IETF
ccamp
ccamp@jabber.ietf.org
Thursday, 28 July 2011< ^ >
Room Configuration

GMT+0
[17:00:59] Giovanni Martinelli joins the room
[17:01:16] danielking.net joins the room
[17:03:17] cyril.margaria joins the room
[17:03:18] cyril.margaria leaves the room
[17:03:18] cyril.margaria joins the room
[17:03:25] <cyril.margaria> test
[17:03:30] <danielking.net> echo response
[17:04:33] adrianfarrel joins the room
[17:07:02] <louberger> we're now on draft-peloso-ccamp-wson-ospf-oeo-04 <http://tools.ietf.org/agenda/81/slides/ccamp-15.ppt>
[17:07:12] <louberger> cover slide
[17:07:47] julien.meuric joins the room
[17:09:29] <louberger> slide 2
[17:11:07] <louberger> slide 3
[17:11:32] Hayim joins the room
[17:12:41] <louberger> slide 4
[17:12:53] <adrianfarrel> Hey Julien! Wanna talk babies or focus on CCAMP?
[17:13:16] <julien.meuric> Hi.
[17:13:40] <cyril.margaria> Hi, all well at home, julien?
[17:13:41] <julien.meuric> Both: the mother-to-be is sitting rigth next to me. :D
[17:15:50] <louberger> slide 5 (and happy to hear all is well!)
[17:16:01] <louberger> slide 6
[17:18:24] <louberger> slide 7
[17:19:13] <louberger> slide 8
[17:20:33] <louberger> slide 9
[17:21:40] <louberger> slide 10
[17:22:48] <louberger> 12
[17:24:53] <louberger> 14
[17:25:47] <louberger> 15
[17:25:54] <louberger> 16
[17:26:52] <louberger> 17
[17:33:37] <julien.meuric> 22?
[17:36:20] <julien.meuric> One, but out of the room.
[17:36:31] <julien.meuric> I care. ;)
[17:37:29] <adrianfarrel> @julien.meuric Good to hear (first comment not recent comment)
[17:41:28] <louberger> on to draft-ietf-ccamp-rwa-info-11, rwa-wson-encode-11 <http://tools.ietf.org/agenda/81/slides/ccamp-16.pptx>
[17:42:26] <louberger> slide 3
[17:42:39] <louberger> slide 4
[17:44:53] <louberger> slide 8
[17:50:24] <louberger> slide 15
[17:52:11] <louberger> 17
[17:53:05] <louberger> 18
[18:04:16] <louberger> slide 26
[18:06:49] Giovanni Martinelli leaves the room: Disconnected.
[18:14:46] <julien.meuric> Nobody wants to, but has to...
[18:21:05] <julien.meuric> I would go for my prefered solution.
[18:24:22] <louberger> draft-martinelli-wson-interface-class-00 <http://tools.ietf.org/agenda/81/slides/ccamp-17.ppt>
[18:24:38] <louberger> Julien's comment is noted
[18:25:00] <louberger> doesn't significatnly change results :-(
[18:25:19] <louberger> slide 3
[18:26:55] <louberger> s5
[18:27:03] <julien.meuric> As I can't tell from here how many people built those 50%, I thus understand there were more than 2 voters.
[18:28:11] <louberger> about 12 implementers, about 10 who want one solution or the other, about half for each. Slightly less saying they want "a" solution from the WG
[18:28:45] <julien.meuric> Thanks
[18:29:03] <cyril.margaria> Well, I noticed that one specifc half were, as far as I could see, share the same email address.
[18:33:15] <julien.meuric> Lyndon speaking?
[18:33:24] <louberger> sorry yes
[18:33:31] <louberger> now someone from infinera
[18:34:28] <louberger> draft-li-ccamp-flexible-grid-label-00 <http://tools.ietf.org/agenda/81/slides/ccamp-18.ppt>
[18:34:42] <louberger> motivation slide
[18:34:47] Giovanni Martinelli joins the room
[18:35:39] <louberger> next
[18:36:24] <louberger> slide 4
[18:37:30] <louberger> 5
[18:39:38] <louberger> draft-shimazaki-ccamp-wson-interoperability-00 <http://tools.ietf.org/agenda/81/slides/ccamp-19.ppt>
[18:40:10] <louberger> slide 4
[18:40:17] Giovanni Martinelli leaves the room: Disconnected.
[18:40:30] Giovanni Martinelli joins the room
[18:41:44] <adrianfarrel> @cyril It is also possible that my question completely baffled everyone :-)
[18:43:03] <cyril.margaria> @adrian : I must admit I did get the question completly
[18:45:31] <louberger> draft-kunze-g-698-2-management-control-framework-00 <http://tools.ietf.org/agenda/81/slides/ccamp-20.ppt>
[18:45:53] <louberger> you "did get" or "did not get"?
[18:46:01] <cyril.margaria> One point regarding the WSON and resource ids : it is indeed always possible to asign virtual IDs, but it not a good point from implementation point of view and for management system . They prefer to have and easy 1:1 mapping between management name space and control plane name space.
[18:46:10] <cyril.margaria> @lou : did not, sorry
[18:46:35] <cyril.margaria> @lou : I understood your statement,
[18:46:55] <louberger> slide 3
[18:47:31] <louberger> slide 4
[18:49:04] <louberger> slide 5
[18:49:26] <louberger> 7
[18:49:47] <louberger> 8
[18:51:10] <louberger> draft-galimbe-kunze-g-698-2-snmp-mib-00 <http://tools.ietf.org/agenda/81/slides/ccamp-21.pptx>
[18:52:08] <louberger> slide 5
[18:53:11] <louberger> s 6
[18:53:18] <louberger> 7
[18:56:43] <louberger> moving to
draft-zhang-ccamp-srlg-fa-configuration-03 <http://tools.ietf.org/agenda/81/slides/ccamp-22.ppt>
[19:00:50] <julien.meuric> +1
[19:01:05] <julien.meuric> 2nd Q: +1
[19:01:29] <julien.meuric> SRLG: +1
[19:02:03] <julien.meuric> abstain
[19:02:34] <adrianfarrel> @julien I'm wondering about time-lag with jabber :-)
[19:02:52] <adrianfarrel> we're done
[19:02:54] <adrianfarrel> byeeee
[19:02:56] <louberger> thanks
[19:02:57] <cyril.margaria> bye
[19:02:58] <danielking.net> Thanks guys
[19:02:58] <Giovanni Martinelli> we miss the third voting option
[19:03:05] <Giovanni Martinelli> : no opinion
[19:03:07] cyril.margaria leaves the room
[19:03:10] <Giovanni Martinelli> ah bye
[19:03:13] Giovanni Martinelli leaves the room: Disconnected.
[19:03:18] <adrianfarrel> single transferable jabber
[19:03:21] adrianfarrel leaves the room
[19:03:22] danielking.net leaves the room
[19:03:29] <louberger> bye, hope all goes well J
[19:04:01] louberger leaves the room
[19:04:09] louberger joins the room
[19:04:14] louberger leaves the room
[19:07:07] <julien.meuric> For the reccord, I vote for collection, abstain for update (but I might have missed the question).
[19:07:35] julien.meuric leaves the room
[19:25:07] Giovanni Martinelli joins the room
[19:25:57] Giovanni Martinelli leaves the room
[19:36:49] Hayim leaves the room