IETF
sfc
sfc@jabber.ietf.org
Wednesday, July 23, 2014< ^ >
Room Configuration
Room Occupants

GMT+0
[00:17:03] test Teat joins the room
[00:18:02] monitor moa joins the room
[00:20:13] monitor moa leaves the room
[00:20:18] test Teat leaves the room
[12:28:30] meetecho video joins the room
[12:29:00] meetecho video leaves the room
[12:29:20] meetecho video feed joins the room
[12:29:40] meetecho video feed leaves the room
[12:29:52] video feed joins the room
[12:31:43] slides feed joins the room
[12:48:23] alessandro amirante joins the room
[12:52:52] Carlos Pignataro joins the room
[12:56:33] Sowmini Varadhan joins the room
[12:57:36] Jeffrey Haas joins the room
[12:57:41] Carlos Pignataro leaves the room
[12:57:57] Carlos Pignataro joins the room
[12:58:49] dhruvdhody joins the room
[12:58:49] bpenfield joins the room
[12:58:52] <Jeffrey Haas> If you are remote, please confirm that the audio is working fine.
[12:58:55] Carlos Pignataro leaves the room
[12:58:56] Carlos Pignataro joins the room
[12:59:19] narten joins the room
[12:59:27] <narten> is the audio stream working?
[12:59:30] Atarashi Yoshifumi joins the room
[12:59:44] <narten> Do we have any remote participants?
[12:59:59] <Carlos Pignataro> I am remote, audio is working now
[13:00:00] <Sowmini Varadhan> audio is working but faint on meetecho
[13:00:06] <Carlos Pignataro> Very faint though
[13:00:14] <Carlos Pignataro> Much better :-)
[13:00:52] Joel Halpern joins the room
[13:02:04] David Lamparter joins the room
[13:03:12] sarikaya2012 joins the room
[13:04:55] dick chen joins the room
[13:04:55] <alessandro amirante> meetecho audio should be better now
[13:04:56] Sowmini Varadhan leaves the room
[13:05:14] sowmini varadhan joins the room
[13:06:29] Melinda Shore joins the room
[13:06:38] <Carlos Pignataro> Audio is much better now -- thank you Alessandro
[13:07:00] <alessandro amirante> you're welcome ;)
[13:07:25] Robert Raszuk joins the room
[13:07:40] <narten> can you all hear ron OK?
[13:08:53] <Carlos Pignataro> The SFC charter does not mention requirements milestones, from a chartering perspective problem statement + architecture seems to cover it
[13:09:13] sowmini varadhan leaves the room
[13:09:14] <Carlos Pignataro> Thomas, yes, we can hear perfectly -- thanks for checking
[13:09:34] Sowmini Varadhan joins the room
[13:09:49] Martin Stiemerling joins the room
[13:11:30] David Lamparter leaves the room
[13:11:32] <Carlos Pignataro> Another comment on requirements: this document seems to be grossly over-specified with trivial as well as lawyer-like requirements
[13:12:47] Melinda Shore leaves the room
[13:13:21] Melinda Shore joins the room
[13:13:28] <Carlos Pignataro> Unnecessarily overly constraining -- requirements are covered as part of the architecture
[13:14:53] <Carlos Pignataro> Agree with Thomas, requirements implicitly covered in the architecture
[13:15:36] David Lamparter joins the room
[13:17:34] bpenfield leaves the room
[13:21:31] bpenfield joins the room
[13:22:10] Sowmini Varadhan leaves the room
[13:23:42] <Joel Halpern> In this case, I think Carlos' comment has been echoed enough times by others.  Putting this instance aside, is there someone who will be relaying jabber comments to the mike?  (I expect to be standing up at the mike a bit too much myself to do so.)
[13:23:45] sowmini varadhan joins the room
[13:26:22] Nik Tomkinson joins the room
[13:27:33] Sriganesh Kini joins the room
[13:28:34] sowmini varadhan leaves the room
[13:28:47] sowmini varadhan joins the room
[13:29:14] Hadriel Kaplan joins the room
[13:29:43] k mak joins the room
[13:29:45] dabernie@lightwitch.org joins the room
[13:30:48] Abhay Roy joins the room
[13:32:00] Praveen Kumar joins the room
[13:33:27] Jon Hudson joins the room
[13:35:35] Abhay Roy leaves the room
[13:35:42] Sriganesh Kini_1199 joins the room
[13:37:38] Nik Tomkinson leaves the room
[13:38:09] <Carlos Pignataro> Yaakov -- thanks! Comment added to Open Items and we will circle back a proposal
[13:40:29] Abhay Roy joins the room
[13:40:54] <Carlos Pignataro> Ack -- thanks Joel. Could not say that better
[13:41:26] Abhay Roy leaves the room
[13:42:15] sowmini varadhan leaves the room
[13:42:27] <Carlos Pignataro> Linda -- the parallel with IP Routing does not work
[13:42:33] Sowmini Varadhan joins the room
[13:42:51] Abhay Roy joins the room
[13:42:59] <Carlos Pignataro> because this is the instantiation of a (partial) ordered list of SFs. It's *NOT* source to dest and nothing else...
[13:43:30] Sowmini Varadhan leaves the room
[13:45:17] <dabernie@lightwitch.org> hi does anybody have trouble with the audio stream ?
[13:45:38] Abhay Roy leaves the room
[13:45:43] <Carlos Pignataro> Thanks Ron -- for the record, there was no text that implied source-routed path always -- but we need to be unambiguous
[13:46:38] Louis Fourie joins the room
[13:47:03] Sowmini Varadhan joins the room
[13:47:07] Prashant Kumar joins the room
[13:48:03] Simon Dredge joins the room
[13:48:07] <Joel Halpern> Someone just pointed out to me that there is a typo in my original message, which we have repeated in each quoting.  s/fully abstract notion of service path as a sequence/fully abstract notion of service chain as a sequence/
[13:48:59] akatlas joins the room
[13:49:16] <Carlos Pignataro> Ack
[13:49:22] Martin Stiemerling leaves the room
[13:51:43] bpenfield leaves the room
[13:54:47] Dean Bogdanovic joins the room
[13:54:57] <narten> can folk hear paul ?
[13:55:05] <Dean Bogdanovic> yes
[13:55:12] <Louis Fourie> yes
[13:55:25] <Dean Bogdanovic> ppt deck is out of focus
[13:55:44] Abhay Roy joins the room
[13:57:15] dhrao joins the room
[13:57:34] dhrao leaves the room
[13:58:19] Martin Stiemerling joins the room
[13:58:23] kiran makhijani joins the room
[13:58:35] Jeffrey Haas leaves the room
[13:58:35] k mak leaves the room
[13:59:13] <Robert Raszuk> Dean ,, with meetecho is always out of focus. That's the meetecho characteristics by IETF noc :)
[14:02:38] Martin Stiemerling leaves the room
[14:03:46] Martin Stiemerling joins the room
[14:03:55] Martin Stiemerling leaves the room
[14:06:09] <Louis Fourie> ack on joel's comment
[14:07:24] ghaleb.al-habian joins the room
[14:12:20] bpenfield joins the room
[14:16:46] ghaleb.al-habian leaves the room
[14:22:22] Simon Romano joins the room
[14:23:13] Simon Romano leaves the room
[14:26:33] Simon Romano joins the room
[14:26:33] akatlas leaves the room
[14:28:40] Jon Hudson leaves the room
[14:30:32] bpenfield leaves the room
[14:32:32] Hudson Jon joins the room
[14:32:40] Atarashi Yoshifumi leaves the room
[14:35:01] dabernie@lightwitch.org leaves the room
[14:35:25] David Lamparter leaves the room
[14:35:59] Dean Bogdanovic leaves the room
[14:42:15] D Rao joins the room
[14:44:25] D Rao leaves the room
[14:46:31] Melinda Shore leaves the room
[14:48:00] Louis Fourie leaves the room
[14:48:22] Louis Fourie joins the room
[14:56:20] Sowmini Varadhan leaves the room
[14:56:39] Sowmini Varadhan joins the room
[14:58:19] bpenfield joins the room
[15:01:00] Sowmini Varadhan leaves the room
[15:03:36] Robert Raszuk leaves the room
[15:04:21] Robert Raszuk joins the room
[15:04:21] Louis Fourie leaves the room
[15:05:08] louis fourie joins the room
[15:06:48] Sriganesh Kini leaves the room
[15:07:16] Sriganesh Kini_1199 leaves the room
[15:11:36] bpenfield leaves the room
[15:13:09] Hudson Jon leaves the room
[15:14:43] Hadriel Kaplan leaves the room
[15:15:50] Pasquale Bevilacqua joins the room
[15:16:48] dhruvdhody leaves the room
[15:16:48] Robert Raszuk leaves the room
[15:17:38] Pasquale Bevilacqua leaves the room
[15:18:23] Prashant Kumar leaves the room
[15:18:47] Simon Dredge leaves the room
[15:19:25] Simon Dredge joins the room
[15:22:04] Simon Dredge leaves the room
[15:22:23] sarikaya2012 leaves the room
[15:22:33] alessandro amirante leaves the room
[15:22:43] Carlos Pignataro leaves the room
[15:22:45] dick chen leaves the room
[15:23:02] slides feed leaves the room
[15:23:23] Abhay Roy leaves the room
[15:23:30] louis fourie leaves the room
[15:23:31] Simon Romano leaves the room
[15:23:40] kiran makhijani leaves the room
[15:23:51] Praveen Kumar leaves the room
[15:24:27] video feed leaves the room
[15:25:48] Joel Halpern leaves the room
[15:28:52] dhruvdhody joins the room
[15:31:50] Carlos Pignataro joins the room
[15:42:20] narten leaves the room
[16:25:34] narten joins the room
[16:26:37] narten leaves the room
[16:35:00] dhruvdhody leaves the room
[16:48:03] dhruvdhody joins the room
[16:53:49] Sriganesh Kini joins the room
[17:06:58] Sriganesh Kini leaves the room
[17:16:08] Joel Halpern joins the room
[18:45:57] Joel Halpern leaves the room
[18:50:12] dhruvdhody leaves the room
[19:25:25] Carlos Pignataro leaves the room
Powered by ejabberd Powered by Erlang Valid XHTML 1.0 Transitional Valid CSS!