[sidr] implementation - work for the working group?

[Sandra Murphy <sandy at sparta.com>]

There have been two presentations to this working group in past IETF 
meetings suggesting mechanisms for implementations of the BGP route 
decision based on the RPKI.  The first was Ruediger Volk's presentation at 
IETF72 that suggested a way to map ROAs to IRR route objects so as to feed 
into existing operator tools. 
(http://tools.ietf.org/agenda/72/slides/sidr-6.pdf)  The second was David 
Ward's presentation at IETF75 that suggested a way to use prefix -> origin 
AS maps (possibly produced from ROAs) in the BGP decision process. 
(http://tools.ietf.org/agenda/75/slides/sidr-8.pdf)

Obviously people are beginning to work on implementations, but we 
presently have no work going on concerning implementation.  So the 
question is - does the wg believe that working on implementations of use 
of the RPKI and ROAs should be a work item for this wg?  That is, should 
the wg produce implementation specs?


--Sandy