Re: [yam] Comments on draft-ietf-yam-rfc1652bis-pre-evaluation-00

[Alexey Melnikov <alexey.melnikov at isode.com>]

Hi SM,
Some quick comments on a part of your message.

S Moonesamy wrote:
[...]

> There was a comment from Adrian Farrel that "The universal deployment 
> of this feature is well-known" in the I-D seems like an exaggeration.  
> Based on feedback from John Klensin and Tony Hansen, it is suggested 
> that a sentence similar to the text below be used in other 
> pre-evaluation I-Ds:
>
>   'The extensive deployment of this feature is well-known within the 
> email
>    implementation and operational communities.'

(not wearing any hats:) This looks good to me.

> The DISCUSS positions and comments are related to the work of the 
> Working Group instead of being questions that Dave Crocker should address.

(with my AD hat on) Agreed.

> The document itself (draft-ietf-yam-rfc1652bis-pre-evaluation-00) is 
> scheduled to be evaluated by the IESG on October 22.

I will let the WG know if anything else comes up during the discussion 
next week.