[04:46:56] alex-meetecho joins the room
[04:56:24] <Meetecho> Hi all, please notice that the jabber room seems disconnected for Meetecho users, investigating
[04:56:39] Yisong Liu joins the room
[04:56:59] Bala Balarajah joins the room
[04:57:47] Timothy Winters joins the room
[04:58:02] Paolo Saviano joins the room
[04:58:07] Lorenzo Miniero joins the room
[04:58:08] Warren Kumari joins the room
[04:58:28] <Meetecho> Checking
[04:58:30] Sun Kj joins the room
[04:58:35] Duke Moon joins the room
[04:58:36] Sergey Fomin joins the room
[04:58:45] Gábor Lencse joins the room
[04:58:50] <Meetecho> Fixed, reloading the page will fix the chat for Meetecho users
[04:59:15] Warren Kumari leaves the room
[04:59:19] Warren Kumari joins the room
[04:59:32] <Warren Kumari> Hullo all...
[05:00:58] Juhamatti Kuusisaari joins the room
[05:01:56] Yoshiaki Kitaguchi joins the room
[05:02:06] Benson Muite joins the room
[05:02:19] Quang-Huy Nguyen joins the room
[05:02:34] <Sun Kj> I cannot hear Al's sound because there are noise..is it just my problem?
[05:03:15] <Meetecho> Sun Kj: it seems to be working fine here, let me check
[05:03:33] Yisong Liu leaves the room
[05:03:36] <Sun Kj> and now i'm good to hear
[05:03:49] <Meetecho> Ack
[05:03:54] Yisong Liu joins the room
[05:04:11] Alister Winfield joins the room
[05:04:39] Luis Contreras joins the room
[05:04:39] Sun Kj leaves the room
[05:05:21] Sun Kj joins the room
[05:06:34] Sun Kj leaves the room
[05:06:37] Sun Kj joins the room
[05:07:03] Sun Kj leaves the room
[05:07:06] Sun Kj joins the room
[05:07:25] Benson Muite leaves the room
[05:07:32] <Warren Kumari> Wheeee!!! Work!!!!
[05:07:35] Benson Muite joins the room
[05:07:43] Yuanlong Jiang joins the room
[05:07:56] <Warren Kumari> I like BMWG work...
[05:08:24] Benson Muite leaves the room
[05:08:29] Benson Muite joins the room
[05:09:18] Yisong Liu leaves the room
[05:09:26] Yuanlong Jiang leaves the room
[05:09:29] Yisong Liu joins the room
[05:10:42] Bill Cerveny joins the room
[05:10:44] Vladimir Vassilev joins the room
[05:10:50] <Bill Cerveny> test
[05:11:06] <Timothy Winters> I see Bill's test
[05:11:16] <Benson Muite> Me as well
[05:11:18] <Vladimir Vassilev> yes that was my problem
[05:11:27] Luis Contreras leaves the room
[05:11:31] Luis Contreras joins the room
[05:11:38] Benson Muite leaves the room
[05:11:51] <Vladimir Vassilev> Al go on .. I had an issue with the chat
[05:11:55] Benson Muite joins the room
[05:15:04] Benson Muite leaves the room
[05:15:09] Carsten Rossenhoevel joins the room
[05:15:59] Benson Muite joins the room
[05:16:08] <Warren Kumari> @Brian: Thank you!!!
[05:16:48] Benson Muite leaves the room
[05:16:51] Benson Muite joins the room
[05:17:42] Yuji Koyama joins the room
[05:18:05] Benson Muite leaves the room
[05:18:10] Benson Muite joins the room
[05:18:35] Benson Muite leaves the room
[05:18:38] Benson Muite joins the room
[05:21:02] Benson Muite leaves the room
[05:21:10] Benson Muite joins the room
[05:22:10] Benson Muite leaves the room
[05:22:13] Benson Muite joins the room
[05:23:09] Benson Muite leaves the room
[05:23:12] Benson Muite joins the room
[05:24:02] Benson Muite leaves the room
[05:24:09] Benson Muite joins the room
[05:24:52] <Bill Cerveny> click on the chart icon to indicate if you've read the draft or not.
[05:24:59] Benson Muite leaves the room
[05:25:05] Benson Muite joins the room
[05:25:43] Sun Kj leaves the room
[05:25:49] Sun Kj joins the room
[05:26:33] Vladimir Vassilev leaves the room
[05:26:36] Vladimir Vassilev joins the room
[05:26:45] Benson Muite leaves the room
[05:26:53] Benson Muite joins the room
[05:27:51] Benson Muite leaves the room
[05:27:57] Benson Muite joins the room
[05:28:39] Vladimir Vassilev leaves the room
[05:28:42] Vladimir Vassilev joins the room
[05:28:54] Vladimir Vassilev leaves the room
[05:32:45] Benson Muite leaves the room
[05:32:51] Benson Muite joins the room
[05:33:11] Vladimir Vassilev joins the room
[05:33:28] Sarah Banks joins the room
[05:34:17] Sarah Banks leaves the room
[05:34:32] Luis Contreras leaves the room
[05:34:37] Luis Contreras joins the room
[05:34:46] Sarah Banks joins the room
[05:35:34] Sarah Banks leaves the room
[05:35:51] Sarah Banks joins the room
[05:36:02] Sarah Banks leaves the room
[05:36:18] Benson Muite leaves the room
[05:36:36] Benson Muite joins the room
[05:38:54] Benson Muite leaves the room
[05:38:59] Benson Muite joins the room
[05:42:02] Yuji Koyama leaves the room
[05:47:04] <Carsten Rossenhoevel> Luis, two questions:
1) Is IETF the right place for this work item, or should it rather be standardized in 3GPP or ETSI (or O-RAN)?  I am active in O-RAN WG9 which works on something potentially similar.
2) Since this WG is about benchmarking, what do you plan to define in the draft to support RAN benchmarking?  This would require advanced emulators. Testing with real User Equipment (UEs) would not work well for benchmarking I think?
[05:53:00] <Carsten Rossenhoevel> Thank you for your response, Luis.  With regards to test tools, I suggest to compare with the next-gen-firewall document.  We also added new test methodology which requires test tools to support.  I would suggest you work with test tool vendors to ensure that the methodology you plan to define is implementable (in good IETF sense to first conduct a full proof of concept before an RFC is approved). I am quite worried that testing with single UEs does not do justice to the problem and that the document might become a dead horse iif there is no way to implement e2e benchmarking across RAN and 5GCore in reality.
[06:04:57] Carsten Rossenhoevel leaves the room
[06:05:00] Carsten Rossenhoevel joins the room
[06:08:48] <Benson Muite> NUMA allocation has several modes. Can one pin to specific cores? Do NUMA and other hardware specific effects need to be included in the specification or is there some way to make the specification applicable to a wide range of hardware?
[06:14:34] Yisong Liu leaves the room
[06:15:03] Yisong Liu joins the room
[06:19:17] Alister Winfield leaves the room
[06:19:28] Alister Winfield joins the room
[06:22:43] Yisong Liu leaves the room
[06:22:50] Alister Winfield leaves the room
[06:29:13] <Warren Kumari> Common off the shelf system (or similar?)
[06:30:24] Yisong Liu joins the room
[06:31:57] Yisong Liu leaves the room
[06:32:02] Yisong Liu joins the room
[06:33:35] Yisong Liu leaves the room
[06:33:45] Yisong Liu joins the room
[06:35:08] Yisong Liu leaves the room
[06:35:11] Yisong Liu joins the room
[06:36:12] Yisong Liu leaves the room
[06:36:18] Yisong Liu joins the room
[06:42:01] Timothy Winters leaves the room
[06:43:21] <Carsten Rossenhoevel> Thank you very much for chairing the session smoothly, Al, as always!  Have a good night @all U.S. attendees!
[06:43:32] <Benson Muite> Thanks.
[06:43:39] Warren Kumari leaves the room
[06:43:40] Carsten Rossenhoevel leaves the room
[06:43:40] <Sun Kj> Thank you very much
[06:43:46] Juhamatti Kuusisaari leaves the room
[06:43:47] Sergey Fomin leaves the room
[06:43:51] Sun Kj leaves the room
[06:43:57] Bala Balarajah leaves the room
[06:44:15] Gábor Lencse leaves the room
[06:45:18] Vladimir Vassilev leaves the room
[06:45:36] Duke Moon leaves the room
[06:45:43] Duke Moon joins the room
[06:46:02] Meetecho leaves the room
[06:47:32] Duke Moon leaves the room
[06:49:34] Quang-Huy Nguyen leaves the room
[06:50:11] Bill Cerveny leaves the room
[06:50:37] Raphael Rosa joins the room
[06:51:27] Yoshiaki Kitaguchi leaves the room
[06:53:14] Paolo Saviano leaves the room
[06:53:14] Luis Contreras leaves the room
[06:53:14] Benson Muite leaves the room
[06:53:14] Yisong Liu leaves the room
[06:53:14] Raphael Rosa leaves the room
[06:53:14] Lorenzo Miniero leaves the room
[06:53:15] Vladimir Vassilev joins the room
[07:30:25] alex-meetecho leaves the room