<?xml version='1.0' encoding='utf-8'?>
<!DOCTYPE rfc SYSTEM "rfc2629-xhtml.ent">


<?rfc toc="yes"?>
<?rfc tocompact="yes"?>
<?rfc tocdepth="3"?>
<?rfc tocindent="yes"?>
<?rfc symrefs="yes"?>
<?rfc sortrefs="yes"?>
<?rfc comments="yes"?>
<?rfc inline="yes"?>
<?rfc compact="no"?>
<?rfc subcompact="no"?>
<?rfc authorship="yes"?>
<?rfc tocappendix="yes"?>
<rfc  xmlns:xi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XInclude" category="info" ipr='trust200902' tocInclude="true"  obsoletes="" updates="" submissionType="IETF" xml:lang="en" version="3" docName="draft-maeurer-raw-ldacs-04" >

    <!-- ***** FRONT MATTER ***** -->

    <front>

        <title abbrev='LDACS'>L-band Digital Aeronautical Communications System (LDACS)</title>



        <author fullname="Nils Maeurer" initials="N."
            surname="Maeurer" role="editor">
            <organization>German Aerospace Center (DLR)</organization>
            <address>
                <postal>
                    <street ascii="Muenchner Strasse 20">Muenchner Strasse 20</street>
                    <!-- Reorder these if your country does things differently -->
                    <code>82234</code>
                    <city ascii="Wessling">Wessling</city>
                    <region></region>
                    <country>Germany</country>
                </postal>
                <!--<phone></phone>-->
                <email>Nils.Maeurer@dlr.de</email>
                <!-- uri and facsimile elements may also be added -->
            </address>
        </author>
        
        
        
<!--role="editor"-->
        <author fullname="Thomas Graeupl" initials="T."
            surname="Graeupl" role="editor">
            <organization>German Aerospace Center (DLR)</organization>

            <address>
                <postal>
                    <street ascii="Muenchner Strasse 20">Muenchner Strasse 20</street>
                    <!-- Reorder these if your country does things differently -->
                    <code>82234</code>
                    <city ascii="Wessling">Wessling</city>
                    <region></region>
                    <country>Germany</country>
                </postal>
                <!--<phone></phone>-->
                <email>Thomas.Graeupl@dlr.de</email>
                <!-- uri and facsimile elements may also be added -->
            </address>
        </author>



        <author fullname="Corinna Schmitt" initials="C."  
            surname="Schmitt" role="editor">
            <organization>Research Institute CODE, UniBwM</organization>

            <address>
                <postal>
                    <street>Werner-Heisenberg-Weg 28</street>
                    <!-- Reorder these if your country does things differently -->
                    <code>85577</code>
                    <city>Neubiberg</city>
                    <region></region>
                    <country>Germany</country>
                </postal>
                <!--<phone></phone>-->
                <email>corinna.schmitt@unibw.de</email>

                <!-- uri and facsimile elements may also be added -->
            </address>
        </author>

        <date/>

        <!-- If the month and year are both specified and are the current ones, xml2rfc will fill
         in the current day for you. If only the current year is specified, xml2rfc will fill
         in the current day and month for you. If the year is not the current one, it is
         necessary to specify at least a month (xml2rfc assumes day="1" if not specified for the
         purpose of calculating the expiry date). With drafts it is normally sufficient to
         specify just the year. -->


        <area>Routing</area>

        <workgroup>RAW</workgroup>


        <abstract>
            <t> This document provides an overview of the architecture of the L-band Digital Aeronautical Communications System (LDACS), which provides a secure, scalable and spectrum efficient terrestrial data link for civil aviation. LDACS is a scheduled, reliable multi-application cellular broadband system with support for IPv6. LDACS shall provide a data link for IP network-based aircraft guidance. High reliability
                and availability for IP connectivity over LDACS are therefore
                essential.
            </t>
        </abstract>
    </front>

    <middle>
        <section><name>Introduction</name>

            <t>
                One of the main pillars of the modern Air Traffic Management (ATM)
                system is the existence of a communication infrastructure that
                enables efficient aircraft control and safe separation in all phases
                of flight. Current systems are technically mature but suffering from
                the VHF band's increasing saturation in high-density areas and the
                limitations posed by analogue radio communications. Therefore, aviation globally
                and the European Union (EU) in particular, strives for a sustainable
                modernization of the aeronautical communication infrastructure.
            </t>
            <t>
                In the long-term, ATM communication shall transition from analogue
                VHF voice and VDL2 communication to more spectrum efficient digital
                data communication. The European ATM Master Plan foresees this
                transition to be realized for terrestrial communications by the
                development (and potential implementation) of the L-band Digital Aeronautical
                Communications System (LDACS). LDACS shall enable IPv6 based air-
                ground communication related to the aviation safety and regularity of flight.
                The particular challenge is that no additional spectrum can be
                made available for terrestrial aeronautical communication. It was
                thus necessary to develop co-existence mechanism/procedures to enable
                the interference free operation of LDACS in parallel with other aeronautical
                services/systems in the same frequency band.
            </t>
            <t>
                Since LDACS shall be used for aircraft guidance, high reliability and
                availability for IP connectivity over LDACS are essential.
            </t>

<!--            <section title="Requirements Language">
                <t>The key words "MUST", "MUST NOT", "REQUIRED", "SHALL", "SHALL NOT",
                    "SHOULD", "SHOULD NOT", "RECOMMENDED", "MAY", and "OPTIONAL" in this
                    document are to be interpreted as described in <xref
                        target="RFC2119">RFC 2119</xref>.</t>
            </section> -->
        </section>



        <section><name>Terminology</name>
                <t>
                    The following terms are used in the context of RAW in this document:
                    </t><dl spacing='compact'>
                        <dt>A2A</dt><dd>
                            Air-to-Air
                        </dd>
                        <dt>LDACS A2A</dt><dd>
                            LDACS Air-to-Air
                        </dd>
                        <dt>AeroMACS</dt><dd>
                            Aeronautical Mobile Airport Communication System
                        </dd>
                        <dt>A2G</dt><dd>
                            Air-to-Ground
                        </dd>
                        <dt>AM(R)S</dt><dd>
                            Aeronautical Mobile (Route) Service
                        </dd>
                        <dt>ANSP</dt><dd>
                            Air traffic Network Service Provider
                        </dd>
                        <dt>AOC</dt><dd>
                            Aeronautical Operational Control
                        </dd>
                        <dt>AS</dt><dd>
                            Aircraft Station
                        </dd>
                        <dt>ATC</dt><dd>
                            Air-Traffic Control
                        </dd>
                        <dt>ATM</dt><dd>
                            Air-Traffic Management
                        </dd>
                        <dt>ATN</dt><dd>
                            Aeronautical Telecommunication Network
                        </dd>
                        <dt>ATS</dt><dd>
                            Air Traffic Service
                        </dd>
                        <dt>CCCH</dt><dd>
                            Common Control Channel
                        </dd>
                        <dt>DCCH</dt><dd>
                            Dedicated Control Channel
                        </dd>
                        <dt>DCH</dt><dd>
                            Data Channel
                        </dd>
                        <dt>DLL</dt><dd>
                            Data Link Layer
                        </dd>
                        <dt>DLS</dt><dd>
                            Data Link Service
                        </dd>
                        <dt>DME</dt><dd>
                            Distance Measuring Equipment
                        </dd>
                        <dt>DSB-AM</dt><dd>
                            Double Side-Band Amplitude Modulation
                        </dd>
                        <dt>FAA</dt><dd>
                            Federal Aviation Administration
                        </dd>
                        <dt>FCI</dt><dd>
                            Future Communication Infrastructure
                        </dd>
                        <dt>FDD</dt><dd>
                            Frequency Division Duplex
                        </dd>
                        <dt>FL</dt><dd>
                            Forward Link
                        </dd>
                        <dt>GANP</dt><dd>
                            Global Air Navigation Plan
                        </dd>
                        <dt>GNSS</dt><dd>
                            Global Navigation Satellite System
                        </dd>
                        <dt>GS</dt><dd>
                            Ground Station
                        </dd>
                        <dt>GSC</dt><dd>
                            Ground-Station Controller
                        </dd>
                        <dt>G2A</dt><dd>
                            Ground-to-Air
                        </dd>
                        <dt>HF</dt><dd>
                            High Frequency
                        </dd>
                        <dt>ICAO</dt><dd>
                            International Civil Aviation Organization
                        </dd>
                        <dt>kbit/s</dt><dd>
                            kilobit per second
                        </dd>
                        <dt>LDACS</dt><dd>
                            L-band Digital Aeronautical Communications System
                        </dd>
                        <dt>LLC</dt><dd>
                            Logical Link Layer
                        </dd>
                        <dt>LME</dt><dd>
                            LDACS Management Entity
                        </dd>
                        <dt>MAC</dt><dd>
                            Medium Access Layer
                        </dd>
                        <dt>MF</dt><dd>
                            Multi Frame
                        </dd>
                        <dt>OFDM</dt><dd>
                            Orthogonal Frequency-Division Multiplexing
                        </dd>
                        <dt>OFDMA</dt><dd>
                            Orthogonal Frequency-Division Multiplexing Access
                        </dd>
                        <dt>PDU</dt><dd>
                            Protocol Data Units
                        </dd>
                        <dt>PHY</dt><dd>
                            Physical Layer
                        </dd>
                        <dt>QoS</dt><dd>
                            Quality of Service
                        </dd>
                        <dt>RL</dt><dd>
                            Reverse Link
                        </dd>
                        <dt>SARPs</dt><dd>
                            Standards And Recommended Practices
                        </dd>
                        <dt>SESAR</dt><dd>
                            Single European Sky ATM Research
                        </dd>
                        <dt>SF</dt><dd>
                            Super-Frame
                        </dd>
                        <dt>SNP</dt><dd>
                            Sub-Network Protocol
                        </dd>
                        <dt>SSB-AM</dt><dd>
                            Single Side-Band Amplitude Modulation
                        </dd>
                        <dt>TBO</dt><dd>
                            Trajectory-Based Operations
                        </dd>
                        <dt>TDM</dt><dd>
                            Time Division Multiplexing
                        </dd>
                        <dt>TDMA</dt><dd>
                            Time-Division Multiplexing-Access
                        </dd>
                        <dt>VDL2</dt><dd>
                            VHF Data Link mode 2
                        </dd>
                        <dt>VHF</dt><dd>
                            Very High Frequency
                        </dd>
                        <dt>VI</dt><dd>
                            Voice Interface
                        </dd>
                        
                    </dl><t>
                   </t>
            </section>

        <section anchor='MotivationUC'><name>Motivation and Use Cases</name>

            <t>
                Aircraft are currently connected to Air-Traffic Control (ATC) and Airline Operational Control (AOC) via voice and data communications systems through all phases of a flight. Within the airport terminal, connectivity is focused on high bandwidth communications, while during en-route high reliability, robustness, and range is the main focus. Voice communications may use the same or different equipment as data communications systems. In the following the main differences between voice and data communications capabilities are summarized. The assumed use cases for LDACS completes the list of use cases stated in <xref target="I-D.bernardos-raw-use-cases" format="default"/> and the list of reliable and available wireless technologies presented in <xref target="I-D.thubert-raw-technologies" format="default"/>. 
            </t>

            <section anchor='VoiceCom'><name>Voice Communications Today</name>
                <t>
                    Voice links are used for Air-to-Ground (A2G) and Air-to-Air (A2A)
                    communications. The communication equipment is either ground-based
                    working in the High Frequency (HF) or Very High Frequency (VHF)
                    frequency band or satellite-based. All VHF and HF voice communications
                    is operated via open broadcast channels without authentication,
                    encryption or other protective measures. The use of well-proven
                    communication procedures via broadcast channels helps to enhance the
                    safety of communications by taking into account that other users may
                    encounter communication problems and may be supported, if required.
                    The main voice communications media is still the analogue VHF Double
                    Side-Band Amplitude Modulation (DSB-AM) communications technique,
                    supplemented by HF Single Side-Band Amplitude Modulation (SSB-AM) and
                    satellite communications for remote and oceanic areas. DSB-AM has
                    been in use since 1948, works reliably and safely, and uses low-cost
                    communication equipment. These are the main reasons why VHF DSB-AM
                    communications is still in use, and it is likely that this technology
                    will remain in service for many more years. This however results in
                    current operational limitations and impediments in deploying
                    new Air-Traffic Management (ATM) applications, such as flight-centric
                    operation with Point-to-Point communications.
                    
                </t>
             </section>


            <section anchor='DataCom'><name>Data Communications Today</name>
                <t>
                    Like for voice, data communications into the cockpit is currently
                    provided by ground-based equipment operating either on HF or VHF
                    radio bands or by legacy satellite systems. All these communication
                    systems are using narrowband radio channels with a data throughput
                    capacity in order of kilobits per second. While the aircraft is on
                    ground some additional communications systems are available, like
                    Aeronautical Mobile Airport Communication System (AeroMACS; as of now
                    not widely used) or public cellular networks, operating in the Airport
                    (APT) domain and able to deliver broadband communication capability.
                </t>
                <t>
                    The data communication networks used for the transmission of data relating to the safety and regularity of the flight must be strictly isolated from those providing entertainment services to passengers. This leads to a situation that the flight crews are supported by narrowband services during flight while passengers have access to inflight broadband services. The current HF and VHF data links cannot provide broadband services now or in the future, due to the lack of available spectrum. This technical shortcoming is becoming a limitation to enhanced ATM operations, such as Trajectory-Based Operations (TBO) and 4D trajectory negotiations.
                </t>
                <t>
                    Satellite-based communications are currently under investigation and
                    enhanced capabilities are under development which will be able to
                    provide inflight broadband services and communications supporting the
                    safety and regularity of flight. In parallel, the ground-based
                    broadband data link technology LDACS is being standardized by ICAO
                    and has recently shown its maturity during flight tests <xref target="SCH191"/>.
                    The LDACS technology is scalable, secure and spectrum efficient and
                    provides significant advantages to the users and service providers.
                    It is expected that both - satellite systems and LDACS - will be
                    deployed to support the future aeronautical communication needs as
                    envisaged by the ICAO Global Air Navigation Plan (GANP).
                </t>
            </section>
        </section>


        <section anchor='ProvenanceandDocuments'><name>Provenance and Documents</name>
            <t>
                The development of LDACS has already made substantial progress in the Single European Sky ATM Research (SESAR) framework, and is currently being continued in the follow-up program, SESAR2020 <xref target="RIH18"/>. A key objective of the SESAR activities is to develop, implement and validate a modern aeronautical data link able to evolve with aviation needs over long-term. To this end, an LDACS specification has been produced <xref target="GRA19"/> and is continuously updated; transmitter demonstrators were developed to test the spectrum compatibility of LDACS with legacy systems operating in the L-band <xref target="SAJ14"/>; and the overall system performance was analyzed by computer simulations, indicating that LDACS can fulfil the identified requirements <xref target="GRA11"/>.
            </t>
            <t>
                LDACS standardization within the framework of the ICAO started in December 2016. The ICAO standardization group has produced an initial Standards and Recommended Practices (SARPs) document <xref target="ICAO18"/>. The SARPs document defines the general characteristics of LDACS. The ICAO standardization group plans to produce an ICAO technical manual - the ICAO equivalent to a technical standard - within the next years. Generally, the group is open to input from all sources and develops LDACS in the open.
            </t>
            <t>
                Up to now LDACS standardization has been focused on the
                development of the physical layer and the data link layer, only
                recently have higher layers come into the focus of the LDACS
                development activities. There is currently no "IPv6 over LDACS"
                specification publicly available; however, SESAR2020 has started the
                testing of IPv6-based LDACS testbeds.
            </t>
            <t>
                The IPv6 architecture for the aeronautical telecommunication network
                is called the Future Communications Infrastructure (FCI). FCI shall
                support quality of service, diversity, and mobility under the umbrella
                of the "multi-link concept". This work is conducted by ICAO Communication Panel working group WG-I.
                
            </t>
            <t>
                In addition to standardization activities several industrial LDACS prototypes have been built. One set of LDACS prototypes has been evaluated in flight trials confirming the theoretical results predicting the system performance <xref target="GRA18"/> <xref target="SCH191"/>.
            </t>
        </section>
        
        <section anchor='Applicability'><name>Applicability</name>
            <t>
                LDACS is a multi-application cellular broadband system capable of simultaneously providing various kinds of Air Traffic Services (including ATS-B3) and Aeronautical Operational Control (AOC) communications services from deployed Ground Stations (GS). The LDACS A2G sub-system physical layer and data link layer are optimized for data link communications, but the system also supports digital air-ground voice communications.
            </t>
            <t>
                LDACS supports communication in all airspaces (airport, terminal maneuvering area, and en-route), and on the airport surface. The physical LDACS cell coverage is effectively de-coupled from the operational coverage required for a particular service. This is new in aeronautical communications. Services requiring wide-area coverage can be installed at several adjacent LDACS cells. The handover between the involved LDACS cells is seamless, automatic, and transparent to the user. Therefore, the LDACS A2G communications concept enables the aeronautical communication infrastructure to support future dynamic airspace management concepts.
            </t>
            
            <section anchor='Advances'><name>Advances Beyond the State-of-the-Art</name>
                <t>
                    LDACS offers several capabilities that are not provided in contemporarily deployed aeronautical communication systems.
                </t>
                
                <section anchor='Priorities'><name>Priorities</name>
                    <t>
                        LDACS is able to manage services priorities, an important feature not available in some of the current data link deployments. Thus, LDACS guarantees bandwidth, low latency, and high continuity of service for safety critical ATS applications while simultaneously accommodating less safety-critical AOC services.
                    </t>
                </section>
                
                <section anchor='Security'><name>Security</name>
                    <t>
                        LDACS is a secure data link with built-in security mechanisms. It enables secure data communications for ATS and AOC services, including secured private communications for aircraft operators and ANSPs (Air Navigation Service Providers). This includes concepts for key and trust management, mutual authenticated key exchange protocols, key derivation measures, user and control message-in-transit confidentiality and authenticity protection, secure logging and availability and robustness measures <xref target="MAE18"/>, <xref target="MAE191"/>, <xref target="MAE192"/>.
                    </t>
                </section>
                
                <section anchor='highdatarates'><name>High Data Rates</name>
                    <t>
                        The user data rate of LDACS is 315 kbit/s to 1428 kbit/s on the forward link (Ground-to-Air), and 294 kbit/s to 1390 kbit/s on the reverse link (Air-to-Ground), depending on coding and modulation. This is 50 times the amount terrestrial digital aeronautical communications systems such as VDLm2 provide <xref target="SCH191"/>.
                    </t>
                </section>
                
            </section>
            
            <section anchor='application'><name>Application</name>
            <t>
                LDACS shall be used by several aeronautical applications ranging from enhanced communication protocol stacks (multi-homed mobile IPv6 networks in the aircraft and potentially ad-hoc networks between aircraft) to classical communication applications (sending GBAS correction data) and integration with other service domains (using the communication signal for navigation).
            </t>
            
            
                <section anchor='MultilinkTechnology'><name>Air-to-Ground Multilink</name>
                    <t>
                    It is expected that LDACS together with upgraded satellite-based communications systems will be deployed within the Future Communication Infrastructure (FCI) and constitute one of the main components of the multilink concept within the FCI.
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        Both technologies, LDACS and satellite systems, have their specific benefits and technical capabilities which complement each other. Especially, satellite systems are well-suited for large coverage areas with less dense air traffic, e.g. oceanic regions. LDACS is well-suited for dense air traffic areas, e.g. continental areas or hot-spots around airports and terminal airspace. In addition, both technologies offer comparable data link capacity and, thus, are well-suited for redundancy, mutual back-up, or load balancing.
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        Technically the FCI multilink concept shall be realized by multi-homed mobile IPv6 networks in the aircraft. The related protocol stack is currently under development by ICAO and SESAR.
                    </t>
                </section>
                
                <section anchor='A2A'><name>Air-to-Air Extension for LDACS</name>
                    <t>
                        A potential extension of the multi-link concept is its extension to
                        ad-hoc networks between aircraft.
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        Direct Air-to-Air (A2A) communication between aircrafts in terms of ad-hoc data networks is currently considered a research topic since there is no immediate operational need for it, although several possible use cases are discussed (digital voice, wake vortex warnings, and trajectory negotiation) <xref target="BELL19"/>. It should also be noted that currently deployed analog VHF voice radios support direct voice communication between aircraft, making a similar use case for digital voice plausible.
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        LDACS direct A2A is currently not part of standardization.
                    </t>
                 </section>
                
                 <section anchor='FlightGuidance'><name>Flight Guidance</name>
                    <t>
                        The FCI (and therefore LDACS) shall be used to host flight guidance. This is realized using three applications:
                    </t><dl spacing='compact'>
                        <dt>1.</dt><dd>
                            Context Management (CM): The CM application shall manage the automatic logical connection to the ATC center currently responsible to guide the aircraft. Currently this is done by the air crew manually changing VHF voice frequencies according to the progress of the flight. The CM application automatically sets up equivalent sessions.
                        </dd>
                        <dt>2.</dt><dd>
                            Controller Pilot Data Link Communication (CPDLC): The CPDLC application provides the air crew with the ability to exchange data messages similar to text messages with the currently responsible ATC center. The CPDLC application shall take over most of the communication currently performed over VHF voice and enable new services that do not lend themselves to voice communication (e.g., trajectory negotiation).
                            
                        </dd>
                        <dt>3.</dt><dd>
                            Automatic Dependent Surveillance – Contract (ADS-C): ADS-C reports the position of the aircraft to the currently active ATC center. Reporting is bound to “contracts”, i.e. pre-defined events related to the progress of the flight (i.e. the trajectory). ADS-C and CPDLC are the primary applications used to implement in-flight trajectory management.
                        </dd>
                    </dl>
                    
                    <t>
                        CM, CPDLC, and ADS-C are available on legacy datalinks, but not widely deployed and with limited functionality.
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        Further ATC applications may be ported to use the FCI or LDACS as well. A notable application is GBAS for secure, automated landings: The Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) based Ground Based Augmentation System (GBAS) is used to improve the accuracy of GNSS to allow GNSS based instrument landings.  This is realized by sending GNSS correction data (e.g., compensating ionospheric errors in the GNSS signal) to the airborne GNSS receiver via a separate data link. Currently the VDB data link is used.  VDB is a narrow-band single-purpose datalink without advanced security only used to transmit GBAS correction data. This makes VDB a natural candidate for replacement by LDACS.
                    </t>
                 </section>
                
                 <section anchor='BusinessCommunicationofAirlines'><name>Business Communication of Airlines</name>
                    <t>
                        In addition to air traffic services airline operational control (AOC) services shall be transmitted over LDACS. AOC is a generic term referring to the business communication of airlines. Regulatory this is considered related to the safety and regularity of flight and may therefore be transmitted over LDACS.
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        AOC communication is considered the main business case for LDACS communication service providers since modern aircraft generate significant amounts of data (e.g., engine maintenance data).
                    </t>
                 </section>
              <!--      <t>
                        There are some challenges for the design of the LDACS A2A mode. First, the scarcity  of free spectrum in the L-band, where LDACS operates, significantly limits  the  design freedom with respect to the radiated power, suitable frequency allocations, and usable spectrum bandwidth. Second, in contrast to the LDACS  A2G, the LDACS A2A must be able to operate without any external support, given  that it must also support Aircraft-to-Aircraft communications in oceanic, remote, and polar (ORP) regions, and in autonomous operation areas, where support from  satellites or ground infrastructure might not be available.
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        Consequently, the LDACS A2A mode must provide means for the aircraft to establish and organize a communications ad-hoc network without any external support. Such a  network entails numerous additional challenges for the design, primarily in the  medium-access control and the network routing. To enable the new services  and  operational concepts, the LDACS A2A mode shall support broadcast communications,  for concepts such as self-separation and wake vortex prediction, and Point-to-Point communications to allow  aircraft to negotiate trajectories, resolve  conflicts, and use other aircraft as relays to enable communications beyond radio line-of-sight <xref target="BELL19"/>.
                    </t>
                </section>
                
                <section anchor='gbasvialdacs'><name>GBAS via LDACS for Secure, Automated Landings</name>
                    <t>
                        The Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) based Ground Based Augmentation System (GBAS) is used to improve the accuracy of GNSS to allow GNSS based instrument landings. This is realized by sending GNSS correction data (e.g., compensating ionospheric errors in the GNSS signal) to the airborne GNSS receiver via a separate data link. Currently the VDB data link is used. VDB is a narrow-band single-purpose datalink without advanced security only used to transmit GBAS correction data.
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        With GBAS evolving to GAST-D, allowing for safe and secure automatic CAT III landings for civil aircraft, it will have to be extended in multiple ways. VDB provides no cyber-security comparable to modern wireless networks. The VDB datalink will not be sufficient in bandwidth for GAST-D GBAS, as it lacks the necessary capacity to transmit additional corrections and parameters. VDB siting is also very difficult, as it requires Line of Sight (LoS) to work properly, which is difficult especially in the aircraft-on-the-apron situation. Fourthly, VDB has too little range for long-range approach calculations, forcing aircraft to wait for landing approach trajectories until when they are very close to the airport. A possible solution is the transition from the VDB datalink to LDACS for GBAS.
                    </t> -->
              
                
                <section anchor='LDACSNavigation'><name>LDACS Navigation</name>
                    <t>
                        Beyond communication radio signals can always also be used for navigation. LDACS takes this into account.
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        For future aeronautical navigation, ICAO recommends the further development of Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) based technologies as primary means for navigation. However, the drawback of GNSS is its inherent single point of failure - the satellite. Due to the large separation between navigational satellites and aircraft, the received power of GNSS signals on the ground is very low. As a result, GNSS disruptions might occasionally occur due to unintentional interference, or intentional jamming. Yet the navigation services must be available with sufficient performance for all phases of flight. Therefore, during GNSS outages, or blockages, an alternative solution is needed. This is commonly referred to as Alternative Positioning, Navigation, and Timing (APNT).
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        One of such APNT solution consists of integrating the navigation functionality into LDACS. The ground infrastructure for APNT is deployed through the implementation of LDACS ground stations and the navigation capability comes "for free".
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        LDACS navigation has already been demonstrated in practice in a flight measurement campaign <xref target="SCH191"/>.
                    </t>
                </section>
            
        </section>
    </section>
        
        
    <section anchor='Characteristics'><name>Characteristics of LDACS</name>
        <t>
            LDACS will become one of several wireless access networks connecting aircraft to the Aeronautical Telecommunications Network (ATN) implemented by the FCI and possibly ACARS/FANS networks <xref target="FAN19"/>.
        </t>
            
            
        <section anchor='LDACSSub-Network'><name>LDACS Sub-Network</name>
            <t>
                An LDACS sub-network contains an Access Router (AR), a Ground-Station Controller (GSC), and several Ground-Stations (GS), each of them providing one LDACS radio cell.
            </t>
            <t>
                User plane interconnection to the ATN is facilitated by the Access Router (AR) peering with an Air-to-Ground Router (A2G Router) connected to the ATN. It is up to implementer’s choice to keep Access Router and Air-Ground Router functions separated, or to merge them.
            </t>
            <t>
                The internal control plane of an LDACS sub-network is managed by the Ground-Station Controller (GSC). An LDACS sub-network is illustrated in <xref target="fig_LDACSwirelesstopology"/>.
            </t>
            
            <figure title="LDACS sub-network with two GSs and one AS"  anchor="fig_LDACSwirelesstopology">
                <artwork>
                    <![CDATA[
                            
wireless      user
link          plane
  A--------------G-------------Access---A2G-----ATN
  S..............S             Router   Router
                 . control      . |
                 . plane        . |
                 .              . |
                 GSC..............|
                 .                |
                 .                |
                 GS---------------+
                            
                            
                    ]]>
                </artwork>
            </figure>
                
        </section>

        <section anchor='topology'><name>Topology</name>
            <t>
                LDACS operating in A2G mode is a cellular point-to-multipoint system. The A2G mode assumes a star-topology in each cell where Airborne Stations (AS) belonging to aircraft within a certain volume of space (the LDACS cell) is connected to the controlling GS. The LDACS GS is a centralized instance that controls LDACS A2G communications within its cell. The LDACS GS can simultaneously support multiple bi-directional communications to the ASs under its control. LDACS ground stations themselves are connected to a ground station controller (GSC) controlling the LDACS sub-network.
            </t>
            <t>
                Prior to utilizing the system an AS has to register with the controlling GS to establish dedicated logical channels for user and control data. Control channels have statically allocated resources, while user channels have dynamically assigned resources according to the current demand. Logical channels exist only between the GS and the AS.
            </t>
            <t>
                The LDACS wireless link protocol stack defines two layers, the physical layer and the data link layer.
            </t>
        </section>

        <section anchor='LDACSPhysicalLayer'><name>LDACS Physical Layer</name>
            <t>
                The physical layer provides the means to transfer data over the radio channel. The LDACS GS supports bi-directional links to multiple aircraft under its control. The forward link direction (FL; G2A) and the reverse link direction (RL; A2G) are separated by frequency division duplex. Forward link and reverse link use a 500 kHz channel each. The ground-station transmits a continuous stream of Orthogonal Frequency-Division Multiplexing (OFDM) symbols on the forward link. In the reverse link different aircraft are separated in time and frequency using a combination of Orthogonal Frequency-Division Multiple-Access (OFDMA) and Time-Division Multiple-Access (TDMA). Aircraft thus transmit discontinuously on the reverse link with radio bursts sent in precisely defined transmission opportunities allocated by the ground-station.
            </t>
        </section>
            
        <section anchor='LDACSDataLinkLayer'><name>LDACS Data Link Layer</name>
            <t>
                The data-link layer provides the necessary protocols to facilitate concurrent and reliable data transfer for multiple users. The LDACS data link layer is organized in two sub-layers: The medium access sub-layer and the logical link control sub-layer. The medium access sub-layer manages the organization of transmission opportunities in slots of time and frequency. The logical link control sub-layer provides acknowledged point-to-point logical channels between the aircraft and the ground-station using an automatic repeat request protocol.  LDACS supports also unacknowledged point-to-point channels and G2A broadcast.
            </t>
        </section>
            
        <section anchor='LDACSMobility'><name>LDACS Mobility</name>
            <t>
                LDACS supports layer 2 handovers to different LDACS channels. Handovers may be initiated by the aircraft (break-before-make) or by the GS (make-before-break).  Make-before-break handovers are only supported for ground-stations connected to the same GSC.
            </t>
            <t>
                External handovers between non-connected LDACS sub-networks or different aeronautical data links shall be handled by the FCI multi-link concept.
            </t>
        </section>
            
         <!--   <section anchor='LDACSDataRates'><name>LDACS Data Rates</name>
                <t>
                    The user data rate of LDACS is 315 kbit/s to 1428 kbit/s on the
                    forward link, and 294 kbit/s to 1390 kbit/s on the reverse link,
                    depending on coding and modulation.
                    
                </t>
            </section> -->
    </section>
            
    <section anchor='ReliabilityandAvailability'><name>Reliability and Availability</name>
        <t>
            LDACS has been designed with applications related to the safety and regularity of flight in mind.  It has therefore been designed as a deterministic wireless data link (as far as this is possible).
        </t>
        <t>
            Based on channel measurements of the L-band channel <xref target="SCHN2016"/> and respecting the specific nature of the area of application, LDACS was designed from the PHY layer up with robustness in mind.
        </t>
        <t>
            In order to maximize the capacity per channel and to optimally use the available spectrum, LDACS was designed as an OFDM-based FDD system, supporting simultaneous transmissions in Forward Link (FL; G2A) and Reverse Link (RL; A2G). The legacy systems already deployed in the L-band limit the bandwidth of both channels to approximately 500 kHz.
        </t>
        <t>
            The LDACS physical layer design includes propagation guard times sufficient for the operation at a maximum distance of 200 nautical miles from the GS. In actual deployment, LDACS can be configured for any range up to this maximum range.
        </t>
        <t>
            The LDACS FL physical layer is a continuous OFDM transmission. LDACS RL transmission is based on OFDMA-TDMA bursts, with silence between such bursts. The RL resources (i.e. bursts) are assigned to different users (ASs) on demand by the ground station (GS).
        </t>
        <t>
            The LDACS physical layer supports adaptive coding and modulation for user data. Control data is always encoded with the most robust coding and modulation (QPSK coding rate 1/2).
        </t>
        <t>
            LDACS medium access on top of the physical layer uses a static frame structure to support deterministic timer management. As shown in figure 3 and 4, LDACS framing structure is based on Super-Frames (SF) of 240ms duration corresponding to 2000 OFDM symbols. FL and RL boundaries are aligned in time (from the GS perspective) allowing for deterministic sending windows for KEEP ALIVE messages and control and data channels in general.
        </t>
        <t>
            LDACS medium access is always under the control of the GS of a radio cell.  Any medium access for the transmission of user data has to be requested with a resource request message stating the requested amount of resources and class of service. The GS performs resource scheduling on the basis of these requests and grants resources with resource allocation messages. Resource request and allocation messages are exchanged over dedicated contention-free control channels.
        </t>
        <t>
            LDACS has two mechanisms to request resources from the scheduler in the GS.
        </t>
        <t>
            Resources can either be requested "on demand" with a given priority. On the forward link, this is done locally in the GS, on the reverse link a dedicated contention-free control channel is used called Dedicated Control Channel (DCCH; roughly 83 bit every 60 ms).  A resource allocation is always announced in the control channel of the forward link (Common Control Channel (CCCH); variably sized).  Due to the spacing of the reverse link control channels every 60 ms, a medium access delay in the same order of magnitude is to be expected.
        </t>
        <t>
            Resources can also be requested "permanently". The permanent resource request mechanism supports requesting recurring resources in given time intervals. A permanent resource request has to be canceled by the user (or by the ground-station, which is always in control).
        </t>
        <t>
            User data transmissions over LDACS are therefore always scheduled by the GS, while control data uses statically (i.e. at cell entry) allocated recurring resources (DCCH and CCCH). The current specification specifies no scheduling algorithm. Scheduling of reverse link resources is done in physical Protocol Data Units (PDU) of 112 bit (or larger if more aggressive coding and modulation is used).  Scheduling on the forward link is done Byte- wise since the forward link is transmitted continuously by the GS.
        </t>
        <t>
            In addition to having full control over resource scheduling, the GS can send forced Handover (HO) commands for off-loading or RF channel management, e.g. when the signal quality declines and a more suitable GS is in the AS reach. With robust resource management of the capacities of the radio channel, reliability and robustness measures are therefore also anchored in the LDACS management entity.
        </t>
        <t>
            The LDACS data link layer protocol running on top of the medium access sub-layer uses ARQ to provide reliable data transmission on layer 2.
        </t>
        <t>
            It employs selective repeat ARQ with transparent fragmentation and reassembly to the resource allocation size to achieve low latency and a low overhead without losing reliability. It ensures correct order of packet delivery without duplicates. In case of transmission errors it identifies lost fragments with deterministic timers synced to the medium access frame structure and initiates retransmission. Additionally the priority mechanism of LDACS ensures the timely delivery of messages with high importance.
        </t>
        <t>
            As of now no reliability and availability mechanisms for layer 3 and above have been specified.
        </t>
    </section>
            
           <!--     <section anchor='LDACSMediumAccess'><name>LDACS Medium Access</name>
                    <t>
                        LDACS medium access is always under the control of the ground-station
                        of a radio cell. Any medium access for the transmission of user data
                        has to be requested with a resource request message stating the
                        requested amount of resources and class of service. The ground-
                        station performs resource scheduling on the basis of these requests
                        and grants resources with resource allocation messages. Resource
                        request and allocation messages are exchanged over dedicated
                        contention-free control channels.
                        
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        LDACS has two mechanisms to request resources from the scheduler in
                        the ground-station.
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        Resources can either be requested "on demand" with a given class of service. On the forward link, this is done locally in the ground-station, on the reverse link a dedicated contention-free control channel is used called Dedicated Control Channel (DCCH; roughly 83 bit every 60 ms). A resource allocation is always announced in the control channel of the forward link (Common Control Channel (CCCH); variable sized). Due to the spacing of the reverse link control channels every 60 ms, a medium access delay in the same order of magnitude is to be expected.
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        Resources can also be requested "permanently". The permanent
                        resource request mechanism supports requesting recurring resources in
                        given time intervals. A permanent resource request has to be
                        canceled by the user (or by the ground-station, which is always in
                        control).
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        User data transmissions over LDACS are therefore always
                        scheduled by the ground-station, while control data uses statically
                        (i.e. at cell entry) allocated recurring resources (DCCH and CCCH).
                        The current specification documents specify no scheduling algorithm.
                        However performance evaluations so far have used strict priority
                        scheduling and round robin for equal priorities for simplicity. In
                        the current prototype implementations LDACS classes of service are
                        thus realized as priorities of medium access and not as flows. Note
                        that this can starve out low priority flows. However, this is not
                        seen as a big problem since safety related message always go first in
                        any case. Scheduling of reverse link resources is done in physical
                        Protocol Data Units (PDU) of 112 bit (or larger if more aggressive
                        coding and modulation is used). Scheduling on the forward link is
                        done Byte-wise since the forward link is transmitted continuously
                        by the ground-station.
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        The LDACS data link layer protocol running on top of the medium access
                        sub-layer uses ARQ to provide reliable data transmission.
                    </t>
                </section>
            -->
                
           <!--     <section anchor='LDACSMobility'><name>LDACS Mobility</name>
                    <t>
                        The LDACS mobility service manages in the GSC and LME cell entry, cell exit and handover between cells.
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        LDACS supports internal handovers to different RF channels. Handovers
                        may be initiated by the aircraft (break-before-make) or by the ground-
                        station (make-before-break). Make-before-break handovers are only supported
                        for ground-stations connected to the same ground-station controller.
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        External handovers between non-connected LDACS deployments or different aeronautical data links shall be handled by the FCI multi-link concept.
                        
                    </t>
                </section>
                
                <section anchor='LDACSIncrementalDeployment'><name>LDACS Incremental Deployment</name>
                    <t>
                        The LDACS data link provides enhanced capabilities to the future IPv6 based ATN enabling it to better support user needs and new applications. The deployment scalability of LDACS allows its implementation to start in areas where most needed to improve immediately the performance of already fielded infrastructure. Later the deployment is extended based on operational demand.
                        
                    </t>
                </section>
                
            </section> -->
       
       
        
        <section anchor='ProtocolStack'><name>Protocol Stack</name>
            <t>
                The protocol stack of LDACS is implemented in the AS, GS, and GSC:
                It consists of the Physical Layer (PHY) with five major
                functional blocks above it. Four are placed in the Data Link Layer
                (DLL) of the AS and GS: (1) Medium Access Layer (MAC), (2) Voice
                Interface (VI), (3) Data Link Service (DLS), (4) LDACS Management
                Entity (LME). The last entity resides within the sub-network layer:
                Sub-Network Protocol (SNP). The LDACS network is externally connected
                to voice units, radio control units, and the ATN network layer.
            </t>

            <t>
                <xref target="fig_LDACSprotocolstack"/> shows the protocol stack of LDACS as implemented in the AS and GS.
            </t>
                
                <figure title="LDACS protocol stack in AS and GS"  anchor="fig_LDACSprotocolstack">
                    <artwork>
                        <![CDATA[
                            
         IPv6                   network layer
          |
          |
+------------------+  +----+
|        SNP       |--|    |   sub-network
|                  |  |    |   layer
+------------------+  |    |
          |           | LME|
+------------------+  |    |
|        DLS       |  |    |   logical link
|                  |  |    |   control layer
+------------------+  +----+
          |             |
         DCH         DCCH/CCCH
          |          RACH/BCCH
          |             |
+--------------------------+
|           MAC            |   medium access
|                          |   layer
+--------------------------+
             |
+--------------------------+
|           PHY            |   physical layer
+--------------------------+
             |
             |
           ((*))
           FL/RL              radio channels
                              separated by FDD
                            
                        ]]>
                    </artwork>
                </figure>
                
                <section anchor='MediumAccessControlMACEntityServices'><name>Medium Access Control (MAC) Entity Services</name>
                    <t>
                        The MAC time framing service provides the frame
                        structure necessary to realize slot-based Time Division Multiplex
                        (TDM) access on the physical link. It provides the functions for the
                        synchronization of the MAC framing structure and the PHY layer
                        framing. The MAC time framing provides a dedicated time slot for
                        each logical channel.
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        The MAC sub-layer offers access to the
                        physical channel to its service users. Channel access is provided
                        through transparent logical channels. The MAC sub-layer maps logical
                        channels onto the appropriate slots and manages the access to these
                        channels. Logical channels are used as interface between the MAC and
                        LLC sub-layers.
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        The LDACS framing structure for FL and RL is based on Super-Frames
                        (SF) of 240 ms duration. Each SF corresponds to 2000 OFDM symbols.
                        The FL and RL SF boundaries are aligned in time (from the view of the
                        GS).
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        In the FL, an SF contains a Broadcast Frame of duration 6.72 ms
                        (56 OFDM symbols) for the Broadcast Control Channel (BCCH), and four Multi-Frames (MF), each of duration
                        58.32 ms (486 OFDM symbols).
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        In the RL, each SF starts with a Random Access (RA) slot of length
                        6.72 ms with two opportunities for sending reverse link random
                        access frames for the Random Access Channel (RACH), followed by four MFs. These MFs have the same fixed
                        duration of 58.32 ms as in the FL, but a different internal
                        structure
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        <xref target="fig_LDACSframesuper"/> and <xref target="fig_LDACSframesmulti"/> illustrates the LDACS frame structure.
                    </t>

                     <figure title="LDACS super-frame structure"  anchor="fig_LDACSframesuper">
                            <artwork>
                                <![CDATA[
^
|     +------+------------+------------+------------+------------+
|  FL | BCCH |     MF     |     MF     |     MF     |     MF     |
F     +------+------------+------------+------------+------------+
r     <---------------- Super-Frame (SF) - 240ms ---------------->
e
q     +------+------------+------------+------------+------------+
u  RL | RACH |     MF     |     MF     |     MF     |     MF     |
e     +------+------------+------------+------------+------------+
n     <---------------- Super-Frame (SF) - 240ms ---------------->
c
y
|
----------------------------- Time ------------------------------>
|
                                ]]>
                            </artwork>
                        </figure>
                        
                        <figure title="LDACS multi-frame (MF) structure"  anchor="fig_LDACSframesmulti">
                            <artwork>
                                <![CDATA[
^
|     +-------------+------+-------------+
|  FL |     DCH     | CCCH |     DCH     |
F     +-------------+------+-------------+
r     <---- Multi-Frame (MF) - 58.32ms -->
e
q     +------+---------------------------+
u  RL | DCCH |             DCH           |
e     +------+---------------------------+
n     <---- Multi-Frame (MF) - 58.32ms -->
c
y
|
----------------------------- Time ------------------------------>
|
                                ]]>
                            </artwork>
                        </figure>
                </section>
                
                
                
                <section anchor='DataLinkServiceDLSEntityServices'><name>Data Link Service (DLS) Entity Services</name>
                    <t>
                        The DLS provides acknowledged and unacknowledged (including broadcast and packet mode voice) bi-directional exchange of user data. If user data is transmitted using the acknowledged data link service, the sending DLS entity will wait for an acknowledgement from the receiver. If no acknowledgement is received within a specified time frame, the sender may automatically try to retransmit its data. However, after a certain number of failed retries, the sender will suspend further retransmission attempts and inform its client of the failure.
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        The data link service uses the logical channels provided by the MAC:
                    </t><dl spacing='compact'>
                        <dt>1.</dt><dd>
                            A ground-stations announces its existence and access parameters in
                            the Broadcast Channel (BC).
                        </dd>
                        <dt>2.</dt><dd>
                            The Random Access Channel (RA) enables AS to request access
                            to an LDACS cell.
                        </dd>
                        <dt>3.</dt><dd>
                            In the Forward Link (FL) the Common Control Channel (CCCH) is
                            used by the GS to grant access to data channel resources.
                        </dd>
                        <dt>4.</dt><dd>
                            The reverse direction is covered by the Reverse Link (RL), where
                            aircraft-stations need to request resources before sending.
                            This happens via the Dedicated Common Control Channel (DCCH).
                        </dd>
                        <dt>5.</dt><dd>
                            User data itself is communicated in the Data Channel (DCH) on the
                            FL and RL.
                        </dd>
                    </dl>
                </section>
                
                
              
                <section anchor='VoiceInterfaceVIServices'><name>Voice Interface (VI) Services</name>
                    <t>
                        The VI provides support for virtual voice circuits. Voice circuits may either be set-up permanently by the GS (e.g., to emulate voice party line) or may be created on demand. The creation and selection of voice circuits is performed in the LME. The VI provides only the transmission services.
                    </t>
                </section>
                
                <section anchor='LinkManagementEntityLMEServices'><name>LDACS Management Entity (LME) Services</name>
                    <t>
                        The mobility management service in the LME provides
                        support for registration and de-registration (cell entry and cell
                        exit), scanning RF channels of neighboring cells and handover
                        between cells. In addition, it manages the addressing of aircraft/
                        ASs within cells. It is controlled by the network management service
                        in the GSC.
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        The resource management service provides
                        link maintenance (power, frequency and time adjustments), support for
                        adaptive coding and modulation (ACM), and resource allocation.
                    </t>
                </section>
                
                <section anchor='Sub-NetworkProtocolSNPServices'><name>Sub-Network Protocol (SNP) Services</name>
                    <t>
                        The data link service provides functions required
                        for the transfer of user plane data and control plane data over the
                        LDACS sub-network.
                    </t>
                    <t>
                        The security service provides functions for
                        secure communication over the LDACS sub-network. Note that the SNP
                        security service applies cryptographic measures as configured by the
                        ground station controller.
                    </t>
                </section>
            </section>
            
            
        <section anchor='Security2'><name>Security Considerations</name>
            <t>
                Aviation will require secure exchanges of data and voice messages for managing the air-traffic flow safely through the airspaces all over the world. The main communication method for ATC today is still an open analogue voice broadcast within the aeronautical VHF band. Currently, the information security is purely procedural based by using well-trained personnel and proven communications procedures. This communication method has been in service since 1948. Future digital communications waveforms will need additional embedded security features to fulfill modern information security requirements like authentication and integrity. These security features require sufficient bandwidth which is beyond the capabilities of a VHF narrowband communications system. For voice and data communications, sufficient data throughput capability is needed to support the security functions while not degrading performance. LDACS is a mature data link technology with sufficient bandwidth to support security.
            </t>
            <t>
                Security considerations for LDACS are defined by the official ICAO SARPS <xref target="ICAO18"/>:

            </t><dl spacing='compact'>
                <dt>1.</dt><dd>
                    LDACS shall provide a capability to protect the availability and continuity of the system.</dd>
                <dt>2.</dt><dd>
                    LDACS shall provide a capability including cryptographic mechanisms to protect the integrity of messages in transit.
                </dd>
                <dt>3.</dt><dd>
                    LDACS shall provide a capability to ensure the authenticity of messages in transit.
                </dd>
                <dt>4.</dt><dd>
                    LDACS should provide a capability for nonrepudiation of origin for messages in transit.
                </dd>
                <dt>5.</dt><dd>
                    LDACS should provide a capability to protect the confidentiality of messages in transit.
                </dd>
                <dt>6.</dt><dd>
                    LDACS shall provide an authentication capability.
                </dd>
                <dt>7.</dt><dd>
                    LDACS shall provide a capability to authorize the permitted actions of users of the system and to deny actions that are not explicitly authorized.
                </dd>
                <dt>8.</dt><dd>
                    If LDACS provides interfaces to multiple domains, LDACS shall provide capability to prevent the propagation of intrusions within LDACS domains and towards external domains.
                </dd>
            </dl><t>

            </t>
            <t> The cybersecurity architecture of LDACS <xref target="ICAO18"/>, <xref target="MAE18"/> and its extensions <xref target="MAE191"/>, <xref target="MAE192"/> regard all of the aforementioned requirements, since LDACS has been mainly designed for air traffic management communication. Thus it supports mutual entity authentication, integrity and confidentiality capabilities of user data messages and some control channel protection capabilities <xref target="MAE192"/>.
            </t>
        </section>

        <section anchor='PrivacyConsiderations'><name>Privacy Considerations</name>
            <t> LDACS provides a Quality of Service (QoS), and the generic considerations for
                such mechanisms apply.</t>
        </section>

        <!-- Possibly a 'Contributors' section ... -->
        
        <section anchor='IANA'><name>IANA Considerations</name>
            <t>This memo includes no request to IANA.</t>
            
        </section>


        <section anchor='Acknowledgements'><name>Acknowledgements</name>
            <t>
                Thanks to all contributors to the development of
                LDACS and ICAO PT-T.
            </t>
            <t>
                Thanks to Klaus-Peter Hauf, Bart Van Den Einden, and Pierluigi Fantappie for further input to this draft.
            </t>
            <t>
                Thanks to SBA Research Vienna for fruitful discussions on aeronautical communications concerning security incentives for industry and potential economic spillovers.
            </t>
        </section>




    </middle>

    <!--  *****BACK MATTER ***** -->

    <back>
        <!-- References split into informative and normative -->

        <!-- There are 2 ways to insert reference entries from the citation libraries:
         1. define an ENTITY at the top, and use "ampersand character"RFC2629; here (as shown)
         2. simply use a PI "less than character"?rfc include="reference.RFC.2119.xml"?> here
         (for I-Ds: include="reference.I-D.narten-iana-considerations-rfc2434bis.xml")

         Both are cited textually in the same manner: by using xref elements.
         If you use the PI option, xml2rfc will, by default, try to find included files in the same
         directory as the including file. You can also define the XML_LIBRARY environment variable
         with a value containing a set of directories to search.  These can be either in the local
         filing system or remote ones accessed by http (http://domain/dir/... ).-->

<!--<displayreference   target="I-D.pthubert-raw-problem-statement"       to="RAW-PROBLEM"/>-->
<displayreference   target="I-D.thubert-raw-technologies"             to="RAW-TECHNOS"/>
<displayreference   target="I-D.bernardos-raw-use-cases"              to="RAW-USE-CASES"/>

        <references><name>Normative References</name>

<!-- Reliable and Available Wireless Technologies -->


        </references>

        <references><name>Informative References</name>
            
        <reference anchor="SCHN2016"> <!--REF1-->
            <front>
                <title>Measurement of the L-band Air-to-Ground Channel for Positioning Applications
                </title>
                <author initials="N." surname="Schneckenburger"/>
                <author initials="T." surname="Jost"/>
                <author initials="D." surname="Shutin"/>
                <author initials="M." surname="Walter"/>
                <author initials="T." surname="Thiasiriphet"/>
                <author initials="M." surname="Schnell"/>
                <author initials="U.C." surname="Fiebig"/>
                <date year="2016"/>
            </front>
            <seriesInfo name='IEEE Transactions on Aerospace and Electronic Systems, 52(5), pp.2281-229' value=''/>
        </reference>

        <reference anchor="MAE191"> <!--REF1-->
            <front>
                <title>Evaluation of the LDACS Cybersecurity Implementation
                </title>
                <author initials="N." surname="Maeurer"/>
                <author initials="T." surname="Graeupl"/>
                <author initials="C." surname="Schmitt"/>
                <date year="2019"/>
            </front>
            <seriesInfo name='IEEE 38th Digital Avionics Systems Conference (DACS), pp. 1-10, San Diego, CA, USA' value=''/>
        </reference>
        
        <reference anchor="MAE192"> <!--REF2-->
            <front>
                <title>Towards Successful Realization of the LDACS Cybersecurity Architecture: An Updated Datalink Security Threat- and Risk Analysis
                </title>
                <author initials="N." surname="Maeurer"/>
                <author initials="C." surname="Schmitt"/>
                <date year="2019"/>
            </front>
            <seriesInfo name='IEEE Integrated Communications, Navigation and Surveillance Conference (ICNS),  pp. 1-13, Herndon, VA, USA' value=''/>
        </reference>
        
        
        <reference anchor="GRA19"> <!--REF3-->
            <front>
                <title>LDACS A/G Specification
                </title>
                <author initials="T." surname="Graeupl"/>
                <author initials="C." surname="Rihacek"/>
                <author initials="B." surname="Haindl"/>
                <date year="2019"/>
            </front>
            <seriesInfo name='SESAR2020 PJ14-02-01 D3.3.030' value=''/>
        </reference>
        
        <reference anchor="FAN19"> <!--REF3-->
            <front>
                <title>LDACS Deployment Options and Recommendations
                </title>
                <author initials="S." surname="Pierattelli"/>
                <author initials="P." surname="Fantappie"/>
                <author initials="S." surname="Tamalet"/>
                <author initials="B." surname="van den Einden"/>
                <author initials="C." surname="Rihacek"/>
                <author initials="T." surname="Graeupl"/>
                <date year="2019"/>
            </front>
            <seriesInfo name='SESAR2020 PJ14-02-01 D3.4.020' value=''/>
        </reference>
        
        
    <!--    <reference anchor="REF4">
            <front>
                <title>Transmitting GBAS Messages via LDACS
                </title>
                <author initials="M." surname="Felux"/>
                <author initials="T." surname="Graeupl"/>
                <author initials="N." surname="Maeurer"/>
                <author initials="M." surname="Stanisak"/>
                <date year="2018"/>
            </front>
            <seriesInfo name='IEEE 37th Digital Avionics Systems Conference (DASC), pp. 1-7, New York, NY, USA' value=''/>
        </reference>-->
        
    <!--    <reference anchor="REF5">
            <front>
                <title>Update on LDACS - The FCI Terrestrial Data Link
                </title>
                <author initials="M." surname="Schnell"/>
                <date year="2019"/>
            </front>
            <seriesInfo name='IEEE 19th Integrated Communications, Navigation and Surveillance Conference (ICNS), pp. 1-10, New York, NY, USA' value=''/>
        </reference>-->
        
        
 <!--       <reference anchor="REF6">
            <front>
                <title>Using the Future L-band Communication System for Navigation
                </title>
                <author initials="M." surname="Schnell"/>
                <author initials="U." surname="Epple"/>
                <author initials="F." surname="Hoffmann"/>
                <date year="2011"/>
            </front>
            <seriesInfo name='IEEE 11th Integrated Communications, Nav-
            igation and Surveillance Conference (ICNS), pp. J1/1-J1/12, New York, NY, USA' value=''/>
        </reference> -->
        
        
 <!--       <reference anchor="REF7">
            <front>
                <title>Improving the Availability of LDACS-based APNT with Air-to-Air Ranging
                </title>
                <author initials="O." surname="Osechas"/>
                <author initials="G." surname="Berz"/>
                <date year="2016"/>
            </front>
            <seriesInfo name='IEEE/ION Position, Location and Naviga-
            tion Symposium (PLANS), pp. 91-99, New York, NY, USA' value=''/>
        </reference> -->
        
<!--        <reference anchor="REF8">
            <front>
                <title>Ambiguity Function Analysis for OFDM-Based LDACS Passive Multistatic Radar
                </title>
                <author initials="A." surname="Filip"/>
                <author initials="D." surname="Shutin"/>
                <date year="2017"/>
            </front>
            <seriesInfo name='IEEE Transactions on Aerospace and Electronic Systems, vol. 54, no. 3, pp. 1323-1340, New York, NY, USA' value=''/>
        </reference> -->
        
        
        <reference anchor="MAE18"> <!--REF9-->
            <front>
                <title>A Cybersecurity Architecture for the L-band Digital Aeronautical Communications System (LDACS)
                </title>
                <author initials="N." surname="Maeurer"/>
                <author initials="A." surname="Bilzhause"/>
                <date year="2017"/>
            </front>
            <seriesInfo name='IEEE 37th Digital Avionics Systems Conference (DASC), pp. 1-10, London, UK' value=''/>
        </reference>
        
        
        <reference anchor="GRA11"> <!--REF10-->
            <front>
                <title>L-DACS1 Data Link Layer Evolution of ATN/IPS
                </title>
                <author initials="T." surname="Graeupl"/>
                <author initials="M." surname="Ehammer"/>
                <date year="2011"/>
            </front>
            <seriesInfo name='30th IEEE/AIAA Digital Avionics Systems Conference (DASC), pp. 1-28, Seattle, WA, USA' value=''/>
        </reference>
        
        <reference anchor="GRA18"> <!--REF11-->
            <front>
                <title>L-band Digital Aeronautical Communications System (LDACS) flight trials in the national German project MICONAV
                </title>
                <author initials="T." surname="Graeupl"/>
                <author initials="N." surname="Schneckenburger"/>
                <author initials="T." surname="Jost"/>
                <author initials="M." surname="Schnell"/>
                <author initials="A." surname="Filip"/>
                <author initials="M.A." surname="Bellido-Manganell"/>
                <author initials="D.M." surname="Mielke"/>
                <author initials="N." surname="Maeurer"/>
                <author initials="R." surname="Kumar"/>
                <author initials="O." surname="Osechas"/>
                <author initials="G." surname="Battista"/>
                <date year="2018"/>
            </front>
            <seriesInfo name='Integrated Communications, Navigation, Surveillance Conference (ICNS), pp. 1-7, Herndon, VA, USA' value=''/>
        </reference>
        
        <reference anchor="SCH191"> <!--REF12-->
            <front>
                <title>DLR Tests Digital Communications Technologies Combined with Additional Navigation Functions for the First Time
                </title>
                <author initials="M." surname="Schnell"/>
                <date year="2019"/>
            </front>
            <!--<seriesInfo name='https://www.dlr.de/dlr/en/desktopdefault.aspx/tabid-10081/151_read-32951/#/gallery/33877 value=''/> -->
        </reference>
        
        <!--<reference anchor="SCH192">
            <front>
                <title>Update on LDACS - The FCI Terrestrial Data Link
                </title>
                <author initials="M." surname="Schnell"/>
                <date year="2019"/>
            </front>
            <seriesInfo name='19th Integrated Communications, Navigation and Surveillance Conference (ICNS), pp. 1-10, New York, NY, USA' value=''/>
        </reference>-->
        
        <reference anchor="ICAO18"> <!--REF13-->
            <front>
                <title>L-Band Digital Aeronautical Communication System (LDACS)
                </title>
                <author initials="" surname="International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO)"/>
                <date year="2018"/>
            </front>
            <seriesInfo name='International Standards and Recommended Practices Annex 10 - Aeronautical Telecommunications, Vol. III - Communication Systems' value=''/>
        </reference>
        
        <reference anchor="SAJ14">
            <front>
                <title>LDACS1 Conformance and Compatibility Assessment
                </title>
                <author initials="B." surname="Haindl"/>
                <author initials="J." surname="Meser"/>
                <author initials="M." surname="Sajatovic"/>
                <author initials="S." surname="Mueller"/>
                <author initials="H." surname="Arthaber"/>
                <author initials="T." surname="Faseth"/>
                <author initials="M." surname="Zaisberger"/>
                <date year="2014"/>
            </front>
            <seriesInfo name='IEEE/AIAA 33rd Digital Avionics Systems Conference (DASC), pp. 1-11, Colorado Springs, CO, USA' value=''/>
        </reference>
        <!--https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/6979447-->
        
        <reference anchor="RIH18"> <!--REF3-->
            <front>
                <title>L-band Digital Aeronautical Communications System (LDACS) Activities in SESAR2020
                </title>
                <author initials="C." surname="Rihacek"/>
                <author initials="B." surname="Haindl"/>
                <author initials="P." surname="Fantappie"/>
                <author initials="S." surname="Pierattelli"/>
                <author initials="T." surname="Graeupl"/>
                <author initials="M." surname="Schnell"/>
                <author initials="N." surname="Fistas"/>
                <date year="2018"/>
            </front>
            <seriesInfo name='Integrated Communications Navigation and Surveillance Conference (ICNS), pp. 1-8, Herndon, VA, USA' value=''/>
        </reference>
        
        <reference anchor="BELL19"> <!--BELL19-->
            <front>
                <title>Towards Modern Air-to-Air Communications: the LDACS A2A Mode
                </title>
                <author initials="M. A." surname="Bellido-Manganell"/>
                <author initials="M." surname="Schnell"/>
                <date year="2019"/>
            </front>
            <seriesInfo name='IEEE/AIAA 38th Digital Avionics Systems Conference (DASC), pp. 1-10, San Diego, CA, USA' value=''/>
        </reference>

<xi:include href="http://xml2rfc.tools.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml3/reference.I-D.thubert-raw-technologies.xml"/>
<!-- Reliable and Available Wireless Technologies -->

<xi:include href="http://xml2rfc.tools.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml3/reference.I-D.bernardos-raw-use-cases.xml"/>
<!-- RAW use cases -->

        </references>

    </back>
</rfc>


<!-- CONVERT WARNING: wide character found at character 2254 of the output -->
