Minutes of the HIP WG Session at IETF 80
========================================

Minutes edited by Gonzalo Camarillo
Based on notes by Ari Keranen and Tom Henderson
Meeting chaired by Gonzalo Camarillo
Slides presented included in the proceedings

Thursday, March 31st, 1520-1720
-------------------------------

Topic: Agenda Bash
Discussions led by: Chair

The chair presented the status of the WG.


Topic: RFC 4423bis
Discussion led by: Robert Moskowitz

Bob presented the status of the document. There is an open issue about
whether it is possible to use random 128 EIDs. We need to look at the
implications of allowing HITs to be random or justify the benefits of
making it cryptographic. It was pointed out that HIP for RELOAD
benefits from alternative HITs and that HIP for RFID also uses random
identifiers.


Topic: RFC 5201bis
Discussion led by: Robert Moskowitz

Bob presented the status of the document. Gonzalo sugested to use the
WG's tracker to track open issues. Bob pointed out that the prefix for
ORCHIDs (RFC 4843) is not listed by the IANA. Bob will send a note to
the list so that someone takes care of resolving the issue.

Bob stated that ignoring incoming IP addresses may violate other
policies. Tom thinks it is probably not relevant because it is already
allowed and because it may be out of scope anyway. The goal is to be
able to WGLC this draft before Quebec.


Topic: RFC 5206bis
Discussion led by: Tom Henderson

Tom presented the status of the draft. It was suggested to use UPDATEs
with different type values. Discussions on UPDATE signatures and
middle boxes will be taken to the list. The goal is to be able to WGLC
this draft before Quebec.


The meeting ended.