Re: [rrg] I plan to write critiques of LISP and TIDR

[Lixia Zhang <lixia at cs.ucla.edu>]

On Jan 13, 2010, at 8:13 AM, Robin Whittle wrote:

> Over the weekend I intend to write critiques of LISP and TIDR - the
> only other core-edge separation proposals apart from Ivip.
>
> I have read the TIDR ID and plan to check my understanding of TIDR
> with Juanjo before finalising what I write.
>
> Then I plan to post them to the list.  This can be raw material for
> other people to discuss, criticise, contribute to or whatever happens
> to arrive at a critique which most or all interested people (except
> probably the proponents!) are happy with.
>
> I understand from Lixia's message 05558 that the deadline is this
> Friday - but I will probably need till Sunday or Monday.  Later, I
> intend to write critiques of all the other proposals.  That may be
> too late for the deadline, but I want to read them all and write what
> I think about them.
>
>  - Robin

Robin,

I believe people would all appreciate the effort you put into RRG  
work. Regarding the deadline: yes I did say 1/15, but Tony argued for  
1/12, and now I'd like to second your vote for Monday 1/18 as I myself  
need that few extra days as well.

Lixia