IETF
idr
idr@jabber.ietf.org
Friday, March 31, 2017< ^ >
joel jaeggli has set the subject to: IDR IETF 94
Room Configuration
Room Occupants

GMT+0
[13:44:15] Meetecho joins the room
[13:52:58] Martin Horneffer joins the room
[13:58:00] jo e joins the room
[13:58:47] Colin Petrie joins the room
[13:58:48] Wes George joins the room
[14:00:22] poorna B joins the room
[14:01:29] Andrei Robachevsky joins the room
[14:03:52] <Wes George> folks I am jabber scribing
[14:04:01] <Wes George> anyone not following along on meetecho?
[14:04:47] Robert Butler joins the room
[14:05:06] <Robert Butler> Yes - just joined
[14:05:29] <Wes George> ok, since meetecho covers slides, I’ll just watch to carry comments to the mic
[14:05:38] <Martin Horneffer> but you do use meet echo, don’t you?
[14:05:49] <Wes George> if you want something said at the mic, please precede your comment with MIC:
[14:05:53] <Robert Butler> Yes. Thanks
[14:06:00] <Robert Butler> Ok
[14:07:17] Kamran Raza joins the room
[14:08:31] Eric Rosen joins the room
[14:09:06] <Andrei Robachevsky> Thank you Wes
[14:09:25] richie g joins the room
[14:12:58] jch joins the room
[14:16:38] Keyur Patel joins the room
[14:30:42] Kamran Raza leaves the room
[14:31:17] jch leaves the room: Disconnected: No route to host
[14:31:40] Kamran Raza joins the room
[14:35:25] Carlos Martinez joins the room
[14:39:02] Carlos Martinez leaves the room
[14:51:58] jch joins the room
[14:57:36] Juan Cerezo joins the room
[14:59:22] Andrei Robachevsky leaves the room
[15:03:57] slm joins the room
[15:21:22] <Keyur Patel> MIC:@tony - Ideally if LLDP packets are lost you have much bigger problem wrt discovery. Having said that we could augment the text to make it bit more robust
[15:21:51] <Keyur Patel> @tony - completly agree about his comments about tweaking the transport
[15:23:07] IBN KHEDHER Hatem joins the room
[15:23:55] <Keyur Patel> MIC: @Jeff - Yep a group ID makes sense.
[15:24:47] IBN KHEDHER Hatem leaves the room
[15:28:10] <Keyur Patel> MIC @Enke: LDP like discovery mechanism is a lot heavier. The biggest adv of LLDP is that discovery is decoupled from the protocol namely BGP
[15:28:23] jo e leaves the room
[15:28:42] <Keyur Patel> Wes are you planning to channel the comments?
[15:28:43] <Keyur Patel> :)
[15:28:52] Mohan Nanduri joins the room
[15:29:20] Cathy Aronson joins the room
[15:29:42] <jch> When people are speaking of LDP, they refer to the MPLS thing, right?
[15:30:16] <Keyur Patel> yes
[15:30:33] <Keyur Patel> the LDP discovery aspect of the LDP protocol to be precise
[15:30:43] <jch> Ce
[15:30:47] <jch> Clear, thanks.
[15:31:28] <Wes George> sorry keyur, the window was hiding and I didn’t get notification someone was typing
[15:31:34] <Wes George> do you still need me to channel?
[15:31:37] <Keyur Patel> yep
[15:31:43] <Keyur Patel> that would be nice
[15:33:38] Cathy Aronson leaves the room
[15:34:44] Ashutosh Gupta joins the room
[15:37:38] Satoru Matsushima joins the room
[15:39:20] <Kamran Raza> MIC:Please take a look @ "srv6 net pgm" document.
[15:39:27] <Keyur Patel> Thanks Wes
[15:39:33] <Keyur Patel> for channeling my comments
[15:40:10] <Kamran Raza> Thanks.
[15:44:23] Kamran Raza leaves the room
[15:48:04] <jch> Huffman black magic?  DIfficult to believe.
[15:53:58] Satoru Matsushima leaves the room
[15:54:03] Gaurav Dawra joins the room
[15:54:55] john heasley joins the room
[15:55:53] <Keyur Patel> MIC: We have an IDR draft for extended messages. If the messages are extended with bigger window size how would this solution stack up considering convergence is paramount for BGP.
[15:58:21] <Wes George> ack
[16:01:06] randy joins the room
[16:01:25] <randy> the complexity of this is a disaster waiting to happen
[16:01:44] <randy> @wes: no need to repeat at mic
[16:03:38] Gaurav Dawra leaves the room
[16:04:52] <jch> Tony P. should be a member of a heavy metal band ;-)
[16:05:38] richie g leaves the room
[16:06:43] Eric Rosen leaves the room
[16:08:20] Lorenzo Martin Mañalac joins the room
[16:10:01] Gaurav Dawra joins the room
[16:13:28] <Keyur Patel> MIC @tiger: I am not sure if the hello mechanism is needed inside bgp with keepalives
[16:13:32] <Keyur Patel> there are discovery protocols
[16:13:44] <Keyur Patel> lets leverage them and not load BGP up
[16:21:53] poorna B leaves the room
[16:23:51] Lorenzo Martin Mañalac leaves the room
[16:27:03] Robert Butler leaves the room
[16:28:29] Colin Petrie leaves the room
[16:29:39] randy leaves the room
[16:29:45] <Wes George> session ends
[16:29:45] slm leaves the room
[16:29:47] Wes George leaves the room
[16:29:53] Martin Horneffer leaves the room
[16:30:13] Meetecho leaves the room
[16:30:26] Gaurav Dawra leaves the room
[16:30:27] Keyur Patel leaves the room
[16:30:27] Juan Cerezo leaves the room
[16:30:27] Ashutosh Gupta leaves the room
[16:30:27] john heasley leaves the room
[16:30:27] Mohan Nanduri leaves the room
[16:47:13] jch leaves the room: Disconnected: No route to host
[17:14:55] jch joins the room
[17:15:01] jch leaves the room
[17:54:42] slm joins the room
[19:46:22] slm leaves the room