Re: [sidr] wg consideration of IPR

[George Michaelson <ggm+ietf at apnic.net>]

I must apologize to the WG for having made a mistake in my dates. I have post-dated the work Geoff and I submitted, which actually hit the IETF draft status in February 2008.

I wish to revise my statements.

1) Geoff and I co-authored an individual submission in February of 2008.

	draft-huston-sidr-roa-validation-00

  this was subsequently adopted  August 7 2008

	draft-ietf-sidr-roa-validation-00

2) Pradosh Mohapatra and John Scudder edited a draft dated October 27, 2008

	draft-pmohapat-sidr-pfx-validate-00

3) In November 2008, Cisco filed IPR in respect of this draft. This is what I can tell from looking in the IETF IPR disclosure system. I received no notification of this, relating to my work.

4) In October 2009, I became aware of a Cisco IPR claim in respect of

       draft-pmohapat-sidr-pfx-validate-00

The IPR statement was lodged with the IETF dated November 18 2008.

5) In November 2009 I received direct notification from Cisco/IETF that the IPR claim was also applied to the draft I co-authored. 

This is an IPR statement dated November 2 2009

So, thats the time sequence as I see it, based on what I can recall from emails to sidr WG, personal mail, and the drafts found online.

-George

Again, this is my personal opinion. I speak for nobody else in this matter.