nsis@conference.ietf.jabber.com - 2002/11/19
[10:52] %% mrose has arrived.
[11:13] %% andersa has arrived.
[11:23] %% davidoran has arrived.
[11:27] %% davidoran has left.
[11:36] %% hta has arrived.
[11:41] %% samting has arrived.
[11:44] %% davidoran has arrived.
[11:44] %% samting has left.
[11:45] %% avri has arrived.
[11:45] %% avri has left.
[11:55] %% jsau has arrived.
[11:55] %% jsau has left.
[12:02] %% paul.knight has arrived.
[12:04] %% starsu has arrived.
[12:11] %% paul.knight has left.
[12:11] %% davidoran has left.
[12:15] %% mrose has left.
[12:23] %% andersa has left.
[12:27] %% starsu has left.
[12:28] %% hta has left.
[14:13] %% john loughney has arrived.
[14:19] %% john loughney has left.
nsis@conference.ietf.jabber.com - 2002/11/20
[06:20] %% Xiaoming has arrived.
[06:22] %% Xiaoming has left.
[07:18] %% mrose has arrived.
[07:22] %% Xiaoming has arrived.
[07:22] %% Xiaoming has left.
[07:27] %% smb@research.att.com has arrived.
[07:30] %% mlshore has arrived.
[07:32] %% andersa has arrived.
[07:41] %% Xiaoming has arrived.
[07:42] %% Xiaoming has left.
[07:43] %% Xiaoming has arrived.
[07:43] %% Xiaoming has left.
[07:52] %% swb has arrived.
[07:52] %% john loughney has arrived.
[07:53] <john loughney> Slides available at: http://www-nrc.nokia.com/sua/nsis/ietf55/index.htm
[07:53] <john loughney> current discussion:
[07:54] <john loughney> Trade-offs and open issues with path discovery and transport - Henning Schulzrinne - (15 min)
http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-schulzrinne-nsis-casp-00.txt
Trade-offs and open issues with path discovery and transport - Henning Schulzrinne - (15 min)
http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-schulzrinne-nsis-casp-00.txt
Trade-offs and open issues with path discovery and transport - Henning Schulzrinne - (15 min)
[07:57] %% admcd has arrived.
[08:15] %% swb has left.
[08:15] %% starsu has arrived.
[08:37] %% andersa has left.
[08:47] <john loughney> Just presented: A Two-Level Architecture for Internet Signaling - chair - (10 min)
http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-braden-2level-signaling-01.txt
http://www-nrc.nokia.com/sua/nsis/ietf55/2level.atlanta.ppt
[08:47] <john loughney> Big discussion on issues on layer splitting.
[08:48] <john loughney> Some discussion if RSVP is really broken so that we should embark on larger work of redesigning everything.
[08:49] <john loughney> Now being discussed: Sender and Receiver Orientation Issues in NSIS - Robert Hancock - (10 min)
http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-hancock-nsis-sender-receiver-00.txt
http://www-nrc.Nokia.com/sua/nsis/ietf55/NSIS-Sender-Receiver-Issues.ppt
[08:53] <john loughney> Comment:discussion of directionality at the transport layer is a non-issue
[08:54] <john loughney> Analysis of Existing Quality of Service Signaling Protocols - Jukka Manner - (10 min)
http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-ietf-nsis-signalling-analysis-00.txt
http://www-nrc.nokia.com/sua/nsis/ietf55/analysis.pdf
[08:56] <john loughney> Suggestion from chair: those with experience with RSVP, please submit your experiences. If you have suggestions for other protocols to be included, please suggest text.
[08:57] <starsu> I'll consider your proposal. (Sung-Hyuck Lee)
[08:58] <john loughney> thanks
[09:01] <john loughney> now presenting:
[09:01] <john loughney> NSIS Threats - H. Tschofenig - (10min)
http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-ietf-nsis-threats-00.txt
http://www-nrc.nokia.com/sua/nsis/ietf55/Security-Signaling.ppt
[09:10] %% Rocket Man has arrived.
[09:19] %% john loughney has left.
[09:19] %% john loughney has arrived.
[09:19] <john loughney> Good discussion, with Steve Bellovin discussing some issues with multi-party authorization.
[09:19] <john loughney> Authorization is probably the major issue to tackle.
[09:20] <john loughney> Replay protection & confidentiality are needed
[09:21] <john loughney> One possible mechanism is to try to split the functionality in the 2 layer architecture to enable authorization on a 2-party (or limited number of parties) basis.
[09:21] <john loughney> Now discussing: RSVP Security Properties - H. Tschofenig - (10min)
http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-ietf-nsis-rsvp-sec-properties-00.txt
http://www-nrc.nokia.com/sua/nsis/ietf55/RSVP-Security-Properties.ppt
[09:25] <john loughney> Chair requests everyone to review this document and send comments
[09:27] <john loughney> Now discussing: Analysis of Existing QoS Solutions - G. Karagiannis - (10 min)
http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-demeer-nsis-analysis-03.txt
http://www-nrc.nokia.com/sua/nsis/ietf55/IETF55-Analysis-karagiannis-02.ppt
[09:34] <john loughney> now up:
[09:34] <john loughney> Analysis of Mobile IP and RSVP Interactions - Mike Thomas - (10 minutes)
http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-thomas-nsis-rsvp-analysis-00.txt
http://www-nrc.nokia.com/sua/nsis/ietf55/NSIS-RSVP-Mobility-Interactions.ppt
[09:40] %% mrose has left.
[09:42] %% Rocket Man has left.
[09:45] %% mlshore has left.
[09:45] %% starsu has left.
[09:47] %% john loughney has left.
[09:49] %% smb@research.att.com has left.
[09:49] %% admcd has left.