IETF
manet
manet@jabber.ietf.org
Wednesday, 16 November 2011< ^ >
bebemaster has set the subject to: End
Room Configuration

GMT+0
[00:22:01] Axel Colin de Verdiere joins the room
[00:22:36] Axel Colin de Verdiere leaves the room
[04:53:26] jpmacker joins the room
[05:01:35] Axel Colin de Verdiere joins the room
[05:02:21] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> Hello everybody
[05:02:32] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> Do you have the sound?
[05:03:13] yi.jiazi joins the room
[05:03:15] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> (slide 4 now)
[05:03:21] teco.boot joins the room
[05:03:38] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> (manet WG Agenda)
[05:03:51] yi.jiazi leaves the room
[05:04:02] yi.jiazi joins the room
[05:04:23] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> Does anyone *not* have the audio?
[05:04:35] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> (slide 5 currently)
[05:04:45] jpmacker leaves the room
[05:05:19] monden joins the room
[05:06:03] jpmacker joins the room
[05:06:09] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> (charlie perkins at the mic)
[05:07:24] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> Thomas Clausen at the mic
[05:10:23] h-suzuki joins the room
[05:14:04] thomas.heide.clausen joins the room
[05:16:25] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> change of slides
[05:17:26] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> slide 4
[05:20:45] igarashi joins the room
[05:26:16] <jpmacker> We should get OLSRv2 comments within a month.
[05:33:13] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> Bob Cole presenting
[05:33:18] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> sildes: NHDP, SMF, REPORT and OLSRv2 MIBs
[05:33:21] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> slide 2/8
[05:34:37] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> slide 3/8
[05:36:22] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> slide 4/8 (SMF-MIB)
[05:36:59] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> slide 5/8 (report-MIB )
[05:37:53] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> slide 6/8 (OLSRv2-MIB )
[05:38:36] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> slide 7
[05:38:41] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> end
[05:39:07] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> Next: Ulrich Herberg, Updates on RFC5444/NHDP Sec
[05:39:13] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> slide 1
[05:39:34] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> slide 2
[05:48:54] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> slide 3
[05:50:57] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> Stan Ratliff presenting
[05:50:59] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> DLEP status
[05:51:07] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> slide 2
[05:52:57] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> slide 3
[05:53:04] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> (current status, continued)
[05:53:37] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> slide 4
[05:53:40] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> (other issues)
[05:54:25] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> end. questions?
[05:58:21] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> Next: slot for Bob Cole
[05:58:50] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> slides: Radios, SatCom and Considerations
[05:58:53] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> slide 1
[05:59:03] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> slide 2
[05:59:34] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> slide 3
[06:01:40] chiyuan joins the room
[06:03:33] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> slide 4
[06:04:23] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> previous slide (3)
[06:10:46] <jpmacker> I think DLEP provides a interface but it does not provide the control for a multi-hop reservation protocol.
[06:11:04] <jpmacker> I think that is ok for me
[06:11:52] <jpmacker> I do worry about flow control locally
[06:15:38] <jpmacker> Hello?
[06:15:49] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> yes, next one sorry
[06:15:54] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> waiting for the mic
[06:16:26] <jpmacker> right.. I have a few comments but now they are off topic from the original question.
[06:16:54] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> Well I can still add them to your previous ones?
[06:18:24] <jpmacker> Main point: DLEP isnt doing multi-hop reservation and thats ok (there are many proprietary ways to do that) it provides a common interface for communicating in both directions modem/router.
[06:18:53] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> does it replace or add to your other comments?
[06:19:06] <jpmacker> yes replace, plus next one
[06:19:12] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> ok
[06:20:11] <jpmacker> Second: I would like to hear about local flow control role/thoughts for DLEP (modem, router).
[06:21:14] <jpmacker> Question was for DLEP authors
[06:21:30] <jpmacker> thanks
[06:21:47] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> Ok, I'll go clarify sorry
[06:28:02] <jpmacker> FLow control
[06:28:15] <jpmacker> Flow control throughts
[06:28:57] <teco.boot> Joe: do you mean shaping in router?
[06:29:22] <jpmacker> Also want to keep autoconf discussions out of router group
[06:29:23] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> (slide 5)
[06:31:10] <jpmacker> I think it will be a good exercise to define a few radio modem types for DLEP and get some example prototypes running.. perhaps defined in sourceforge
[06:33:48] <jpmacker> To Teco: I mean the equivalent of credit-based flow control.
[06:37:33] <jpmacker> Ok, got Stan's answer ... fine with that fact that its being addressed.
[06:38:22] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> Want to have it voiced?
[06:39:08] <jpmacker> if convenient.
[06:43:50] <jpmacker> I am going to take it out of the IPv4 mode.
[06:50:16] <jpmacker> I will talk to Adrian/others/WG more about what I am thinking of doing. I think the hash mode will work albeit not as robustly. My intention is to take it out.
[06:50:33] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> Transmitting just after Teco
[06:51:02] <jpmacker> That is already in the ID
[06:51:18] <jpmacker> the fragment id is already used
[06:52:15] <jpmacker> are we?
[06:54:09] <jpmacker> In the fragment case we are not overloading.
[06:54:26] <jpmacker> in the unfragmented case we are overloading
[06:55:49] <Axel Colin de Verdiere> End of session
[06:55:53] jpmacker leaves the room
[06:55:53] yi.jiazi leaves the room
[06:56:18] h-suzuki leaves the room
[06:57:07] igarashi leaves the room
[06:57:14] chiyuan leaves the room
[07:00:12] teco.boot leaves the room
[07:00:45] Axel Colin de Verdiere leaves the room
[07:02:32] monden leaves the room
[07:04:10] monden joins the room
[07:04:32] monden leaves the room
[07:04:40] monden joins the room
[07:05:02] monden leaves the room
[07:12:51] Axel Colin de Verdiere joins the room
[08:52:44] thomas.heide.clausen leaves the room
[11:12:03] Axel Colin de Verdiere leaves the room
[11:16:36] Axel Colin de Verdiere joins the room
[15:09:02] Axel Colin de Verdiere leaves the room
[16:56:50] monden joins the room
[17:11:46] monden leaves the room
[17:21:51] monden joins the room
[17:25:45] monden leaves the room