[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Re-revised idea for early cross-area review



Allison Mankin wrote:



I don't see these reviews as critical-path.  The working group
should keep working, and not block or change their activities
in any way while a review is pending.

Right. I don't think we should set this up as a guaranteed
service with full coverage of all -00 drafts and committed
deadlines. In practise, we can hope to cover the most important
stuff. And yes, WGs should keep on working.

The main reason for having the dispatcher is to be sure that broad
coverage is occurring.  If an -01 were to show up quickly before the
review showed up, then the review could be on the -01.  "Early"
doesn't have to be a mathematically precise term.

Yes.

--Jari