IETF
nmrg
nmrg@jabber.ietf.org
Thursday, July 19, 2018< ^ >
Room Configuration
Room Occupants

GMT+0
[17:15:00] oqmLXkMr joins the room
[17:16:35] Meetecho joins the room
[17:21:45] Yoshiro Yoneya joins the room
[17:25:11] Lorenzo Miniero joins the room
[17:25:11] Kiran Makhijani joins the room
[17:25:35] ULU ABIMIKU joins the room
[17:27:59] Mark Ellison joins the room
[17:31:15] Börje Ohlman joins the room
[17:32:11] H. Anthony Chan joins the room
[17:33:19] SHUCHENG LIU joins the room
[17:33:59] Simon Pietro Romano joins the room
[17:35:28] <SHUCHENG LIU> This is jabber scribe. Please prepend statements you would like you to relay with "RELAY" or "MIC"
[17:35:43] Jeferson Nobre joins the room
[17:36:50] <SHUCHENG LIU> 1. Introduction, Chairs
[17:37:35] H. Anthony Chan leaves the room
[17:37:36] H. Anthony Chan joins the room
[17:37:42] Juergen Schoenwaelder joins the room
[17:38:00] Chi-Jiun Su joins the room
[17:40:20] Ana Laura Diedrichs joins the room
[17:44:07] Ana Laura Diedrichs leaves the room
[17:45:38] <SHUCHENG LIU> 2a. Exploiting External Event Detectors to Anticipate Resource Requirements for the Elastic Adaptation of SDN/NFV Systems, Pedro Martinez-Julia       https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-pedro-nmrg-anticipated-adaptation/       13:40, 10 min.
[17:47:59] Dapeng Liu joins the room
[17:49:05] ULU ABIMIKU leaves the room
[17:49:17] Laurent Ciavaglia joins the room
[17:49:47] Giovane Moura joins the room
[17:52:41] Ana Laura Diedrichs joins the room
[17:54:52] H. Anthony Chan leaves the room
[17:54:54] H. Anthony Chan joins the room
[17:55:01] Dapeng Liu leaves the room
[17:55:01] Giovane Moura leaves the room
[17:55:01] Lorenzo Miniero leaves the room
[17:55:01] SHUCHENG LIU leaves the room
[17:55:01] Börje Ohlman leaves the room
[17:55:01] Chi-Jiun Su leaves the room
[17:55:52] Ana Laura Diedrichs leaves the room
[17:56:31] Ana Laura Diedrichs joins the room
[17:56:55] Kiran Makhijani leaves the room
[17:56:57] Kiran MakhijaniMakhijani joins the room
[17:57:04] Juergen Schoenwaelder leaves the room
[17:57:07] Juergen Schoenwaelder joins the room
[17:57:18] Yoshiro Yoneya joins the room
[17:57:46] Meetecho leaves the room
[17:57:46] Meetecho joins the room
[17:58:01] <Meetecho> AC died here, working to restore
[17:58:19] Jeferson Nobre leaves the room
[17:58:21] Jeferson Nobre joins the room
[17:58:36] Kiran MakhijaniMakhijani leaves the room
[17:59:07] Mark Ellison leaves the room
[17:59:09] Mark Ellison joins the room
[17:59:11] Kiran MakhijaniMakhijani joins the room
[18:00:57] <Ana Laura Diedrichs> Video/audio stop working, I can't see/hear the presentation
[18:01:05] <Kiran MakhijaniMakhijani> same here.
[18:02:02] Börje Ohlman joins the room
[18:03:42] Simon Pietro Romano leaves the room
[18:04:20] Bernard Sales joins the room
[18:04:51] anstone joins the room
[18:04:58] <Meetecho> As I said, AC went out (power out in the hotel)
[18:06:02] Mark Ellison leaves the room
[18:06:03] Mark Ellison joins the room
[18:06:06] SHUCHENG LIU joins the room
[18:06:21] <SHUCHENG LIU> reconnected
[18:06:46] <SHUCHENG LIU> as wifi is still working. chair wants to start without projector
[18:07:41] <Ana Laura Diedrichs> could someone share the etherpad link?
[18:07:50] H. Anthony Chan leaves the room
[18:07:52] H. Anthony Chan joins the room
[18:08:45] <Mark Ellison> https://etherpad.tools.ietf.org/p/notes-ietf-102-nmrg?useMonospaceFont=true
[18:09:11] Yoshiro Yoneya joins the room
[18:10:37] <SHUCHENG LIU> 2b. Toward a Network Telemetry Framework, Haoyu Song     https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-song-ntf/     13:50, 10 min.
[18:10:40] <SHUCHENG LIU> start now
[18:11:35] Yoshiro Yoneya leaves the room
[18:13:15] Bernard Sales leaves the room
[18:13:17] Bernard Sales joins the room
[18:13:50] anstone leaves the room
[18:13:51] <Meetecho> Going to start our streamers ASAP now that the power seems to be back
[18:13:57] Ana Laura Diedrichs leaves the room
[18:14:05] Kiran MakhijaniMakhijani leaves the room
[18:14:08] Kiran Makhijani joins the room
[18:14:23] <Meetecho> It might take a bit as we need the switches in the rooms to come back
[18:14:26] Bernard Sales leaves the room
[18:14:27] <SHUCHENG LIU> page4
[18:14:27] Bernard Sales joins the room
[18:15:32] Bernard Sales leaves the room
[18:15:32] Laurent Ciavaglia leaves the room
[18:15:32] SHUCHENG LIU leaves the room
[18:15:32] Börje Ohlman leaves the room
[18:16:43] SHUCHENG LIU joins the room
[18:17:04] Laurent Ciavaglia joins the room
[18:17:05] <SHUCHENG LIU> page6
[18:17:49] Meetecho leaves the room
[18:17:56] Meetecho joins the room
[18:18:43] Ana Laura Diedrichs joins the room
[18:18:56] <SHUCHENG LIU> page9
[18:19:15] Mark Ellison leaves the room
[18:19:17] Mark Ellison joins the room
[18:19:42] <SHUCHENG LIU> 10
[18:19:47] H. Anthony Chan leaves the room
[18:19:48] <Kiran Makhijani> i got presentations and video restored but no audio. Is it just me?
[18:19:49] H. Anthony Chan joins the room
[18:19:56] <Ana Laura Diedrichs> same here
[18:20:01] <Laurent Ciavaglia> try restart your session
[18:20:11] Ana Laura Diedrichs leaves the room
[18:20:24] Ana Laura Diedrichs joins the room
[18:20:24] Juergen Schoenwaelder leaves the room
[18:20:27] Kiran Makhijani leaves the room
[18:20:33] Juergen Schoenwaelder joins the room
[18:20:42] <Jeferson Nobre> same here, even after restarting the session
[18:20:42] Kiran Makhijani joins the room
[18:21:15] <Ana Laura Diedrichs> so do I
[18:21:20] <Mark Ellison> (after a restart) might be a audio volume issue- lower left corner of Meetecho things Audio in is at 28kbs
[18:21:28] Bernard Sales joins the room
[18:21:35] <Mark Ellison> now audio!
[18:21:39] <Kiran Makhijani> its good now.
[18:22:04] Mark Ellison leaves the room
[18:22:05] Mark Ellison joins the room
[18:22:16] <Meetecho> Everything should be back now
[18:22:22] Yoshiro Yoneya leaves the room
[18:22:26] <Ana Laura Diedrichs> it's working now
[18:22:30] Yoshiro Yoneya joins the room
[18:22:40] <Jeferson Nobre> same here :)
[18:22:50] Chi-Jiun Su joins the room
[18:23:24] <SHUCHENG LIU> is it ok now?
[18:23:48] <SHUCHENG LIU> great
[18:24:29] Lorenzo Miniero joins the room
[18:25:05] Yoshiro Yoneya leaves the room
[18:26:42] Jeferson Nobre leaves the room
[18:27:00] Jéferson Nobre joins the room
[18:28:23] Lorenzo Miniero leaves the room
[18:28:36] Lorenzo Miniero joins the room
[18:28:58] Meetecho leaves the room
[18:28:58] Meetecho joins the room
[18:32:04] Jéferson Nobre leaves the room
[18:32:05] Jéferson Nobre joins the room
[18:34:22] <SHUCHENG LIU> 3. Topic: Management aspects of network slicing [14:10 – 14:40]     3a. Management slicing problems and gap analysis, Alex Galis     14:10, 10 min.
[18:38:49] <SHUCHENG LIU> page4
[18:38:52] <Laurent Ciavaglia> Kiran: is everything working on your side? (you are next to present)
[18:39:46] Laurent Ciavaglia leaves the room
[18:39:47] Laurent Ciavaglia joins the room
[18:41:59] Reza Rokui joins the room
[18:42:33] <Kiran Makhijani> yes.
[18:42:41] Mark Ellison leaves the room
[18:44:05] Reza Rokui leaves the room
[18:44:05] Reza Rokui joins the room
[18:44:17] Reza Rokui leaves the room
[18:45:45] <SHUCHENG LIU>     3b. (remote) Network Slice use cases, Kiran Makhijani     14:20, 10 min.  
[18:47:43] Laurent Ciavaglia leaves the room
[18:48:00] Danny Alex Lachos Perez joins the room
[18:49:58] <SHUCHENG LIU> page4
[18:50:18] Danny Alex Lachos Perez leaves the room
[18:54:19] Yoshiro Yoneya joins the room
[19:03:35] Yoshiro Yoneya leaves the room
[19:03:52] Kiran Makhijani leaves the room
[19:04:15] <SHUCHENG LIU> 4. Topic: Novel approaches to network management [14:40 – 15:30]     4a. Intelligent Network Management using Reinforcement Learning, Yong-Geun Hong      https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-kim-nmrg-rl/     14:40, 10 min.
[19:09:14] <Ana Laura Diedrichs> can we have access to the slides in pdf format?
[19:09:39] Laurent Ciavaglia joins the room
[19:10:09] <Laurent Ciavaglia> the slides are on the meeting page (should be in pdf)
[19:12:46] <SHUCHENG LIU>     4b. Roadmap to a Networkless World, Bing Liu     https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-liu-nmrg-networkless-roadmap/     14:50, 10 min.
[19:14:14] <SHUCHENG LIU> slides: https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/102/session/nmrg
[19:15:35] Yoshiro Yoneya leaves the room
[19:23:33] <SHUCHENG LIU> 4c. (remote) Autonomics 3.0, Jéferson Campos Nobre     15:00, 10 min.
[19:24:38] Bernard Sales leaves the room
[19:25:57] Bernard Sales joins the room
[19:30:58] Laurent Ciavaglia leaves the room
[19:35:32] <SHUCHENG LIU> session close
[19:35:44] Bernard Sales leaves the room
[19:35:44] SHUCHENG LIU leaves the room
[19:35:44] Jéferson Nobre leaves the room
[19:35:44] Juergen Schoenwaelder leaves the room
[19:35:44] Chi-Jiun Su leaves the room
[19:35:44] Ana Laura Diedrichs leaves the room
[19:35:44] Lorenzo Miniero leaves the room
[19:35:44] H. Anthony Chan leaves the room
[19:36:12] Meetecho leaves the room
[19:42:07] oqmLXkMr leaves the room
[19:52:07] Yoshiro Yoneya joins the room
[20:27:45] anstone joins the room
[20:28:25] anstone leaves the room
[20:29:12] fee49bwR joins the room
[21:57:19] meetecho joins the room
[21:58:03] fee49bwR leaves the room
[21:59:54] Yoshiro Yoneya joins the room
[22:00:06] Yoshiro Yoneya leaves the room
[22:05:09] Mark Ellison joins the room
[22:05:10] Hammad Mazhar joins the room
[22:05:14] Ana Laura Diedrichs joins the room
[22:08:58] H. Anthony Chan joins the room
[22:12:04] Juergen Schoenwaelder joins the room
[22:12:08] Simon Pietro Romano joins the room
[22:12:30] Laurent Ciavaglia joins the room
[22:16:05] Jéferson Nobre joins the room
[22:16:46] Zubair Shafiq joins the room
[22:17:06] <Laurent Ciavaglia> I'll act as Jabber scribe, if you want me to relay a question/comment, please prefix with 'MIC:'
[22:17:07] <Laurent Ciavaglia> thanks
[22:17:42] <Ana Laura Diedrichs> where can I find the slides in pdf format?
[22:17:58] SHUCHENG LIU joins the room
[22:18:20] <Laurent Ciavaglia> https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/102/session/nmrg
[22:18:25] Zubair Shafiq leaves the room
[22:18:26] Zubair Shafiq joins the room
[22:21:25] <SHUCHENG LIU> the slides of second presentation seems the same as previous session?
[22:29:25] H. Anthony Chan leaves the room
[22:31:06] <Laurent Ciavaglia> yes, partially because they refer also to the topic of the second session
[22:34:14] <Jéferson Nobre> It seems that someone in the IETF knows how to spell "ontology"
[22:34:17] <Jéferson Nobre> :)
[22:35:02] H. Anthony Chan joins the room
[22:35:31] <Jéferson Nobre> MIC: since you are using terms from other area (AI/ML), it would be nice if you could bring some references
[22:37:15] <Jéferson Nobre> In addition: as a question, it would be useful to have a document on AI/ML terminology in network management?
[22:37:56] <Laurent Ciavaglia> Ok Jéferson, I will relay
[22:39:58] <Ana Laura Diedrichs> Jeferson: maybe this document could help you https://www.ietf.org/archive/id/draft-jiang-nmlrg-network-machine-learning-02.txt
[22:50:35] <Jéferson Nobre> maybe a reboot?
[22:59:31] mark.ellison@jabber.org joins the room
[23:00:40] mark.ellison@jabber.org leaves the room: offline
[23:09:24] <Ana Laura Diedrichs> who's on the mic?
[23:12:01] SHUCHENG LIU leaves the room
[23:12:01] H. Anthony Chan leaves the room
[23:12:37] Juergen Schoenwaelder leaves the room
[23:12:37] Hammad Mazhar leaves the room
[23:12:37] Simon Pietro Romano leaves the room
[23:12:37] Zubair Shafiq leaves the room
[23:12:37] Mark Ellison leaves the room
[23:12:37] Jéferson Nobre leaves the room
[23:12:37] Laurent Ciavaglia leaves the room
[23:12:38] Ana Laura Diedrichs leaves the room
[23:13:36] meetecho leaves the room
[23:18:36] Yoshiro Yoneya leaves the room