Re: Stupid NAT tricks and how to stop them.

[Keith Moore <moore at cs.utk.edu>]

> > NAT is a dead end.  If the Internet does not develop a way to obsolete 
> > NAT, the Internet will die.  It will gradually be replaced by networks 
> > that are more-or-less IP based but which only run a small number of 
> > applications, poorly, and expensively.
>
>
> ...or you will see an overlay network build on top of NAT+IPv4 that 
> abstracts the shortcomings away - aka what the peer to peer networks are 
> doing. End-to-end addressing...

the overlay networks depend on having some hosts that aren't behind a 
NAT to serve as tunnel endpoints for hosts that do.  this will become 
less viable in the future as IPv4 address space gets more and more scarce.

also, for the most part, overlay networks do not perform as well as 
native networks (there are exceptions, as in bittorrent).  so they do 
not abstract (all of) the shortcomings away.

OTOH, one transition path away from NATs might be to extend NATs so that 
they support creation of overlay networks.  such devices could also aid 
v4/v6 coexistence.

Keith

_______________________________________________
Ietf mailing list
Ietf at ietf.org
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf