Andrei Presented protocol & negotiation draft discussion about the need to validate presented/referred token IDs in the federated case discussion about token key binding parameters consensus to use 1-byte IDs reusing existing TLS registry & track what TLS1.3 is going to do discussion on token binding extensions - eg for use to convey attestations - martin thomson: extensions need to be signed martin thomson (and others): why are extensions needed? need more examples? weak support for extensibility right now , consensus to punt on extensions for later, possibly with a revised protocol version consensus to adopt the negotiation draft as WG document, Andrei will revise and republish under wg name in a couple of weeks discussion on how to verify provided tokens id's in the federated case and the implications for key parameter negotiations Dirk presented HTTPS binding recap of tokenbinding-https review of changes to http header & dropped DOM APIs open issues - threat analysis and the need for the Sec- prefix martin thomson, john bradley, phil hunt - discussion at mic about the threat analysis, maybe Sec- is not needed but estethically good extent of federation support in spec: only include redirect case in spec martin: we need to spell out referred token id verification discussion continues on list - consensus to add security threat analysis to security considerations section