Nicolas: review of 3 darfts. Review of the definition of multihomed MN mip6-analysis draft FD: What is point 3 (one HoA and one CoA configured on different interfaces) Bechet : Multiple HoA is multiple HA addreses ? Nicolas : No, it is multiple Home addresses, and not necessarily different HAs George : Bi-casting is defined as n-casting or not? Nicolas: n-casting Multiple CoA draft by Ruyji ----------------- Hesham: C & R flags only for the HA? Ruyji: yes xx: BID - 1 byte instead of 2 bytes? xx: Considering deployment of MIP in wireless networks, like planes & ships with many interafces. Vijay: When u send bulk regi, does HA create tunnels, without veryfying all the paths? Sri: How to verify connectivity between HA & CoA? we need to clarify Chanwah - Mechanisms exist. MIP can use alternate CoA. Utilizing Home and Away Interfaces Simultaneously by Benjamin?? ------------------------------------------------ Hesham: McoA registers two CoAs. MN is at home and foreign network - Why do u want to support this? xx: e.g. Cellular & WLAN Hesham : Should be resolved by MCoA ? => Where should it be resolved ? Ruyji : modification is required when returning home network What is the address in the HomeLink ? => HomeLink Prefix + UID => 2 HoA Policy exchanges - what is in charter by Nicolas ----------------------------------------------- Hendrik: policy vs filter rules. Filters rules are the result of policy application monami6 - only filter rules shim6 - only policy rules Filter rules are identified filter ID, flow ID represents truplets, definition is misleading filter format has to be static/dynamic & conflicting Hesham: policy/filter rules should be exchange by SHIM6 or other mech Henrik: filter rules to multiple coas. define the filter rule definition language, pf format. Hesham : Why a protocol for all (MIP, SHIM6) ? Concepts are similar but a generic solution may not be desirable. There's no conflict at the moment hendrik: It may not be a good idea, but nothing tell us it is a bad. hesham. my point is -> general discussion level, i can't accept, at the moment it's too complicated Hendrik : you can define rule in the sameway George: Two things to consider. Filter rule lanusage is binary vs text based. Filter rule can be mipv6 or hip based hendrik: This is the wrong trade xx: Binary vs text - efficiency is important for some of the protocols hendrik : can we do a comparision Do we have expertise on Monami6 to define a language for filter rules Is there another protocol carrying same information => Flow binding by Hesham ------------------------ Alex: is this format extensible? => Yes, by sub-option and option length vijay : you only have 256 mobility options should not define everything that makes complicated Hesham: sub options can be added Hendrik; can u send it in both direction (from and to HA) How do you address Some conflict resolution? Hesham: priority field A Scheme Fragment for Flow Distribution ------------------------------------------- Transport and XML choices may be discussed JMCombes : If transmitted with BU,BA, security assoc is already done, if done differently, a new SA should be setup Log of Jabber - monami6 ------------------------ koojana has entered the room. [23:36] The topic has been set to: [23:40] momose has entered the room. [23:47] I am on the jabber [23:47] bonninjm@jabber.org has entered the room. [23:48] FDupont has entered the room. [23:48] henrik has entered the room. [23:48] Monami6 session is starting [23:49] Thierry is going through the agenda [23:49] It is Nicolas [23:50] Yes, now. [23:51] Slide 2 of doc summary [23:51] slide 3 [23:53] Francis D asks for a clarification of item III of slide 3 [23:53] Bechet at the mike [23:53] - wondering if HA is home addresses or home agents [23:53] slide 4 [23:54] gr8k@jabber.org has entered the room. [23:54] (on 'Change in requirements') [23:54] Slide 5 on Bicasting [23:55] xcasting ? [23:55] George at the mike: Bicasting or X-casting? [23:55] bi- tri- etc. [23:56] ok [23:56] Benjamin presenting MCoA draft status [23:57] could people annouce their name when coming to the mike plz ? [23:57] Benjamin or Ruyji? [23:57] Sorry, Ryuji [23:57] Hesham S at the mike [23:58] George at the mike [23:58] miaofy has entered the room. [23:59] Alex and George about one or two bytes for numbering the bindings [23:59] Sri at the mike [00:01] Chang Hua at the mike [00:04] Benjamin? about simultaneously using home link and foreign link interfaces [00:06] Now on slide 4 [00:07] slide 5 [00:08] slide 6 [00:08] Hesham sneaking up to the mike [00:11] Ryuji at the mike [00:12] Kent at the mike [00:13] washad has entered the room. [00:19] is Hendrik's presentation available? [00:29] Courtney has entered the room. [00:29] Courtney has left the room. [00:32] scribe ? [00:40] washad has left the room. [00:42] washad has entered the room. [00:50] FDupont has left the room. [00:50] miaofy has left the room.