[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

RE: Advancing the Protocol and Morin Drafts



> create 2 drafts, one documenting a PIM based solutions set, and an
> other based on BGP. Both moving forward on standards track. These

I agree.

> documents don't need to make comparisons between BGP and PIM (as is
> done in the Morin draft), because this creates endless discussions
> and don't get us anywhere. It just needs to document how the
> different modules work together so that vendors can be interoperable.
> Each customer can choose the preferred approach and talk to the
> vendor for an implementation.

I agree with this statement.
Comparing protocols is not productive, especially when comparing a
protocol which has a significant deployment with one that doesn't.