Re: [Sip] draft-ietf-sip-199-06

[Tom Taylor <tom.taylor at rogers.com>]

Some text , as requested.

Christer Holmberg wrote:
...
> > In section 6:
> >
> >   When a forking proxy receives a non-2xx final response that it
> >   recognizes as terminating one or more early dialogs, if the proxy
> >   does not intend to forward the final response immediately (in
> >   accordance with rules for a forking proxy) and the UAC has indicated
> >   support for the 199 response code, the proxy SHOULD generate and
> send
> >   a 199 response upstream for each early dialog terminated on the
> >   downstream side by the non-2xx final response, except for any early
> >   dialog for which the proxy has previously received and forwarded a
> >   199 response.
...

My suggestion:

"When a forking proxy receives a non-2xx final response that it
 recognizes as terminating one or more early dialogs, it SHOULD generate
 and send a 199 response upstream for each such early dialog satisfying the
 following conditions:
 -- the proxy does not intend to forward the final response immediately
    (in accordance with rules for a forking proxy);
 -- the UAC has indicated support for the 199 response code;
 -- the proxy has not already received and forwarded a 199 response for
    that early dialogue."