[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[no subject]

With regard to the paging assessment, if you look at
draft-ietf-seamoby-paging-protocol-assessment-00.txt, you will see that
there is a separate
column for rating draft-guri-seamoby-lahap-00.txt, and a separate set of
comments. So, even
though both drafts were done by the same assessor (which is what I meant
by them
being bundled), the assessments were written up separately. However,
since
draft-guri-seamoby-lahap-00.txt does not present a complete solution for
IP paging, it was not possible to consider it on its own as the solution
for the Seamoby
IP paging protocol. That's another and perhaps more compelling reason
why it was not
accepted as the basis for the Seamoby protocol. I should have made this
clearer at the meeting.

As you may know, working group drafts are the product of the working
group, not
the editor, so your work, along with good work from the other protocol
proposal
authors, will be invaluable in generating a superior result. Rather than
"declaring the
assessment moot", I suggest you talk to Marco about folding some of your
work
into the working group draft, if that seems appropriate.  If not, then
perhaps
the venue of an L2 trigger BOF would be the right place to continue
the work. We will certainly need a good interface between IP paging and
Layer 2
paging in the final Seamoby paging protocol.

                    jak

----- Original Message -----
From: "Behcet Sarikaya" <behcet.sarikaya@alcatel.com>
To: <seamoby@ietf.org>
Sent: Saturday, December 15, 2001 3:23 PM
Subject: Re: [Seamoby] Paging Protocol Assessment Presentation at SLC


> Dear All,
>   According to the slides presented by WG cochair on Friday Dec. 14,
> 2001 at IETF 52 (these slides have to be posted for public access, as
> other WGs do), the two drafts:
> draft 1. draft-sarikaya-seamoby-mipv6hp-00.txt and
> draft 2. draft-guri-seamoby-lahap-00.txt
> were considered together because they were submitted by the same team
and
> since draft-sarikaya-seamoby-mipv6hp-00.txt
> was based on hmipv6 both of them were eliminated, i.e.
> draft-guri-seamoby-lahap-00.txt was not at all considered, there were
no
> slides on this draft..
>   This raises several concerns on my side:
> - the two drafts have only two authors in common, the two draft main
> authors are different and
> more importantly the two drafts define two different paging protocols.
> - draft 1 is an extension of Mobile IPv6. Its dependence on hmipv6 can
> easily be removed, as we intend to do it in the next version.
> - draft 2 is completely based on the architecture defined in RFC 3154.
> Apart from many other aspects, it defines paging triggers.
> - draft 2 was probably the only draft that generated some discussion
on
> the maling list by people who have not submitted drafts, i.e., by
> external people .
> - WG cochair Jim sent us private emails providing some useful feedback
> on the definition of an API for paging triggers. He even offered to
> collaborate on a joint draft. I have the emails and willing to
> distribute them on the mailing list if asked.
>
>   Based on the above facts I hereby declare the paging protocol
> assessment to be moot.
>
> Regards,
>
> --
> Behcet
>
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Seamoby mailing list
> Seamoby@ietf.org
&amp;amp;gt; &amp;lt;A  HREF=&amp;quot;&lt;a  rel=&quot;nofollow&quot; href=&quot;<a  rel="nofollow" href="https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/seamoby&amp;quot&quot";>https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/seamoby&amp;quot&quot</a>;&gt;<a  rel="nofollow" href="https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/seamoby&amp;quot";>https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/seamoby&amp;quot</a>&lt;/a&gt;;&amp;gt;&lt;a  rel=&quot;nofollow&quot; href=&quot;<a  rel="nofollow" href="https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/seamoby&quot";>https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/seamoby&quot</a>;&gt;<a  rel="nofollow" href="https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/seamoby";>https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/seamoby</a>&lt;/a&gt;&amp;lt;/A&amp;gt;
&amp;amp;gt;


_______________________________________________
Seamoby mailing list
Seamoby@ietf.org
&amp;lt;A  HREF=&amp;quot;&lt;a  rel=&quot;nofollow&quot; href=&quot;<a  rel="nofollow" href="https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/seamoby&amp;quot&quot";>https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/seamoby&amp;quot&quot</a>;&gt;<a  rel="nofollow" href="https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/seamoby&amp;quot";>https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/seamoby&amp;quot</a>&lt;/a&gt;;&amp;gt;&lt;a  rel=&quot;nofollow&quot; href=&quot;<a  rel="nofollow" href="https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/seamoby&quot";>https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/seamoby&quot</a>;&gt;<a  rel="nofollow" href="https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/seamoby";>https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/seamoby</a>&lt;/a&gt;&amp;lt;/A&amp;gt;


&amp;lt;/PRE&amp;gt;

&amp;lt;!--X-Body-of-Message-End--&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;!--X-MsgBody-End--&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;!--X-Follow-Ups--&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;hr&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;ul&amp;gt;&amp;lt;li&amp;gt;&amp;lt;strong&amp;gt;Follow-Ups&amp;lt;/strong&amp;gt;:
&amp;lt;ul&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;li&amp;gt;&amp;lt;strong&amp;gt;&amp;lt;a name=&amp;quot;00013&amp;quot; href=&amp;quot;msg00013.html&amp;quot;&amp;gt;Re: [Seamoby] Paging Triggers&amp;lt;/a&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/strong&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;ul&amp;gt;&amp;lt;li&amp;gt;&amp;lt;em&amp;gt;From:&amp;lt;/em&amp;gt; Behcet Sarikaya &amp;amp;lt;behcet.sarikaya@alcatel.com&amp;amp;gt;&amp;lt;/li&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/ul&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/li&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;li&amp;gt;&amp;lt;strong&amp;gt;&amp;lt;a name=&amp;quot;00011&amp;quot; href=&amp;quot;msg00011.html&amp;quot;&amp;gt;Re: [Seamoby] Paging Protocol Assessment Presentation at SLC&amp;lt;/a&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/strong&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;ul&amp;gt;&amp;lt;li&amp;gt;&amp;lt;em&amp;gt;From:&amp;lt;/em&amp;gt; Behcet Sarikaya &amp;amp;lt;behcet.sarikaya@alcatel.com&amp;amp;gt;&amp;lt;/li&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/ul&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/li&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;/ul&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/li&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/ul&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;!--X-Follow-Ups-End--&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;!--X-References--&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;ul&amp;gt;&amp;lt;li&amp;gt;&amp;lt;strong&amp;gt;References&amp;lt;/strong&amp;gt;:
&amp;lt;ul&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;li&amp;gt;&amp;lt;strong&amp;gt;&amp;lt;a name=&amp;quot;00005&amp;quot; href=&amp;quot;msg00005.html&amp;quot;&amp;gt;[Seamoby] WG Last Call: draft-ietf-seamoby-ct-reqs-02.txt&amp;lt;/a&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/strong&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;ul&amp;gt;&amp;lt;li&amp;gt;&amp;lt;em&amp;gt;From:&amp;lt;/em&amp;gt; &amp;amp;quot;Pat R. Calhoun&amp;amp;quot; &amp;amp;lt;pcalhoun@bstormnetworks.com&amp;amp;gt;&amp;lt;/li&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/ul&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/li&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;li&amp;gt;&amp;lt;strong&amp;gt;&amp;lt;a name=&amp;quot;00006&amp;quot; href=&amp;quot;msg00006.html&amp;quot;&amp;gt;Re: [Seamoby] Paging Protocol Assessment Presentation at SLC&amp;lt;/a&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/strong&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;ul&amp;gt;&amp;lt;li&amp;gt;&amp;lt;em&amp;gt;From:&amp;lt;/em&amp;gt; Behcet Sarikaya &amp;amp;lt;behcet.sarikaya@alcatel.com&amp;amp;gt;&amp;lt;/li&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/ul&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/li&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;/ul&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/li&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/ul&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;!--X-References-End--&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;!--X-BotPNI--&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;ul&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;li&amp;gt;Prev by Date:
&amp;lt;strong&amp;gt;&amp;lt;a href=&amp;quot;msg00008.html&amp;quot;&amp;gt;[Seamoby] Announce: Mobile Networks monet mailing list&amp;lt;/a&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/strong&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;/li&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;li&amp;gt;Next by Date:
&amp;lt;strong&amp;gt;&amp;lt;a href=&amp;quot;msg00010.html&amp;quot;&amp;gt;Re: [Seamoby] Paging Protocol Assessment Presentation at SLC&amp;lt;/a&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/strong&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;/li&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;li&amp;gt;Previous by thread:
&amp;lt;strong&amp;gt;&amp;lt;a href=&amp;quot;msg00006.html&amp;quot;&amp;gt;Re: [Seamoby] Paging Protocol Assessment Presentation at SLC&amp;lt;/a&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/strong&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;/li&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;li&amp;gt;Next by thread:
&amp;lt;strong&amp;gt;&amp;lt;a href=&amp;quot;msg00011.html&amp;quot;&amp;gt;Re: [Seamoby] Paging Protocol Assessment Presentation at SLC&amp;lt;/a&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/strong&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;/li&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;li&amp;gt;Index(es):
&amp;lt;ul&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;li&amp;gt;&amp;lt;a href=&amp;quot;mail78.html#00009&amp;quot;&amp;gt;&amp;lt;strong&amp;gt;Date&amp;lt;/strong&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/a&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/li&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;li&amp;gt;&amp;lt;a href=&amp;quot;thrd78.html#00009&amp;quot;&amp;gt;&amp;lt;strong&amp;gt;Thread&amp;lt;/strong&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/a&amp;gt;&amp;lt;/li&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;/ul&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;/li&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;/ul&amp;gt;

&amp;lt;!--X-BotPNI-End--&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;!--X-User-Footer--&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;!--X-User-Footer-End--&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;/body&amp;gt;
&amp;lt;/html&amp;gt;
&lt;/pre&gt;
&lt;!--X-Body-of-Message-End--&gt;
&lt;!--X-MsgBody-End--&gt;
&lt;!--X-Follow-Ups--&gt;
&lt;hr&gt;
&lt;!--X-Follow-Ups-End--&gt;
&lt;!--X-References--&gt;
&lt;!--X-References-End--&gt;
&lt;!--X-BotPNI--&gt;
&lt;ul&gt;
&lt;li&gt;Prev by Date:
&lt;strong&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;msg00008.html&quot;&gt;[no subject]&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/strong&gt;
&lt;/li&gt;
&lt;li&gt;Next by Date:
&lt;strong&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;msg00010.html&quot;&gt;[no subject]&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/strong&gt;
&lt;/li&gt;
&lt;li&gt;Previous by thread:
&lt;strong&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;msg00008.html&quot;&gt;[no subject]&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/strong&gt;
&lt;/li&gt;
&lt;li&gt;Next by thread:
&lt;strong&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;msg00010.html&quot;&gt;[no subject]&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/strong&gt;
&lt;/li&gt;
&lt;li&gt;Index(es):
&lt;ul&gt;
&lt;li&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;maillist.html#00009&quot;&gt;&lt;strong&gt;Date&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/li&gt;
&lt;li&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;threads.html#00009&quot;&gt;&lt;strong&gt;Thread&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/li&gt;
&lt;/ul&gt;
&lt;/li&gt;
&lt;/ul&gt;

&lt;!--X-BotPNI-End--&gt;
&lt;!--X-User-Footer--&gt;
&lt;!--X-User-Footer-End--&gt;
&lt;/body&gt;
&lt;/html&gt;
</pre>
<!--X-Body-of-Message-End-->
<!--X-MsgBody-End-->
<!--X-Follow-Ups-->
<hr>
<!--X-Follow-Ups-End-->
<!--X-References-->
<!--X-References-End-->
<!--X-BotPNI-->
<ul>
<li>Prev by Date:
<strong><a href="msg00008.html">[no subject]</a></strong>
</li>
<li>Next by Date:
<strong><a href="msg00010.html">[no subject]</a></strong>
</li>
<li>Previous by thread:
<strong><a href="msg00008.html">[no subject]</a></strong>
</li>
<li>Next by thread:
<strong><a href="msg00010.html">[no subject]</a></strong>
</li>
<li>Index(es):
<ul>
<li><a href="maillist.html#00009"><strong>Date</strong></a></li>
<li><a href="threads.html#00009"><strong>Thread</strong></a></li>
</ul>
</li>
</ul>

<!--X-BotPNI-End-->
<!--X-User-Footer-->
<!--X-User-Footer-End-->
</body>
</html>