[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: [NSIS] I-D Action:draft-ietf-nsis-ext-02.txt

Roland Bless wrote:

Hi Xiaomin,

Xiaoming Fu wrote:

Just a quick comment: I would envision an update of the extensibility
document could consider potential use for off-path signaling, especially
in the GIST section.
Xiaoming


This should be already covered:
Section 8.2:

o  Use of different Message Routing Methods: currently only two
      message routing methods are supported (Path-coupled MRM and Loose-
      End MRM), but further MRMs may be defined in the future.  See
      Section 3.8.  One possible additional MRM under development is
      documented in [I-D.bless-nsis-est-mrm].

EST-MRM is effectively a path-decoupled MRM.
maybe worth making it clearer: firstly tell what does a path-decoupled MRM basically mean, then possibly an example... (comparison: while talking about path-coupled and loosely-coupled ones there is some text) 
Xiaoming


Section 8.3:

 Another current proposal
   seeks to extend the whole NSIS framework towards path-decoupled
   signaling and QoS reservations [I-D.cordeiro-nsis-hypath].

Or what is missing from your point of view?

Regards,
 Roland