Re: [Simple] Soon you can Blink!

[Iñaki Baz Castillo <ibc at aliax.net>]

2009/9/29 Iñaki Baz Castillo <ibc at aliax.net>:
> So, what we have? nothing. We have a hyper-complex and ambiguous set
> of specifications which don't provide interoperability at all. When I
> read "this softphones implements XCAP" I understand "this softphone
> implements XCAP so it works ONLY with same vendor's softphones, XCAP
> server and presence server". Is this what we want?
>
> OMA's XDM specification is a specification layer on top of XCAP/SIMPLE
> documents which tries to create a fixed and strict subset of IETF
> specifications in order to make it feasible for clients adoption. For
> example it defines a very strict format for the pres-rules document.
> It also defines the XCAP server behavior (XDMS server).
>
> I really think that this should be a task of IETF rather than OMA. I
> cannot understand why IETF has published such useless and half-done
> documents, can I ask *why*?? sharing a simple budy list or privacy
> rules is IMPOSSIBLE with IETF's specifications!!!. Anyhow this is what
> we have.
>
> Which should be the way to go? perhaps implement OMA's XDM specs?
> (I've read XDM documents and they are designed to be SIP core agnostic
> (valid for IMS or any kind of SIP core).
>
>
> Sorry for this mail, but this subject is really depressing for me.


Of course, I really appreciate the effort AG-Projects is doing in SIP
presence stuff, really amazing!

-- 
Iñaki Baz Castillo
<ibc at aliax.net>