit at all into the Scheme proposed there. There were several 
> discussions between RFC Editors, authors of the draft, and authors of 
> the Enumservices guide, without reaching the "perfect solution".
>
> ToDo: Find solution how to fit Enumservice into the scheme developed in
> Enumservice guide.

Update:
The issues have been closed and RFC 5333 is expected to be published 
within the next days.

cheers,
 Bernie