Notifications and Acknowledgements Requirements (notary)
































Charter































Status: Concluded November, 1995 































































Chair(s):































































 Harald Alvestrand 































 Ned Freed 































































Description of Working Group:































The purpose of the NOTARY Working Group is to give the Internet e-mail































user better tools to build a system where the sender of a message can































find out what happened to it.































































Work items for this group:































































- Specify a reporting format that can be used for delivery,































non-delivery and receipt reports. The format should conform to MIME,































and be at least as informative as current examples of non-standardized































non-delivery notifications. This format should be usable as-is in































current e-mail products to replace the current, non-standardized and































sometimes quite cryptic textual non-delivery reports.  The drafts by































Keith Moore and Greg Vaudreuil are taken as a working basis.  (See































the document list below for details.)































































- Specify a way for the sender to request that positive delivery































reports be generated for a message sent via SMTP. The draft by































Keith Moore is taken as a working basis.































































- Generate an Informational document that gives advice on how to handle































delivery notifications (positive and negative) and requests for them at































boundaries to other mail systems, such as X.400 and PC LANs.































































Relationship to X.400 and X.400 gateways:































































While the intent of this work includes specification of an































acknowledgement system that can be translated to work across the































































821/822/MIME to X.400 boundary, the effort will focus on design from































the former standpoint.  That will be followed by changes to the































successor of RFC 1327 to match these features, but those changes will be































made as part of the RFC 1327 revision process, not by this working 































group.































Of course, if any features specified by this working group turn out to 































be































impossible to accomodate in the RFC 1327 revision, that would be cause 































for































reviewing both sets of specifications.































































Additional items not on the agenda of this working group:































































- Specification of a way in which the sender can request that a receipt































notification (``the recipient has read this message'') be sent upon































receipt of the message. The document should identify the controversial































aspects of such a function, and should attempt to specify the function































in a way that minimizes surprise at both the sending and receiving end,































even in the face of varying local policies.































































However, the group will, as part of its work, make a recommendation to































the IESG where and how such work should be tackled.































Request for Comments:

  • RFC1891 SMTP Service Extension for Delivery Status Notifications (Proposed Standard)
  • RFC1892 The Multipart/Report Content Type for the Reporting of Mail System Administrative Messages (Proposed Standard)
  • RFC1893 Enhanced Mail System Status Codes (Proposed Standard)
  • RFC1894 An Extensible Message Format for Delivery Status Notifications (Proposed Standard)