Re: [rohc] New ROHC Milesstones.

["Ghyslain Pelletier" <ghyslain.pelletier at ericsson.com>]

Hello Carl,

Thanks for initiating the update of the ROHC WG charter.
This is indeed overdue.

I agree wrt the three "Done" items (RFC5225 and ROHCoIPSec).
I am fine with adding a milestone for the revised ROHC FW with Sep 2009
as target.
I agree wrt the proposal about removal items (encapsulation and nr
registration).

Further more, I propose to update the following, from:

Jun 2007 - Recharter of WG to develop additional profiles if needed, or
           possible additional compression schemes. Consideration of
           concluding the working group.
To:

Sep 2009 - Conclusion of the working group.

I believe that at this point, we can actually agree in-principle for
aiming at concluding the working group (pending AD feedback, of course).

///Ghyslain

-----Original Message-----
From: rohc-bounces at ietf.org [mailto:rohc-bounces at ietf.org] On Behalf Of
Carl Knutsson
Sent: den 10 september 2009 10:35
To: rohc at ietf.org
Subject: [rohc] New ROHC Milesstones.

rohcers,

It is time to update the milestones for the rohc wg. I should have done
this a long time ago. I have sent my suggestion to our AD, but I want to
make sure that it represent the consensus of the group and not just my
opinions. So I need your feedback here. Please send in your comments
about the new milestones.

Below follows my suggestion:

The item I want to mark as "Done" is:

Dec 2006 - Revised ROHC IP/UDP/RTP profiles submitted to IESG for
           publication as Proposed Standard

Mar 2007 - IKE/IPsec extensions for HC-session Parameter Negotiation
           submitted to IESG for publication as Proposed Standard

Mar 2007 - Header Compression over IPsec (HCoIPsec) submitted to IESG
           for publication as Informational

The first item resulted in RFC 5225, the second and the third items
forms the ROHCoIPSec framework and are all drafts):

draft-ietf-rohc-hcoipsec-11
draft-ietf-rohc-ikev2-extensions-hcoipsec-09
draft-ietf-rohc-ipsec-extensions-hcoipsec-05

All ROHCoIPSec have passed the AD evaluation and drafts are now in IETF
last-call.

I would like to add one item:

Sep 2009 - Revised ROHC framework submitted to IESG for publication as
           Proposed Standard

This is the new framework draft that is in WG last-call. It includes a
fix to the feedback format (to make piggybacked feedback possible) and
some editorial changes in the text.

I would like to remove two items.

Feb 2007 - ROHC encapsulation profile(s) for IPHC/CRTP/eCRTP submitted
           to IESG for publication as Proposed Standard
Jan 2007 - RObust Header Compression Protocol Number Registration
           submitted to IESG for publication as Proposed Standard

This was added before I started as a chair and it is not completely
clear to me what the consensus is for this item. I can't really see what
these new legacy profiles solve that can't be solved by existing
profiles. I would like to have this discussion now.

The Protocol Number Registration item is not needed. The registration is
included in the ROHCoIPSec drafts.

I would like to see a change of date for the last item. From Jun 2007 to
Sep 2009. It is long overdue:

Jun 2007 - Recharter of WG to develop additional profiles if needed, or
           possible additional compression schemes. Consideration of
           concluding the working group.

Please send in your comments.


Best Regards,

/Carl Knutsson, ROHC WG Chair
_______________________________________________
Rohc mailing list
Rohc at ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/rohc