Provisional resolution of the last-call comments received so far

["Dr. Carsten Bormann" <cabo@tzi.org>]

ROHCers,

in the WG meeting we just had, consensus occurred on the following
resolution of the last-call comments received so far.  I'm sorry this list
is a bit terse right now, but I promised to send this out quickly.

If I have missed any last-call comments sent in so far, please tell me!

Please note that these resolutions are the sense of a room in San Diego.
WG consensus occurs on the mailing list.
If you disagree with these resolutions, please tell...

Gruesse, Carsten

ROHC-RTP-requirements-03 last-call issues
Editorial
-- Make definition of loss/damage propagation consistent with rest
   (loss propagation = losses caused by earlier loss or damage etc.)
-- Issue: Handover requirements
   3a: Handover loss events
       change to “Loss events of length 150 ms should be handled efficiently
and without additional packet loss or erroneous headers being introduced by
ROHC”.
   3b: Handover context recreation
       add “ROHC should not introduce packet loss during such events”.

ROHC-RTP-06 last-call issues (1): Editorial:
-- Make definition of loss/damage propagation consistent with rest
   (loss propagation = losses caused by earlier loss or damage etc.)
-- 5.2: can’t have Add-CID on feedback
-- Two sections numbered 5.2.6
-- 5.6.4: replace by just pointing to 5.6.3
-- 5.7: Fix GRE section references (5.8.4.5, not 5.8.4.2)
-- 5.7.5.2: Tsc is always 1, set to 0 in ext3
-- 5.7.6.11 feedback example: code: s/2/1/
-- Issue: Location of “Impairment Considerations” section
   Change does improve document, but reshuffling too complicated at this
stage

ROHC-RTP-06 last-call issues (2): Not-quite-so-editorial:
-- 5.3.2.2.3: No CRC-based repair of SN in context in R-mode
-- 5.3.2.2.4: b for Full->Static, c for Static->no context
-- 5.4.2.2: handle IR-DYN packets like UOR-2 packets
-- 5.6: Add reference to mode bits in IR/IR-DYN
-- 5.7.5.1.: RND flag (no ACK should be required in O-mode)
-- Appendix A: v4 vs. v6 (fixed text supplied by Lars-Erik)

ROHC-RTP-06 last-call issues (3): Document dependencies:
-- Remove MIPv6 destination option support (!)
   -- HA works well enough without special support
   -- BU etc. occur infrequently
-- GRE: replace RFC1701 reference by RFC2784 and RFC2890
   (and attendant changes in the scheme)
   Need to find GRE people to discuss this offline!

Change requests:
-- Issue: IR-DYN/UOR-2 feedback option (withdrawn)