Minutes of the 1st IETF Trade Working Group Meeting: Wednesday August 26th, 1998 9 am-11:30 AM 1. Donald Eastlake started the 1st IETF Trade Working Group meeting with the following agenda: 0. Agenda Bashing (5 minutes) 1. Status of Implementation a. Royal Bank of Canada (15 minutes) b. other(s)? 2. v1.0 Status of Documents (15 minutes) a. Main 1.0 OTP Draft b. OTP Digital Signatures c. OTP architecutre d. OTP over HTTP e. SET over OTP f. Secure Channel Credit/Debit over OTP g. Electronic cash over OTP 3. v1.0 Technical Issues (40 minutes) a. Digital Signatures b. other technical issues 4. v2.0 Planning (30 minutes) Disucssion of how to proceed towards a fuller OTP 5. Future meetings (15 minutes) a. September at CyberCash in Virginia b. November at Hitachi in Japan c. December at IETF Unfortunately a number of documents were not ready in time and so could not be substantively discussed. 2. Group members raised many questions regarding the trade charter. Donald advised them to discuss that on the list. 3. IOTP 1.0 will be published as informational RFC. 4. Group felt that we need to come up with requirements for 2.0 work which will be carried out under IETF Working Group. Donald pointed Business Functional requirements of the IOTP 1.0 spec would be a good candidates for starting of discussions on IOTP 2.0 requirements. 5. Donald requested the group members to send their suggestions/comments on transitioning IOTP specification development from OTP Consortium to IETF. 6. Implementation Status of IOTP Spec 0.9: RBC(Royal Bank of Canada) has implemented OTP product based on otp .9 spec. Waiting for Chris Smith's report on the completeness of the .9 spec and hence released 99. 7. Donald explained the difference between OBI (Open Buying on the Internet) and IOTP as: IOTP(C2B) -- customer to {merchant, payment handler, deliver, customer care, payment customer care}. OBI(B2B) -- { requistor, approver, payer} to merchant. Is more matured specification but deployment seems to be disappointing 8. Patrik Faltstrom (Area Director) explained to the group that all IETF Trade WG intermediate meetings between IETF meetings MUST be announced on the IETF Announce list and minutes SHOULD be published to WG mailing list. 9. On the issue of getting access to the OTP Consortium web site private area and mailing lists, Donald and Steve Fabes explained that all mailing lists from OTP can be moved to IETF Trade WG archive and Steve Fabes also mentioned that all IETF Trade WG members will be given access to the current OTP private area. All IETF Trade discussions are archived at: http://www.elistx/com/archives/ietf-trade 10. Steve Fabes read out the list of OTP consortium members. 11. Different members expressed the immediate need for strawman documents on Requirements and current IOTP specification. Donald assured to the group that these documents would be published at the earlist as I-Ds. 12. Next interim IETF Trade WG meeting will be held at Cybercash in Reston, Virginia, on September 9th through 11th and Donald mentioned that all the minutes of these meeting would be published Trade discussion list. As there is no further issues to be discussed, meeting adjourned.