IETF
ippm
ippm@jabber.ietf.org
Monday, 26 March 2012< ^ >
Joseph has set the subject to: IPPM Working Group
Room Configuration

GMT+0
[09:14:58] Andreas J joins the room
[09:54:22] Andreas J leaves the room
[09:54:27] Andreas J joins the room
[09:59:06] Andreas J leaves the room
[09:59:23] Andreas J joins the room
[10:07:36] Andreas J leaves the room
[10:07:42] Andreas J joins the room
[10:08:54] Andreas J leaves the room
[10:50:15] Andreas J joins the room
[10:50:36] Andreas J leaves the room
[10:51:01] Andreas J joins the room
[10:53:08] wesley.m.eddy joins the room
[10:53:33] Henk Uijterwaal joins the room
[10:56:32] <Henk Uijterwaal> Hello, anybody there, did we start yet?
[10:58:48] Andreas J leaves the room
[10:58:53] Andreas J joins the room
[11:00:17] <Henk Uijterwaal> Hello, anybody out there? Did we start?
[11:00:33] paul.aitken joins the room
[11:00:36] jpc joins the room
[11:00:58] Brian Trammell joins the room
[11:01:39] <wesley.m.eddy> Henk: Al is finishing setting up
[11:01:42] acmacm joins the room
[11:02:18] Matt Zekauskas joins the room
[11:02:40] YJS joins the room
[11:03:50] hagen.pfeifer joins the room
[11:04:01] <paul.aitken> Al is going through the agenda.
[11:04:21] <Henk Uijterwaal> I have no sound, anybody else the same problem>
[11:04:54] <Brian Trammell> can you hear al now?
[11:05:28] <jpc> nop, no sound
[11:05:32] <Henk Uijterwaal> No
[11:05:52] <paul.aitken> Brian is trying the other mics
[11:06:01] <paul.aitken> Can you here him?
[11:06:08] <paul.aitken> *hear
[11:06:14] <Henk Uijterwaal> No
[11:06:46] <acmacm> Yaakov will contact NOC, we will forge onb with status...
[11:07:22] <Brian Trammell> No agenda bashing, moving on with the agenda...
[11:07:22] Martin Swany joins the room
[11:07:35] <Henk Uijterwaal> OK, in worst case, I'll have to rely on notes
[11:07:49] <paul.aitken> Reviewing IPPM drafts status
[11:07:50] Marc Linsner joins the room
[11:08:20] <paul.aitken> FYI, minutes are being recordedhere: http://tools.ietf.org/wg/ippm/minutes
[11:08:31] Andreas J leaves the room
[11:09:04] <paul.aitken> Al says to Disclose Intellectual Property Rights.
[11:09:31] Andreas J joins the room
[11:09:40] <paul.aitken> Status item 2 : dead drafts
[11:09:52] <paul.aitken> ippm-reporting-06
[11:11:21] <paul.aitken> Update RFC 5136?
[11:11:26] Andreas J leaves the room
[11:11:28] <paul.aitken> -> dead activity
[11:11:31] Andreas J joins the room
[11:12:12] <paul.aitken> draft-ietf-ippm-twamp-value-added-octets will be under item 4 on today's agenda
[11:13:06] Andreas J leaves the room
[11:13:11] Andreas J joins the room
[11:14:29] <paul.aitken> Al is getting ready to present draft-morton-ippm-rate-problem-01.txt
[11:15:17] Andreas J leaves the room
[11:15:21] Andreas J joins the room
[11:15:24] <paul.aitken> It's pronounced "T-wamp"
[11:17:12] Martin Swany leaves the room
[11:17:14] Martin Swany joins the room
[11:17:38] <paul.aitken> Slide 2: motivation
[11:18:51] <paul.aitken> Slide 3: Scope
[11:19:34] <paul.aitken> Slide 4, more scope
[11:20:27] Andreas J leaves the room
[11:20:31] Andreas J joins the room
[11:20:57] <paul.aitken> Slide 5: summary of spec
[11:23:26] <paul.aitken> Slide 6: conclusion
[11:23:52] <paul.aitken> Someone seems to be fixing the audio now.
[11:24:02] <paul.aitken> Can you hear?
[11:24:08] <Matt Zekauskas> just came on
[11:24:08] <Henk Uijterwaal> Yes, I can hear something
[11:24:13] Andreas J leaves the room
[11:24:18] <Brian Trammell> (sound of clapping)
[11:24:18] Andreas J joins the room
[11:25:29] <paul.aitken> Any remote questions?
[11:26:26] Andreas J leaves the room
[11:26:30] Andreas J joins the room
[11:28:05] Andreas J leaves the room
[11:28:09] Andreas J joins the room
[11:29:42] Brian Trammell leaves the room
[11:31:08] Brian Trammell joins the room
[11:31:47] Andreas J leaves the room
[11:31:51] Andreas J joins the room
[11:32:02] Marc Linsner leaves the room
[11:35:00] <paul.aitken> Hum for, and no hum against adopting.
[11:35:14] <Henk Uijterwaal> I'll take this to the list
[11:35:21] <paul.aitken> No humming in jabber?
[11:35:41] <Henk Uijterwaal> I agree with adopting but want to check with folks on the list
[11:36:22] <paul.aitken> Item #2 on the agenda: test plan
[11:39:12] <paul.aitken> Ruediger presenting
[11:39:19] <paul.aitken> slide 2
[11:39:26] <paul.aitken> test configuration
[11:41:05] <paul.aitken> Slide 3
[11:41:11] <paul.aitken> Tests in the plan
[11:42:27] Andreas J leaves the room
[11:42:27] <paul.aitken> Slide 4: Overview
[11:42:32] Andreas J joins the room
[11:44:50] <paul.aitken> Slide 5
[11:45:41] <paul.aitken> Slide 6: Results
[11:48:39] <paul.aitken> Any questions?
[11:50:33] <paul.aitken> slide 7
[11:51:27] Andreas J leaves the room
[11:51:31] Andreas J joins the room
[11:51:45] <paul.aitken> Any questions?
[11:51:48] <paul.aitken> Slide 8
[11:52:23] <paul.aitken> That's it.
[11:52:39] <paul.aitken> Is it time for a WGLC on this?
[11:52:55] <Henk Uijterwaal> I agree with a WGLC
[11:54:11] <Henk Uijterwaal> Metrics test is now an RFC, published as 6576 this morning.
[11:54:12] Andreas J leaves the room
[11:54:16] Andreas J joins the room
[12:07:06] <paul.aitken> Up next: 2680 test plan
[12:07:38] <paul.aitken> Slide 2
[12:07:40] <paul.aitken> ooutline
[12:07:59] <paul.aitken> Slide 3: Process
[12:10:34] <paul.aitken> Slide 6 already
[12:10:47] <paul.aitken> #7
[12:12:56] <paul.aitken> #9
[12:14:06] <paul.aitken> #10
[12:16:13] <paul.aitken> Slide 11: should this be adopted as a WG doc?
[12:18:23] <hagen.pfeifer> full name: Hagen Paul Pfeifer (netem sidenote)
[12:18:28] <paul.aitken> Thanks.
[12:19:11] <Henk Uijterwaal> I did upload them!
[12:19:20] <Matt Zekauskas> http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/83/slides/ has them, look for ippm
[12:20:06] <Matt Zekauskas> https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/83/materials.html
[12:21:50] <paul.aitken> 2 people have read the value-add octets draft
[12:21:55] <Henk Uijterwaal> I put this on the agenda to block time, I don't think there is much need for f2f discussion here
[12:22:06] <Henk Uijterwaal> as no issues have been raised
[12:25:24] <paul.aitken> Closing IPPM? There are still a few things which need to be done.
[12:25:36] <paul.aitken> Also, the WG can become dormant, rather than close.
[12:26:17] <Henk Uijterwaal> We don't plan to close before the current open items are done.
[12:27:02] <Henk Uijterwaal> We can pick up other work if there is sufficient interest to get something done "soon"
[12:27:34] <paul.aitken> Any remote volunteers to co-author?
[12:28:46] <Henk Uijterwaal> Brian: that would be great, but we'd need to recharter for that.
[12:28:55] <Matt Zekauskas> yes, need to scope
[12:29:31] <Henk Uijterwaal> We had this discussion, decided back then to postpone until it was clear what people wanted to do.
[12:29:45] <Henk Uijterwaal> Discussion of the topic for future charter is fine, of course
[12:32:08] <paul.aitken> AOB?
[12:32:50] <Henk Uijterwaal> Thanks Al for chairing the meeting. Can people please mail me notes so I can pull out minutes
[12:33:09] <paul.aitken> http://tools.ietf.org/wg/ippm/minutes
[12:33:10] <Brian Trammell> Henk: there are also notes in Etherpad...
[12:33:50] <Henk Uijterwaal> txs
[12:34:48] <paul.aitken> Anything else?
[12:34:54] <paul.aitken> Meeting closed.
[12:35:22] Matt Zekauskas leaves the room
[12:35:44] Brian Trammell leaves the room
[12:36:03] paul.aitken leaves the room
[12:37:54] wesley.m.eddy leaves the room
[12:48:41] Henk Uijterwaal leaves the room
[12:49:01] YJS leaves the room
[12:50:24] hagen.pfeifer leaves the room
[12:51:40] hagen.pfeifer joins the room
[12:52:24] Andreas J leaves the room
[12:53:18] acmacm leaves the room
[13:01:33] Martin Swany leaves the room
[13:08:43] Martin Swany joins the room
[13:09:17] Martin Swany leaves the room
[13:18:07] wesley.m.eddy joins the room
[13:20:04] jpc leaves the room
[14:12:56] wesley.m.eddy leaves the room
[14:42:27] hagen.pfeifer leaves the room
[14:54:56] wesley.m.eddy joins the room
[15:35:27] wesley.m.eddy leaves the room
[15:38:54] wesley.m.eddy joins the room
[15:39:16] wesley.m.eddy leaves the room
[18:48:10] paul.aitken joins the room
[19:05:44] paul.aitken leaves the room
[19:06:01] paul.aitken joins the room
[19:48:36] paul.aitken leaves the room