< draft-ietf-suit-manifest-09.txt   draft-ietf-suit-manifest-10.txt >
SUIT B. Moran SUIT B. Moran
Internet-Draft H. Tschofenig Internet-Draft H. Tschofenig
Intended status: Standards Track Arm Limited Intended status: Standards Track Arm Limited
Expires: January 14, 2021 H. Birkholz Expires: May 6, 2021 H. Birkholz
Fraunhofer SIT Fraunhofer SIT
K. Zandberg K. Zandberg
Inria Inria
July 13, 2020 November 02, 2020
A Concise Binary Object Representation (CBOR)-based Serialization Format A Concise Binary Object Representation (CBOR)-based Serialization Format
for the Software Updates for Internet of Things (SUIT) Manifest for the Software Updates for Internet of Things (SUIT) Manifest
draft-ietf-suit-manifest-09 draft-ietf-suit-manifest-10
Abstract Abstract
This specification describes the format of a manifest. A manifest is This specification describes the format of a manifest. A manifest is
a bundle of metadata about the firmware for an IoT device, where to a bundle of metadata about code/data obtained by a recipient (chiefly
find the firmware, the devices to which it applies, and cryptographic the firmware for an IoT device), where to find the that code/data,
information protecting the manifest. Firmware updates and secure the devices to which it applies, and cryptographic information
boot both tend to use sequences of common operations, so the manifest protecting the manifest. Software updates and Trusted Invocation
both tend to use sequences of common operations, so the manifest
encodes those sequences of operations, rather than declaring the encodes those sequences of operations, rather than declaring the
metadata. The manifest also serves as a building block for secure metadata.
boot.
Status of This Memo Status of This Memo
This Internet-Draft is submitted in full conformance with the This Internet-Draft is submitted in full conformance with the
provisions of BCP 78 and BCP 79. provisions of BCP 78 and BCP 79.
Internet-Drafts are working documents of the Internet Engineering Internet-Drafts are working documents of the Internet Engineering
Task Force (IETF). Note that other groups may also distribute Task Force (IETF). Note that other groups may also distribute
working documents as Internet-Drafts. The list of current Internet- working documents as Internet-Drafts. The list of current Internet-
Drafts is at https://datatracker.ietf.org/drafts/current/. Drafts is at https://datatracker.ietf.org/drafts/current/.
Internet-Drafts are draft documents valid for a maximum of six months Internet-Drafts are draft documents valid for a maximum of six months
and may be updated, replaced, or obsoleted by other documents at any and may be updated, replaced, or obsoleted by other documents at any
time. It is inappropriate to use Internet-Drafts as reference time. It is inappropriate to use Internet-Drafts as reference
material or to cite them other than as "work in progress." material or to cite them other than as "work in progress."
This Internet-Draft will expire on January 14, 2021. This Internet-Draft will expire on May 6, 2021.
Copyright Notice Copyright Notice
Copyright (c) 2020 IETF Trust and the persons identified as the Copyright (c) 2020 IETF Trust and the persons identified as the
document authors. All rights reserved. document authors. All rights reserved.
This document is subject to BCP 78 and the IETF Trust's Legal This document is subject to BCP 78 and the IETF Trust's Legal
Provisions Relating to IETF Documents Provisions Relating to IETF Documents
(https://trustee.ietf.org/license-info) in effect on the date of (https://trustee.ietf.org/license-info) in effect on the date of
publication of this document. Please review these documents publication of this document. Please review these documents
skipping to change at page 2, line 25 skipping to change at page 2, line 25
Table of Contents Table of Contents
1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
2. Conventions and Terminology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 2. Conventions and Terminology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
3. How to use this Document . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 3. How to use this Document . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
4. Background . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 4. Background . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
4.1. IoT Firmware Update Constraints . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 4.1. IoT Firmware Update Constraints . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
4.2. SUIT Workflow Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 4.2. SUIT Workflow Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
5. Metadata Structure Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 5. Metadata Structure Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11
5.1. Envelope . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 5.1. Envelope . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
5.2. Delegation Chains . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 5.2. Delegation Chains . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
5.3. Authentication Block . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 5.3. Authentication Block . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
5.4. Manifest . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 5.4. Manifest . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
5.4.1. Critical Metadata . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 5.4.1. Critical Metadata . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
5.4.2. Common . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 5.4.2. Common . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
5.4.3. Command Sequences . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 5.4.3. Command Sequences . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
5.4.4. Integrity Check Values . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 5.4.4. Integrity Check Values . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
5.4.5. Human-Readable Text . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 5.4.5. Human-Readable Text . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
5.5. Severable Elements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 5.5. Severable Elements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
5.6. Integrated Dependencies and Payloads . . . . . . . . . . 15 5.6. Integrated Dependencies and Payloads . . . . . . . . . . 16
6. Interpreter Behavior . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 6. Manifest Processor Behavior . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
6.1. Interpreter Setup . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 6.1. Manifest Processor Setup . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
6.2. Required Checks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 6.2. Required Checks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
6.2.1. Minimizing Signature Verifications . . . . . . . . . 18 6.2.1. Minimizing Signature Verifications . . . . . . . . . 19
6.3. Interpreter Fundamental Properties . . . . . . . . . . . 19 6.3. Interpreter Fundamental Properties . . . . . . . . . . . 19
6.4. Abstract Machine Description . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 6.4. Abstract Machine Description . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
6.5. Special Cases of Component Index and Dependency Index . . 21 6.5. Special Cases of Component Index and Dependency Index . . 22
6.6. Serialized Processing Interpreter . . . . . . . . . . . . 22 6.6. Serialized Processing Interpreter . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
6.7. Parallel Processing Interpreter . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22 6.7. Parallel Processing Interpreter . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
6.8. Processing Dependencies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 6.8. Processing Dependencies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25
6.9. Multiple Manifest Processors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 6.9. Multiple Manifest Processors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25
7. Creating Manifests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 7. Creating Manifests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27
7.1. Compatibility Check Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 7.1. Compatibility Check Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27
7.2. Secure Boot Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 7.2. Trusted Invocation Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28
7.3. Firmware Download Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 7.3. Component Download Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28
7.4. Install Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 7.4. Install Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29
7.5. Integrated Payload Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27 7.5. Install and Transform Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29
7.6. Load from Nonvolatile Storage Template . . . . . . . . . 27 7.6. Integrated Payload Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30
7.7. Load & Decompress from Nonvolatile Storage Template . . . 27 7.7. Load from Nonvolatile Storage Template . . . . . . . . . 31
7.8. Dependency Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 7.8. Load & Decompress from Nonvolatile Storage Template . . . 31
7.8.1. Composite Manifests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 7.9. Dependency Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31
7.9. Encrypted Manifest Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 7.9.1. Composite Manifests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32
7.10. A/B Image Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 7.10. Encrypted Manifest Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32
8. Metadata Structure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30 7.11. A/B Image Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33
8.1. Encoding Considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31 8. Metadata Structure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35
8.2. Envelope . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31 8.1. Encoding Considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35
8.3. Delegation Chains . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31 8.2. Envelope . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35
8.4. Authenticated Manifests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32 8.3. Delegation Chains . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35
8.5. Encrypted Manifests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32 8.4. Authenticated Manifests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36
8.6. Manifest . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32 8.5. Encrypted Manifests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36
8.6.1. suit-manifest-version . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33 8.6. Manifest . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36
8.6.2. suit-manifest-sequence-number . . . . . . . . . . . . 33 8.6.1. suit-manifest-version . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37
8.6.3. suit-reference-uri . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33 8.6.2. suit-manifest-sequence-number . . . . . . . . . . . . 37
8.6.4. suit-text . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34 8.6.3. suit-reference-uri . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38
8.7. text-version-required . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35 8.6.4. suit-text . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38
8.7.1. suit-coswid . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35 8.7. text-version-required . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40
8.7.2. suit-common . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36 8.7.1. suit-coswid . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40
8.7.3. SUIT_Command_Sequence . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 8.7.2. suit-common . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40
8.7.4. Reporting Policy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40 8.7.3. SUIT_Command_Sequence . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42
8.7.5. SUIT_Parameters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 41 8.7.4. Reporting Policy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44
8.7.6. SUIT_Condition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 51 8.7.5. SUIT_Parameters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46
8.7.7. SUIT_Directive . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 55 8.7.6. SUIT_Condition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 56
8.7.8. Integrity Check Values . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 62 8.7.7. SUIT_Directive . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 60
8.8. Severable Elements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 62 8.7.8. Integrity Check Values . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 67
9. Access Control Lists . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 63 8.8. Severable Elements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 67
10. SUIT Digest Container . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 63 9. Access Control Lists . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68
11. IANA Considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 63 10. SUIT Digest Container . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68
11.1. SUIT Commands . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 64 11. IANA Considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 69
11.2. SUIT Parameters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 65 11.1. SUIT Commands . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 69
11.3. SUIT Text Values . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 67 11.2. SUIT Parameters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 71
11.4. SUIT Component Text Values . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 67 11.3. SUIT Text Values . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 73
11.5. SUIT Algorithm Identifiers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 67 11.4. SUIT Component Text Values . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 73
11.5.1. SUIT Digest Algorithm Identifiers . . . . . . . . . 67 11.5. SUIT Algorithm Identifiers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 73
11.5.2. SUIT Compression Algorithm Identifiers . . . . . . . 68 11.5.1. SUIT Digest Algorithm Identifiers . . . . . . . . . 73
11.5.3. Unpack Algorithms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68 11.5.2. SUIT Compression Algorithm Identifiers . . . . . . . 74
12. Security Considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 69 11.5.3. Unpack Algorithms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 74
13. Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 69 12. Security Considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 75
14. References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 69 13. Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 75
14.1. Normative References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 69 14. References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 75
14.2. Informative References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 70 14.1. Normative References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 75
14.3. URIs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 71 14.2. Informative References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 76
A. Full CDDL . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 72 Appendix A. A. Full CDDL . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 78
B. Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 82 Appendix B. B. Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 87
B.1. Example 0: Secure Boot . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 83 B.1. Example 0: Secure Boot . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 88
B.2. Example 1: Simultaneous Download and Installation of B.2. Example 1: Simultaneous Download and Installation of
Payload . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 85 Payload . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 90
B.3. Example 2: Simultaneous Download, Installation, Secure B.3. Example 2: Simultaneous Download, Installation, Secure
Boot, Severed Fields . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 88 Boot, Severed Fields . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 92
B.4. Example 3: A/B images . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 92 B.4. Example 3: A/B images . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 96
B.5. Example 4: Load and Decompress from External Storage . . 96 B.5. Example 4: Load and Decompress from External Storage . . 99
B.6. Example 5: Two Images . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 100 B.6. Example 5: Two Images . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 102
C. Design Rational . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 103 Appendix C. C. Design Rational . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 105
C.1. C.1 Design Rationale: Envelope . . . . . . . . . . . . . 104 C.1. C.1 Design Rationale: Envelope . . . . . . . . . . . . . 106
C.2. C.2 Byte String Wrappers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 105 C.2. C.2 Byte String Wrappers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 107
D. Implementation Conformance Matrix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 106 Appendix D. D. Implementation Conformance Matrix . . . . . . . . 108
Authors' Addresses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 109 Authors' Addresses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111
1. Introduction 1. Introduction
A firmware update mechanism is an essential security feature for IoT A firmware update mechanism is an essential security feature for IoT
devices to deal with vulnerabilities. While the transport of devices to deal with vulnerabilities. While the transport of
firmware images to the devices themselves is important there are firmware images to the devices themselves is important there are
already various techniques available. Equally important is the already various techniques available. Equally important is the
inclusion of metadata about the conveyed firmware image (in the form inclusion of metadata about the conveyed firmware image (in the form
of a manifest) and the use of a security wrapper to provide end-to- of a manifest) and the use of a security wrapper to provide end-to-
end security protection to detect modifications and (optionally) to end security protection to detect modifications and (optionally) to
skipping to change at page 4, line 36 skipping to change at page 4, line 36
the author, who builds the firmware image, to be sure that no other the author, who builds the firmware image, to be sure that no other
party (including potential adversaries) can install firmware updates party (including potential adversaries) can install firmware updates
on IoT devices without adequate privileges. For confidentiality on IoT devices without adequate privileges. For confidentiality
protected firmware images it is additionally required to encrypt the protected firmware images it is additionally required to encrypt the
firmware image. Starting security protection at the author is a risk firmware image. Starting security protection at the author is a risk
mitigation technique so firmware images and manifests can be stored mitigation technique so firmware images and manifests can be stored
on untrusted repositories; it also reduces the scope of a compromise on untrusted repositories; it also reduces the scope of a compromise
of any repository or intermediate system to be no worse than a denial of any repository or intermediate system to be no worse than a denial
of service. of service.
A manifest is a bundle of metadata about the firmware for an IoT A manifest is a bundle of metadata describing one or more code or
device, where to find the firmware, the devices to which it applies, data payloads and how to:
and cryptographic information protecting the manifest.
- Obtain any dependencies
- Obtain the payload(s)
- Install them
- Verify them
- Load them into memory
- Invoke them
This specification defines the SUIT manifest format and it is This specification defines the SUIT manifest format and it is
intended to meet several goals: intended to meet several goals:
- Meet the requirements defined in - Meet the requirements defined in
[I-D.ietf-suit-information-model]. [I-D.ietf-suit-information-model].
- Simple to parse on a constrained node - Simple to parse on a constrained node
- Simple to process on a constrained node - Simple to process on a constrained node
skipping to change at page 5, line 4 skipping to change at page 5, line 15
- Meet the requirements defined in - Meet the requirements defined in
[I-D.ietf-suit-information-model]. [I-D.ietf-suit-information-model].
- Simple to parse on a constrained node - Simple to parse on a constrained node
- Simple to process on a constrained node - Simple to process on a constrained node
- Compact encoding - Compact encoding
- Comprehensible by an intermediate system - Comprehensible by an intermediate system
- Expressive enough to enable advanced use cases on advanced nodes - Expressive enough to enable advanced use cases on advanced nodes
- Extensible - Extensible
The SUIT manifest can be used for a variety of purposes throughout The SUIT manifest can be used for a variety of purposes throughout
its lifecycle, such as: its lifecycle, such as:
- the Firmware Author to reason about releasing a firmware. - a Firmware Author to reason about releasing a firmware.
- the Network Operator to reason about compatibility of a firmware. - a Network Operator to reason about compatibility of a firmware.
- the Device Operator to reason about the impact of a firmware. - a Device Operator to reason about the impact of a firmware.
- the Device Operator to manage distribution of firmware to devices. - the Device Operator to manage distribution of firmware to devices.
- the Plant Manager to reason about timing and acceptance of - a Plant Manager to reason about timing and acceptance of firmware
firmware updates. updates.
- the device to reason about the authority & authenticity of a - a device to reason about the authority & authenticity of a
firmware prior to installation. firmware prior to installation.
- the device to reason about the applicability of a firmware. - a device to reason about the applicability of a firmware.
- the device to reason about the installation of a firmware. - a device to reason about the installation of a firmware.
- the device to reason about the authenticity & encoding of a - a device to reason about the authenticity & encoding of a firmware
firmware at boot. at boot.
Each of these uses happens at a different stage of the manifest Each of these uses happens at a different stage of the manifest
lifecycle, so each has different requirements. lifecycle, so each has different requirements.
It is assumed that the reader is familiar with the high-level It is assumed that the reader is familiar with the high-level
firmware update architecture [I-D.ietf-suit-architecture] and the firmware update architecture [I-D.ietf-suit-architecture] and the
threats, requirements, and user stories in threats, requirements, and user stories in
[I-D.ietf-suit-information-model]. [I-D.ietf-suit-information-model].
The design of this specification is based on an observation that the The design of this specification is based on an observation that the
vast majority of operations that a device can perform during an vast majority of operations that a device can perform during an
update or secure boot are composed of a small group of operations: update or Trusted Invocation are composed of a small group of
operations:
- Copy some data from one place to another - Copy some data from one place to another
- Transform some data - Transform some data
- Digest some data and compare to an expected value - Digest some data and compare to an expected value
- Compare some system parameters to an expected value - Compare some system parameters to an expected value
- Run some code - Run some code
In the SUIT manifest specification, these operations are called In this document, these operations are called commands. Commands are
commands. Commands are classed as either conditions or directives. classed as either conditions or directives. Conditions have no side-
Conditions have no side-effects, while directives do have side- effects, while directives do have side-effects. Conceptually, a
effects. Conceptually, a sequence of commands is like a script but sequence of commands is like a script but the used language is
the used language is tailored to software updates and secure boot. tailored to software updates and Trusted Invocation.
The available commands support simple steps, such as copying a The available commands support simple steps, such as copying a
firmware image from one place to another, checking that a firmware firmware image from one place to another, checking that a firmware
image is correct, verifying that the specified firmware is the image is correct, verifying that the specified firmware is the
correct firmware for the device, or unpacking a firmware. By using correct firmware for the device, or unpacking a firmware. By using
these steps in different orders and changing the parameters they use, these steps in different orders and changing the parameters they use,
a broad range of use cases can be supported. The SUIT manifest uses a broad range of use cases can be supported. The SUIT manifest uses
this observation to optimize metadata for consumption by constrained this observation to optimize metadata for consumption by constrained
devices. devices.
While the SUIT manifest is informed by and optimized for firmware While the SUIT manifest is informed by and optimized for firmware
update and secure boot use cases, there is nothing in the update and Trusted Invocation use cases, there is nothing in the
[I-D.ietf-suit-information-model] that restricts its use to only [I-D.ietf-suit-information-model] that restricts its use to only
those use cases. Other use cases include the management of trusted those use cases. Other use cases include the management of trusted
applications in a Trusted Execution Environment (TEE), see applications (TAs) in a Trusted Execution Environment (TEE), as
[I-D.ietf-teep-architecture]. discussed in [I-D.ietf-teep-architecture].
2. Conventions and Terminology 2. Conventions and Terminology
The key words "MUST", "MUST NOT", "REQUIRED", "SHALL", "SHALL NOT", The key words "MUST", "MUST NOT", "REQUIRED", "SHALL", "SHALL NOT",
"SHOULD", "SHOULD NOT", "RECOMMENDED", "NOT RECOMMENDED", "MAY", and "SHOULD", "SHOULD NOT", "RECOMMENDED", "NOT RECOMMENDED", "MAY", and
"OPTIONAL" in this document are to be interpreted as described in "OPTIONAL" in this document are to be interpreted as described in
BCP 14 [RFC2119] [RFC8174] when, and only when, they appear in all BCP 14 [RFC2119] [RFC8174] when, and only when, they appear in all
capitals, as shown here. capitals, as shown here.
The following terminology is used throughout this document: Additionally, the following terminology is used throughout this
document:
- SUIT: Software Update for the Internet of Things, also the IETF - SUIT: Software Update for the Internet of Things, also the IETF
working group for this standard. working group for this standard.
- Payload: A piece of information to be delivered. Typically - Payload: A piece of information to be delivered. Typically
Firmware for the purposes of SUIT. Firmware for the purposes of SUIT.
- Resource: A piece of information that is used to construct a - Resource: A piece of information that is used to construct a
payload. payload.
- Manifest: A manifest is a bundle of metadata about the firmware - Manifest: A manifest is a bundle of metadata about the firmware
for an IoT device, where to find the firmware, and the devices to for an IoT device, where to find the firmware, and the devices to
which it applies. which it applies.
- Envelope: A container with the manifest, an authentication wrapper - Envelope: A container with the manifest, an authentication wrapper
with cryptographic information protecting the manifest, with cryptographic information protecting the manifest,
authorization information, and severed fields. authorization information, and severable elements (see: TBD).
- Update: One or more manifests that describe one or more payloads. - Update: One or more manifests that describe one or more payloads.
- Update Authority: The owner of a cryptographic key used to sign - Update Authority: The owner of a cryptographic key used to sign
updates, trusted by Recipients. updates, trusted by Recipients.
- Recipient: The system, typically an IoT device, that receives and - Recipient: The system, typically an IoT device, that receives and
processes a manifest. processes a manifest.
- Manifest Processor: A component of the Recipient that consumes - Manifest Processor: A component of the Recipient that consumes
skipping to change at page 7, line 33 skipping to change at page 7, line 46
- Component Set: A group of interdependent Components that must be - Component Set: A group of interdependent Components that must be
updated simultaneously. updated simultaneously.
- Command: A Condition or a Directive. - Command: A Condition or a Directive.
- Condition: A test for a property of the Recipient or its - Condition: A test for a property of the Recipient or its
Components. Components.
- Directive: An action for the Recipient to perform. - Directive: An action for the Recipient to perform.
- Trusted Execution: A process by which a system ensures that only - Trusted Invocation: A process by which a system ensures that only
trusted code is executed, for example secure boot. trusted code is executed, for example secure boot or launching a
Trusted Application.
- A/B images: Dividing a Recipient's storage into two or more - A/B images: Dividing a Recipient's storage into two or more
bootable images, at different offsets, such that the active image bootable images, at different offsets, such that the active image
can write to the inactive image(s). can write to the inactive image(s).
- Record: The result of a Command and any metadata about it. - Record: The result of a Command and any metadata about it.
- Report: A list of Records. - Report: A list of Records.
- Procedure: The process of invoking one or more sequences of - Procedure: The process of invoking one or more sequences of
commands. commands.
- Update Procedure: A procedure that updates a Recipient by fetching - Update Procedure: A procedure that updates a Recipient by fetching
dependencies, software images, and installing them. dependencies and images, and installing them.
- Boot Procedure: A procedure that boots a Recipient by verifying - Invocation Procedure: A procedure in which a Recipient verifies
dependencies and images, loading images, and invoking one or more dependencies and images, loading images, and invokes one or more
image. image.
- Software: Instructions and data that allow a Recipient to perform - Software: Instructions and data that allow a Recipient to perform
a useful function. a useful function.
- Firmware: Instructions and data that allow a Recipient to perform - Firmware: Software that is typically changed infrequently, stored
a useful function. Typically, changed infrequently, stored in in nonvolatile memory, and small enough to apply to [RFC7228]
nonvolatile memory, and small enough to apply to [RFC7228] Class Class 0-2 devices.
0-2 devices.
- Image: Information that a Recipient uses to perform its function, - Image: Information that a Recipient uses to perform its function,
typically firmware/software, configuration, or resource data such typically firmware/software, configuration, or resource data such
as text or images. Also, a Payload, once installed is an Image. as text or images. Also, a Payload, once installed is an Image.
- Slot: One of several possible storage locations for a given - Slot: One of several possible storage locations for a given
Component, typically used in A/B image systems Component, typically used in A/B image systems
- Abort: The Manifest Processor immediately halts execution of the - Abort: An event in which the Manifest Processor immediately halts
current Procedure. It creates a Record of an error condition. execution of the current Procedure. It creates a Record of an
error condition.
3. How to use this Document 3. How to use this Document
This specification covers five aspects of firmware update: This specification covers five aspects of firmware update:
- Section 4 describes the device constraints, use cases, and design - Section 4 describes the device constraints, use cases, and design
principles that informed the structure of the manifest. principles that informed the structure of the manifest.
- Section 5 gives a general overview of the metadata structure to - Section 5 gives a general overview of the metadata structure to
inform the following sections inform the following sections
skipping to change at page 8, line 46 skipping to change at page 9, line 12
- Section 8 specifies the content of the Envelope and the Manifest. - Section 8 specifies the content of the Envelope and the Manifest.
To implement an updatable device, see Section 6 and Section 8. To To implement an updatable device, see Section 6 and Section 8. To
implement a tool that generates updates, see Section 7 and Section 8. implement a tool that generates updates, see Section 7 and Section 8.
The IANA consideration section, see Section 11, provides instructions The IANA consideration section, see Section 11, provides instructions
to IANA to create several registries. This section also provides the to IANA to create several registries. This section also provides the
CBOR labels for the structures defined in this document. CBOR labels for the structures defined in this document.
The complete CDDL description is provided in [full-cddl], examples The complete CDDL description is provided in Appendix A, examples are
are given in [examples] and a design rational is offered in given in Appendix B and a design rational is offered in Appendix C.
[design-rationale]. Finally, [implementation-matrix] gives a Finally, Appendix D gives a summarize of the mandatory-to-implement
summarize of the mandatory-to-implement features of this features of this specification.
specification.
4. Background 4. Background
Distributing firmware updates to diverse devices with diverse trust Distributing software updates to diverse devices with diverse trust
anchors in a coordinated system presents unique challenges. Devices anchors in a coordinated system presents unique challenges. Devices
have a broad set of constraints, requiring different metadata to make have a broad set of constraints, requiring different metadata to make
appropriate decisions. There may be many actors in production IoT appropriate decisions. There may be many actors in production IoT
systems, each of whom has some authority. Distributing firmware in systems, each of whom has some authority. Distributing firmware in
such a multi-party environment presents additional challenges. Each such a multi-party environment presents additional challenges. Each
party requires a different subset of data. Some data may not be party requires a different subset of data. Some data may not be
accessible to all parties. Multiple signatures may be required from accessible to all parties. Multiple signatures may be required from
parties with different authorities. This topic is covered in more parties with different authorities. This topic is covered in more
depth in [I-D.ietf-suit-architecture]. The security aspects are depth in [I-D.ietf-suit-architecture]. The security aspects are
described in [I-D.ietf-suit-information-model]. described in [I-D.ietf-suit-information-model].
4.1. IoT Firmware Update Constraints 4.1. IoT Firmware Update Constraints
The various constraints of IoT devices and the range of use cases The various constraints of IoT devices and the range of use cases
that need to be supported create a broad set of urequirements. For that need to be supported create a broad set of requirements. For
example, devices with: example, devices with:
- limited processing power and storage may require a simple - limited processing power and storage may require a simple
representation of metadata. representation of metadata.
- bandwidth constraints may require firmware compression or partial - bandwidth constraints may require firmware compression or partial
update support. update support.
- bootloader complexity constraints may require simple selection - bootloader complexity constraints may require simple selection
between two bootable images. between two bootable images.
skipping to change at page 9, line 44 skipping to change at page 10, line 7
- small internal storage may require external storage support. - small internal storage may require external storage support.
- multiple microcontrollers may require coordinated update of all - multiple microcontrollers may require coordinated update of all
applications. applications.
- large storage and complex functionality may require parallel - large storage and complex functionality may require parallel
update of many software components. update of many software components.
- extra information may need to be conveyed in the manifest in the - extra information may need to be conveyed in the manifest in the
earlier stages of the device lifecycle before those data items are earlier stages of the device lifecycle before those data items are
stripped when the manifest is delivery to a constrained device. stripped when the manifest is delivered to a constrained device.
Supporting the requirements introduced by the constraints on IoT Supporting the requirements introduced by the constraints on IoT
devices requires the flexibility to represent a diverse set of devices requires the flexibility to represent a diverse set of
possible metadata, but also requires that the encoding is kept possible metadata, but also requires that the encoding is kept
simple. simple.
4.2. SUIT Workflow Model 4.2. SUIT Workflow Model
There are several fundamental assumptions that inform the model of There are several fundamental assumptions that inform the model of
Update Procedure workflow: Update Procedure workflow:
skipping to change at page 10, line 20 skipping to change at page 10, line 29
- Compatibility must be checked before any other operation is - Compatibility must be checked before any other operation is
performed. performed.
- All dependency manifests should be present before any payload is - All dependency manifests should be present before any payload is
fetched. fetched.
- In some applications, payloads must be fetched and validated prior - In some applications, payloads must be fetched and validated prior
to installation. to installation.
There are several fundamental assumptions that inform the model of There are several fundamental assumptions that inform the model of
the Boot Procedure workflow: the Invocation Procedure workflow:
- Compatibility must be checked before any other operation is - Compatibility must be checked before any other operation is
performed. performed.
- All dependencies and payloads must be validated prior to loading. - All dependencies and payloads must be validated prior to loading.
- All loaded images must be validated prior to execution. - All loaded images must be validated prior to execution.
Based on these assumptions, the manifest is structured to work with a Based on these assumptions, the manifest is structured to work with a
pull parser, where each section of the manifest is used in sequence. pull parser, where each section of the manifest is used in sequence.
skipping to change at page 11, line 9 skipping to change at page 11, line 18
1. Verify image(s). 1. Verify image(s).
2. Load image(s). 2. Load image(s).
3. Run image(s). 3. Run image(s).
If verification and running is implemented in a bootloader, then the If verification and running is implemented in a bootloader, then the
bootloader MUST also verify the signature of the manifest and the bootloader MUST also verify the signature of the manifest and the
applicability of the manifest in order to implement secure boot applicability of the manifest in order to implement secure boot
workflows. The bootloader may add its own authentication, e.g. a workflows. The bootloader may add its own authentication, e.g. a
MAC, to the manifest in order to prevent further verifications. Message Authentication Code (MAC), to the manifest in order to
prevent further verifications.
When multiple manifests are used for an update, each manifest's steps When multiple manifests are used for an update, each manifest's steps
occur in a lockstep fashion; all manifests have dependency resolution occur in a lockstep fashion; all manifests have dependency resolution
performed before any manifest performs a payload fetch, etc. performed before any manifest performs a payload fetch, etc.
5. Metadata Structure Overview 5. Metadata Structure Overview
This section provides a high level overview of the manifest This section provides a high level overview of the manifest
structure. The full description of the manifest structure is in structure. The full description of the manifest structure is in
Section 8.6 Section 8.6
skipping to change at page 11, line 46 skipping to change at page 12, line 8
broken down into: broken down into:
1. Critical metadata, such as sequence number. 1. Critical metadata, such as sequence number.
2. Common metadata, including lists of dependencies and affected 2. Common metadata, including lists of dependencies and affected
components. components.
3. Command sequences, directing the Recipient how to install and 3. Command sequences, directing the Recipient how to install and
use the payload(s). use the payload(s).
4. Integrity check values for severable fields. 4. Integrity check values for severable elements.
5. Severable fields (see Section 5.5). 5. Severable elements (see Section 5.5).
6. Integrated dependencies (see Section 5.6). 6. Integrated dependencies (see Section 5.6).
7. Integrated payloads (see Section 5.6). 7. Integrated payloads (see Section 5.6).
The diagram below illustrates the hierarchy of the Envelope. The diagram below illustrates the hierarchy of the Envelope.
+-------------------------+ +-------------------------+
| Envelope | | Envelope |
+-------------------------+ +-------------------------+
| Delegation Chains | | Delegation Chains |
| Authentication Block | | Authentication Block |
| Manifest ------------> +------------------------------+ | Manifest --------------> +------------------------------+
| Severable Elements | | Manifest | | Severable Elements | | Manifest |
| Human-Readable Text | +------------------------------+ | Human-Readable Text | +------------------------------+
| COSWID | | Structure Version | | COSWID | | Structure Version |
| Integrated Dependencies | | Sequence Number | | Integrated Dependencies | | Sequence Number |
| Integrated Payloads | | Reference to Full Manifest | | Integrated Payloads | | Reference to Full Manifest |
+-------------------------+ +------ Common Structure | +-------------------------+ +------ Common Structure |
| +---- Commands | | +---- Command Sequences |
+-----------------------+ | | | Digests of Envelope Elements | +-------------------------+ | | | Digests of Envelope Elements |
| Common Structure | <--+ | +------------------------------+ | Common Structure | <--+ | +------------------------------+
+-----------------------+ | +-------------------------+ |
| Dependencies | +-> +-----------------------+ | Dependencies | +-> +-----------------------+
| Components IDs | | Commands | | Components IDs | | Command Sequence |
| Common Commands ---------------> +-----------------------+ | Common Command Sequence ---------> +-----------------------+
+-----------------------+ | List of ( pairs of ( | +-------------------------+ | List of ( pairs of ( |
| * command code | | * command code |
| * argument | | * argument / |
| )) | | reporting policy |
+-----------------------+ | )) |
+-----------------------+
5.1. Envelope 5.1. Envelope
The SUIT Envelope is a container that encloses Delegation Chains, the The SUIT Envelope is a container that encloses Delegation Chains, the
Authentication Block, the Manifest, any Severable Elements, and any Authentication Block, the Manifest, any Severable Elements, and any
integrated payloads or dependencies. The Envelope is used instead of integrated payloads or dependencies. The Envelope is used instead of
conventional cryptographic envelopes, such as COSE_Envelope because conventional cryptographic envelopes, such as COSE_Envelope because
it allows modular processing, severing of elements, and integrated it allows modular processing, severing of elements, and integrated
payloads in a way that would add substantial complexity with existing payloads in a way that would add substantial complexity with existing
solutions. See Appendix C.1 for a description of the reasoning for solutions. See Appendix C.1 for a description of the reasoning for
this. this.
See Section 8.2 for more detail. See Section 8.2 for more detail.
5.2. Delegation Chains 5.2. Delegation Chains
Delegation Chains allow a Recipient to validate intermediate Update Delegation Chains allow a Recipient to establish a chain of trust
Authorities against long-term a Trust Anchor. These are lists of from a Trust Anchor to the signer of a manifest by validating
CWTs, where the first in the list is signed by a Trust Anchor. delegation claims. Each delegation claim is a [RFC8392] CBOR Web
Tokens (CWTs). The first claim in each list is signed by a Trust
Anchor. Each subsequent claim in a list is signed by the public key
claimed in the preceding list element. The last element in each list
claims a public key that can be used to verify a signature in the
Authentication Block (Section 5.3).
See Section 8.3 for more detail. See Section 8.3 for more detail.
5.3. Authentication Block 5.3. Authentication Block
The Authentication Block contains one or more COSE authentication The Authentication Block contains a bstr-wrapped Section 10 and one
blocks. These blocks are one of: or more [RFC8152] CBOR Object Signing and Encryption (COSE)
authentication blocks. These blocks are one of:
- COSE_Sign_Tagged - COSE_Sign_Tagged
- COSE_Sign1_Tagged - COSE_Sign1_Tagged
- COSE_Mac_Tagged - COSE_Mac_Tagged
- COSE_Mac0_Tagged - COSE_Mac0_Tagged
The payload element in each of these COSE elements is a SUIT_Digest Each of these objects is used in detached payload mode. The payload
Section 10. is the bstr-wrapped SUIT_Digest.
See Section 8.4 for more detail. See Section 8.4 for more detail.
5.4. Manifest 5.4. Manifest
The Manifest contains most metadata about one or more images. The The Manifest contains most metadata about one or more images. The
Manifest is divided into Critical Metadata, Common Metadata, Command Manifest is divided into Critical Metadata, Common Metadata, Command
Sequences, and Integrity Check Values. Sequences, and Integrity Check Values.
See Section 8.6 for more detail. See Section 8.6 for more detail.
5.4.1. Critical Metadata 5.4.1. Critical Metadata
Some metadata needs to be accessed before the manifest is processed. Some metadata needs to be accessed before the manifest is processed.
This metadata can be used to determine which the newest manifest is This metadata can be used to determine which manifest is newest and
and whether the structure version is supported. It also MAY provide whether the structure version is supported. It also MAY provide a
a URI for obtaining a canonical copy of the manifest and Envelope. URI for obtaining a canonical copy of the manifest and Envelope.
See Section 8.6.1, Section 8.6.2, Section 8.6.3 for more detail. See Section 8.6.1, Section 8.6.2, and Section 8.6.3 for more detail.
5.4.2. Common 5.4.2. Common
Some metadata is used repeatedly and in more than one command Some metadata is used repeatedly and in more than one command
sequence. In order to reduce the size of the manifest, this metadata sequence. In order to reduce the size of the manifest, this metadata
is collected into the Common section. Common is composed of three is collected into the Common section. Common is composed of three
parts: a list of dependencies, a list of components referenced by the parts: a list of dependencies, a list of components referenced by the
manifest, and a command sequence to execute prior to each other manifest, and a command sequence to execute prior to each other
command sequence. The common command sequence is typically used to command sequence. The common command sequence is typically used to
set commonly used values and perform compatibility checks. The set commonly used values and perform compatibility checks. The
common command sequence MUST NOT have any side-effects outside of common command sequence MUST NOT have any side-effects outside of
setting parameter values. setting parameter values.
See Section 8.7.2, Section 8.7.2.1 for more detail. See Section 8.7.2, and Section 8.7.2.1 for more detail.
5.4.3. Command Sequences 5.4.3. Command Sequences
Command sequences provide the instructions that a Recipient requires Command sequences provide the instructions that a Recipient requires
in order to install or use an image. These sequences tell a device in order to install or use an image. These sequences tell a device
to set parameter values, test system parameters, copy data from one to set parameter values, test system parameters, copy data from one
place to another, transform data, digest data, and run code. place to another, transform data, digest data, and run code.
Command sequences are broken up into three groups: Common Command Command sequences are broken up into three groups: Common Command
Sequence (see Section 5.4.2), update commands, and secure boot Sequence (see Section 5.4.2), update commands, and secure boot
commands. commands.
Update Command Sequences are: Dependency Resolution, Payload Fetch, Update Command Sequences are: Dependency Resolution, Payload Fetch,
and Payload Installation. An Update Procedure is the complete set of and Payload Installation. An Update Procedure is the complete set of
each Update Command Sequence, each preceded by the Common Command each Update Command Sequence, each preceded by the Common Command
Sequence. Sequence.
Boot Command Sequences are: System Validation, Image Loading, and Invocation Command Sequences are: System Validation, Image Loading,
Image Invocation. A Boot Procedure is the complete set of each Boot and Image Invocation. A Invocation Procedure is the complete set of
Command Sequence, each preceded by the Common Command Sequence. each Invocation Command Sequence, each preceded by the Common Command
Sequence.
Command Sequences are grouped into these sets to ensure that there is Command Sequences are grouped into these sets to ensure that there is
common coordination between dependencies and dependents on when to common coordination between dependencies and dependents on when to
execute each command. execute each command.
See Section 8.7.3 for more detail. See Section 8.7.3 for more detail.
5.4.4. Integrity Check Values 5.4.4. Integrity Check Values
To enable Section 5.5, there needs to be a mechanism to verify To enable Section 5.5, there needs to be a mechanism to verify
integrity of any metadata outside the manifest. Integrity Check integrity of any metadata outside the manifest. Integrity Check
Values are used to verify the integrity of metadata that is not Values are used to verify the integrity of metadata that is not
contained in the manifest. This MAY include Severable Command contained in the manifest. This MAY include Severable Command
Sequences, CoSWID, or Text data. Integrated Dependencies and Sequences, Concise Software Identifiers (CoSWID
[I-D.ietf-sacm-coswid]), or Text data. Integrated Dependencies and
Integrated Payloads are integrity-checked using Command Sequences, so Integrated Payloads are integrity-checked using Command Sequences, so
they do not have Integrity Check Values present in the Manifest. they do not have Integrity Check Values present in the Manifest.
See Section 8.7.8 for more detail. See Section 8.7.8 for more detail.
5.4.5. Human-Readable Text 5.4.5. Human-Readable Text
Text is typically a Severable Element (Section 5.5). It contains all Text is typically a Severable Element (Section 5.5). It contains all
the text that describes the update. Because text is explicitly for the text that describes the update. Because text is explicitly for
human consumption, it is all grouped together so that it can be human consumption, it is all grouped together so that it can be
skipping to change at page 15, line 16 skipping to change at page 15, line 41
Severable Elements are elements of the Envelope (Section 5.1) that Severable Elements are elements of the Envelope (Section 5.1) that
have Integrity Check Values (Section 5.4.4) in the Manifest have Integrity Check Values (Section 5.4.4) in the Manifest
(Section 5.4). (Section 5.4).
Because of this organisation, these elements can be discarded or Because of this organisation, these elements can be discarded or
"Severed" from the Envelope without changing the signature of the "Severed" from the Envelope without changing the signature of the
Manifest. This allows savings based on the size of the Envelope in Manifest. This allows savings based on the size of the Envelope in
several scenarios, for example: several scenarios, for example:
- A management system Severs the Text and CoSWID sections before - A management system severs the Text and CoSWID sections before
sending an Envelope to a constrained Recipient, which saves sending an Envelope to a constrained Recipient, which saves
Recipient bandwidth. Recipient bandwidth.
- A Recipient Severs the Installation section after installing the - A Recipient severs the Installation section after installing the
Update, which saves storage space. Update, which saves storage space.
See Section 8.8 for more detail. See Section 8.8 for more detail.
5.6. Integrated Dependencies and Payloads 5.6. Integrated Dependencies and Payloads
In some cases, it is beneficial to include a dependency or a payload In some cases, it is beneficial to include a dependency or a payload
in the Envelope of a manifest. For example: in the Envelope of a manifest. For example:
- When an update is delivered via a comparatively unconstrained - When an update is delivered via a comparatively unconstrained
skipping to change at page 15, line 42 skipping to change at page 16, line 22
beneficial to bundle updates into single files. beneficial to bundle updates into single files.
- When a manifest requires encryption, it must be referenced as a - When a manifest requires encryption, it must be referenced as a
dependency, so a trivial manifest may be used to enclose the dependency, so a trivial manifest may be used to enclose the
encrypted manifest. The encrypted manifest may be contained in encrypted manifest. The encrypted manifest may be contained in
the dependent manifest's envelope. the dependent manifest's envelope.
- When a manifest transports a small payload, such as an encrypted - When a manifest transports a small payload, such as an encrypted
key, that payload may be placed in the manifest's envelope. key, that payload may be placed in the manifest's envelope.
See Section 7.8.1, Section 8.5 for more detail. See Section 7.9.1, Section 8.5 for more detail.
6. Interpreter Behavior 6. Manifest Processor Behavior
This section describes the behavior of the manifest interpreter and This section describes the behavior of the manifest processor and
focuses primarily on interpreting commands in the manifest. However, focuses primarily on interpreting commands in the manifest. However,
there are several other important behaviors of the interpreter: there are several other important behaviors of the manifest
encoding version detection, rollback protection, and authenticity processor: encoding version detection, rollback protection, and
verification are chief among these. authenticity verification are chief among these.
6.1. Interpreter Setup 6.1. Manifest Processor Setup
Prior to executing any command sequence, the interpreter or its host Prior to executing any command sequence, the manifest processor or
application MUST inspect the manifest version field and fail when it its host application MUST inspect the manifest version field and fail
encounters an unsupported encoding version. Next, the interpreter or when it encounters an unsupported encoding version. Next, the
its host application MUST extract the manifest sequence number and manifest processor or its host application MUST extract the manifest
perform a rollback check using this sequence number. The exact logic sequence number and perform a rollback check using this sequence
of rollback protection may vary by application, but it has the number. The exact logic of rollback protection may vary by
following properties: application, but it has the following properties:
- Whenever the interpreter can choose between several manifests, it - Whenever the manifest processor can choose between several
MUST select the latest valid, authentic manifest. manifests, it MUST select the latest valid, authentic manifest.
- If the latest valid, authentic manifest fails, it MAY select the - If the latest valid, authentic manifest fails, it MAY select the
next latest valid, authentic manifest. next latest valid, authentic manifest, according to application-
specific policy.
Here, valid means that a manifest has a supported encoding version Here, valid means that a manifest has a supported encoding version
and it has not been excluded for other reasons. Reasons for and it has not been excluded for other reasons. Reasons for
excluding typically involve first executing the manifest and may excluding typically involve first executing the manifest and may
include: include:
- Test failed (e.g. Vendor ID/Class ID). - Test failed (e.g. Vendor ID/Class ID).
- Unsupported command encountered. - Unsupported command encountered.
- Unsupported parameter encountered. - Unsupported parameter encountered.
- Unsupported component ID encountered. - Unsupported Component Identifier encountered.
- Payload not available. - Payload not available.
- Dependency not available. - Dependency not available.
- Application crashed when executed. - Application crashed when executed.
- Watchdog timeout occurred. - Watchdog timeout occurred.
- Dependency or Payload verification failed. - Dependency or Payload verification failed.
- Missing component from a set. - Missing component from a set.
- Required parameter not supplied. - Required parameter not supplied.
These failure reasons MAY be combined with retry mechanisms prior to These failure reasons MAY be combined with retry mechanisms prior to
marking a manifest as invalid. marking a manifest as invalid.
Following these initial tests, the interpreter clears all parameter Selecting an older manifest in the event of failure of the latest
storage. This ensures that the interpreter begins without any leaked valid manifest is a robustness mechanism that is necessary for
data. supporting the requirements in [I-D.ietf-suit-architecture], section
3.5. It may not be appropriate for all applications. In particular
Trusted Execution Environments MAY require a failure to invoke a new
installation, rather than a rollback approach. See
[I-D.ietf-suit-information-model], Section 4.2.1 for more discussion
on the security considerations that apply to rollback.
Following these initial tests, the manifest processor clears all
parameter storage. This ensures that the manifest processor begins
without any leaked data.
6.2. Required Checks 6.2. Required Checks
The RECOMMENDED process is to verify the signature of the manifest The RECOMMENDED process is to verify the signature of the manifest
prior to parsing/executing any section of the manifest. This guards prior to parsing/executing any section of the manifest. This guards
the parser against arbitrary input by unauthenticated third parties, the parser against arbitrary input by unauthenticated third parties,
but it costs extra energy when a Recipient receives an incompatible but it costs extra energy when a Recipient receives an incompatible
manifest. manifest.
When validating authenticity of manifests, the interpreter MAY use an When validating authenticity of manifests, the manifest processor MAY
ACL (see Section 9) to determine the extent of the rights conferred use an ACL (see Section 9) to determine the extent of the rights
by that authenticity. Where a device supports only one level of conferred by that authenticity. Where a device supports only one
access, it MAY choose to skip signature verification of dependencies, level of access, it MAY choose to skip signature verification of
since they are referenced by digest. Where a device supports more dependencies, since they are referenced by digest. Where a device
than one trusted party, it MAY choose to defer the verification of supports more than one trusted party, it MAY choose to defer the
signatures of dependencies until the list of affected components is verification of signatures of dependencies until the list of affected
known so that it can skip redundant signature verifications. For components is known so that it can skip redundant signature
example, a dependency signed by the same author as the dependent does verifications. For example, a dependency signed by the same author
not require a signature verification. Similarly, if the signer of as the dependent does not require a signature verification.
the dependent has full rights to the device, according to the ACL, Similarly, if the signer of the dependent has full rights to the
then no signature verification is necessary on the dependency. device, according to the ACL, then no signature verification is
necessary on the dependency.
Once a valid, authentic manifest has been selected, the interpreter Once a valid, authentic manifest has been selected, the manifest
MUST examine the component list and verify that its maximum number of processor MUST examine the component list and verify that its maximum
components is not exceeded and that each listed component ID is number of components is not exceeded and that each listed component
supported. is supported.
For each listed component, the interpreter MUST provide storage for For each listed component, the manifest processor MUST provide
the supported parameters. If the interpreter does not have storage for the supported parameters. If the manifest processor does
sufficient temporary storage to process the parameters for all not have sufficient temporary storage to process the parameters for
components, it MAY process components serially for each command all components, it MAY process components serially for each command
sequence. See Section 6.6 for more details. sequence. See Section 6.6 for more details.
The interpreter SHOULD check that the common section contains at The manifest processor SHOULD check that the common sequence contains
least one vendor ID check and at least one class ID check. at least Check Vendor Identifier command and at least one Check Class
Identifier command.
If the manifest contains more than one component, each command Because the common sequence contains Check Vendor Identifier and
sequence MUST begin with a Set Current Component command. Check Class Identifier command(s), no custom commands are permitted
in the common sequence. This ensures that any custom commands are
only executed by devices that understand them.
If a dependency is specified, then the interpreter MUST perform the If the manifest contains more than one component and/or dependency,
following checks: each command sequence MUST begin with a Set Component Index or Set
Dependency Index command.
If a dependency is specified, then the manifest processor MUST
perform the following checks:
1. At the beginning of each section in the dependent: all previous 1. At the beginning of each section in the dependent: all previous
sections of each dependency have been executed. sections of each dependency have been executed.
2. At the end of each section in the dependent: The corresponding 2. At the end of each section in the dependent: The corresponding
section in each dependency has been executed. section in each dependency has been executed.
If the interpreter does not support dependencies and a manifest If the interpreter does not support dependencies and a manifest
specifies a dependency, then the interpreter MUST reject the specifies a dependency, then the interpreter MUST reject the
manifest. manifest.
If a Recipient supports groups of interdependent components (a If a Recipient supports groups of interdependent components (a
Component Set), then it SHOULD require that all Components in the Component Set), then it SHOULD verify that all Components in the
Component Set are specified by one manifest and its dependencies. Component Set are specified by one update, where an update is
This manifest is called the Root Manifest. composed of all the TODO: Wording
manifest and its dependencies. This manifest is called the Root
Manifest.
6.2.1. Minimizing Signature Verifications 6.2.1. Minimizing Signature Verifications
Signature verification can be energy and time expensive on a Signature verification can be energy and time expensive on a
constrained device. MAC verification is typically unaffected by constrained device. MAC verification is typically unaffected by
these concerns. A Recipient MAY choose to parse and execute only the these concerns. A Recipient MAY choose to parse and execute only the
SUIT_Common section of the manifest prior to signature verification, SUIT_Common section of the manifest prior to signature verification,
if all of the below apply: if all of the below apply:
- The Authentication Block contains a COSE_Sign_Tagged or - The Authentication Block contains a COSE_Sign_Tagged or
COSE_Sign1_Tagged COSE_Sign1_Tagged
- The Recipient can receive many incompatible or inapplicable - The Recipient receives manifests over an unauthenticated channel,
manifests, and exposing it to more inauthentic or incompatible manifests, and
- The Recipient has a power budget that makes signature verification - The Recipient has a power budget that makes signature verification
undesirable undesirable
The guidelines in Creating Manifests (Section 7) require that the The guidelines in Creating Manifests (Section 7) require that the
common section contains the applicability checks, so this section is common section contains the applicability checks, so this section is
sufficient for applicability verification. The parser MUST restrict sufficient for applicability verification. The parser MUST restrict
acceptable commands to: Conditions, Override Parameters, Set acceptable commands to conditions and the following directives:
Parameters, Try-Each, and Run Sequence ONLY. The manifest parser Override Parameters, Set Parameters, Try Each, and Run Sequence ONLY.
MUST NOT execute any command with side-effects outside the parser The manifest parser MUST NOT execute any command with side-effects
(for example, Run, Copy, Swap, or Fetch commands) prior to outside the parser (for example, Run, Copy, Swap, or Fetch commands)
authentication and any such command MUST Abort. The Common Sequence prior to authentication and any such command MUST Abort. The Common
MUST be executed again in its entirety after authenticity validation. Sequence MUST be executed again in its entirety after authenticity
validation.
When executing Common prior to authenticity validation, the Manifest When executing Common prior to authenticity validation, the Manifest
Processor MUST evaluate the integrity of the manifest using the Processor MUST evaluate the integrity of the manifest using the
SUIT_Digest present in the authentication block. SUIT_Digest present in the authentication block.
Alternatively, a Recipient MAY rely on network infrastructure to Alternatively, a Recipient MAY rely on network infrastructure to
filter inapplicable manifests. filter inapplicable manifests.
6.3. Interpreter Fundamental Properties 6.3. Interpreter Fundamental Properties
The interpreter has a small set of design goals: The interpreter has a small set of design goals:
1. Executing an update MUST either result in an error, or a 1. Executing an update MUST either result in an error, or a
verifiably correct system state. verifiably correct system state.
2. Executing a secure boot MUST either result in an error, or a 2. Executing a Trusted Invocation MUST either result in an error, or
booted system. an invoked image.
3. Executing the same manifest on multiple Recipients MUST result in 3. Executing the same manifest on multiple Recipients MUST result in
the same system state. the same system state.
NOTE: when using A/B images, the manifest functions as two (or more) NOTE: when using A/B images, the manifest functions as two (or more)
logical manifests, each of which applies to a system in a particular logical manifests, each of which applies to a system in a particular
starting state. With that provision, design goal 3 holds. starting state. With that provision, design goal 3 holds.
6.4. Abstract Machine Description 6.4. Abstract Machine Description
The heart of the manifest is the list of commands, which are The heart of the manifest is the list of commands, which are
processed by an interpreter. This interpreter can be modeled as a processed by a Manifest Processor-a form of interpreter. This
simple abstract machine. This machine consists of several data Manifest Processor can be modeled as a simple abstract machine. This
storage locations that are modified by commands. machine consists of several data storage locations that are modified
by commands.
There are two types of commands, namely those that modify state There are two types of commands, namely those that modify state
(directives) and those that perform tests (conditions). Parameters (directives) and those that perform tests (conditions). Parameters
are used as the inputs to commands. Some directives offer control are used as the inputs to commands. Some directives offer control
flow operations. Directives target a specific component or flow operations. Directives target a specific component or
dependency. A dependency is another SUIT_Envelope that describes dependency. A dependency is another SUIT_Envelope that describes
additional components. Dependencies are identified by digest, but additional components. Dependencies are identified by digest, but
referenced in commands by Dependency Index, the index into the array referenced in commands by Dependency Index, the index into the array
of Dependencies. A component is a unit of code or data that can be of Dependencies. A component is a unit of code or data that can be
targeted by an update. Components are identified by Component targeted by an update. Components are identified by Component
Identifiers, i.e. arrays of binary strings, but referenced in Identifiers, but referenced in commands by Component Index; Component
commands by Component Index, the index into the array of Component Identifiers are arrays of binary strings and a Component Index is an
Identifiers. index into the array of Component Identifiers.
Conditions MUST NOT have any side-effects other than informing the Conditions MUST NOT have any side-effects other than informing the
interpreter of success or failure. The Interpreter does not Abort if interpreter of success or failure. The Interpreter does not Abort if
the Soft Failure flag is set when a Condition reports failure. the Soft Failure flag (Section 8.7.5.23) is set when a Condition
reports failure.
Directives MAY have side-effects in the parameter table, the Directives MAY have side-effects in the parameter table, the
interpreter state, or the current component. The Interpreter MUST interpreter state, or the current component. The Interpreter MUST
Abort if a Directive reports failure regardless of the Soft Failure Abort if a Directive reports failure regardless of the Soft Failure
flag. flag.
To simplify the logic describing the command semantics, the object
"current" is used. It represents the component identified by the
Component Index or the dependency identified by the Dependency Index:
current := components\[component-index\]
if component-index is not false
else dependencies\[dependency-index\]
As a result, Set Component Index is described as current :=
components[arg]. The actual operation performed for Set Component
Index is described by the following pseudocode, however, because of
the definition of current (above), these are semantically equivalent.
component-index := arg
dependency-index := false
Similarly, Set Dependency Index is semantically equivalent to current
:= dependencies[arg]
The following table describes the behavior of each command. "params" The following table describes the behavior of each command. "params"
represents the parameters for the current component or dependency. represents the parameters for the current component or dependency.
Most commands operate on either a component or a dependency. Setting Most commands operate on either a component or a dependency. Setting
the Component Index clears the Dependency Index. Setting the the Component Index clears the Dependency Index. Setting the
Dependency Index clears the Component Index. Dependency Index clears the Component Index.
+-------------------+-----------------------------------------------+ +-------------------+-----------------------------------------------+
| Command Name | Semantic of the Operation | | Command Name | Semantic of the Operation |
+-------------------+-----------------------------------------------+ +-------------------+-----------------------------------------------+
| Check Vendor | assert(binary-match(current, | | Check Vendor | assert(binary-match(current, |
| Identifier | current.params[vendor-id])) | | Identifier | current.params[vendor-id])) |
| | | | | |
| Check Class | assert(binary-match(current, | | Check Class | assert(binary-match(current, |
| Identifier | current.params[class-id])) | | Identifier | current.params[class-id])) |
| | | | | |
| Verify Image | assert(binary-match(digest(current), | | Verify Image | assert(binary-match(digest(current), |
| | current.params[digest])) | | | current.params[digest])) |
| | | | | |
| Set Component | current := components[arg] | | Set Component | current := components[arg] |
| Index | | | Index | |
| | | | | |
| Override | current.params[k] := v for k,v in arg | | Override | current.params[k] := v for-each k,v in arg |
| Parameters | | | Parameters | |
| | | | | |
| Set Dependency | current := dependencies[arg] | | Set Dependency | current := dependencies[arg] |
| Index | | | Index | |
| | | | | |
| Set Parameters | current.params[k] := v if not k in params for | | Set Parameters | current.params[k] := v if not k in params |
| | k,v in arg | | | for-each k,v in arg |
| | | | | |
| Process | exec(current[common]); exec(current[current- | | Process | exec(current[common]); exec(current[current- |
| Dependency | segment]) | | Dependency | segment]) |
| | | | | |
| Run | run(current) | | Run | run(current) |
| | | | | |
| Fetch | store(current, fetch(current.params[uri])) | | Fetch | store(current, fetch(current.params[uri])) |
| | | | | |
| Use Before | assert(now() < arg) | | Use Before | assert(now() < arg) |
| | | | | |
skipping to change at page 21, line 12 skipping to change at page 22, line 29
| Check Minimum | assert(battery >= arg) | | Check Minimum | assert(battery >= arg) |
| Battery | | | Battery | |
| | | | | |
| Check Update | assert(isAuthorized()) | | Check Update | assert(isAuthorized()) |
| Authorized | | | Authorized | |
| | | | | |
| Check Version | assert(version_check(current, arg)) | | Check Version | assert(version_check(current, arg)) |
| | | | | |
| Abort | assert(0) | | Abort | assert(0) |
| | | | | |
| Try Each | break if exec(seq) is not error for-each seq | | Try Each | try-each-done if exec(seq) is not error for- |
| | in arg | | | each seq in arg |
| | | | | |
| Copy | store(current, current.params[src-component]) | | Copy | store(current, current.params[src-component]) |
| | | | | |
| Swap | swap(current, current.params[src-component]) | | Swap | swap(current, current.params[src-component]) |
| | | | | |
| Wait For Event | until event(arg), wait | | Wait For Event | until event(arg), wait |
| | | | | |
| Run Sequence | exec(arg) | | Run Sequence | exec(arg) |
| | | | | |
| Run with | run(current, arg) | | Run with | run(current, arg) |
| Arguments | | | Arguments | |
+-------------------+-----------------------------------------------+ +-------------------+-----------------------------------------------+
6.5. Special Cases of Component Index and Dependency Index 6.5. Special Cases of Component Index and Dependency Index
The interpreter MUST support a special case of Component Index if Component Index and Dependency Index can each take on one of three
more than two or more components are supported: setting Component types:
Index to True is allowed. When a command is invoked and the
Component Index is True, the command MUST be invoked once for each
Component, in the order listed in the array of Component Identifiers.
The interpreter MUST support a special case of Dependency Index when
two or more dependencies are supported. When a command is invoked
and the Dependency Index is True, the command MUST be invoked once
for each Dependency, in the order listed in the array of
Dependencies.
This is represented by the following pseudocode. 1. Integer
if iscomponent(current): 2. Array of integers
if current is true: 3. True
cmd(component) for-each component in components
else: Integers MUST always be supported by Set Component Index and Set
cmd(current) Dependency Index. Arrays of integers MUST be supported by Set
Component Index and Set Dependency Index if the Recipient supports 3
or more components or 3 or more dependencies, respectively. True
MUST be supported by Set Component Index and Set Dependency Index if
the Recipient supports 2 or more components or 2 or more
dependencies, respectively. Each of these operates on the list of
components or list of dependencies declared in the manifest.
Integer indices are the default case as described in the previous
section. An array of integers represents a list of the components
(Set Component Index) or a list of dependencies (Set Dependency
Index) to which each subsequent command applies. The value True
replaces the list of component indices or dependency indices with the
full list of components or the full list of dependencies,
respectively, as defined in the manifest.
When a command is executed, it either 1. operates on the component or
dependency identified by the component index or dependency index if
that index is an integer, or 2. it operates on each component or
dependency identified by an array of indicies, or 3. it operates on
every component or every dependency if the index is the boolean True.
This is described by the following pseudocode:
if component-index is true:
current-list = components
else if component-index is array:
current-list = [ components[idx] for idx in component-index ]
else if component-index is integer:
current-list = [ components[component-index] ]
else if dependency-index is true:
current-list = dependencies
else if dependency-index is array:
current-list = [ dependencies[idx] for idx in dependency-index ]
else: else:
if current is true: current-list = [ dependencies[dependency-index] ]
cmd(dependency) for-each dependency in dependencies for current in current-list:
else: cmd(current)
cmd(current)
Try Each and Run Sequence are affected in the same way as other Try Each and Run Sequence are affected in the same way as other
commands: they are invoked once for each possible Component or commands: they are invoked once for each possible Component or
Dependency. This means that the sequences that are arguments to Try Dependency. This means that the sequences that are arguments to Try
Each and Run Sequence are NOT invoked with Component Index = True or Each and Run Sequence are NOT invoked with Component Index = True or
Dependency Index = True. They are only invoked with integer indices. Dependency Index = True, nor are they invoked with array indices.
The interpreter loops over the whole sequence, setting the Component They are only invoked with integer indices. The interpreter loops
Index or Dependency Index to each possible index in turn. over the whole sequence, setting the Component Index or Dependency
Index to each index in turn.
6.6. Serialized Processing Interpreter 6.6. Serialized Processing Interpreter
In highly constrained devices, where storage for parameters is In highly constrained devices, where storage for parameters is
limited, the manifest processor MAY handle one component at a time, limited, the manifest processor MAY handle one component at a time,
traversing the manifest tree once for each listed component. In this traversing the manifest tree once for each listed component. In this
mode, the interpreter ignores any commands executed while the mode, the interpreter ignores any commands executed while the
component index is not the current component. This reduces the component index is not the current component. This reduces the
overall volatile storage required to process the update so that the overall volatile storage required to process the update so that the
only limit on number of components is the size of the manifest. only limit on number of components is the size of the manifest.
skipping to change at page 22, line 38 skipping to change at page 24, line 32
When a serialized Manifest Processor encounters a component or When a serialized Manifest Processor encounters a component or
dependency index of True, it does not ignore any commands. It dependency index of True, it does not ignore any commands. It
applies them to the current component or dependency on each applies them to the current component or dependency on each
iteration. iteration.
6.7. Parallel Processing Interpreter 6.7. Parallel Processing Interpreter
Advanced Recipients MAY make use of the Strict Order parameter and Advanced Recipients MAY make use of the Strict Order parameter and
enable parallel processing of some Command Sequences, or it may enable parallel processing of some Command Sequences, or it may
reorder some Command Sequences. To perform parallel processing, once reorder some Command Sequences. To perform parallel processing, once
the Strict Order parameter is set to False, the Recipient may fork a the Strict Order parameter is set to False, the Recipient may issue
process for each command until the Strict Order parameter is returned each or every command concurrently until the Strict Order parameter
to True or the Command Sequence ends. Then, it joins all forked is returned to True or the Command Sequence ends. Then, it waits for
processes before continuing processing of commands. To perform out- all issued commands to complete before continuing processing of
of-order processing, a similar approach is used, except the Recipient commands. To perform out-of-order processing, a similar approach is
consumes all commands after the Strict Order parameter is set to used, except the Recipient consumes all commands after the Strict
False, then it sorts these commands into its preferred order, invokes Order parameter is set to False, then it sorts these commands into
them all, then continues processing. its preferred order, invokes them all, then continues processing.
Under each of these scenarios the parallel processing must halt: Under each of these scenarios the parallel processing MUST halt until
all issued commands have completed:
- Set Parameters. - Set Parameters.
- Override Parameters. - Override Parameters.
- Set Strict Order = True. - Set Strict Order = True.
- Set Dependency Index. - Set Dependency Index.
- Set Component Index. - Set Component Index.
To perform more useful parallel operations, sequences of commands may To perform more useful parallel operations, a manifest author may
be collected in a suit-directive-run-sequence. Then, each of these collect sequences of commands in a Run Sequence command. Then, each
sequences may be run in parallel. Each sequence defaults to Strict of these sequences MAY be run in parallel. Each sequence defaults to
Order = True. To isolate each sequence from each other sequence, Strict Order = True. To isolate each sequence from each other
each sequence MUST begin with a Set Component Index directive. The sequence, each sequence MUST begin with a Set Component Index or Set
interpreter MUST track each Set Component Index directive, and cause Dependency Index directive with the following exception: when the
an Abort if more than one Set Component Index directive targets the index is either True or an array of indices, the Set Component Index
same Component Index. When Strict Order = False, each suit- or Set Dependency Index is implied. Any further Set Component Index
directive-run-sequence MUST begin with a Set Component Index directives MUST cause an Abort. This allows the interpreter that
directive. Any further Set Component Index directives MUST cause an issues Run Sequence commands to check that the first element is
Abort. This allows the interpreter that forks suit-directive-run- correct, then issue the sequence to a parallel execution context to
sequence processes to check that the first element is correct, then handle the remainder of the sequence.
fork a process to handle the remainder of the sequence.
6.8. Processing Dependencies 6.8. Processing Dependencies
As described in Section 6.2, each manifest must invoke each of its As described in Section 6.2, each manifest must invoke each of its
dependencies sections from the corresponding section of the dependencies sections from the corresponding section of the
dependent. Any changes made to parameters by the dependency persist dependent. Any changes made to parameters by the dependency persist
in the dependent. in the dependent.
When a Process Dependency command is encountered, the interpreter When a Process Dependency command is encountered, the interpreter
loads the dependency identified by the Current Dependency Index. The loads the dependency identified by the Current Dependency Index. The
interpreter first executes the common-sequence section of the interpreter first executes the common-sequence section of the
identified dependency, then it executes the section of the dependency identified dependency, then it executes the section of the dependency
that corresponds to the currently executing section of the dependent. that corresponds to the currently executing section of the dependent.
If the specified dependency does not contain the current section,
Process Dependency succeeds immediately.
The Manifest Processor MUST also support a Dependency Index of True, The Manifest Processor MUST also support a Dependency Index of True,
which applies to every dependency, as described in Section 6.5 which applies to every dependency, as described in Section 6.5
The interpreter also performs the checks described in Section 6.2 to The interpreter also performs the checks described in Section 6.2 to
ensure that the dependent is processing the dependency correctly. ensure that the dependent is processing the dependency correctly.
6.9. Multiple Manifest Processors 6.9. Multiple Manifest Processors
When a system has multiple security domains they MAY require When a system has multiple security domains, each domain might
independent verification of authenticity or security policies. require independent verification of authenticity or security
Security domains may be divided by separation technology such as Arm policies. Security domains might be divided by separation technology
TrustZone, or Intel SGX. Security domains may also be divided into such as Arm TrustZone, Intel SGX, or another TEE technology.
separate processors and memory spaces, with a communication interface Security domains might also be divided into separate processors and
between them. memory spaces, with a communication interface between them.
For example, an application processor may have an attached For example, an application processor may have an attached
communications module that contains a processor. The communications communications module that contains a processor. The communications
module may require metadata signed by a specific Trust Authority for module might require metadata signed by a specific Trust Authority
regulatory approval. This may be a different Trust Authority than for regulatory approval. This may be a different Trust Authority
the application processor. than the application processor.
When there are two or more security domains, a manifest processor MAY When there are two or more security domains (see
be required in each. The first manifest processor is the normal [I-D.ietf-teep-architecture]), a manifest processor might be required
manifest processor as described for the Recipient in Abstract in each. The first manifest processor is the normal manifest
Machine. The second manifest processor only executes sections when processor as described for the Recipient in Section 6.4. The second
the first manifest processor requests it. An API interface is manifest processor only executes sections when the first manifest
provided from the second manifest processor to the first. This processor requests it. An API interface is provided from the second
allows the first manifest processor to request a limited set of manifest processor to the first. This allows the first manifest
operations from the second. These operations are limited to: setting processor to request a limited set of operations from the second.
parameters, inserting an Envelope, invoking a Manifest Command These operations are limited to: setting parameters, inserting an
Sequence. The second manifest processor declares a prefix to the Envelope, invoking a Manifest Command Sequence. The second manifest
first, which tells the first manifest processor when it should processor declares a prefix to the first, which tells the first
delegate to the second. These rules are enforced by underlying manifest processor when it should delegate to the second. These
separation of privilege infrastructure, such as TEEs, or physical rules are enforced by underlying separation of privilege
separation. infrastructure, such as TEEs, or physical separation.
When the first manifest processor encounters a dependency prefix, When the first manifest processor encounters a dependency prefix,
that informs the first manifest processor that it should provide the that informs the first manifest processor that it should provide the
second manifest processor with the corresponding dependency Envelope. second manifest processor with the corresponding dependency Envelope.
This is done when the dependency is fetched. The second manifest This is done when the dependency is fetched. The second manifest
processor immediately verifies any authentication information in the processor immediately verifies any authentication information in the
dependency Envelope. When a parameter is set for any component that dependency Envelope. When a parameter is set for any component that
matches the prefix, this parameter setting is passed to the second matches the prefix, this parameter setting is passed to the second
manifest processor via an API. As the first manifest processor works manifest processor via an API. As the first manifest processor works
through the Procedure (set of command sequences) it is executing, through the Procedure (set of command sequences) it is executing,
each time it sees a Process Dependency command that is associated each time it sees a Process Dependency command that is associated
with the prefix declared by the second manifest processor, it uses with the prefix declared by the second manifest processor, it uses
the API to ask the second manifest processor to invoke that the API to ask the second manifest processor to invoke that
dependency section instead. dependency section instead.
This mechanism ensures that the two or more manifest processors do
not need to trust each other, except in a very limited case. When
parameter setting across security domains is used, it must be very
carefully considered. Only parameters that do not have an effect on
security properties should be allowed. The dependency manifest MAY
control which parameters are allowed to be set by using the Override
Parameters directive. The second manifest processor MAY also control
which parameters may be set by the first manifest processor by means
of an ACL that lists the allowed parameters. For example, a URI may
be set by a dependent without a substantial impact on the security
properties of the manifest.
7. Creating Manifests 7. Creating Manifests
Manifests are created using tools for constructing COSE structures, Manifests are created using tools for constructing COSE structures,
calculating cryptographic values and compiling desired system state calculating cryptographic values and compiling desired system state
into a sequence of operations required to achieve that state. The into a sequence of operations required to achieve that state. The
process of constructing COSE structures and the calculation of process of constructing COSE structures and the calculation of
cryptographic values is covered in [RFC8152]. cryptographic values is covered in [RFC8152].
Compiling desired system state into a sequence of operations can be Compiling desired system state into a sequence of operations can be
accomplished in many ways. Several templates are provided below to accomplished in many ways. Several templates are provided below to
cover common use-cases. These templates can be combined to produce cover common use-cases. These templates can be combined to produce
more complex behavior. more complex behavior.
The Author MUST ensure that all parameters consumed by a command are The author MUST ensure that all parameters consumed by a command are
set prior to invoking that command. Where Component Index = True or set prior to invoking that command. Where Component Index = True or
Dependency Index = True, this means that the parameters consumed by Dependency Index = True, this means that the parameters consumed by
each command MUST have been set for each Component or Dependency, each command MUST have been set for each Component or Dependency,
respectively. respectively.
NOTE: On systems that support only a single component, Set Current This section details a set of templates for creating manifests.
Component has no effect and can be omitted. These templates explain which parameters, commands, and orders of
commands are necessary to achieve a stated goal.
NOTE: On systems that support only a single component and no
dependencies, Set Component Index has no effect and can be omitted.
NOTE: *A digest MUST always be set using Override Parameters, since NOTE: *A digest MUST always be set using Override Parameters, since
this prevents a less-privileged dependent from replacing the digest.* this prevents a less-privileged dependent from replacing the digest.*
7.1. Compatibility Check Template 7.1. Compatibility Check Template
The compatibility check ensures that Recipients only install The goal of the compatibility check template ensure that Recipients
compatible images. In this template all information is contained in only install compatible images.
the common block and the following sequence of operations are used:
In this template all information is contained in the common sequence
and the following sequence of commands is used:
- Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1) - Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1)
- Set Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.6) for Vendor ID and - Set Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.5) for Vendor ID and
Class ID (see Section 8.7.5) Class ID (see Section 8.7.5)
- Check Vendor Identifier condition (see Section 8.7.5.1) - Check Vendor Identifier condition (see Section 8.7.5.2)
- Check Class Identifier condication (see Section 8.7.5.1) - Check Class Identifier condition (see Section 8.7.5.2)
7.2. Secure Boot Template 7.2. Trusted Invocation Template
This template performs a secure boot operation. The goal of the Trusted Invocation template is to ensure that only
authorized code is invoked; such as in Secure Boot or when a Trusted
Application is loaded into a TEE.
The following operations are placed into the common block: The following commands are placed into the common sequence:
- Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1) - Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1)
- Override Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.7) for Image - Override Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.6) for Image
Digest and Image Size (see Section 8.7.5) Digest and Image Size (see Section 8.7.5)
Then, the run block contains the following operations: Then, the run sequence contains the following commands:
- Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1) - Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1)
- Check Image Match condition (see Section 8.7.6.2) - Check Image Match condition (see Section 8.7.6.2)
- Run directive (see Section 8.7.7.13) - Run directive (see Section 8.7.7.12)
According to Section 6.4, the Run directive applies to the component
referenced by the current Component Index. Hence, the Set Component
Index directive has to be used to target a specific component.
7.3. Firmware Download Template 7.3. Component Download Template
This template triggers the download of firmware. The goal of the Component Download template is to acquire and store
an image.
The following operations are placed into the common block: The following commands are placed into the common sequence:
- Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1) - Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1)
- Override Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.7) for Image - Override Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.6) for Image
Digest and Image Size (see Section 8.7.5) Digest and Image Size (see Section 8.7.5)
Then, the install block contains the following operations: Then, the install sequence contains the following commands:
- Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1) - Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1)
- Set Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.6) for URI (see - Set Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.5) for URI (see
Section 8.7.5.12) Section 8.7.5.13)
- Fetch directive (see Section 8.7.7.8) - Fetch directive (see Section 8.7.7.7)
- Check Image Match condition (see Section 8.7.6.2) - Check Image Match condition (see Section 8.7.6.2)
The Fetch directive needs the URI parameter to be set to determine The Fetch directive needs the URI parameter to be set to determine
where the image is retrieved from. Additionally, the destination of where the image is retrieved from. Additionally, the destination of
where the component shall be stored has to be configured. The URI is where the component shall be stored has to be configured. The URI is
configured via the Set Parameters directive while the destination is configured via the Set Parameters directive while the destination is
configured via the Set Component Index directive. configured via the Set Component Index directive.
Optionally, the Set Parameters directive in the install sequence MAY
also contain Encryption Info (see Section 8.7.5.10), Compression Info
(see Section 8.7.5.11), or Unpack Info (see Section 8.7.5.12) to
perform simultaneous download and decryption, decompression, or
unpacking, respectively.
7.4. Install Template 7.4. Install Template
This template modifies the Firmware Download template and adds an The goal of the Install template is to use an image already stored in
additional sequence. The Firmware Download operations are moved from an identified component to copy into a second component.
the Payload Install sequence to the Payload Fetch sequence.
Then, the Install sequence contains the following operations: This template is typically used with the Component Download template,
however a modification to that template is required: the Component
Download operations are moved from the Payload Install sequence to
the Payload Fetch sequence.
Then, the install sequence contains the following commands:
- Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1) - Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1)
- Set Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.6) for Source - Set Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.5) for Source
Component (see Section 8.7.5.13) Component (see Section 8.7.5.14)
- Copy directive (see Section 8.7.7.10) - Copy directive (see Section 8.7.7.9)
- Check Image Match condition (see Section 8.7.6.2) - Check Image Match condition (see Section 8.7.6.2)
7.5. Integrated Payload Template 7.5. Install and Transform Template
This template triggers the installation of a payload included in the The goal of the Install and Transform template is to use an image
manifest envelope. It is identical to Section 7.3 except that it already stored in an identified component to decompress, decrypt, or
places an added restriction on the URI passed to the Set Parameters unpack at time of installation.
directive.
An implementor MAY choose to place a payload in the envelope of a This template is typically used with the Component Download template,
however a modification to that template is required: all Component
Download operations are moved from the common sequence and the
install sequence to the fetch sequence. The Component Download
template targets a download component identifier, while the Install
and Transform template uses an install component identifier. In-
place unpacking, decompression, and decryption is complex and
vulnerable to power failure. Therefore, these identifiers SHOULD be
different; in-place installation SHOULD NOT be used without
establishing guarantees of robustness to power failure.
The following commands are placed into the common sequence:
- Set Component Index directive for install component identifier
(see Section 8.7.7.1)
- Override Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.6) for Image
Digest and Image Size (see Section 8.7.5)
Then, the install sequence contains the following commands:
- Set Component Index directive for install component identifier
(see Section 8.7.7.1)
- Set Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.5) for:
o Source Component for download component identifier (see
Section 8.7.5.14)
o Encryption Info (see Section 8.7.5.10)
o Compression Info (see Section 8.7.5.11)
o Unpack Info (see Section 8.7.5.12)
- Copy directive (see Section 8.7.7.9)
- Check Image Match condition (see Section 8.7.6.2)
7.6. Integrated Payload Template
The goal of the Integrated Payload template is to install a payload
that is included in the manifest envelope. It is identical to the
Component Download template (Section 7.3) except that it places an
added restriction on the URI passed to the Set Parameters directive.
An implementer MAY choose to place a payload in the envelope of a
manifest. The payload envelope key MAY be a positive or negative manifest. The payload envelope key MAY be a positive or negative
integer. The payload envelope key MUST NOT be a value between 0 and integer. The payload envelope key MUST NOT be a value between 0 and
24 and it MUST NOT be used by any other envelope element in the 24 and it MUST NOT be used by any other envelope element in the
manifest. The payload MUST be serialized in a bstr element. manifest. The payload MUST be serialized in a bstr element.
The URI for a payload enclosed in this way MUST be expressed as a The URI for a payload enclosed in this way MUST be expressed as a
fragment-only reference, as defined in [RFC3986], Section 4.4. The fragment-only reference, as defined in [RFC3986], Section 4.4. The
fragment identifier is the stringified envelope key of the payload. fragment identifier is the stringified envelope key of the payload.
For example, an envelope that contains a payload a key 42 would use a For example, an envelope that contains a payload a key 42 would use a
URI "#42", key -73 would use a URI "#-73". URI "#42", key -73 would use a URI "#-73".
7.6. Load from Nonvolatile Storage Template 7.7. Load from Nonvolatile Storage Template
This directive loads an firmware image from external storage. The goal of the Load from Nonvolatile Storage template is to load an
image from a non-volatile component into a volatile component, for
example loading a firmware image from external Flash into RAM.
The following operations are placed into the load block: The following commands are placed into the load sequence:
- Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1) - Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1)
- Set Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.6) for Component Index - Set Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.5) for Component Index
(see Section 8.7.5) (see Section 8.7.5)
- Copy directive (see Section 8.7.7.10) - Copy directive (see Section 8.7.7.9)
As outlined in Section 6.4, the Copy directive needs a source and a As outlined in Section 6.4, the Copy directive needs a source and a
destination to be configured. The source is configured via Component destination to be configured. The source is configured via Component
Index (with the Set Parameters directive) and the destination is Index (with the Set Parameters directive) and the destination is
configured via the Set Component Index directive. configured via the Set Component Index directive.
7.7. Load & Decompress from Nonvolatile Storage Template 7.8. Load & Decompress from Nonvolatile Storage Template
The following operations are placed into the load block: The goal of the Load & Decompress from Nonvolatile Storage template
is to load an image from a non-volatile component into a volatile
component, decompressing on-the-fly, for example loading a firmware
image from external Flash into RAM.
The following commands are placed into the load sequence:
- Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1) - Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1)
- Set Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.6) for Source - Set Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.5) for Source
Component Index and Compression Info (see Section 8.7.5) Component Index and Compression Info (see Section 8.7.5)
- Copy directive (see Section 8.7.7.10) - Copy directive (see Section 8.7.7.9)
This template is similar to Section 7.6 but additionally performs
This template is similar to Section 7.7 but additionally performs
decompression. Hence, the only difference is in setting the decompression. Hence, the only difference is in setting the
Compression Info parameter. Compression Info parameter.
7.8. Dependency Template This template can be modified for decryption or unpacking by adding
Decryption Info or Unpack Info to the Set Parameters directive.
The following operations are placed into the dependency resolution 7.9. Dependency Template
block:
The goal of the Dependency template is to obtain, verify, and process
a dependency manifest as appropriate.
The following commands are placed into the dependency resolution
sequence:
- Set Dependency Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.2) - Set Dependency Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.2)
- Set Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.6) for URI (see - Set Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.5) for URI (see
Section 8.7.5) Section 8.7.5)
- Fetch directive (see Section 8.7.7.8) - Fetch directive (see Section 8.7.7.7)
- Check Image Match condition (see Section 8.7.6.2) - Check Image Match condition (see Section 8.7.6.2)
- Process Dependency directive (see Section 8.7.7.5) - Process Dependency directive (see Section 8.7.7.4)
Then, the validate block contains the following operations: Then, the validate sequence contains the following operations:
- Set Dependency Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.2) - Set Dependency Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.2)
- Check Image Match condition (see Section 8.7.6.2) - Check Image Match condition (see Section 8.7.6.2)
- Process Dependency directive (see Section 8.7.7.5) - Process Dependency directive (see Section 8.7.7.4)
NOTE: Any changes made to parameters in a dependency persist in the NOTE: Any changes made to parameters in a dependency persist in the
dependent. dependent.
7.8.1. Composite Manifests 7.9.1. Composite Manifests
An implementor MAY choose to place a dependency's envelope in the An implementer MAY choose to place a dependency's envelope in the
envelope of its dependent. The dependent envelope key for the envelope of its dependent. The dependent envelope key for the
dependency envelope MUST NOT be a value between 0 and 24 and it MUST dependency envelope MUST NOT be a value between 0 and 24 and it MUST
NOT be used by any other envelope element in the dependent manifest. NOT be used by any other envelope element in the dependent manifest.
The URI for a dependency enclosed in this way MUST be expressed as a The URI for a dependency enclosed in this way MUST be expressed as a
fragment-only reference, as defined in [RFC3986], Section 4.4. The fragment-only reference, as defined in [RFC3986], Section 4.4. The
fragment identifier is the stringified envelope key of the fragment identifier is the stringified envelope key of the
dependency. For example, an envelope that contains a dependency at dependency. For example, an envelope that contains a dependency at
key 42 would use a URI "#42", key -73 would use a URI "#-73". key 42 would use a URI "#42", key -73 would use a URI "#-73".
7.9. Encrypted Manifest Template 7.10. Encrypted Manifest Template
To use an encrypted manifest, create a plaintext dependent, and add The goal of the Encrypted Manifest template is to fetch and decrypt a
the encrypted manifest as a dependency. The dependent can include manifest so that it can be used as a dependency. To use an encrypted
very little information. manifest, create a plaintext dependent, and add the encrypted
manifest as a dependency. The dependent can include very little
information.
The following operations are placed into the dependency resolution The following operations are placed into the dependency resolution
block: block:
- Set Dependency Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.2) - Set Dependency Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.2)
- Set Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.6) for - Set Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.5) for
o URI (see Section 8.7.5) o URI (see Section 8.7.5)
o Encryption Info (see Section 8.7.5) o Encryption Info (see Section 8.7.5)
- Fetch directive (see Section 8.7.7.8) - Fetch directive (see Section 8.7.7.7)
- Check Image Match condition (see Section 8.7.6.2) - Check Image Match condition (see Section 8.7.6.2)
- Process Dependency directive (see Section 8.7.7.5) - Process Dependency directive (see Section 8.7.7.4)
Then, the validate block contains the following operations: Then, the validate block contains the following operations:
- Set Dependency Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.2) - Set Dependency Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.2)
- Check Image Match condition (see Section 8.7.6.2) - Check Image Match condition (see Section 8.7.6.2)
- Process Dependency directive (see Section 8.7.7.5) - Process Dependency directive (see Section 8.7.7.4)
A plaintext manifest and its encrypted dependency may also form a A plaintext manifest and its encrypted dependency may also form a
composite manifest (Section 7.8.1). composite manifest (Section 7.9.1).
7.10. A/B Image Template 7.11. A/B Image Template
The following operations are placed in the common block: The goal of the A/B Image Template is to acquire, validate, and
invoke one of two images, based on a test.
The following commands are placed in the common block:
- Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1) - Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1)
- Try Each - Try Each
o First Sequence: o First Sequence:
* Override Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.7, * Override Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.6,
Section 8.7.5) for Offset A Section 8.7.5) for Offset A
* Check Offset Condition (see Section 8.7.6.5) * Check Offset Condition (see Section 8.7.6.5)
* Override Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.7) for
* Override Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.6) for
Image Digest A and Image Size A (see Section 8.7.5) Image Digest A and Image Size A (see Section 8.7.5)
o Second Sequence: o Second Sequence:
* Override Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.7, * Override Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.6,
Section 8.7.5) for Offset B Section 8.7.5) for Offset B
* Check Offset Condition (see Section 8.7.6.5) * Check Offset Condition (see Section 8.7.6.5)
* Override Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.7) for * Override Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.6) for
Image Digest B and Image Size B (see Section 8.7.5) Image Digest B and Image Size B (see Section 8.7.5)
The following operations are placed in the fetch block or install The following commands are placed in the fetch block or install block
block
- Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1) - Set Component Index directive (see Section 8.7.7.1)
- Try Each - Try Each
o First Sequence: o First Sequence:
* Override Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.7, * Override Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.6,
Section 8.7.5) for Offset A Section 8.7.5) for Offset A
* Check Offset Condition (see Section 8.7.6.5) * Check Offset Condition (see Section 8.7.6.5)
* Set Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.7) for URI A * Set Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.6) for URI A
(see Section 8.7.5) (see Section 8.7.5)
o Second Sequence: o Second Sequence:
* Override Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.7, * Override Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.6,
Section 8.7.5) for Offset B Section 8.7.5) for Offset B
* Check Offset Condition (see Section 8.7.6.5) * Check Offset Condition (see Section 8.7.6.5)
* Set Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.7) for URI B * Set Parameters directive (see Section 8.7.7.6) for URI B
(see Section 8.7.5) (see Section 8.7.5)
- Fetch - Fetch
If Trusted Invocation (Section 7.2) is used, only the run sequence is
added to this template, since the common sequence is populated by
this template.
NOTE: Any test can be used to select between images, Check Offset
Condition is used in this template because it is a typical test for
execute-in-place devices.
8. Metadata Structure 8. Metadata Structure
The metadata for SUIT updates is composed of several primary The metadata for SUIT updates is composed of several primary
constituent parts: the Envelope, Delegation Chains, Authentication constituent parts: the Envelope, Delegation Chains, Authentication
Information, Manifest, and Severable Elements. Information, Manifest, and Severable Elements.
For a diagram of the metadata structure, see Section 5. For a diagram of the metadata structure, see Section 5.
8.1. Encoding Considerations 8.1. Encoding Considerations
The map indices in the envelope encoding are reset to 1 for each map The map indices in the envelope encoding are reset to 1 for each map
within the structure. This is to keep the indices as small as within the structure. This is to keep the indices as small as
possible. The goal is to keep the index objects to single bytes possible. The goal is to keep the index objects to single bytes
(CBOR positive integers 1-23). (CBOR positive integers 1-23).
Wherever enumerations are used, they are started at 1. This allows Wherever enumerations are used, they are started at 1. This allows
detection of several common software errors that are caused by detection of several common software errors that are caused by
uninitialised variables. Positive numbers in enumerations are uninitialized variables. Positive numbers in enumerations are
reserved for IANA registration. Negative numbers are used to reserved for IANA registration. Negative numbers are used to
identify application-specific implementations. identify application-specific values, as described in Section 11.
All elements of the envelope must be wrapped in a bstr to minimize All elements of the envelope must be wrapped in a bstr to minimize
the complexity of the code that evaluates the cryptographic integrity the complexity of the code that evaluates the cryptographic integrity
of the element and to ensure correct serialization for integrity and of the element and to ensure correct serialization for integrity and
authenticity checks. authenticity checks.
8.2. Envelope 8.2. Envelope
The Envelope contains each of the other primary constituent parts of The Envelope contains each of the other primary constituent parts of
the SUIT metadata. It allows for modular processing of the manifest the SUIT metadata. It allows for modular processing of the manifest
by ordering components in the expected order of processing. by ordering components in the expected order of processing.
The Envelope is encoded as a CBOR Map. Each element of the Envelope The Envelope is encoded as a CBOR Map. Each element of the Envelope
is enclosed in a bstr, which allows computation of a message digest is enclosed in a bstr, which allows computation of a message digest
against known bounds. against known bounds.
8.3. Delegation Chains 8.3. Delegation Chains
The suit-delegation field MAY carry one or more CBOR Web Tokens The suit-delegation element MAY carry one or more CBOR Web Tokens
(CWTs) [RFC8392], with [RFC8747] cnf claims. They can be used to (CWTs) [RFC8392], with [RFC8747] cnf claims. They can be used to
perform enhanced authorization decisions. The CWTs are arranged into perform enhanced authorization decisions. The CWTs are arranged into
a list of lists. Each list starts with CWT authorized by a Trust a list of lists. Each list starts with a CWT authorized by a Trust
Anchor, and finishes with a key used to authenticate the Manifest Anchor, and finishes with a key used to authenticate the Manifest
(see Section 8.4). This allows an Update Authority to delegate from (see Section 8.4). This allows an Update Authority to delegate from
a long term Trust Anchor, down through intermediaries, to a delegate a long term Trust Anchor, down through intermediaries, to a delegate
without any out-of-band updates Trust Anchors. without any out-of-band provisioning of Trust Anchors or intermediary
keys.
A Recipient MAY choose to cache intermediaries and/or delegates. If A Recipient MAY choose to cache intermediaries and/or delegates. If
an Update Distributor knows that a targeted Recipient has cached some an Update Distributor knows that a targeted Recipient has cached some
intermediaries or delegates, it MAY choose to strip any cached intermediaries or delegates, it MAY choose to strip any cached
intermediaries or delegates from the Delegation Chains in order to intermediaries or delegates from the Delegation Chains in order to
reduce bandwidth and energy. reduce bandwidth and energy.
8.4. Authenticated Manifests 8.4. Authenticated Manifests
The suit-authentication-wrapper contains a list of one or more The suit-authentication-wrapper contains a list containing a
cryptographic authentication wrappers for the Manifest. These are Section 10 and one or more cryptographic authentication wrappers for
implemented as COSE_Mac_Tagged or COSE_Sign_Tagged blocks. Each of the Manifest. These are implemented as COSE_Mac_Tagged or
these blocks contains a SUIT_Digest of the Manifest. This enables COSE_Sign_Tagged blocks. Each of these blocks contains a SUIT_Digest
modular processing of the manifest. The COSE_Mac_Tagged and of the Manifest. This enables modular processing of the manifest.
COSE_Sign_Tagged blocks are described in RFC 8152 [RFC8152]. The The COSE_Mac_Tagged and COSE_Sign_Tagged blocks are described in RFC
suit-authentication-wrapper MUST come before any element in the 8152 [RFC8152]. The suit-authentication-wrapper MUST come before any
SUIT_Envelope, except for the OPTIONAL suit-delegation, regardless of element in the SUIT_Envelope, except for the OPTIONAL suit-
canonical encoding of CBOR. All validators MUST reject any delegation, regardless of canonical encoding of CBOR. All validators
SUIT_Envelope that begins with any element other than a suit- MUST reject any SUIT_Envelope that begins with any element other than
authentication-wrapper or suit-delegation. a suit-authentication-wrapper or suit-delegation.
A SUIT_Envelope that has not had authentication information added A SUIT_Envelope that has not had authentication information added
MUST still contain the suit-authentication-wrapper element, but the MUST still contain the suit-authentication-wrapper element, but the
content MUST be an empty list. content MUST be a list containing only the SUIT_Digest.
A signing application MUST verify the suit-manifest element against
the SUIT_Digest prior to signing.
8.5. Encrypted Manifests 8.5. Encrypted Manifests
To use an encrypted manifest, it must be a dependency of a plaintext To use an encrypted manifest, it must be a dependency of a plaintext
manifest. This allows fine-grained control of what information is manifest. This allows fine-grained control of what information is
accessible to intermediate systems for the purposes of management, accessible to intermediate systems for the purposes of management,
while still preserving the confidentiality of the manifest contents. while still preserving the confidentiality of the manifest contents.
This also means that a Recipient can process an encrypted manifest in This also means that a Recipient can process an encrypted manifest in
the same way as an encrypted payload, allowing code reuse. the same way as an encrypted payload, allowing code reuse.
A template for using an encrypted manifest is covered in Encrypted A template for using an encrypted manifest is covered in Encrypted
Manifest Template (Section 7.9). Manifest Template (Section 7.10).
8.6. Manifest 8.6. Manifest
The manifest contains: The manifest contains:
- a version number (see Section 8.6.1) - a version number (see Section 8.6.1)
- a sequence number (see Section 8.6.2) - a sequence number (see Section 8.6.2)
- a reference URI (see Section 8.6.3) - a reference URI (see Section 8.6.3)
skipping to change at page 32, line 44 skipping to change at page 37, line 4
8.6. Manifest 8.6. Manifest
The manifest contains: The manifest contains:
- a version number (see Section 8.6.1) - a version number (see Section 8.6.1)
- a sequence number (see Section 8.6.2) - a sequence number (see Section 8.6.2)
- a reference URI (see Section 8.6.3) - a reference URI (see Section 8.6.3)
- a common structure with information that is shared between command - a common structure with information that is shared between command
sequences (see Section 8.7.2) sequences (see Section 8.7.2)
- one or more lists of commands that the Recipient should perform - one or more lists of commands that the Recipient should perform
(see Section 8.7.3) (see Section 8.7.3)
- a reference to the full manifest (see Section 8.6.3) - a reference to the full manifest (see Section 8.6.3)
- human-readable text describing the manifest found in the - human-readable text describing the manifest found in the
SUIT_Envelope (see Section 8.6.4) SUIT_Envelope (see Section 8.6.4)
- a Concise Software Identifier found in the SUIT_Envelope (see - a Concise Software Identifier (CoSWID) found in the SUIT_Envelope
Section 8.7.1) (see Section 8.7.1)
The CoSWID, Text section, or any Command Sequence of the Update The CoSWID, Text section, or any Command Sequence of the Update
Procedure (Dependency Resolution, Image Fetch, Image Installation) Procedure (Dependency Resolution, Image Fetch, Image Installation)
can be either a CBOR structure or a SUIT_Digest. In each of these can be either a CBOR structure or a SUIT_Digest. In each of these
cases, the SUIT_Digest provides for a severable field. Severable cases, the SUIT_Digest provides for a severable element. Severable
fields are RECOMMENDED to implement. In particular, the human- elements are RECOMMENDED to implement. In particular, the human-
readable text SHOULD be severable, since most useful text elements readable text SHOULD be severable, since most useful text elements
occupy more space than a SUIT_Digest, but are not needed by the occupy more space than a SUIT_Digest, but are not needed by the
Recipient. Because SUIT_Digest is a CBOR Array and each severable Recipient. Because SUIT_Digest is a CBOR Array and each severable
element is a CBOR bstr, it is straight-forward for a Recipient to element is a CBOR bstr, it is straight-forward for a Recipient to
determine whether an element has been severed. The key used for a determine whether an element has been severed. The key used for a
severable element is the same in the SUIT_Manifest and in the severable element is the same in the SUIT_Manifest and in the
SUIT_Envelope so that a Recipient can easily identify the correct SUIT_Envelope so that a Recipient can easily identify the correct
data in the envelope. See Section 8.7.8 for more detail. data in the envelope. See Section 8.7.8 for more detail.
8.6.1. suit-manifest-version 8.6.1. suit-manifest-version
skipping to change at page 33, line 37 skipping to change at page 37, line 45
to encode the manifest. Version 1 is the version described in this to encode the manifest. Version 1 is the version described in this
document. suit-manifest-version is REQUIRED to implement. document. suit-manifest-version is REQUIRED to implement.
8.6.2. suit-manifest-sequence-number 8.6.2. suit-manifest-sequence-number
The suit-manifest-sequence-number is a monotonically increasing anti- The suit-manifest-sequence-number is a monotonically increasing anti-
rollback counter. It also helps Recipients to determine which in a rollback counter. It also helps Recipients to determine which in a
set of manifests is the "root" manifest in a given update. Each set of manifests is the "root" manifest in a given update. Each
manifest MUST have a sequence number higher than each of its manifest MUST have a sequence number higher than each of its
dependencies. Each Recipient MUST reject any manifest that has a dependencies. Each Recipient MUST reject any manifest that has a
sequence number lower than its current sequence number. It MAY be sequence number lower than its current sequence number. For
convenient to use a UTC timestamp in seconds as the sequence number. convenience, an implementer MAY use a UTC timestamp in seconds as the
suit-manifest-sequence-number is REQUIRED to implement. sequence number. suit-manifest-sequence-number is REQUIRED to
implement.
8.6.3. suit-reference-uri 8.6.3. suit-reference-uri
suit-reference-uri is a text string that encodes a URI where a full suit-reference-uri is a text string that encodes a URI where a full
version of this manifest can be found. This is convenient for version of this manifest can be found. This is convenient for
allowing management systems to show the severed elements of a allowing management systems to show the severed elements of a
manifest when this URI is reported by a Recipient after installation. manifest when this URI is reported by a Recipient after installation.
8.6.4. suit-text 8.6.4. suit-text
suit-text SHOULD be a severable element. suit-text is a map of pairs. suit-text SHOULD be a severable element. suit-text is a map
It MAY contain two different types of pair: containing two different types of pair:
- integer => text mappings - integer => text
- SUIT_Component_Identifier => map mappings - SUIT_Component_Identifier => map
Each SUIT_Component_Identifier => map entry contains a map of integer Each SUIT_Component_Identifier => map entry contains a map of integer
=> text values. All SUIT_Component_Identifiers present in suit-text => text values. All SUIT_Component_Identifiers present in suit-text
MUST also be present in suit-common (Section 8.7.2) or the suit- MUST also be present in suit-common (Section 8.7.2) or the suit-
common of a dependency. common of a dependency.
suit-text contains all the human-readable information that describes suit-text contains all the human-readable information that describes
any and all parts of the manifest, its payload(s) and its any and all parts of the manifest, its payload(s) and its
resource(s). The text section is typically severable, allowing resource(s). The text section is typically severable, allowing
manifests to be distributed without the text, since end-nodes do not manifests to be distributed without the text, since end-nodes do not
skipping to change at page 34, line 43 skipping to change at page 39, line 17
+--------------------------------+----------------------------------+ +--------------------------------+----------------------------------+
| suit-text-manifest-description | Free text description of the | | suit-text-manifest-description | Free text description of the |
| | manifest | | | manifest |
| | | | | |
| suit-text-update-description | Free text description of the | | suit-text-update-description | Free text description of the |
| | update | | | update |
| | | | | |
| suit-text-manifest-json-source | The JSON-formatted document that | | suit-text-manifest-json-source | The JSON-formatted document that |
| | was used to create the manifest | | | was used to create the manifest |
| | | | | |
| suit-text-manifest-yaml-source | The yaml-formatted document that | | suit-text-manifest-yaml-source | The YAML ([YAML])-formatted |
| | was used to create the manifest | | | document that was used to create |
| | the manifest |
+--------------------------------+----------------------------------+ +--------------------------------+----------------------------------+
The following table describes the text fields available in each map The following table describes the text fields available in each map
identified by a SUIT_Component_Identifier. identified by a SUIT_Component_Identifier.
+---------------------------------+---------------------------------+ +---------------------------------+---------------------------------+
| CDDL Structure | Description | | CDDL Structure | Description |
+---------------------------------+---------------------------------+ +---------------------------------+---------------------------------+
| suit-text-vendor-name | Free text vendor name | | suit-text-vendor-name | Free text vendor name |
| | | | | |
skipping to change at page 35, line 21 skipping to change at page 39, line 41
| | | | | |
| suit-text-vendor-domain | The domain used to create the | | suit-text-vendor-domain | The domain used to create the |
| | vendor-id condition | | | vendor-id condition |
| | | | | |
| suit-text-model-info | The information used to create | | suit-text-model-info | The information used to create |
| | the class-id condition | | | the class-id condition |
| | | | | |
| suit-text-component-description | Free text description of each | | suit-text-component-description | Free text description of each |
| | component in the manifest | | | component in the manifest |
| | | | | |
| suit-text-component-version | A text version number | | suit-text-component-version | A free text representation of |
| | the component version |
| | | | | |
| suit-text-version-required | A text expression of the | | suit-text-version-required | A free text expression of the |
| | required version number | | | required version number |
+---------------------------------+---------------------------------+ +---------------------------------+---------------------------------+
suit-text is OPTIONAL to implement. suit-text is OPTIONAL to implement.
8.7. text-version-required 8.7. text-version-required
suit-text-version-required is used to represent a version-based suit-text-version-required is used to represent a version-based
dependency on suit-parameter-version as described in Section 8.7.5.17 dependency on suit-parameter-version as described in Section 8.7.5.18
and Section 8.7.6.8. To describe a version dependency, a Manifest and Section 8.7.6.8. To describe a version dependency, a Manifest
Author should populate the suit-text map with a Author SHOULD populate the suit-text map with a
SUIT_Component_Identifier key for the dependency component, and place SUIT_Component_Identifier key for the dependency component, and place
in the corresponding map a suit-text-version-required key with a text in the corresponding map a suit-text-version-required key with a free
expression that is representative of the version constraints placed text expression that is representative of the version constraints
on the dependency. placed on the dependency. This text SHOULD be expressive enough that
a device operator can be expected to understand the dependency. This
is a free text field and there are no specific formatting rules.
For example, to express a dependency on a component "['x', 'y']", By way of example only, to express a dependency on a component "['x',
where the version should be any v1.x later than v1.2.5, but not v2.0 'y']", where the version should be any v1.x later than v1.2.5, but
or above, the author would add the following structure to the suit- not v2.0 or above, the author would add the following structure to
text element. Note that this text is in cbor-diag notation. the suit-text element. Note that this text is in cbor-diag notation.
" [h'78',h'79'] : { 7 : ">=1.2.5,<2" } " [h'78',h'79'] : {
7 : ">=1.2.5,<2"
}
8.7.1. suit-coswid 8.7.1. suit-coswid
suit-coswid contains a Concise Software Identifier. This element suit-coswid contains a Concise Software Identifier (CoSWID) as
SHOULD be made severable so that it can be discarded by the Recipient defined in [I-D.ietf-sacm-coswid]. This element SHOULD be made
or an intermediary if it is not required by the Recipient. severable so that it can be discarded by the Recipient or an
intermediary if it is not required by the Recipient.
suit-coswid is OPTIONAL to implement. suit-coswid typically requires no processing by the Recipient.
However all Recipients MUST NOT fail if a suit-coswid is present.
8.7.2. suit-common 8.7.2. suit-common
suit-common encodes all the information that is shared between each suit-common encodes all the information that is shared between each
of the command sequences, including: suit-dependencies, suit- of the command sequences, including: suit-dependencies, suit-
components, and suit-common-sequence. suit-common is REQUIRED to components, and suit-common-sequence. suit-common is REQUIRED to
implement. implement.
suit-dependencies is a list of Section 8.7.2.1 blocks that specify suit-dependencies is a list of Section 8.7.2.1 blocks that specify
manifests that must be present before the current manifest can be manifests that must be present before the current manifest can be
skipping to change at page 36, line 27 skipping to change at page 41, line 8
suit-components is a list of SUIT_Component_Identifier suit-components is a list of SUIT_Component_Identifier
(Section 8.7.2.2) blocks that specify the component identifiers that (Section 8.7.2.2) blocks that specify the component identifiers that
will be affected by the content of the current manifest. suit- will be affected by the content of the current manifest. suit-
components is REQUIRED to implement; at least one manifest in a components is REQUIRED to implement; at least one manifest in a
dependency tree MUST contain a suit-components block. dependency tree MUST contain a suit-components block.
suit-common-sequence is a SUIT_Command_Sequence to execute prior to suit-common-sequence is a SUIT_Command_Sequence to execute prior to
executing any other command sequence. Typical actions in suit- executing any other command sequence. Typical actions in suit-
common-sequence include setting expected Recipient identity and image common-sequence include setting expected Recipient identity and image
digests when they are conditional (see Section 8.7.7.4 and digests when they are conditional (see Section 8.7.7.3 and
Section 7.10 for more information on conditional sequences). suit- Section 7.11 for more information on conditional sequences). suit-
common-sequence is RECOMMENDED to implement. It is REQUIRED if the common-sequence is RECOMMENDED to implement. It is REQUIRED if the
optimizations described in Section 6.2.1 will be used. Whenever a optimizations described in Section 6.2.1 will be used. Whenever a
parameter or try-each is required by more than one Command Sequence, parameter or Try Each command is required by more than one Command
suit-common-sequence results in a smaller encoding. Sequence, placing that parameter or commamd in suit-common-sequence
results in a smaller encoding.
8.7.2.1. Dependencies 8.7.2.1. Dependencies
SUIT_Dependency specifies a manifest that describes a dependency of SUIT_Dependency specifies a manifest that describes a dependency of
the current manifest. The Manifest is identified, however the the current manifest. The Manifest is identified, but the Recipient
Recipient should expect an Envelope when it acquires the dependency. should expect an Envelope when it acquires the dependency. This is
This is because the Manifest is the one invariant element of the because the Manifest is the one invariant element of the Envelope,
Envelope, where other elements may change by countersigning, adding where other elements may change by countersigning, adding
authentication blocks, or severing elements. authentication blocks, or severing elements.
The suit-dependency-digest specifies the dependency manifest uniquely The suit-dependency-digest specifies the dependency manifest uniquely
by identifying a particular Manifest structure. This is identical to by identifying a particular Manifest structure. This is identical to
the digest that would be present as the payload of any suit- the digest that would be present as the payload of any suit-
authentication-block in the dependency's Envelope. The digest is authentication-block in the dependency's Envelope. The digest is
calculated over the Manifest structure instead of the COSE calculated over the Manifest structure instead of the COSE
Sig_structure or Mac_structure. This is necessary to ensure that Sig_structure or Mac_structure. This is necessary to ensure that
removing a signature from a manifest does not break dependencies due removing a signature from a manifest does not break dependencies due
to missing signature elements. This is also necessary to support the to missing signature elements. This is also necessary to support the
trusted intermediary use case, where an intermediary re-signs the trusted intermediary use case, where an intermediary re-signs the
Manifest, removing the original signature, potentially with a Manifest, removing the original signature, potentially with a
different algorithm, or trading COSE_Sign for COSE_Mac. different algorithm, or trading COSE_Sign for COSE_Mac.
The suit-dependency-prefix element contains a The suit-dependency-prefix element contains a
SUIT_Component_Identifier (see Section 8.7.2.2). This specifies the SUIT_Component_Identifier (see Section 8.7.2.2). This specifies the
scope at which the dependency operates. This allows the dependency scope at which the dependency operates. This allows the dependency
to be forwarded on to a component that is capable of parsing its own to be forwarded on to a component that is capable of parsing its own
manifests. It also allows one manifest to be deployed to multiple manifests. It also allows one manifest to be deployed to multiple
dependent Recipients without those Recipients needing consistent dependent Recipients without those Recipients needing consistent
component hierarchy. This element is OPTIONAL. component hierarchy. This element is OPTIONAL for Recipients to
implement.
A dependency prefix can be used with a component identifier. This A dependency prefix can be used with a component identifier. This
allows complex systems to understand where dependencies need to be allows complex systems to understand where dependencies need to be
applied. The dependency prefix can be used in one of two ways. The applied. The dependency prefix can be used in one of two ways. The
first simply prepends the prefix to all Component Identifiers in the first simply prepends the prefix to all Component Identifiers in the
dependency. dependency.
A dependency prefix can also be used to indicate when a dependency A dependency prefix can also be used to indicate when a dependency
manifest needs to be processed by a secondary manifest processor, as manifest needs to be processed by a secondary manifest processor, as
described in Section 6.9. described in Section 6.9.
8.7.2.2. SUIT_Component_Identifier 8.7.2.2. SUIT_Component_Identifier
A component is a unit of code or data that can be targeted by an A component is a unit of code or data that can be targeted by an
update. To facilitate composite devices, components are identified update. To facilitate composite devices, components are identified
by a list of CBOR byte strings, which allows construction of by a list of CBOR byte strings, which allows construction of
hierarchical component structures. A dependency MAY declare a prefix hierarchical component structures. A dependency MAY declare a prefix
to the components defined in the dependency manifest. Components are to the components defined in the dependency manifest. Components are
identified by Component Identifiers, i.e. arrays of binary strings, identified by Component Identifiers, but referenced in commands by
but referenced in commands Component Index; Component Identifiers are arrays of binary strings
and a Component Index is an index into the array of Component
Identifiers.
A Component Identifier can be trivial, such as the simple array A Component Identifier can be trivial, such as the simple array
[h'00']. It can also represent a filesystem path by encoding each [h'00']. It can also represent a filesystem path by encoding each
segment of the path as an element in the list. For example, the path segment of the path as an element in the list. For example, the path
"/usr/bin/env" would encode to ['usr','bin','env']. "/usr/bin/env" would encode to ['usr','bin','env'].
This hierarchical construction allows a component identifier to This hierarchical construction allows a component identifier to
identify any part of a complex, multi-component system. identify any part of a complex, multi-component system.
8.7.3. SUIT_Command_Sequence 8.7.3. SUIT_Command_Sequence
skipping to change at page 38, line 38 skipping to change at page 43, line 23
targeting all dependencies SHOULD be present in validate. targeting all dependencies SHOULD be present in validate.
5. Image Loading: suit-load is a SUIT_Command_Sequence to execute in 5. Image Loading: suit-load is a SUIT_Command_Sequence to execute in
order to prepare a payload for execution. Typical actions order to prepare a payload for execution. Typical actions
include copying an image from permanent storage into RAM, include copying an image from permanent storage into RAM,
optionally including actions such as decryption or decompression. optionally including actions such as decryption or decompression.
suit-load is OPTIONAL to implement. suit-load is OPTIONAL to implement.
6. Run or Boot: suit-run is a SUIT_Command_Sequence to execute in 6. Run or Boot: suit-run is a SUIT_Command_Sequence to execute in
order to run an image. suit-run typically contains a single order to run an image. suit-run typically contains a single
instruction: either the "run" directive for the bootable manifest instruction: either the "run" directive for the invocable
or the "process dependencies" directive for any dependents of the manifest or the "process dependencies" directive for any
bootable manifest. suit-run is OPTIONAL to implement. Only one dependents of the invocable manifest. suit-run is OPTIONAL to
manifest in an update may contain the "run" directive. implement.
Goals 1,2,3 form the Update Procedure. Goals 4,5,6 form the Boot Goals 1,2,3 form the Update Procedure. Goals 4,5,6 form the
Procedure. Invocation Procedure.
Each Command Sequence follows exactly the same structure to ensure Each Command Sequence follows exactly the same structure to ensure
that the parser is as simple as possible. that the parser is as simple as possible.
Lists of commands are constructed from two kinds of element: Lists of commands are constructed from two kinds of element:
1. Conditions that MUST be true-any failure is treated as a failure 1. Conditions that MUST be true and any failure is treated as a
of the update/load/boot failure of the update/load/invocation
2. Directives that MUST be executed. 2. Directives that MUST be executed.
Each condition is a command code identifier, followed by a Each condition is composed of:
SUIT_Reporting_Policy (Section 8.7.4).
1. A command code identifier
2. A SUIT_Reporting_Policy (Section 8.7.4)
Each directive is composed of: Each directive is composed of:
1. A command code identifier 1. A command code identifier
2. An argument block or a reporting policy 2. An argument block or a SUIT_Reporting_Policy (Section 8.7.4)
Argument blocks are consumed only by flow-control directives: Argument blocks are consumed only by flow-control directives:
- Set Component/Dependency Index - Set Component/Dependency Index
- Set/Override Parameters - Set/Override Parameters
- Try Each - Try Each
- Run Sequence - Run Sequence
Reporting policies provide a hint to the manifest processor of Reporting policies provide a hint to the manifest processor of
whether or not to add the success or failure of a command to any whether to add the success or failure of a command to any report that
report that it generates. it generates.
Many conditions and directives apply to a given component, and these Many conditions and directives apply to a given component, and these
generally grouped together. Therefore, a special command to set the generally grouped together. Therefore, a special command to set the
current component index is provided with a matching command to set current component index is provided with a matching command to set
the current dependency index. This index is a numeric index into the the current dependency index. This index is a numeric index into the
component ID tables defined at the beginning of the document. For Component Identifier tables defined at the beginning of the manifest.
the purpose of setting the index, the two component ID tables are For the purpose of setting the index, the two Component Identifier
considered to be concatenated together. tables are considered to be concatenated together.
To facilitate optional conditions, a special directive, To facilitate optional conditions, a special directive, suit-
Section 8.7.7.4, is provided. It runs several new lists of directive-try-each (Section 8.7.7.3), is provided. It runs several
conditions/directives, one after another, that are contained as an new lists of conditions/directives, one after another, that are
argument to the directive. By default, it assumes that a failure of contained as an argument to the directive. By default, it assumes
a condition should not indicate a failure of the update/boot, but a that a failure of a condition should not indicate a failure of the
parameter is provided to override this behavior. See update/invocation, but a parameter is provided to override this
Section 8.7.5.22. behavior. See suit-parameter-soft-failure (Section 8.7.5.23).
8.7.4. Reporting Policy 8.7.4. Reporting Policy
To facilitate construction of Reports that describe the success, or To facilitate construction of Reports that describe the success, or
failure of a given Procedure, each command is given a Reporting failure of a given Procedure, each command is given a Reporting
Policy. This is an integer bitfield that follows the command and Policy. This is an integer bitfield that follows the command and
indicates what the Recipient should do with the Record of executing indicates what the Recipient should do with the Record of executing
the command. The options are summarized in the table below. the command. The options are summarized in the table below.
+-----------------------------+-------------------------------------+ +-----------------------------+-------------------------------------+
skipping to change at page 40, line 29 skipping to change at page 45, line 21
| | | | | |
| suit-send-sysinfo-success | Add system information when the | | suit-send-sysinfo-success | Add system information when the |
| | command succeeds | | | command succeeds |
| | | | | |
| suit-send-sysinfo-failure | Add system information when the | | suit-send-sysinfo-failure | Add system information when the |
| | command fails | | | command fails |
+-----------------------------+-------------------------------------+ +-----------------------------+-------------------------------------+
Any or all of these policies may be enabled at once. Any or all of these policies may be enabled at once.
If the component index is set to True when a command is executed with At the completion of each command, a recipient MAY forward that
a non-zero reporting policy, then the Reporting Engine MUST receive command's reporting policy, the result of the command, the current
one Record for each Component, in the order expressed in the set of parameters, and the system information consumed by the command
Components list. If the dependency index is set to True when a to a TODO
command is executed with a non-zero reporting policy, then the
Reporting Engine MUST receive one Record for each Dependency, in the
order expressed in the Dependencies list.
SUIT does NOT REQUIRE a particular format of Records or Reports. several information elements are provided to an implementation
SUIT only defines hints to the Reporting engine for which Records it defined subsystem, the Reporting Engine:
should aggregate into the Report.
For example, a system using DICE certificates MAY use instances of - The reporting policies
suit-send-sysinfo-success to construct its certificates.
An OPTIONAL Record format, SUIT_Record is defined in [full-cddl]. It - The result of the command
is encoded as a map, with the following elements.
+---------------------------------+---------------------------------+ - The parameters consumed by the command
| Element | Description |
+---------------------------------+---------------------------------+
| suit-record-success | The boolean or integer success |
| | or failure code of the command. |
| | |
| suit-record-component-id | The current component when the |
| | record was generated. |
| | |
| suit-record-dependency-id | The current dependency digest |
| | when the record was generated. |
| | |
| suit-record-command-sequence-id | The label of the Command |
| | Sequence that was executing |
| | when the record was generated. |
| | |
| suit-record-command-id | The label of the command that |
| | was in progress when the record |
| | was generated. |
| | |
| suit-record-params | The set of parameters that was |
| | consumed by the current |
| | command. |
| | |
| suit-record-actual | The value against which a suit- |
| | condition compared a parameter. |
+---------------------------------+---------------------------------+
In Secure Boot operations, the Reporting engine MAY aggregate the - The system information consumed by the command
Records produced in a Procedure into the evidence used for an
attestation report. If the component index is set to True or an array when a command is
executed with a non-zero reporting policy, then the Reporting Engine
MUST receive one Record for each Component, in the order expressed in
the Components list or the component index array, respectively. If
the dependency index is set to True or an array when a command is
executed with a non-zero reporting policy, then the Reporting Engine
MUST receive one Record for each Dependency, in the order expressed
in the Dependencies list or the component index array, respectively.
This specification does define a particular format of Records or
Reports. This specification only defines hints to the Reporting
Engine for which Records it should aggregate into the Report. The
Reporting Engine MAY choose to ignore these hints and apply its own
policy instead.
When used in a Invocation Process, the report MAY form the basis of
an attestation report. When used in an Update Process, the report
MAY form the basis for one or more log entries.
8.7.5. SUIT_Parameters 8.7.5. SUIT_Parameters
Many conditions and directives require additional information. That Many conditions and directives require additional information. That
information is contained within parameters that can be set in a information is contained within parameters that can be set in a
consistent way. This allows reduction of manifest size and consistent way. This allows reduction of manifest size and
replacement of parameters from one manifest to the next. replacement of parameters from one manifest to the next.
Most parameters are scoped to a specific component. This means that Most parameters are scoped to a specific component. This means that
setting a parameter for one component has no effect on the parameters setting a parameter for one component has no effect on the parameters
of any other component. The only exceptions to this are two Manifest of any other component. The only exceptions to this are two Manifest
Processor parameters: Strict Order and Soft Failure. Processor parameters: Strict Order and Soft Failure.
The defined manifest parameters are described below. The defined manifest parameters are described below.
+----------------+----------------------------------+---------------+ +----------------+----------------------------------+---------------+
| Name | CDDL Structure | Reference | | Name | CDDL Structure | Reference |
+----------------+----------------------------------+---------------+ +----------------+----------------------------------+---------------+
| Vendor ID | suit-parameter-vendor-identifier | Section 8.7.5 | | Vendor ID | suit-parameter-vendor-identifier | Section 8.7.5 |
| | | .2 | | | | .3 |
| | | | | | | |
| Class ID | suit-parameter-class-identifier | Section 8.7.5 | | Class ID | suit-parameter-class-identifier | Section 8.7.5 |
| | | .3 | | | | .4 |
| | | | | | | |
| Image Digest | suit-parameter-image-digest | Section 8.7.5 | | Device ID | suit-parameter-device-identifier | Section 8.7.5 |
| | | .5 | | | | .5 |
| | | | | | | |
| Image Size | suit-parameter-image-size | Section 8.7.5 | | Image Digest | suit-parameter-image-digest | Section 8.7.5 |
| | | .6 | | | | .6 |
| | | | | | | |
| Use Before | suit-parameter-use-before | Section 8.7.5 | | Image Size | suit-parameter-image-size | Section 8.7.5 |
| | | .7 | | | | .7 |
| | | | | | | |
| Use Before | suit-parameter-use-before | Section 8.7.5 |
| | | .8 |
| | | |
| Component | suit-parameter-component-offset | Section 8.7.5 | | Component | suit-parameter-component-offset | Section 8.7.5 |
| Offset | | .8 | | Offset | | .9 |
| | | | | | | |
| Encryption | suit-parameter-encryption-info | Section 8.7.5 | | Encryption | suit-parameter-encryption-info | Section 8.7.5 |
| Info | | .9 | | Info | | .10 |
| | | | | | | |
| Compression | suit-parameter-compression-info | Section 8.7.5 | | Compression | suit-parameter-compression-info | Section 8.7.5 |
| Info | | .10 | | Info | | .11 |
| | | | | | | |
| Unpack Info | suit-parameter-unpack-info | Section 8.7.5 | | Unpack Info | suit-parameter-unpack-info | Section 8.7.5 |
| | | .11 | | | | .12 |
| | | | | | | |
| URI | suit-parameter-uri | Section 8.7.5 | | URI | suit-parameter-uri | Section 8.7.5 |
| | | .12 | | | | .13 |
| | | | | | | |
| Source | suit-parameter-source-component | Section 8.7.5 | | Source | suit-parameter-source-component | Section 8.7.5 |
| Component | | .13 | | Component | | .14 |
| | | | | | | |
| Run Args | suit-parameter-run-args | Section 8.7.5 | | Run Args | suit-parameter-run-args | Section 8.7.5 |
| | | .14 | | | | .15 |
| | | |
| Device ID | suit-parameter-device-identifier | Section 8.7.5 |
| | | .4 |
| | | | | | | |
| Minimum | suit-parameter-minimum-battery | Section 8.7.5 | | Minimum | suit-parameter-minimum-battery | Section 8.7.5 |
| Battery | | .15 | | Battery | | .16 |
| | | | | | | |
| Update | suit-parameter-update-priority | Section 8.7.5 | | Update | suit-parameter-update-priority | Section 8.7.5 |
| Priority | | .16 | | Priority | | .17 |
| | | | | | | |
| Version | suit-parameter-version | Section 8.7.5 | | Version | suit-parameter-version | Section 8.7.5 |
| | | .17 | | | | .18 |
| | | | | | | |
| Wait Info | suit-parameter-wait-info | Section 8.7.5 | | Wait Info | suit-parameter-wait-info | Section 8.7.5 |
| | | .18 | | | | .19 |
| | | | | | | |
| URI List | suit-parameter-uri-list | Section 8.7.5 | | URI List | suit-parameter-uri-list | Section 8.7.5 |
| | | .19 | | | | .20 |
| | | | | | | |
| Fetch | suit-parameter-fetch-arguments | Section 8.7.5 | | Fetch | suit-parameter-fetch-arguments | Section 8.7.5 |
| Arguments | | .20 | | Arguments | | .21 |
| | | | | | | |
| Strict Order | suit-parameter-strict-order | Section 8.7.5 | | Strict Order | suit-parameter-strict-order | Section 8.7.5 |
| | | .21 | | | | .22 |
| | | | | | | |
| Soft Failure | suit-parameter-soft-failure | Section 8.7.5 | | Soft Failure | suit-parameter-soft-failure | Section 8.7.5 |
| | | .22 | | | | .23 |
| | | | | | | |
| Custom | suit-parameter-custom | Section 8.7.5 | | Custom | suit-parameter-custom | Section 8.7.5 |
| | | .23 | | | | .24 |
+----------------+----------------------------------+---------------+ +----------------+----------------------------------+---------------+
CBOR-encoded object parameters are still wrapped in a bstr. This is CBOR-encoded object parameters are still wrapped in a bstr. This is
because it allows a parser that is aggregating parameters to because it allows a parser that is aggregating parameters to
reference the object with a single pointer and traverse it without reference the object with a single pointer and traverse it without
understanding the contents. This is important for modularization and understanding the contents. This is important for modularization and
division of responsibility within a pull parser. The same division of responsibility within a pull parser. The same
consideration does not apply to Directives because those elements are consideration does not apply to Directives because those elements are
invoked with their arguments immediately invoked with their arguments immediately
8.7.5.1. Constructing Identifiers 8.7.5.1. CBOR PEN UUID Namespace Identifier
The CBOR PEN UUID Namespace Identifier is constructed as follows:
It uses the OID Namespace as a starting point, then uses the CBOR OID
encoding for the IANA PEN OID (1.3.6.1.4.1):
D8 DE # tag(111)
45 # bytes(5)
2B 06 01 04 01 # X.690 Clause 8.19
# 1.3 6 1 4 1 show component encoding
Computing a type 5 UUID from these produces:
NAMESPACE_CBOR_PEN = UUID5(NAMESPACE_OID, h'D86F452B06010401')
NAMESPACE_CBOR_PEN = 08cfcc43-47d9-5696-85b1-9c738465760e
8.7.5.2. Constructing UUIDs
Several conditions use identifiers to determine whether a manifest Several conditions use identifiers to determine whether a manifest
matches a given Recipient or not. These identifiers are defined to matches a given Recipient or not. These identifiers are defined to
be RFC 4122 [RFC4122] UUIDs. These UUIDs are not human-readable and be RFC 4122 [RFC4122] UUIDs. These UUIDs are not human-readable and
are therefore used for machine-based processing only. are therefore used for machine-based processing only.
A Recipient MAY match any number of UUIDs for vendor or class A Recipient MAY match any number of UUIDs for vendor or class
identifier. This may be relevant to physical or software modules. identifier. This may be relevant to physical or software modules.
For example, a Recipient that has an OS and one or more applications For example, a Recipient that has an OS and one or more applications
might list one Vendor ID for the OS and one or more additional Vendor might list one Vendor ID for the OS and one or more additional Vendor
skipping to change at page 44, line 16 skipping to change at page 49, line 4
components: 1. A host MCU 2. A WiFi module components: 1. A host MCU 2. A WiFi module
This same device has three software modules: 1. An operating system This same device has three software modules: 1. An operating system
2. A WiFi module interface driver 3. An application 2. A WiFi module interface driver 3. An application
Suppose that the WiFi module's firmware has a proprietary update Suppose that the WiFi module's firmware has a proprietary update
mechanism and doesn't support manifest processing. This device can mechanism and doesn't support manifest processing. This device can
report four class IDs: report four class IDs:
1. Hardware model/revision 1. Hardware model/revision
2. OS 2. OS
3. WiFi module model/revision 3. WiFi module model/revision
4. Application 4. Application
This allows the OS, WiFi module, and application to be updated This allows the OS, WiFi module, and application to be updated
independently. To combat possible incompatibilities, the OS class ID independently. To combat possible incompatibilities, the OS class ID
can be changed each time the OS has a change to its API. can be changed each time the OS has a change to its API.
This approach allows a vendor to target, for example, all devices This approach allows a vendor to target, for example, all devices
with a particular WiFi module with an update, which is a very with a particular WiFi module with an update, which is a very
powerful mechanism, particularly when used for security updates. powerful mechanism, particularly when used for security updates.
UUIDs MUST be created according to RFC 4122 [RFC4122]. UUIDs SHOULD UUIDs MUST be created according to RFC 4122 [RFC4122]. UUIDs SHOULD
use versions 3, 4, or 5, as described in RFC4122. Versions 1 and 2 use versions 3, 4, or 5, as described in RFC4122. Versions 1 and 2
do not provide a tangible benefit over version 4 for this do not provide a tangible benefit over version 4 for this
application. application.
The RECOMMENDED method to create a vendor ID is: Vendor ID = The RECOMMENDED method to create a vendor ID is:
UUID5(DNS_PREFIX, vendor domain name)
The RECOMMENDED method to create a class ID is: Class ID = Vendor ID = UUID5(DNS_PREFIX, vendor domain name)
UUID5(Vendor ID, Class-Specific-Information)
Class-specific information is composed of a variety of data, for If the Vendor ID is a UUID, the RECOMMENDED method to create a Class
ID is:
Class ID = UUID5(Vendor ID, Class-Specific-Information)
If the Vendor ID is a CBOR PEN (see Section 8.7.5.3), the RECOMMENDED
method to create a Class ID is:
Class ID = UUID5(
UUID5(NAMESPACE_CBOR_PEN, CBOR_PEN),
Class-Specific-Information)
Class-specific-information is composed of a variety of data, for
example: example:
- Model number. - Model number.
- Hardware revision. - Hardware revision.
- Bootloader version (for immutable bootloaders). - Bootloader version (for immutable bootloaders).
8.7.5.2. suit-parameter-vendor-identifier 8.7.5.3. suit-parameter-vendor-identifier
A RFC 4122 UUID representing the vendor of the device or component. suit-parameter-vendor-identifier may be presented in one of two ways:
The UUID is encoded as a 16 byte bstr, containing the raw bytes of
the UUID. It MUST be constructed as described in Section 8.7.5.1
8.7.5.3. suit-parameter-class-identifier - A Private Enterprise Number
- A byte string containing a UUID ([RFC4122])
Private Enterprise Numbers are encoded as a relative OID, according
to the definition in [I-D.ietf-cbor-tags-oid]. All PENs are relative
to the IANA PEN: 1.3.6.1.4.1.
8.7.5.4. suit-parameter-class-identifier
A RFC 4122 UUID representing the class of the device or component. A RFC 4122 UUID representing the class of the device or component.
The UUID is encoded as a 16 byte bstr, containing the raw bytes of The UUID is encoded as a 16 byte bstr, containing the raw bytes of
the UUID. It MUST be constructed as described in Section 8.7.5.1 the UUID. It MUST be constructed as described in Section 8.7.5.2
8.7.5.4. suit-parameter-device-identifier 8.7.5.5. suit-parameter-device-identifier
A RFC 4122 UUID representing the specific device or component. The A RFC 4122 UUID representing the specific device or component. The
UUID is encoded as a 16 byte bstr, containing the raw bytes of the UUID is encoded as a 16 byte bstr, containing the raw bytes of the
UUID. It MUST be constructed as described in Section 8.7.5.1 UUID. It MUST be constructed as described in Section 8.7.5.2
8.7.5.5. suit-parameter-image-digest 8.7.5.6. suit-parameter-image-digest
A fingerprint computed over the component itself, encoded in the A fingerprint computed over the component itself, encoded in the
Section 10 structure. The SUIT_Digest is wrapped in a bstr, as SUIT_Digest Section 10 structure. The SUIT_Digest is wrapped in a
required in Section 8.7.5. bstr, as required in Section 8.7.5.
8.7.5.6. suit-parameter-image-size 8.7.5.7. suit-parameter-image-size
The size of the firmware image in bytes. This size is encoded as a The size of the firmware image in bytes. This size is encoded as a
positive integer. positive integer.
8.7.5.7. suit-parameter-use-before 8.7.5.8. suit-parameter-use-before
An expiry date for the use of the manifest encoded as a POSIX An expiry date for the use of the manifest encoded as the positive
timestamp; a positive integer. Implementations that use this integer number of seconds since 1970-01-01. Implementations that use
parameter MUST use a 64-bit internal representation of the integer. this parameter MUST use a 64-bit internal representation of the
integer.
8.7.5.8. suit-parameter-component-offset 8.7.5.9. suit-parameter-component-offset
This parameter sets the offset in a component. Some components This parameter sets the offset in a component. Some components
support multiple possible Slots (offsets into a storage area). This support multiple possible Slots (offsets into a storage area). This
parameter describes the intended Slot to use, identified by its parameter describes the intended Slot to use, identified by its
offset into the component's storage area. This offset MUST be offset into the component's storage area. This offset MUST be
encoded as a positive integer. encoded as a positive integer.
8.7.5.9. suit-parameter-encryption-info 8.7.5.10. suit-parameter-encryption-info
Encryption Info defines the mechanism that Fetch or Copy should use Encryption Info defines the mechanism that Fetch or Copy should use
to decrypt the data they transfer. SUIT_Parameter_Encryption_Info is to decrypt the data they transfer. SUIT_Parameter_Encryption_Info is
encoded as a COSE_Encrypt_Tagged or a COSE_Encrypt0_Tagged, wrapped encoded as a COSE_Encrypt_Tagged or a COSE_Encrypt0_Tagged, wrapped
in a bstr. in a bstr.
8.7.5.10. suit-parameter-compression-info 8.7.5.11. suit-parameter-compression-info
Compression Info defines any information that is required for a SUIT_Compression_Info defines any information that is required for a
Recipient to perform decompression operations. Typically, this Recipient to perform decompression operations. SUIT_Compression_Info
includes the algorithm identifier. This document defines the use of is a map containing this data. The only element defined for the map
ZLIB [RFC1950], Brotli [RFC7932], and ZSTD in this specification is the suit-compression-algorithm. This
[I-D.kucherawy-rfc8478bis]. document defines the following suit-compression-algorithm's: ZLIB
[RFC1950], Brotli [RFC7932], and ZSTD [I-D.kucherawy-rfc8478bis].
Additional compression formats can be registered through the IANA- Additional suit-compression-algorithm's can be registered through the
maintained registry. IANA-maintained registry. If such a format requires more data than
an algorithm identifier, one or more new elements MUST be introduced
by specifying an element for SUIT_Compression_Info-extensions.
8.7.5.11. suit-parameter-unpack-info 8.7.5.12. suit-parameter-unpack-info
SUIT_Unpack_Info defines the information required for a Recipient to SUIT_Unpack_Info defines the information required for a Recipient to
interpret a packed format. This document defines the use of the interpret a packed format. This document defines the use of the
following binary encodings: Intel HEX [HEX], Motorola S-record following binary encodings: Intel HEX [HEX], Motorola S-record
[SREC], Executable and Linkable Format (ELF) [ELF], and Common Object [SREC], Executable and Linkable Format (ELF) [ELF], and Common Object
File Format (COFF) [COFF]. File Format (COFF) [COFF].
Additional packing formats can be registered through the IANA- Additional packing formats can be registered through the IANA-
maintained registry. maintained registry.
8.7.5.12. suit-parameter-uri 8.7.5.13. suit-parameter-uri
A URI from which to fetch a resource. A URI from which to fetch a resource, encoded as a text string. CBOR
Tag 32 is not used because the meaning of the text string is
unambiguous in this context.
8.7.5.13. suit-parameter-source-component 8.7.5.14. suit-parameter-source-component
This parameter sets the source component to be used with either This parameter sets the source component to be used with either suit-
Section 8.7.7.10 or with Section 8.7.7.14. The current Component, as directive-copy (Section 8.7.7.9) or with suit-directive-swap
set by suit-directive-set-component-index defines the destination, (Section 8.7.7.13). The current Component, as set by suit-directive-
and suit-parameter-source-component defines the source. set-component-index defines the destination, and suit-parameter-
source-component defines the source.
8.7.5.14. suit-parameter-run-args 8.7.5.15. suit-parameter-run-args
This parameter contains an encoded set of arguments for This parameter contains an encoded set of arguments for suit-
Section 8.7.7.11. The arguments MUST be provided as an directive-run (Section 8.7.7.10). The arguments MUST be provided as
implementation-defined bstr. an implementation-defined bstr.
8.7.5.15. suit-parameter-minimum-battery 8.7.5.16. suit-parameter-minimum-battery
This parameter sets the minimum battery level in mWh. This parameter This parameter sets the minimum battery level in mWh. This parameter
is encoded as a positive integer. Used with Section 8.7.6.6. is encoded as a positive integer. Used with suit-condition-minimum-
battery (Section 8.7.6.6).
8.7.5.16. suit-parameter-update-priority 8.7.5.17. suit-parameter-update-priority
This parameter sets the priority of the update. This parameter is This parameter sets the priority of the update. This parameter is
encoded as an integer. It is used along with suit-condition-update- encoded as an integer. It is used along with suit-condition-update-
authorized [1] to ask an application for permission to initiate an authorized (Section 8.7.6.7) to ask an application for permission to
update. This does not constitute a privilege inversion because an initiate an update. This does not constitute a privilege inversion
explicit request for authorization has been provided by the Update because an explicit request for authorization has been provided by
Authority in the form of the suit-condition-update-authorized the Update Authority in the form of the suit-condition-update-
command. authorized command.
Applications MAY define their own meanings for the update priority. Applications MAY define their own meanings for the update priority.
For example, critical reliability & vulnerability fixes MAY be given For example, critical reliability & vulnerability fixes MAY be given
negative numbers, while bug fixes MAY be given small positive negative numbers, while bug fixes MAY be given small positive
numbers, and feature additions MAY be given larger positive numbers, numbers, and feature additions MAY be given larger positive numbers,
which allows an application to make an informed decision about which allows an application to make an informed decision about
whether and when to allow an update to proceed. whether and when to allow an update to proceed.
8.7.5.17. suit-parameter-version 8.7.5.18. suit-parameter-version
Indicates allowable versions for the specified component. Allowable Indicates allowable versions for the specified component. Allowable
versions can be specified, either with a list or with range matching. versions can be specified, either with a list or with range matching.
This parameter is compared with version asserted by the current This parameter is compared with version asserted by the current
component when Section 8.7.6.8 is invoked. The current component may component when suit-condition-version (Section 8.7.6.8) is invoked.
assert the current version in many ways, including storage in a The current component may assert the current version in many ways,
parameter storage database, in a metadata object, or in a known including storage in a parameter storage database, in a metadata
location within the component itself. object, or in a known location within the component itself.
The component version can be compared as: The component version can be compared as:
- Greater. - Greater.
- Greater or Equal. - Greater or Equal.
- Equal. - Equal.
- Lesser or Equal. - Lesser or Equal.
skipping to change at page 48, line 43 skipping to change at page 54, line 5
Where Alpha (-3), Beta (-2), and Release Candidate (-1) are used, Where Alpha (-3), Beta (-2), and Release Candidate (-1) are used,
they are inserted as a negative number between Minor and Patch they are inserted as a negative number between Minor and Patch
numbers. This allows these releases to compare correctly with final numbers. This allows these releases to compare correctly with final
releases. For example, Version 2.0, RC1 should be lower than Version releases. For example, Version 2.0, RC1 should be lower than Version
2.0.0 and higher than any Version 1.x. By encoding RC as -1, this 2.0.0 and higher than any Version 1.x. By encoding RC as -1, this
works correctly: [2,0,-1,1] compares as lower than [2,0,0]. works correctly: [2,0,-1,1] compares as lower than [2,0,0].
Similarly, beta (-2) is lower than RC and alpha (-3) is lower than Similarly, beta (-2) is lower than RC and alpha (-3) is lower than
RC. RC.
8.7.5.18. suit-parameter-wait-info 8.7.5.19. suit-parameter-wait-info
suit-directive-wait Section 8.7.7.12 directs the manifest processor suit-directive-wait (Section 8.7.7.11) directs the manifest processor
to pause until a specified event occurs. The suit-parameter-wait- to pause until a specified event occurs. The suit-parameter-wait-
info encodes the parameters needed for the directive. info encodes the parameters needed for the directive.
The exact implementation of the pause is implementation-defined. For The exact implementation of the pause is implementation-defined. For
example, this could be done by blocking on a semaphore, registering example, this could be done by blocking on a semaphore, registering
an event handler and suspending the manifest processor, polling for a an event handler and suspending the manifest processor, polling for a
notification, or aborting the update entirely, then restarting when a notification, or aborting the update entirely, then restarting when a
notification is received. notification is received.
suit-parameter-wait-info is encoded as a map of wait events. When suit-parameter-wait-info is encoded as a map of wait events. When
ALL wait events are satisfied, the Manifest Processor continues. The ALL wait events are satisfied, the Manifest Processor continues. The
wait events currently defined are described in the following table. wait events currently defined are described in the following table.
+--------------------------------------+----------+-----------------+ +------------------------------+---------+--------------------------+
| Name | Encoding | Description | | Name | Encodin | Description |
+--------------------------------------+----------+-----------------+ | | g | |
| suit-wait-event-authorization | int | Same as Section | +------------------------------+---------+--------------------------+
| | | 8.7.5.16 | | suit-wait-event- | int | Same as suit-parameter- |
| | | | | authorization | | update-priority |
| suit-wait-event-power | int | Wait until | | | | |
| | | power state | | suit-wait-event-power | int | Wait until power state |
| | | | | | | |
| suit-wait-event-network | int | Wait until | | suit-wait-event-network | int | Wait until network state |
| | | network state | | | | |
| | | | | suit-wait-event-other- | See | Wait for other device to |
| suit-wait-event-other-device-version | See | Wait for other | | device-version | below | match version |
| | below | device to match | | | | |
| | | version | | suit-wait-event-time | uint | Wait until time (seconds |
| | | | | | | since 1970-01-01) |
| suit-wait-event-time | uint | Wait until time | | | | |
| | | (POSIX | | suit-wait-event-time-of-day | uint | Wait until seconds since |
| | | timestamp) | | | | 00:00:00 |
| | | | | | | |
| suit-wait-event-time-of-day | uint | Wait until | | suit-wait-event-time-of-day- | uint | Wait until seconds since |
| | | seconds since | | utc | | 00:00:00 UTC |
| | | 00:00:00 | | | | |
| | | | | suit-wait-event-day-of-week | uint | Wait until days since |
| suit-wait-event-day-of-week | uint | Wait until days | | | | Sunday |
| | | since Sunday | | | | |
+--------------------------------------+----------+-----------------+ | suit-wait-event-day-of-week- | uint | Wait until days since |
| utc | | Sunday UTC |
+------------------------------+---------+--------------------------+
suit-wait-event-other-device-version reuses the encoding of suit- suit-wait-event-other-device-version reuses the encoding of suit-
parameter-version-match. It is encoded as a sequence that contains parameter-version-match. It is encoded as a sequence that contains
an implementation-defined bstr identifier for the other device, and a an implementation-defined bstr identifier for the other device, and a
list of one or more SUIT_Parameter_Version_Match. list of one or more SUIT_Parameter_Version_Match.
8.7.5.19. suit-parameter-uri-list 8.7.5.20. suit-parameter-uri-list
Indicates a list of URIs from which to fetch a resource. The URI Indicates a list of URIs from which to fetch a resource. The URI
list is encoded as a list of tstr, in priority order. The Recipient list is encoded as a list of text string, in priority order. CBOR
should attempt to fetch the resource from each URI in turn, ruling Tag 32 is not used because the meaning of the text string is
out each, in order, if the resource is inaccessible or it is unambiguous in this context. The Recipient should attempt to fetch
otherwise undesirable to fetch from that URI. suit-parameter-uri-list the resource from each URI in turn, ruling out each, in order, if the
is consumed by Section 8.7.7.9. resource is inaccessible or it is otherwise undesirable to fetch from
that URI. suit-parameter-uri-list is consumed by suit-directive-
fetch-uri-list (Section 8.7.7.8).
8.7.5.20. suit-parameter-fetch-arguments 8.7.5.21. suit-parameter-fetch-arguments
An implementation-defined set of arguments to Section 8.7.7.8. An implementation-defined set of arguments to suit-directive-fetch
Arguments are encoded in a bstr. (Section 8.7.7.7). Arguments are encoded in a bstr.
8.7.5.21. suit-parameter-strict-order 8.7.5.22. suit-parameter-strict-order
The Strict Order Parameter allows a manifest to govern when The Strict Order Parameter allows a manifest to govern when
directives can be executed out-of-order. This allows for systems directives can be executed out-of-order. This allows for systems
that have a sensitivity to order of updates to choose the order in that have a sensitivity to order of updates to choose the order in
which they are executed. It also allows for more advanced systems to which they are executed. It also allows for more advanced systems to
parallelize their handling of updates. Strict Order defaults to parallelize their handling of updates. Strict Order defaults to
True. It MAY be set to False when the order of operations does not True. It MAY be set to False when the order of operations does not
matter. When arriving at the end of a command sequence, ALL commands matter. When arriving at the end of a command sequence, ALL commands
MUST have completed, regardless of the state of MUST have completed, regardless of the state of
SUIT_Parameter_Strict_Order. If SUIT_Parameter_Strict_Order is SUIT_Parameter_Strict_Order. SUIT_Process_Dependency must preserve
returned to True, ALL preceding commands MUST complete before the and restore the state of SUIT_Parameter_Strict_Order. If
next command is executed. SUIT_Parameter_Strict_Order is returned to True, ALL preceding
commands MUST complete before the next command is executed.
See Section 6.7 for behavioral description of Strict Order. See Section 6.7 for behavioral description of Strict Order.
8.7.5.22. suit-parameter-soft-failure 8.7.5.23. suit-parameter-soft-failure
When executing a command sequence inside Section 8.7.7.4 or When executing a command sequence inside suit-directive-try-each
Section 8.7.7.13 and a condition failure occurs, the manifest (Section 8.7.7.3) or suit-directive-run-sequence (Section 8.7.7.12)
processor aborts the sequence. For suit-directive-try-each, if Soft and a condition failure occurs, the manifest processor aborts the
Failure is True, the next sequence in Try Each is invoked, otherwise sequence. For suit-directive-try-each, if Soft Failure is True, the
suit-directive-try-each fails with the condition failure code. In next sequence in Try Each is invoked, otherwise suit-directive-try-
suit-directive-run-sequence, if Soft Failure is True the suit- each fails with the condition failure code. In suit-directive-run-
directive-run-sequence simply halts with no side-effects and the sequence, if Soft Failure is True the suit-directive-run-sequence
Manifest Processor continues with the following command, otherwise, simply halts with no side-effects and the Manifest Processor
the suit-directive-run-sequence fails with the condition failure continues with the following command, otherwise, the suit-directive-
code. run-sequence fails with the condition failure code.
suit-parameter-soft-failure is scoped to the enclosing suit-parameter-soft-failure is scoped to the enclosing
SUIT_Command_Sequence. Its value is discarded when SUIT_Command_Sequence. Its value is discarded when
SUIT_Command_Sequence terminates. It MUST NOT be set outside of SUIT_Command_Sequence terminates. It MUST NOT be set outside of
suit-directive-try-each or suit-directive-run-sequence. suit-directive-try-each or suit-directive-run-sequence.
When suit-directive-try-each is invoked, Soft Failure defaults to When suit-directive-try-each is invoked, Soft Failure defaults to
True. An Update Author may choose to set Soft Failure to False if True. An Update Author may choose to set Soft Failure to False if
they require a failed condition in a sequence to force an Abort. they require a failed condition in a sequence to force an Abort.
When suit-directive-run-sequence is invoked, Soft Failure defaults to When suit-directive-run-sequence is invoked, Soft Failure defaults to
False. An Update Author may choose to make failures soft within a False. An Update Author may choose to make failures soft within a
suit-directive-run-sequence. suit-directive-run-sequence.
8.7.5.23. suit-parameter-custom 8.7.5.24. suit-parameter-custom
This parameter is an extension point for any proprietary, application This parameter is an extension point for any proprietary, application
specific conditions and directives. specific conditions and directives. It MUST NOT be used in the
common sequence. This effectively scopes each custom command to a
particular Vendor Identifier/Class Identifier pair.
8.7.6. SUIT_Condition 8.7.6. SUIT_Condition
Conditions are used to define mandatory properties of a system in Conditions are used to define mandatory properties of a system in
order for an update to be applied. They can be pre-conditions or order for an update to be applied. They can be pre-conditions or
post-conditions of any directive or series of directives, depending post-conditions of any directive or series of directives, depending
on where they are placed in the list. All Conditions specify a on where they are placed in the list. All Conditions specify a
Reporting Policy as described Section 8.7.4. Conditions include: Reporting Policy as described Section 8.7.4. Conditions include:
+----------------+----------------------------------+---------------+ +----------------+----------------------------------+---------------+
skipping to change at page 52, line 38 skipping to change at page 57, line 38
| | | | | | | |
| Minimum | suit-condition-minimum-battery | Section 8.7.6 | | Minimum | suit-condition-minimum-battery | Section 8.7.6 |
| Battery | | .6 | | Battery | | .6 |
| | | | | | | |
| Update | suit-condition-update-authorized | Section 8.7.6 | | Update | suit-condition-update-authorized | Section 8.7.6 |
| Authorized | | .7 | | Authorized | | .7 |
| | | | | | | |
| Version | suit-condition-version | Section 8.7.6 | | Version | suit-condition-version | Section 8.7.6 |
| | | .8 | | | | .8 |
| | | | | | | |
| Custom | SUIT_Condition_Custom | Section 8.7.6 | | Abort | suit-condition-abort | Section 8.7.6 |
| Condition | | .9 | | | | .9 |
| | | |
| Custom | suit-condition-custom | Section 8.7.6 |
| Condition | | .10 |
+----------------+----------------------------------+---------------+ +----------------+----------------------------------+---------------+
The abstract description of these conditions is defined in The abstract description of these conditions is defined in
Section 6.4. Section 6.4.
Conditions compare parameters against properties of the system. Conditions compare parameters against properties of the system.
These properties may be asserted in many different ways, including: These properties may be asserted in many different ways, including:
calculation on-demand, volatile definition in memory, static calculation on-demand, volatile definition in memory, static
definition within the manifest processor, storage in known location definition within the manifest processor, storage in known location
within an image, storage within a key storage system, storage in One- within an image, storage within a key storage system, storage in One-
Time-Programmable memory, inclusion in mask ROM, or inclusion as a Time-Programmable memory, inclusion in mask ROM, or inclusion as a
register in hardware. Some of these assertion methods are global in register in hardware. Some of these assertion methods are global in
scope, such as a hardware register, some are scoped to an individual scope, such as a hardware register, some are scoped to an individual
component, such as storage at a known location in an image, and some component, such as storage at a known location in an image, and some
assertion methods can be either global or component-scope, based on assertion methods can be either global or component-scope, based on
implementation. implementation.
Each condition MUST report a result code on completion. If a Each condition MUST report a result code on completion. If a
condition reports failure, then the current sequence of commands MUST condition reports failure, then the current sequence of commands MUST
terminate. A subsequent command or command sequence MAY continue terminate. A subsequent command or command sequence MAY continue
executing if Section 8.7.5.22 is set. If a condition requires executing if suit-parameter-soft-failure (Section 8.7.5.23) is set.
additional information, this MUST be specified in one or more If a condition requires additional information, this MUST be
parameters before the condition is executed. If a Recipient attempts specified in one or more parameters before the condition is executed.
to process a condition that expects additional information and that If a Recipient attempts to process a condition that expects
information has not been set, it MUST report a failure. If a additional information and that information has not been set, it MUST
Recipient encounters an unknown condition, it MUST report a failure. report a failure. If a Recipient encounters an unknown condition, it
MUST report a failure.
Condition labels in the positive number range are reserved for IANA Condition labels in the positive number range are reserved for IANA
registration while those in the negative range are custom conditions registration while those in the negative range are custom conditions
reserved for proprietary use. See Section 11 for more details. reserved for proprietary definition by the author of a manifest
processor. See Section 11 for more details.
8.7.6.1. suit-condition-vendor-identifier, suit-condition-class- 8.7.6.1. suit-condition-vendor-identifier, suit-condition-class-
identifier, and suit-condition-device-identifier identifier, and suit-condition-device-identifier
There are three identifier-based conditions: suit-condition-vendor- There are three identifier-based conditions: suit-condition-vendor-
identifier, suit-condition-class-identifier, and suit-condition- identifier, suit-condition-class-identifier, and suit-condition-
device-identifier. Each of these conditions match a RFC 4122 device-identifier. Each of these conditions match a RFC 4122
[RFC4122] UUID that MUST have already been set as a parameter. The [RFC4122] UUID that MUST have already been set as a parameter. The
installing Recipient MUST match the specified UUID in order to installing Recipient MUST match the specified UUID in order to
consider the manifest valid. These identifiers are scoped by consider the manifest valid. These identifiers are scoped by
component in the manifest. The Recipient MAY treat them as scoped by component in the manifest. Each component MAY match more than one
component or as global identifiers. identifier. Care is needed to ensure that manifests correctly
identify their targets using these conditions. Using only a generic
class ID for a device-specific firmware could result in matching
devices that are not compatible.
The Recipient uses the ID parameter that has already been set using The Recipient uses the ID parameter that has already been set using
the Set Parameters directive. If no ID has been set, this condition the Set Parameters directive. If no ID has been set, this condition
fails. suit-condition-class-identifier and suit-condition-vendor- fails. suit-condition-class-identifier and suit-condition-vendor-
identifier are REQUIRED to implement. suit-condition-device- identifier are REQUIRED to implement. suit-condition-device-
identifier is OPTIONAL to implement. identifier is OPTIONAL to implement.
Each identifier condition compares the corresponding identifier Each identifier condition compares the corresponding identifier
parameter to a parameter asserted to the Manifest Processor by the parameter to a parameter asserted to the Manifest Processor by the
Recipient. Identifiers MUST be known to the Manifest Processor in Recipient. Identifiers MUST be known to the Manifest Processor in
order to evaluate compatibility. order to evaluate compatibility.
Globally-scoped identifiers MUST match, regardless of current
component index. Component-scoped identifiers match only when the
current component index resolves to the component associated with the
component-scoped identifier.
8.7.6.2. suit-condition-image-match 8.7.6.2. suit-condition-image-match
Verify that the current component matches the Section 8.7.5.5 for the Verify that the current component matches the suit-parameter-image-
current component. The digest is verified against the digest digest (Section 8.7.5.6) for the current component. The digest is
specified in the Component's parameters list. If no digest is verified against the digest specified in the Component's parameters
specified, the condition fails. suit-condition-image-match is list. If no digest is specified, the condition fails. suit-
REQUIRED to implement. condition-image-match is REQUIRED to implement.
8.7.6.3. suit-condition-image-not-match 8.7.6.3. suit-condition-image-not-match
Verify that the current component does not match the Section 8.7.5.5. Verify that the current component does not match the suit-parameter-
If no digest is specified, the condition fails. suit-condition-image- image-digest (Section 8.7.5.6). If no digest is specified, the
not-match is OPTIONAL to implement. condition fails. suit-condition-image-not-match is OPTIONAL to
implement.
8.7.6.4. suit-condition-use-before 8.7.6.4. suit-condition-use-before
Verify that the current time is BEFORE the specified time. suit- Verify that the current time is BEFORE the specified time. suit-
condition-use-before is used to specify the last time at which an condition-use-before is used to specify the last time at which an
update should be installed. The recipient evaluates the current time update should be installed. The recipient evaluates the current time
against the suit-parameter-use-before parameter (Section 8.7.5.7), against the suit-parameter-use-before parameter (Section 8.7.5.8),
which must have already been set as a parameter, encoded as a POSIX which must have already been set as a parameter, encoded as seconds
timestamp, that is seconds after 1970-01-01 00:00:00. Timestamp after 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC. Timestamp conditions MUST be
conditions MUST be evaluated in 64 bits, regardless of encoded CBOR evaluated in 64 bits, regardless of encoded CBOR size. suit-
size. suit-condition-use-before is OPTIONAL to implement. condition-use-before is OPTIONAL to implement.
8.7.6.5. suit-condition-component-offset 8.7.6.5. suit-condition-component-offset
Verify that the offset of the current component matches the offset Verify that the offset of the current component matches the offset
set in Section 8.7.5.8. This condition allows a manifest to select set in suit-parameter-component-offset (Section 8.7.5.9). This
between several images to match a target offset. condition allows a manifest to select between several images to match
a target offset.
8.7.6.6. suit-condition-minimum-battery 8.7.6.6. suit-condition-minimum-battery
suit-condition-minimum-battery provides a mechanism to test a suit-condition-minimum-battery provides a mechanism to test a
Recipient's battery level before installing an update. This Recipient's battery level before installing an update. This
condition is primarily for use in primary-cell applications, where condition is primarily for use in primary-cell applications, where
the battery is only ever discharged. For batteries that are charged, the battery is only ever discharged. For batteries that are charged,
suit-directive-wait is more appropriate, since it defines a "wait" suit-directive-wait is more appropriate, since it defines a "wait"
until the battery level is sufficient to install the update. suit- until the battery level is sufficient to install the update. suit-
condition-minimum-battery is specified in mWh. suit-condition- condition-minimum-battery is specified in mWh. suit-condition-
minimum-battery is OPTIONAL to implement. suit-condition-minimum- minimum-battery is OPTIONAL to implement. suit-condition-minimum-
battery consumes Section 8.7.5.15. battery consumes suit-parameter-minimum-battery (Section 8.7.5.16).
8.7.6.7. suit-condition-update-authorized 8.7.6.7. suit-condition-update-authorized
Request Authorization from the application and fail if not Request Authorization from the application and fail if not
authorized. This can allow a user to decline an update. authorized. This can allow a user to decline an update. suit-
Section 8.7.5.16 provides an integer priority level that the parameter-update-priority (Section 8.7.5.17) provides an integer
application can use to determine whether or not to authorize the priority level that the application can use to determine whether or
update. Priorities are application defined. suit-condition-update- not to authorize the update. Priorities are application defined.
authorized is OPTIONAL to implement. suit-condition-update-authorized is OPTIONAL to implement.
8.7.6.8. suit-condition-version 8.7.6.8. suit-condition-version
suit-condition-version allows comparing versions of firmware. suit-condition-version allows comparing versions of firmware.
Verifying image digests is preferred to version checks because Verifying image digests is preferred to version checks because
digests are more precise. suit-condition-version examines a digests are more precise. suit-condition-version examines a
component's version against the version info specified in component's version against the version info specified in suit-
Section 8.7.5.17 parameter-version (Section 8.7.5.18)
8.7.6.9. SUIT_Condition_Custom 8.7.6.9. suit-condition-abort
SUIT_Condition_Custom describes any proprietary, application specific Unconditionally fail. This operation is typically used in
conjunction with suit-directive-try-each (Section 8.7.7.3).
8.7.6.10. suit-condition-custom
suit-condition-custom describes any proprietary, application specific
condition. This is encoded as a negative integer, chosen by the condition. This is encoded as a negative integer, chosen by the
firmware developer. If additional information must be provided to firmware developer. If additional information must be provided to
the condition, it should be encoded in a custom parameter (a nint) as the condition, it should be encoded in a custom parameter (a nint) as
described in Section 8.7.5. SUIT_Condition_Custom is OPTIONAL to described in Section 8.7.5. SUIT_Condition_Custom is OPTIONAL to
implement. implement.
8.7.7. SUIT_Directive 8.7.7. SUIT_Directive
Directives are used to define the behavior of the recipient. Directives are used to define the behavior of the recipient.
Directives include: Directives include:
skipping to change at page 56, line 15 skipping to change at page 61, line 15
+---------------+-------------------------------------+-------------+ +---------------+-------------------------------------+-------------+
| Name | CDDL Structure | Reference | | Name | CDDL Structure | Reference |
+---------------+-------------------------------------+-------------+ +---------------+-------------------------------------+-------------+
| Set Component | suit-directive-set-component-index | Section 8.7 | | Set Component | suit-directive-set-component-index | Section 8.7 |
| Index | | .7.1 | | Index | | .7.1 |
| | | | | | | |
| Set | suit-directive-set-dependency-index | Section 8.7 | | Set | suit-directive-set-dependency-index | Section 8.7 |
| Dependency | | .7.2 | | Dependency | | .7.2 |
| Index | | | | Index | | |
| | | | | | | |
| Abort | suit-directive-abort | Section 8.7 |
| | | .7.3 |
| | | |
| Try Each | suit-directive-try-each | Section 8.7 | | Try Each | suit-directive-try-each | Section 8.7 |
| | | .7.4 | | | | .7.3 |
| | | | | | | |
| Process | suit-directive-process-dependency | Section 8.7 | | Process | suit-directive-process-dependency | Section 8.7 |
| Dependency | | .7.5 | | Dependency | | .7.4 |
| | | | | | | |
| Set | suit-directive-set-parameters | Section 8.7 | | Set | suit-directive-set-parameters | Section 8.7 |
| Parameters | | .7.6 | | Parameters | | .7.5 |
| | | | | | | |
| Override | suit-directive-override-parameters | Section 8.7 | | Override | suit-directive-override-parameters | Section 8.7 |
| Parameters | | .7.7 | | Parameters | | .7.6 |
| | | | | | | |
| Fetch | suit-directive-fetch | Section 8.7 | | Fetch | suit-directive-fetch | Section 8.7 |
| | | .7.8 | | | | .7.7 |
| | | |
| Fetch URI | suit-directive-fetch-uri-list | Section 8.7 |
| list | | .7.8 |
| | | | | | | |
| Copy | suit-directive-copy | Section 8.7 | | Copy | suit-directive-copy | Section 8.7 |
| | | .7.10 | | | | .7.9 |
| | | | | | | |
| Run | suit-directive-run | Section 8.7 | | Run | suit-directive-run | Section 8.7 |
| | | .7.11 | | | | .7.10 |
| | | | | | | |
| Wait For | suit-directive-wait | Section 8.7 | | Wait For | suit-directive-wait | Section 8.7 |
| Event | | .7.12 | | Event | | .7.11 |
| | | | | | | |
| Run Sequence | suit-directive-run-sequence | Section 8.7 | | Run Sequence | suit-directive-run-sequence | Section 8.7 |
| | | .7.13 | | | | .7.12 |
| | | | | | | |
| Swap | suit-directive-swap | Section 8.7 | | Swap | suit-directive-swap | Section 8.7 |
| | | .7.14 | | | | .7.13 |
| | | |
| Fetch URI | suit-directive-fetch-uri-list | Section 8.7 |
| list | | .7.9 |
+---------------+-------------------------------------+-------------+ +---------------+-------------------------------------+-------------+
The abstract description of these commands is defined in Section 6.4. The abstract description of these commands is defined in Section 6.4.
When a Recipient executes a Directive, it MUST report a result code. When a Recipient executes a Directive, it MUST report a result code.
If the Directive reports failure, then the current Command Sequence If the Directive reports failure, then the current Command Sequence
MUST terminate. MUST be terminated.
8.7.7.1. suit-directive-set-component-index 8.7.7.1. suit-directive-set-component-index
Set Component Index defines the component to which successive Set Component Index defines the component to which successive
directives and conditions will apply. The supplied argument MUST be directives and conditions will apply. The supplied argument MUST be
either a boolean or an unsigned integer index into suit-components. one of three types:
If the following commands apply to ALL components, then the boolean
value "True" is used instead of an index. If the following commands 1. An unsigned integer (REQUIRED to implement in parser)
apply to NO components, then the boolean value "False" is used. When
suit-directive-set-dependency-index is used, suit-directive-set- 2. A boolean (REQUIRED to implement in parser ONLY IF 2 or more
component-index = False is implied. When suit-directive-set- components supported)
component-index is used, suit-directive-set-dependency-index = False
is implied. 3. An array of unsigned integers (REQUIRED to implement in parser
ONLY IF 3 or more components supported)
If the following commands apply to ONE component, an unsigned integer
index into the component list is used. If the following commands
apply to ALL components, then the boolean value "True" is used
instead of an index. If the following commands apply to more than
one, but not all components, then an array of unsigned integer
indices into the component list is used. TODO: Component list
If the following commands apply to NO components, then the boolean
value "False" is used. When suit-directive-set-dependency-index is
used, suit-directive-set-component-index = False is implied. When
suit-directive-set-component-index is used, suit-directive-set-
dependency-index = False is implied.
If component index is set to True when a command is invoked, then the If component index is set to True when a command is invoked, then the
command applies to all components, in the order they appear in suit- command applies to all components, in the order they appear in suit-
common-components. When the Manifest Processor invokes a command common-components. When the Manifest Processor invokes a command
while the component index is set to True, it must execute the command while the component index is set to True, it must execute the command
once for each possible component index, ensuring that the command once for each possible component index, ensuring that the command
receives the parameters corresponding to that component index. receives the parameters corresponding to that component index.
8.7.7.2. suit-directive-set-dependency-index 8.7.7.2. suit-directive-set-dependency-index
Set Dependency Index defines the manifest to which successive Set Dependency Index defines the manifest to which successive
directives and conditions will apply. The supplied argument MUST be directives and conditions will apply. The supplied argument MUST be
either a boolean or an unsigned integer index into the dependencies. either a boolean or an unsigned integer index into the dependencies.
If the following directives apply to ALL dependencies, then the If the following directives apply to ALL dependencies, then the
boolean value "True" is used instead of an index. If the following boolean value "True" is used instead of an index. If the following
directives apply to NO dependencies, then the boolean value "False" directives apply to NO dependencies, then the boolean value "False"
is used. When suit-directive-set-component-index is used, suit- is used. When suit-directive-set-component-index is used, suit-
directive-set-dependency-index = False is implied. When suit- directive-set-dependency-index = False is implied. When suit-
directive-set-dependency-index is used, suit-directive-set-component- directive-set-dependency-index is used, suit-directive-set-component-
index = False is implied. index = False is implied. TODO: Component list|Dependency List
If dependency index is set to True when a command is invoked, then If dependency index is set to True when a command is invoked, then
the command applies to all dependencies, in the order they appear in the command applies to all dependencies, in the order they appear in
suit-common-components. When the Manifest Processor invokes a suit-common-components. When the Manifest Processor invokes a
command while the dependency index is set to True, it must execute command while the dependency index is set to True, it must execute
the command once for each possible dependency index, ensuring that the command once for each possible dependency index, ensuring that
the command receives the parameters corresponding to that dependency the command receives the parameters corresponding to that dependency
index. index.
Typical operations that require suit-directive-set-dependency-index Typical operations that require suit-directive-set-dependency-index
include setting a source URI or Encryption Information, invoking include setting a source URI or Encryption Information, invoking
"Fetch," or invoking "Process Dependency" for an individual "Fetch," or invoking "Process Dependency" for an individual
dependency. dependency.
8.7.7.3. suit-directive-abort 8.7.7.3. suit-directive-try-each
Unconditionally fail. This operation is typically used in
conjunction with suit-directive-try-each.
8.7.7.4. suit-directive-try-each
This command runs several SUIT_Command_Sequence, one after another, This command runs several SUIT_Command_Sequence instances, one after
in a strict order. Use this command to implement a "try/catch-try/ another, in a strict order. Use this command to implement a "try/
catch" sequence. Manifest processors MAY implement this command. catch-try/catch" sequence. Manifest processors MAY implement this
command.
Section 8.7.5.22 is initialized to True at the beginning of each suit-parameter-soft-failure (Section 8.7.5.23) is initialized to True
sequence. If one sequence aborts due to a condition failure, the at the beginning of each sequence. If one sequence aborts due to a
next is started. If no sequence completes without condition failure, condition failure, the next is started. If no sequence completes
then suit-directive-try-each returns an error. If a particular without condition failure, then suit-directive-try-each returns an
application calls for all sequences to fail and still continue, then error. If a particular application calls for all sequences to fail
an empty sequence (nil) can be added to the Try Each Argument. and still continue, then an empty sequence (nil) can be added to the
Try Each Argument.
The argument to suit-directive-try-each is a list of The argument to suit-directive-try-each is a list of
SUIT_Command_Sequence. suit-directive-try-each does not specify a SUIT_Command_Sequence. suit-directive-try-each does not specify a
reporting policy. reporting policy.
8.7.7.5. suit-directive-process-dependency 8.7.7.4. suit-directive-process-dependency
Execute the commands in the common section of the current dependency, Execute the commands in the common section of the current dependency,
followed by the commands in the equivalent section of the current followed by the commands in the equivalent section of the current
dependency. For example, if the current section is "fetch payload," dependency. For example, if the current section is "fetch payload,"
this will execute "common" in the current dependency, then "fetch this will execute "common" in the current dependency, then "fetch
payload" in the current dependency. Once this is complete, the payload" in the current dependency. Once this is complete, the
command following suit-directive-process-dependency will be command following suit-directive-process-dependency will be
processed. processed.
If the current dependency is False, this directive has no effect. If If the current dependency is False, this directive has no effect. If
the current dependency is True, then this directive applies to all the current dependency is True, then this directive applies to all
dependencies. If the current section is "common," this directive dependencies. If the current section is "common," then the command
MUST have no effect. sequence MUST be terminated with an error.
When SUIT_Process_Dependency completes, it forwards the last status When SUIT_Process_Dependency completes, it forwards the last status
code that occurred in the dependency. code that occurred in the dependency.
8.7.7.6. suit-directive-set-parameters 8.7.7.5. suit-directive-set-parameters
suit-directive-set-parameters allows the manifest to configure suit-directive-set-parameters allows the manifest to configure
behavior of future directives by changing parameters that are read by behavior of future directives by changing parameters that are read by
those directives. When dependencies are used, suit-directive-set- those directives. When dependencies are used, suit-directive-set-
parameters also allows a manifest to modify the behavior of its parameters also allows a manifest to modify the behavior of its
dependencies. dependencies.
Available parameters are defined in Section 8.7.5. Available parameters are defined in Section 8.7.5.
If a parameter is already set, suit-directive-set-parameters will If a parameter is already set, suit-directive-set-parameters will
skip setting the parameter to its argument. This provides the core skip setting the parameter to its argument. This provides the core
of the override mechanism, allowing dependent manifests to change the of the override mechanism, allowing dependent manifests to change the
behavior of a manifest. behavior of a manifest.
suit-directive-set-parameters does not specify a reporting policy. suit-directive-set-parameters does not specify a reporting policy.
8.7.7.7. suit-directive-override-parameters 8.7.7.6. suit-directive-override-parameters
suit-directive-override-parameters replaces any listed parameters suit-directive-override-parameters replaces any listed parameters
that are already set with the values that are provided in its that are already set with the values that are provided in its
argument. This allows a manifest to prevent replacement of critical argument. This allows a manifest to prevent replacement of critical
parameters. parameters.
Available parameters are defined in Section 8.7.5. Available parameters are defined in Section 8.7.5.
suit-directive-override-parameters does not specify a reporting suit-directive-override-parameters does not specify a reporting
policy. policy.
8.7.7.8. suit-directive-fetch 8.7.7.7. suit-directive-fetch
suit-directive-fetch instructs the manifest processor to obtain one suit-directive-fetch instructs the manifest processor to obtain one
or more manifests or payloads, as specified by the manifest index and or more manifests or payloads, as specified by the manifest index and
component index, respectively. component index, respectively.
suit-directive-fetch can target one or more manifests and one or more suit-directive-fetch can target one or more manifests and one or more
payloads. suit-directive-fetch retrieves each component and each payloads. suit-directive-fetch retrieves each component and each
manifest listed in component-index and dependency-index, manifest listed in component-index and dependency-index,
respectively. If component-index or dependency-index is True, respectively. If component-index or dependency-index is True,
instead of an integer, then all current manifest components/manifests instead of an integer, then all current manifest components/manifests
skipping to change at page 60, line 9 skipping to change at page 65, line 21
suit-directive-fetch reads the URI parameter to find the source of suit-directive-fetch reads the URI parameter to find the source of
the fetch it performs. the fetch it performs.
The behavior of suit-directive-fetch can be modified by setting one The behavior of suit-directive-fetch can be modified by setting one
or more of SUIT_Parameter_Encryption_Info, or more of SUIT_Parameter_Encryption_Info,
SUIT_Parameter_Compression_Info, SUIT_Parameter_Unpack_Info. These SUIT_Parameter_Compression_Info, SUIT_Parameter_Unpack_Info. These
three parameters each activate and configure a processing step that three parameters each activate and configure a processing step that
can be applied to the data that is transferred during suit-directive- can be applied to the data that is transferred during suit-directive-
fetch. fetch.
8.7.7.9. suit-directive-fetch-uri-list 8.7.7.8. suit-directive-fetch-uri-list
suit-directive-fetch-uri-list uses the same semantics as suit-directive-fetch-uri-list uses the same semantics as suit-
Section 8.7.7.8, however it iterates over the URI List directive-fetch (Section 8.7.7.7), except that it iterates over the
(Section 8.7.5.19) to select a URI to fetch from. URI List (Section 8.7.5.20) to select a URI to fetch from.
8.7.7.10. suit-directive-copy 8.7.7.9. suit-directive-copy
suit-directive-copy instructs the manifest processor to obtain one or suit-directive-copy instructs the manifest processor to obtain one or
more payloads, as specified by the component index. suit-directive- more payloads, as specified by the component index. As described in
copy retrieves each component listed in component-index, Section 6.5 component index may be a single integer, a list of
respectively. If component-index is True, instead of an integer, integers, or True. suit-directive-copy retrieves each component
then all current manifest components are copied. The current specified by the current component-index, respectively. The current
manifest's dependent-components are not automatically copied. In manifest's dependent-components are not automatically copied. In
order to copy these, they MUST be specified in a component-index order to copy these, they MUST be specified in a component-index
integer. integer.
The behavior of suit-directive-copy can be modified by setting one or The behavior of suit-directive-copy can be modified by setting one or
more of SUIT_Parameter_Encryption_Info, more of SUIT_Parameter_Encryption_Info,
SUIT_Parameter_Compression_Info, SUIT_Parameter_Unpack_Info. These SUIT_Parameter_Compression_Info, SUIT_Parameter_Unpack_Info. These
three parameters each activate and configure a processing step that three parameters each activate and configure a processing step that
can be applied to the data that is transferred during suit-directive- can be applied to the data that is transferred during suit-directive-
copy. copy.
suit-directive-copy reads its source from Section 8.7.5.13. suit-directive-copy reads its source from suit-parameter-source-
component (Section 8.7.5.14).
8.7.7.11. suit-directive-run If either the source component parameter or the source component
itself is absent, this command fails.
8.7.7.10. suit-directive-run
suit-directive-run directs the manifest processor to transfer suit-directive-run directs the manifest processor to transfer
execution to the current Component Index. When this is invoked, the execution to the current Component Index. When this is invoked, the
manifest processor MAY be unloaded and execution continues in the manifest processor MAY be unloaded and execution continues in the
Component Index. Arguments are provided to suit-directive-run Component Index. Arguments are provided to suit-directive-run
through suit-parameter-run-arguments (Section 8.7.5.14) and are through suit-parameter-run-arguments (Section 8.7.5.15) and are
forwarded to the executable code located in Component Index in an forwarded to the executable code located in Component Index in an
application-specific way. For example, this could form the Linux application-specific way. For example, this could form the Linux
Kernel Command Line if booting a Linux device. Kernel Command Line if booting a Linux device.
If the executable code at Component Index is constructed in such a If the executable code at Component Index is constructed in such a
way that it does not unload the manifest processor, then the manifest way that it does not unload the manifest processor, then the manifest
processor may resume execution after the executable completes. This processor may resume execution after the executable completes. This
allows the manifest processor to invoke suitable helpers and to allows the manifest processor to invoke suitable helpers and to
verify them with image conditions. verify them with image conditions.
8.7.7.12. suit-directive-wait 8.7.7.11. suit-directive-wait
suit-directive-wait directs the manifest processor to pause until a suit-directive-wait directs the manifest processor to pause until a
specified event occurs. Some possible events include: specified event occurs. Some possible events include:
1. Authorization 1. Authorization
2. External Power 2. External Power
3. Network availability 3. Network availability
4. Other Device Firmware Version 4. Other Device Firmware Version
5. Time 5. Time
6. Time of Day 6. Time of Day
7. Day of Week 7. Day of Week
8.7.7.13. suit-directive-run-sequence 8.7.7.12. suit-directive-run-sequence
To enable conditional commands, and to allow several strictly ordered To enable conditional commands, and to allow several strictly ordered
sequences to be executed out-of-order, suit-directive-run-sequence sequences to be executed out-of-order, suit-directive-run-sequence
allows the manifest processor to execute its argument as a allows the manifest processor to execute its argument as a
SUIT_Command_Sequence. The argument must be wrapped in a bstr. SUIT_Command_Sequence. The argument must be wrapped in a bstr.
When a sequence is executed, any failure of a condition causes When a sequence is executed, any failure of a condition causes
immediate termination of the sequence. immediate termination of the sequence.
When suit-directive-run-sequence completes, it forwards the last When suit-directive-run-sequence completes, it forwards the last
status code that occurred in the sequence. If the Soft Failure status code that occurred in the sequence. If the Soft Failure
parameter is true, then suit-directive-run-sequence only fails when a parameter is true, then suit-directive-run-sequence only fails when a
directive in the argument sequence fails. directive in the argument sequence fails.
Section 8.7.5.22 defaults to False when suit-directive-run-sequence suit-parameter-soft-failure (Section 8.7.5.23) defaults to False when
begins. Its value is discarded when suit-directive-run-sequence suit-directive-run-sequence begins. Its value is discarded when
terminates. suit-directive-run-sequence terminates.
8.7.7.14. suit-directive-swap 8.7.7.13. suit-directive-swap
suit-directive-swap instructs the manifest processor to move the suit-directive-swap instructs the manifest processor to move the
source to the destination and the destination to the source source to the destination and the destination to the source
simultaneously. Swap has nearly identical semantics to suit- simultaneously. Swap has nearly identical semantics to suit-
directive-copy except that suit-directive-swap replaces the source directive-copy except that suit-directive-swap replaces the source
with the current contents of the destination in an application- with the current contents of the destination in an application-
defined way. If SUIT_Parameter_Compression_Info or defined way. As with suit-directive-copy, if the source component is
SUIT_Parameter_Encryption_Info are present, they MUST be handled in a missing, this command fails.
symmetric way, so that the source is decompressed into the
destination and the destination is compressed into the source. The If SUIT_Parameter_Compression_Info or SUIT_Parameter_Encryption_Info
source is decrypted into the destination and the destination is are present, they MUST be handled in a symmetric way, so that the
encrypted into the source. suit-directive-swap is OPTIONAL to source is decompressed into the destination and the destination is
implement. compressed into the source. The source is decrypted into the
destination and the destination is encrypted into the source. suit-
directive-swap is OPTIONAL to implement.
8.7.8. Integrity Check Values 8.7.8. Integrity Check Values
When the CoSWID, Text section, or any Command Sequence of the Update When the CoSWID, Text section, or any Command Sequence of the Update
Procedure is made severable, it is moved to the Envelope and replaced Procedure is made severable, it is moved to the Envelope and replaced
with a SUIT_Digest. The SUIT_Digest is computed over the entire bstr with a SUIT_Digest. The SUIT_Digest is computed over the entire bstr
enclosing the Manifest element that has been moved to the Envelope. enclosing the Manifest element that has been moved to the Envelope.
Each element that is made severable from the Manifest is placed in Each element that is made severable from the Manifest is placed in
the Envelope with an identical key, so that it matches the key of the the Envelope. The keys for the envelope elements have the same
corresponding Integrity Check Value. values as the keys for the manifest elements.
Each Integrity Check Value covers the corresponding Envelope Element Each Integrity Check Value covers the corresponding Envelope Element
as described in Section 8.8. as described in Section 8.8.
8.8. Severable Elements 8.8. Severable Elements
Because the manifest can be used by different actors at different Because the manifest can be used by different actors at different
times, some parts of the manifest can be removed or "Severed" without times, some parts of the manifest can be removed or "Severed" without
affecting later stages of the lifecycle. Severing of information is affecting later stages of the lifecycle. Severing of information is
achieved by separating that information from the signed container so achieved by separating that information from the signed container so
skipping to change at page 63, line 20 skipping to change at page 68, line 36
First, the simplest model requires that all manifests are First, the simplest model requires that all manifests are
authenticated by a single trusted key. This mode has the advantage authenticated by a single trusted key. This mode has the advantage
that only a root manifest needs to be authenticated, since all of its that only a root manifest needs to be authenticated, since all of its
dependencies have digests included in the root manifest. dependencies have digests included in the root manifest.
This simplest model can be extended by adding key delegation without This simplest model can be extended by adding key delegation without
much increase in complexity. much increase in complexity.
A second model requires an ACL to be presented to the Recipient, A second model requires an ACL to be presented to the Recipient,
authenticated by a trusted party or stored on the Recipient. This authenticated by a trusted party or stored on the Recipient. This
ACL grants access rights for specific component IDs or component ID ACL grants access rights for specific component IDs or Component
prefixes to the listed identities or identity groups. Any identity Identifier prefixes to the listed identities or identity groups. Any
may verify an image digest, but fetching into or fetching from a identity can verify an image digest, but fetching into or fetching
component ID requires approval from the ACL. from a Component Identifier requires approval from the ACL.
A third model allows a Recipient to provide even more fine-grained A third model allows a Recipient to provide even more fine-grained
controls: The ACL lists the component ID or component ID prefix that controls: The ACL lists the Component Identifier or Component
an identity may use, and also lists the commands that the identity Identifier prefix that an identity can use, and also lists the
may use in combination with that component ID. commands and parameters that the identity can use in combination with
that Component Identifier.
10. SUIT Digest Container 10. SUIT Digest Container
RFC 8152 [RFC8152] provides containers for signature, MAC, and RFC 8152 [RFC8152] provides containers for signature, MAC, and
encryption, but no basic digest container. The container needed for encryption, but no basic digest container. The container needed for
a digest requires a type identifier and a container for the raw a digest requires a type identifier and a container for the raw
digest data. Some forms of digest may require additional parameters. digest data. Some forms of digest may require additional parameters.
These can be added following the digest. These can be added following the digest.
The SUIT digest is a CBOR List containing two elements: a suit- The SUIT digest is a CBOR List containing two elements: a suit-
digest-algorithm-id and a bstr containing the bytes of the digest. digest-algorithm-id and a bstr containing the bytes of the digest.
11. IANA Considerations 11. IANA Considerations
IANA is requested to: IANA is requested to:
- allocate a CBOR tag for the SUIT Envelope and another for the SUIT - allocate CBOR tag 48 in the CBOR Tags registry for the SUIT
Envelope.
- allocate CBOR tag 480 in the CBOR Tags registry for the SUIT
Manifest. Manifest.
- allocate a media type for suit: application/suit-envelope - allocate media type application/suit-envelope in the Media Types
registry.
- setup several registries as described below.
- setup several registries as described below
IANA is requested to setup a registry for SUIT manifests. Several IANA is requested to setup a registry for SUIT manifests. Several
registries defined in the subsections below need to be created. registries defined in the subsections below need to be created.
For each registry, values 0-23 are Standards Action, 24-255 are IETF For each registry, values 0-23 are Standards Action, 24-255 are IETF
Review, 256-65535 are Expert Review, and 65536 or greater are First Review, 256-65535 are Expert Review, and 65536 or greater are First
Come First Served. Come First Served.
Negative values -23 to 0 are Experimental Use, -24 and lower are Negative values -23 to 0 are Experimental Use, -24 and lower are
Private Use. Private Use.
11.1. SUIT Commands 11.1. SUIT Commands
+-------+----------------------+ +-------+------------+-----------------------------------+----------+
| Label | Name | | Label | Name | Reference | |
+-------+----------------------+ +-------+------------+-----------------------------------+----------+
| 1 | Vendor Identifier | | 1 | Vendor | Section 8.7.6.1 | |
| | | | | Identifier | | |
| 2 | Class Identifier | | | | | |
| | | | 2 | Class | Section 8.7.6.1 | |
| 3 | Image Match | | | Identifier | | |
| | | | | | | |
| 4 | Use Before | | 3 | Image | Section 8.7.6.2 | |
| | | | | Match | | |
| 5 | Component Offset | | | | | |
| | | | 4 | Use Before | Section 8.7.6.4 | |
| 12 | Set Component Index | | | | | |
| | | | 5 | Component | Section 8.7.6.5 | |
| 13 | Set Dependency Index | | | Offset | | |
| | | | | | | |
| 14 | Abort | | 12 | Set | Section 8.7.7.1 | |
| | | | | Component | | |
| 15 | Try Each | | | Index | | |
| | | | | | | |
| 16 | Reserved | | 13 | Set | Section 8.7.7.2 | |
| | | | | Dependency | | |
| 17 | Reserved | | | Index | | |
| | | | | | | |
| 18 | Process Dependency | | 14 | Abort | | |
| | | | | | | |
| 19 | Set Parameters | | 15 | Try Each | Section 8.7.7.3 | |
| | | | | | | |
| 20 | Override Parameters | | 16 | Reserved | | |
| | | | | | | |
| 21 | Fetch | | 17 | Reserved | | |
| | | | | | | |
| 22 | Copy | | 18 | Process | suit-directive-process-dependency | Section |
| | | | | Dependency | | 8.7.7.4 |
| 23 | Run | | | | | |
| | | | 19 | Set | Section 8.7.7.5 | |
| 24 | Device Identifier | | | Parameters | | |
| | | | | | | |
| 25 | Image Not Match | | 20 | Override | Section 8.7.7.6 | |
| | | | | Parameters | | |
| 26 | Minimum Battery | | | | | |
| | | | 21 | Fetch | Section 8.7.7.7 | |
| 27 | Update Authorized | | | | | |
| | | | 22 | Copy | Section 8.7.7.9 | |
| 28 | Version | | | | | |
| | | | 23 | Run | Section 8.7.7.10 | |
| 29 | Wait For Event | | | | | |
| | | | 24 | Device | Section 8.7.6.1 | |
| 30 | Fetch URI List | | | Identifier | | |
| | | | | | | |
| 31 | Swap | | 25 | Image Not | Section 8.7.6.3 | |
| | | | | Match | | |
| 32 | Run Sequence | | | | | |
| | | | 26 | Minimum | Section 8.7.6.6 | |
| nint | Custom Condition | | | Battery | | |
+-------+----------------------+ | | | | |
| 27 | Update | Section 8.7.6.7 | |
| | Authorized | | |
| | | | |
| 28 | Version | Section 8.7.6.8 | |
| | | | |
| 29 | Wait For | Section 8.7.7.11 | |
| | Event | | |
| | | | |
| 30 | Fetch URI | Section 8.7.7.8 | |
| | List | | |
| | | | |
| 31 | Swap | Section 8.7.7.13 | |
| | | | |
| 32 | Run | Section 8.7.7.12 | |
| | Sequence | | |
| | | | |
| nint | Custom | Section 8.7.6.10 | |
| | Condition | | |
+-------+------------+-----------------------------------+----------+
11.2. SUIT Parameters 11.2. SUIT Parameters
+-------+------------------+ +-------+------------------+---------------------------+
| Label | Name | | Label | Name | Reference |
+-------+------------------+ +-------+------------------+---------------------------+
| 1 | Vendor ID | | 1 | Vendor ID | Section 8.7.5.3 |
| | | | | | |
| 2 | Class ID | | 2 | Class ID | Section 8.7.5.4 |
| | | | | | |
| 3 | Image Digest | | 3 | Image Digest | Section 8.7.5.6 |
| | | | | | |
| 4 | Use Before | | 4 | Use Before | Section 8.7.5.8 |
| | | | | | |
| 5 | Component Offset | | 5 | Component Offset | Section 8.7.5.9 |
| | | | | | |
| 12 | Strict Order | | 12 | Strict Order | Section 8.7.5.22 |
| | | | | | |
| 13 | Soft Failure | | 13 | Soft Failure | Section 8.7.5.23 |
| | | | | | |
| 14 | Image Size | | 14 | Image Size | Section 8.7.5.7 |
| | | | | | |
| 18 | Encryption Info | | 18 | Encryption Info | Section 8.7.5.10 |
| | | | | | |
| 19 | Compression Info | | 19 | Compression Info | Section 8.7.5.11 |
| | | | | | |
| 20 | Unpack Info | | 20 | Unpack Info | Section 8.7.5.12 |
| | | | | | |
| 21 | URI | | 21 | URI | Section 8.7.5.13 |
| | | | | | |
| 22 | Source Component | | 22 | Source Component | Section 8.7.5.14 |
| | | | | | |
| 23 | Run Args | | 23 | Run Args | Section 8.7.5.15 |
| | | | | | |
| 24 | Device ID | | 24 | Device ID | Section 8.7.5.5 |
| | | | | | |
| 26 | Minimum Battery | | 26 | Minimum Battery | Section 8.7.5.16 |
| | | | | | |
| 27 | Update Priority | | 27 | Update Priority | Section 8.7.5.17 |
| | | | | | |
| 28 | Version | | 28 | Version | {{suit-parameter-version} |
| | | | | | |
| 29 | Wait Info | | 29 | Wait Info | Section 8.7.5.19 |
| | | | | | |
| 30 | URI List | | 30 | URI List | Section 8.7.5.20 |
| | | | | | |
| 31 | Component Index | | nint | Custom | Section 8.7.5.24 |
| | | +-------+------------------+---------------------------+
| nint | Custom |
+-------+------------------+
11.3. SUIT Text Values 11.3. SUIT Text Values
+-------+----------------------+ +-------+----------------------+---------------+
| Label | Name | | Label | Name | Reference |
+-------+----------------------+ +-------+----------------------+---------------+
| 1 | Manifest Description | | 1 | Manifest Description | Section 8.6.4 |
| | | | | | |
| 2 | Update Description | | 2 | Update Description | Section 8.6.4 |
| | | | | | |
| 3 | Manifest JSON Source | | 3 | Manifest JSON Source | Section 8.6.4 |
| | | | | | |
| 4 | Manifest YAML Source | | 4 | Manifest YAML Source | Section 8.6.4 |
| | | | | | |
| nint | Custom | | nint | Custom | Section 8.6.4 |
+-------+----------------------+ +-------+----------------------+---------------+
11.4. SUIT Component Text Values 11.4. SUIT Component Text Values
+-------+----------------------------+ +-------+----------------------------+---------------+
| Label | Name | | Label | Name | Reference |
+-------+----------------------------+ +-------+----------------------------+---------------+
| 1 | Vendor Name | | 1 | Vendor Name | Section 8.6.4 |
| | | | | | |
| 2 | Model Name | | 2 | Model Name | Section 8.6.4 |
| | | | | | |
| 3 | Vendor Domain | | 3 | Vendor Domain | Section 8.6.4 |
| | | | | | |
| 4 | Model Info | | 4 | Model Info | Section 8.6.4 |
| | | | | | |
| 5 | Component Description | | 5 | Component Description | Section 8.6.4 |
| | | | | | |
| 6 | Component Version | | 6 | Component Version | Section 8.6.4 |
| | | | | | |
| 7 | Component Version Required | | 7 | Component Version Required | Section 8.6.4 |
| | | | | | |
| nint | Custom | | nint | Custom | Section 8.6.4 |
+-------+----------------------------+ +-------+----------------------------+---------------+
11.5. SUIT Algorithm Identifiers 11.5. SUIT Algorithm Identifiers
11.5.1. SUIT Digest Algorithm Identifiers 11.5.1. SUIT Digest Algorithm Identifiers
+-------+----------+ +-------+----------+------------+
| Label | Name | | Label | Name | |
+-------+----------+ +-------+----------+------------+
| 1 | SHA224 | | 1 | SHA224 | Section 10 |
| | | | | | |
| 2 | SHA256 | | 2 | SHA256 | Section 10 |
| | | | | | |
| 3 | SHA384 | | 3 | SHA384 | Section 10 |
| | | | | | |
| 4 | SHA512 | | 4 | SHA512 | Section 10 |
| | | | | | |
| 5 | SHA3-224 | | 5 | SHA3-224 | Section 10 |
| | | | | | |
| 6 | SHA3-256 | | 6 | SHA3-256 | Section 10 |
| | | | | | |
| 7 | SHA3-384 | | 7 | SHA3-384 | Section 10 |
| | | | | | |
| 8 | SHA3-512 | | 8 | SHA3-512 | Section 10 |
+-------+----------+ +-------+----------+------------+
11.5.2. SUIT Compression Algorithm Identifiers 11.5.2. SUIT Compression Algorithm Identifiers
+-------+--------+ +-------+--------+------------------+
| Label | Name | | Label | Name | Reference |
+-------+--------+ +-------+--------+------------------+
| 1 | zlib | | 1 | zlib | Section 8.7.5.11 |
| | | | | | |
| 2 | Brotli | | 2 | Brotli | Section 8.7.5.11 |
| | | | | | |
| 3 | zstd | | 3 | zstd | Section 8.7.5.11 |
+-------+--------+ +-------+--------+------------------+
11.5.3. Unpack Algorithms 11.5.3. Unpack Algorithms
+-------+------+ +-------+------+------------------+
| Label | Name | | Label | Name | Reference |
+-------+------+ +-------+------+------------------+
| 1 | HEX | | 1 | HEX | Section 8.7.5.12 |
| | | | | | |
| 2 | ELF | | 2 | ELF | Section 8.7.5.12 |
| | | | | | |
| 3 | COFF | | 3 | COFF | Section 8.7.5.12 |
| | | | | | |
| 4 | SREC | | 4 | SREC | Section 8.7.5.12 |
+-------+------+ +-------+------+------------------+
12. Security Considerations 12. Security Considerations
This document is about a manifest format describing and protecting This document is about a manifest format protecting and describing
firmware images and as such it is part of a larger solution for how to retrieve, install, and invoke firmware images and as such it
offering a standardized way of delivering firmware updates to IoT is part of a larger solution for delivering firmware updates to IoT
devices. A detailed security treatment can be found in the devices. A detailed security treatment can be found in the
architecture [I-D.ietf-suit-architecture] and in the information architecture [I-D.ietf-suit-architecture] and in the information
model [I-D.ietf-suit-information-model] documents. model [I-D.ietf-suit-information-model] documents.
13. Acknowledgements 13. Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the following persons for their support in We would like to thank the following persons for their support in
designing this mechanism: designing this mechanism:
- Milosch Meriac - Milosch Meriac
skipping to change at page 70, line 35 skipping to change at page 76, line 35
[COFF] Wikipedia, ., "Common Object File Format (COFF)", 2020, [COFF] Wikipedia, ., "Common Object File Format (COFF)", 2020,
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COFF>. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COFF>.
[ELF] Wikipedia, ., "Executable and Linkable Format (ELF)", [ELF] Wikipedia, ., "Executable and Linkable Format (ELF)",
2020, <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ 2020, <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/
Executable_and_Linkable_Format>. Executable_and_Linkable_Format>.
[HEX] Wikipedia, ., "Intel HEX", 2020, [HEX] Wikipedia, ., "Intel HEX", 2020,
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_HEX>. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_HEX>.
[I-D.ietf-cbor-tags-oid]
Bormann, C. and S. Leonard, "Concise Binary Object
Representation (CBOR) Tags for Object Identifiers", draft-
ietf-cbor-tags-oid-02 (work in progress), October 2020.
[I-D.ietf-sacm-coswid]
Birkholz, H., Fitzgerald-McKay, J., Schmidt, C., and D.
Waltermire, "Concise Software Identification Tags", draft-
ietf-sacm-coswid-15 (work in progress), May 2020.
[I-D.ietf-suit-architecture] [I-D.ietf-suit-architecture]
Moran, B., Tschofenig, H., Brown, D., and M. Meriac, "A Moran, B., Tschofenig, H., Brown, D., and M. Meriac, "A
Firmware Update Architecture for Internet of Things", Firmware Update Architecture for Internet of Things",
draft-ietf-suit-architecture-11 (work in progress), May draft-ietf-suit-architecture-14 (work in progress),
2020. October 2020.
[I-D.ietf-suit-information-model] [I-D.ietf-suit-information-model]
Moran, B., Tschofenig, H., and H. Birkholz, "An Moran, B., Tschofenig, H., and H. Birkholz, "An
Information Model for Firmware Updates in IoT Devices", Information Model for Firmware Updates in IoT Devices",
draft-ietf-suit-information-model-07 (work in progress), draft-ietf-suit-information-model-08 (work in progress),
June 2020. October 2020.
[I-D.ietf-teep-architecture] [I-D.ietf-teep-architecture]
Pei, M., Tschofenig, H., Thaler, D., and D. Wheeler, Pei, M., Tschofenig, H., Thaler, D., and D. Wheeler,
"Trusted Execution Environment Provisioning (TEEP) "Trusted Execution Environment Provisioning (TEEP)
Architecture", draft-ietf-teep-architecture-11 (work in Architecture", draft-ietf-teep-architecture-12 (work in
progress), July 2020. progress), July 2020.
[I-D.kucherawy-rfc8478bis] [I-D.kucherawy-rfc8478bis]
Collet, Y. and M. Kucherawy, "Zstandard Compression and Collet, Y. and M. Kucherawy, "Zstandard Compression and
the application/zstd Media Type", draft-kucherawy- the application/zstd Media Type", draft-kucherawy-
rfc8478bis-05 (work in progress), April 2020. rfc8478bis-05 (work in progress), April 2020.
[RFC1950] Deutsch, P. and J-L. Gailly, "ZLIB Compressed Data Format [RFC1950] Deutsch, P. and J-L. Gailly, "ZLIB Compressed Data Format
Specification version 3.3", RFC 1950, Specification version 3.3", RFC 1950,
DOI 10.17487/RFC1950, May 1996, DOI 10.17487/RFC1950, May 1996,
skipping to change at page 71, line 36 skipping to change at page 77, line 48
May 2018, <https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc8392>. May 2018, <https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc8392>.
[RFC8747] Jones, M., Seitz, L., Selander, G., Erdtman, S., and H. [RFC8747] Jones, M., Seitz, L., Selander, G., Erdtman, S., and H.
Tschofenig, "Proof-of-Possession Key Semantics for CBOR Tschofenig, "Proof-of-Possession Key Semantics for CBOR
Web Tokens (CWTs)", RFC 8747, DOI 10.17487/RFC8747, March Web Tokens (CWTs)", RFC 8747, DOI 10.17487/RFC8747, March
2020, <https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc8747>. 2020, <https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc8747>.
[SREC] Wikipedia, ., "SREC (file format)", 2020, [SREC] Wikipedia, ., "SREC (file format)", 2020,
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SREC_(file_format)>. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SREC_(file_format)>.
14.3. URIs [YAML] "YAML Ain't Markup Language", 2020, <https://yaml.org/>.
[1] suit-condition-update-authorized
A. Full CDDL Appendix A. A. Full CDDL
In order to create a valid SUIT Manifest document the structure of In order to create a valid SUIT Manifest document the structure of
the corresponding CBOR message MUST adhere to the following CDDL data the corresponding CBOR message MUST adhere to the following CDDL data
definition. definition.
SUIT_Envelope_Tagged = #6.48(SUIT_Envelope)
SUIT_Envelope = { SUIT_Envelope = {
? suit-delegation => bstr .cbor SUIT_Delegation, ? suit-delegation => bstr .cbor SUIT_Delegation,
? suit-authentication-wrapper => bstr .cbor SUIT_Authentication, suit-authentication-wrapper => bstr .cbor SUIT_Authentication,
suit-manifest => bstr .cbor SUIT_Manifest, suit-manifest => bstr .cbor SUIT_Manifest,
SUIT_Severable_Manifest_Members, SUIT_Severable_Manifest_Members,
* SUIT_Integrated_Payload,
* SUIT_Integrated_Dependency,
* $$SUIT_Envelope_Extensions, * $$SUIT_Envelope_Extensions,
(int => bstr) * (int => bstr)
} }
SUIT_Delegation = [ + [ + bstr .cbor CWT ] ] SUIT_Delegation = [ + [ + bstr .cbor CWT ] ]
CWT = SUIT_Authentication_Block CWT = SUIT_Authentication_Block
SUIT_Authentication = [ + bstr .cbor SUIT_Authentication_Block ] SUIT_Authentication = [
bstr .cbor SUIT_Digest,
SUIT_Authentication_Block /= COSE_Mac_Tagged * bstr .cbor SUIT_Authentication_Block
SUIT_Authentication_Block /= COSE_Sign_Tagged ]
SUIT_Authentication_Block /= COSE_Mac0_Tagged
SUIT_Authentication_Block /= COSE_Sign1_Tagged
SUIT_Severable_Manifest_Members = (
? suit-dependency-resolution => bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence,
? suit-payload-fetch => bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence,
? suit-install => bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence,
? suit-text => bstr .cbor SUIT_Text_Map,
? suit-coswid => bstr .cbor concise-software-identity,
* $$SUIT_severable-members-extensions,
)
COSE_Mac_Tagged = any
COSE_Sign_Tagged = any
COSE_Mac0_Tagged = any
COSE_Sign1_Tagged = any
COSE_Encrypt_Tagged = any
COSE_Encrypt0_Tagged = any
SUIT_Digest = [ SUIT_Digest = [
suit-digest-algorithm-id : suit-digest-algorithm-ids, suit-digest-algorithm-id : suit-digest-algorithm-ids,
suit-digest-bytes : bstr, suit-digest-bytes : bstr,
* $$SUIT_Digest-extensions * $$SUIT_Digest-extensions
] ]
; Named Information Hash Algorithm Identifiers ; Named Information Hash Algorithm Identifiers
suit-digest-algorithm-ids /= algorithm-id-sha224 suit-digest-algorithm-ids /= algorithm-id-sha224
suit-digest-algorithm-ids /= algorithm-id-sha256 suit-digest-algorithm-ids /= algorithm-id-sha256
suit-digest-algorithm-ids /= algorithm-id-sha384 suit-digest-algorithm-ids /= algorithm-id-sha384
suit-digest-algorithm-ids /= algorithm-id-sha512 suit-digest-algorithm-ids /= algorithm-id-sha512
suit-digest-algorithm-ids /= algorithm-id-sha3-224 suit-digest-algorithm-ids /= algorithm-id-sha3-224
suit-digest-algorithm-ids /= algorithm-id-sha3-256 suit-digest-algorithm-ids /= algorithm-id-sha3-256
suit-digest-algorithm-ids /= algorithm-id-sha3-384 suit-digest-algorithm-ids /= algorithm-id-sha3-384
suit-digest-algorithm-ids /= algorithm-id-sha3-512 suit-digest-algorithm-ids /= algorithm-id-sha3-512
algorithm-id-sha224 = 1 SUIT_Authentication_Block /= COSE_Mac_Tagged
algorithm-id-sha256 = 2 SUIT_Authentication_Block /= COSE_Sign_Tagged
algorithm-id-sha384 = 3 SUIT_Authentication_Block /= COSE_Mac0_Tagged
algorithm-id-sha512 = 4 SUIT_Authentication_Block /= COSE_Sign1_Tagged
algorithm-id-sha3-224 = 5 COSE_Mac_Tagged = any
algorithm-id-sha3-256 = 6 COSE_Sign_Tagged = any
algorithm-id-sha3-384 = 7 COSE_Mac0_Tagged = any
algorithm-id-sha3-512 = 8 COSE_Sign1_Tagged = any
COSE_Encrypt_Tagged = any
COSE_Encrypt0_Tagged = any
SUIT_Severable_Manifest_Members = (
? suit-dependency-resolution => bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence,
? suit-payload-fetch => bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence,
? suit-install => bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence,
? suit-text => bstr .cbor SUIT_Text_Map,
? suit-coswid => bstr .cbor concise-software-identity,
* $$SUIT_severable-members-extensions,
)
SUIT_Integrated_Payload = (suit-integrated-payload-key => bstr)
SUIT_Integrated_Dependency = (
suit-integrated-payload-key => bstr .cbor SUIT_Envelope
)
suit-integrated-payload-key = nint / uint .ge 24
SUIT_Manifest_Tagged = #6.480(SUIT_Manifest)
SUIT_Manifest = { SUIT_Manifest = {
suit-manifest-version => 1, suit-manifest-version => 1,
suit-manifest-sequence-number => uint, suit-manifest-sequence-number => uint,
suit-common => bstr .cbor SUIT_Common, suit-common => bstr .cbor SUIT_Common,
? suit-reference-uri => tstr, ? suit-reference-uri => tstr,
SUIT_Severable_Members, SUIT_Severable_Manifest_Members,
SUIT_Severable_Members_Digests, SUIT_Severable_Members_Digests,
SUIT_Unseverable_Members, SUIT_Unseverable_Members,
* $$SUIT_Manifest_Extensions, * $$SUIT_Manifest_Extensions,
} }
SUIT_Unseverable_Members = ( SUIT_Unseverable_Members = (
? suit-validate => bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence, ? suit-validate => bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence,
? suit-load => bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence, ? suit-load => bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence,
? suit-run => bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence, ? suit-run => bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence,
* $$unserverble-manifest-member-extensions, * $$unserverble-manifest-member-extensions,
) )
SUIT_Severable_Members_Digests = ( SUIT_Severable_Members_Digests = (
? suit-dependency-resolution-digest => SUIT_Digest, ? suit-dependency-resolution => SUIT_Digest,
? suit-payload-fetch-digest => SUIT_Digest, ? suit-payload-fetch => SUIT_Digest,
? suit-install-digest => SUIT_Digest, ? suit-install => SUIT_Digest,
? suit-text-digest => SUIT_Digest, ? suit-text => SUIT_Digest,
? suit-coswid-digest => SUIT_Digest, ? suit-coswid => SUIT_Digest,
* $$severable-manifest-members-digests-extensions * $$severable-manifest-members-digests-extensions
) )
SUIT_Common = { SUIT_Common = {
? suit-dependencies => SUIT_Dependencies, ? suit-dependencies => SUIT_Dependencies,
? suit-components => SUIT_Components, ? suit-components => SUIT_Components,
? suit-common-sequence => bstr .cbor SUIT_Common_Sequence, ? suit-common-sequence => bstr .cbor SUIT_Common_Sequence,
* $$SUIT_Common-extensions, * $$SUIT_Common-extensions,
} }
skipping to change at page 74, line 22 skipping to change at page 80, line 27
concise-software-identity = any concise-software-identity = any
SUIT_Dependency = { SUIT_Dependency = {
suit-dependency-digest => SUIT_Digest, suit-dependency-digest => SUIT_Digest,
? suit-dependency-prefix => SUIT_Component_Identifier, ? suit-dependency-prefix => SUIT_Component_Identifier,
* $$SUIT_Dependency-extensions, * $$SUIT_Dependency-extensions,
} }
SUIT_Component_Identifier = [* bstr] SUIT_Component_Identifier = [* bstr]
SUIT_Component_Reference = {
suit-component-identifier => SUIT_Component_Identifier,
suit-component-dependency-index => uint
}
SUIT_Common_Sequence = [ SUIT_Common_Sequence = [
+ ( SUIT_Condition // SUIT_Common_Commands ) + ( SUIT_Condition // SUIT_Common_Commands )
] ]
SUIT_Common_Commands //= (suit-directive-set-component-index, uint/bool) SUIT_Common_Commands //= (suit-directive-set-component-index, IndexArg)
SUIT_Common_Commands //= (suit-directive-set-dependency-index, uint/bool) SUIT_Common_Commands //= (suit-directive-set-dependency-index, IndexArg)
SUIT_Common_Commands //= (suit-directive-run-sequence, SUIT_Common_Commands //= (suit-directive-run-sequence,
bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence) bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence)
SUIT_Common_Commands //= (suit-directive-try-each, SUIT_Common_Commands //= (suit-directive-try-each,
SUIT_Directive_Try_Each_Argument) SUIT_Directive_Try_Each_Argument)
SUIT_Common_Commands //= (suit-directive-set-parameters, SUIT_Common_Commands //= (suit-directive-set-parameters,
{+ SUIT_Parameters}) {+ SUIT_Parameters})
SUIT_Common_Commands //= (suit-directive-override-parameters, SUIT_Common_Commands //= (suit-directive-override-parameters,
{+ SUIT_Parameters}) {+ SUIT_Parameters})
IndexArg /= uint
IndexArg /= bool
IndexArg /= [+uint]
SUIT_Command_Sequence = [ + ( SUIT_Command_Sequence = [ + (
SUIT_Condition // SUIT_Directive // SUIT_Command_Custom SUIT_Condition // SUIT_Directive // SUIT_Command_Custom
) ] ) ]
SUIT_Command_Custom = (suit-command-custom, bstr/tstr/int/nil) SUIT_Command_Custom = (suit-command-custom, bstr/tstr/int/nil)
SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-vendor-identifier, SUIT_Reporting_Policy) SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-vendor-identifier, SUIT_Rep_Policy)
SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-class-identifier, SUIT_Reporting_Policy) SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-class-identifier, SUIT_Rep_Policy)
SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-device-identifier, SUIT_Reporting_Policy) SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-device-identifier, SUIT_Rep_Policy)
SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-image-match, SUIT_Reporting_Policy) SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-image-match, SUIT_Rep_Policy)
SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-image-not-match, SUIT_Reporting_Policy) SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-image-not-match, SUIT_Rep_Policy)
SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-use-before, SUIT_Reporting_Policy) SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-use-before, SUIT_Rep_Policy)
SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-minimum-battery, SUIT_Reporting_Policy) SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-minimum-battery, SUIT_Rep_Policy)
SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-update-authorized, SUIT_Reporting_Policy) SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-update-authorized, SUIT_Rep_Policy)
SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-version, SUIT_Reporting_Policy) SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-version, SUIT_Rep_Policy)
SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-component-offset, SUIT_Reporting_Policy) SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-component-offset, SUIT_Rep_Policy)
SUIT_Condition //= (suit-condition-abort, SUIT_Rep_Policy)
SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-set-component-index, uint/bool) SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-set-component-index, IndexArg)
SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-set-dependency-index, uint/bool) SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-set-dependency-index, IndexArg)
SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-run-sequence, SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-run-sequence,
bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence) bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence)
SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-try-each, SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-try-each,
SUIT_Directive_Try_Each_Argument) SUIT_Directive_Try_Each_Argument)
SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-process-dependency, SUIT_Reporting_Policy) SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-process-dependency, SUIT_Rep_Policy)
SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-set-parameters, SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-set-parameters,
{+ SUIT_Parameters}) {+ SUIT_Parameters})
SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-override-parameters, SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-override-parameters,
{+ SUIT_Parameters}) {+ SUIT_Parameters})
SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-fetch, SUIT_Reporting_Policy) SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-fetch, SUIT_Rep_Policy)
SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-copy, SUIT_Reporting_Policy) SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-copy, SUIT_Rep_Policy)
SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-swap, SUIT_Reporting_Policy) SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-swap, SUIT_Rep_Policy)
SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-run, SUIT_Reporting_Policy) SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-run, SUIT_Rep_Policy)
SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-wait, SUIT_Reporting_Policy) SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-wait, SUIT_Rep_Policy)
SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-abort, SUIT_Reporting_Policy) SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-fetch-uri-list, SUIT_Rep_Policy)
SUIT_Directive //= (suit-directive-fetch-uri-list, SUIT_Reporting_Policy)
SUIT_Directive_Try_Each_Argument = [ SUIT_Directive_Try_Each_Argument = [
+ bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence, + bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence,
nil / bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence nil / bstr .cbor SUIT_Command_Sequence
] ]
SUIT_Reporting_Policy = uint .bits suit-reporting-bits SUIT_Rep_Policy = uint .bits suit-reporting-bits
suit-reporting-bits = &( suit-reporting-bits = &(
suit-send-record-success : 0, suit-send-record-success : 0,
suit-send-record-failure : 1, suit-send-record-failure : 1,
suit-send-sysinfo-success : 2, suit-send-sysinfo-success : 2,
suit-send-sysinfo-failure : 3 suit-send-sysinfo-failure : 3
) )
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-command-custom
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-condition-vendor-identifier
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-condition-class-identifier
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-condition-image-match
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-condition-use-before
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-condition-component-offset
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-condition-device-identifier
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-condition-image-not-match
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-condition-minimum-battery
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-condition-update-authorized
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-condition-version
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-directive-set-component-index
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-directive-set-dependency-index
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-directive-abort
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-directive-try-each
;SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-directive-do-each
;SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-directive-map-filter
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-directive-process-dependency
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-directive-set-parameters
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-directive-override-parameters
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-directive-fetch
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-directive-copy
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-directive-run
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-directive-wait
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-directive-run-sequence
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-directive-swap
SUIT_Command_ID /= suit-directive-fetch-uri-list
suit-record = {
suit-record-success => bool/int,
? suit-record-component-id => SUIT_Component_ID,
? suit-record-dependency-id => SUIT_Digest,
? suit-record-command-sequence-id => (
suit-common-sequence /
suit-dependency-resolution /
suit-payload-fetch /
suit-install /
suit-validate /
suit-load /
suit-run /
* $$suit-command-sequence-list-extensions
),
? suit-record-interpeter-offset => uint,
? suit-record-command-id => SUIT_Command_ID,
? suit-record-params => SUIT_Parameters,
? suit-record-actual => SUIT_Parameters,
* $$suit-record-extensions
}
SUIT_Wait_Event = { + SUIT_Wait_Events } SUIT_Wait_Event = { + SUIT_Wait_Events }
SUIT_Wait_Events //= (suit-wait-event-authorization => int) SUIT_Wait_Events //= (suit-wait-event-authorization => int)
SUIT_Wait_Events //= (suit-wait-event-power => int) SUIT_Wait_Events //= (suit-wait-event-power => int)
SUIT_Wait_Events //= (suit-wait-event-network => int) SUIT_Wait_Events //= (suit-wait-event-network => int)
SUIT_Wait_Events //= (suit-wait-event-other-device-version SUIT_Wait_Events //= (suit-wait-event-other-device-version
=> SUIT_Wait_Event_Argument_Other_Device_Version) => SUIT_Wait_Event_Argument_Other_Device_Version)
SUIT_Wait_Events //= (suit-wait-event-time => uint); Timestamp SUIT_Wait_Events //= (suit-wait-event-time => uint); Timestamp
SUIT_Wait_Events //= (suit-wait-event-time-of-day SUIT_Wait_Events //= (suit-wait-event-time-of-day
=> uint); Time of Day (seconds since 00:00:00) => uint); Time of Day (seconds since 00:00:00)
SUIT_Wait_Events //= (suit-wait-event-day-of-week SUIT_Wait_Events //= (suit-wait-event-day-of-week
=> uint); Days since Sunday => uint); Days since Sunday
SUIT_Wait_Event_Argument_Other_Device_Version = [ SUIT_Wait_Event_Argument_Other_Device_Version = [
other-device: bstr, other-device: bstr,
other-device-version: [ + SUIT_Parameter_Version_Match ] other-device-version: [ + SUIT_Parameter_Version_Match ]
] ]
SUIT_Parameters //= (suit-parameter-vendor-identifier => RFC4122_UUID) SUIT_Parameters //= (suit-parameter-vendor-identifier =>
(RFC4122_UUID / cbor-pen))
cbor-pen = #6.112(bstr)
SUIT_Parameters //= (suit-parameter-class-identifier => RFC4122_UUID) SUIT_Parameters //= (suit-parameter-class-identifier => RFC4122_UUID)
SUIT_Parameters //= (suit-parameter-image-digest SUIT_Parameters //= (suit-parameter-image-digest
=> bstr .cbor SUIT_Digest) => bstr .cbor SUIT_Digest)
SUIT_Parameters //= (suit-parameter-image-size => uint) SUIT_Parameters //= (suit-parameter-image-size => uint)
SUIT_Parameters //= (suit-parameter-use-before => uint) SUIT_Parameters //= (suit-parameter-use-before => uint)
SUIT_Parameters //= (suit-parameter-component-offset => uint) SUIT_Parameters //= (suit-parameter-component-offset => uint)
SUIT_Parameters //= (suit-parameter-encryption-info SUIT_Parameters //= (suit-parameter-encryption-info
=> bstr .cbor SUIT_Encryption_Info) => bstr .cbor SUIT_Encryption_Info)
SUIT_Parameters //= (suit-parameter-compression-info SUIT_Parameters //= (suit-parameter-compression-info
skipping to change at page 79, line 14 skipping to change at page 84, line 20
SUIT_Unpack_Algorithms /= SUIT_Unpack_Algorithm_Srec SUIT_Unpack_Algorithms /= SUIT_Unpack_Algorithm_Srec
SUIT_Unpack_Algorithm_Hex = 1 SUIT_Unpack_Algorithm_Hex = 1
SUIT_Unpack_Algorithm_Elf = 2 SUIT_Unpack_Algorithm_Elf = 2
SUIT_Unpack_Algorithm_Coff = 3 SUIT_Unpack_Algorithm_Coff = 3
SUIT_Unpack_Algorithm_Srec = 4 SUIT_Unpack_Algorithm_Srec = 4
SUIT_URI_List = [+ tstr ] SUIT_URI_List = [+ tstr ]
SUIT_Text_Map = { SUIT_Text_Map = {
? suit-text-components => * SUIT_Component_Identifier => {
[ SUIT_Text_Component_Keys
+ { },
1 => SUIT_Component_Identifier
SUIT_Text_Component_Keys
}
],
SUIT_Text_Keys SUIT_Text_Keys
} }
SUIT_Text_Component_Keys = ( SUIT_Text_Component_Keys = (
? suit-text-vendor-name => tstr, ? suit-text-vendor-name => tstr,
? suit-text-model-name => tstr, ? suit-text-model-name => tstr,
? suit-text-vendor-domain => tstr, ? suit-text-vendor-domain => tstr,
? suit-text-model-info => tstr, ? suit-text-model-info => tstr,
? suit-text-component-description => tstr, ? suit-text-component-description => tstr,
? suit-text-component-version => tstr, ? suit-text-component-version => tstr,
skipping to change at page 79, line 47 skipping to change at page 84, line 49
? suit-text-update-description => tstr, ? suit-text-update-description => tstr,
? suit-text-manifest-json-source => tstr, ? suit-text-manifest-json-source => tstr,
? suit-text-manifest-yaml-source => tstr, ? suit-text-manifest-yaml-source => tstr,
* $$suit-text-key-extensions * $$suit-text-key-extensions
) )
suit-delegation = 1 suit-delegation = 1
suit-authentication-wrapper = 2 suit-authentication-wrapper = 2
suit-manifest = 3 suit-manifest = 3
algorithm-id-sha224 = 1
algorithm-id-sha256 = 2
algorithm-id-sha384 = 3
algorithm-id-sha512 = 4
algorithm-id-sha3-224 = 5
algorithm-id-sha3-256 = 6
algorithm-id-sha3-384 = 7
algorithm-id-sha3-512 = 8
suit-manifest-version = 1 suit-manifest-version = 1
suit-manifest-sequence-number = 2 suit-manifest-sequence-number = 2
suit-common = 3 suit-common = 3
suit-reference-uri = 4 suit-reference-uri = 4
suit-dependency-resolution = 7 suit-dependency-resolution = 7
suit-payload-fetch = 8 suit-payload-fetch = 8
suit-install = 9 suit-install = 9
suit-validate = 10 suit-validate = 10
suit-load = 11 suit-load = 11
suit-run = 12 suit-run = 12
suit-text = 13 suit-text = 13
suit-coswid = 14 suit-coswid = 14
suit-dependencies = 1 suit-dependencies = 1
suit-components = 2 suit-components = 2
suit-dependency-components = 3
suit-common-sequence = 4 suit-common-sequence = 4
suit-dependency-digest = 1 suit-dependency-digest = 1
suit-dependency-prefix = 2 suit-dependency-prefix = 2
suit-component-identifier = 1
suit-component-dependency-index = 2
suit-command-custom = nint suit-command-custom = nint
suit-condition-vendor-identifier = 1 suit-condition-vendor-identifier = 1
suit-condition-class-identifier = 2 suit-condition-class-identifier = 2
suit-condition-image-match = 3 suit-condition-image-match = 3
suit-condition-use-before = 4 suit-condition-use-before = 4
suit-condition-component-offset = 5 suit-condition-component-offset = 5
suit-condition-abort = 14
suit-condition-device-identifier = 24 suit-condition-device-identifier = 24
suit-condition-image-not-match = 25 suit-condition-image-not-match = 25
suit-condition-minimum-battery = 26 suit-condition-minimum-battery = 26
suit-condition-update-authorized = 27 suit-condition-update-authorized = 27
suit-condition-version = 28 suit-condition-version = 28
suit-directive-set-component-index = 12 suit-directive-set-component-index = 12
suit-directive-set-dependency-index = 13 suit-directive-set-dependency-index = 13
suit-directive-abort = 14
suit-directive-try-each = 15 suit-directive-try-each = 15
;suit-directive-do-each = 16 ; TBD ;suit-directive-do-each = 16 ; TBD
;suit-directive-map-filter = 17 ; TBD ;suit-directive-map-filter = 17 ; TBD
suit-directive-process-dependency = 18 suit-directive-process-dependency = 18
suit-directive-set-parameters = 19 suit-directive-set-parameters = 19
suit-directive-override-parameters = 20 suit-directive-override-parameters = 20
suit-directive-fetch = 21 suit-directive-fetch = 21
suit-directive-copy = 22 suit-directive-copy = 22
suit-directive-run = 23 suit-directive-run = 23
skipping to change at page 81, line 42 skipping to change at page 86, line 48
suit-parameter-device-identifier = 24 suit-parameter-device-identifier = 24
suit-parameter-minimum-battery = 26 suit-parameter-minimum-battery = 26
suit-parameter-update-priority = 27 suit-parameter-update-priority = 27
suit-parameter-version = 28 suit-parameter-version = 28
suit-parameter-wait-info = 29 suit-parameter-wait-info = 29
suit-parameter-uri-list = 30 suit-parameter-uri-list = 30
suit-parameter-custom = nint suit-parameter-custom = nint
suit-compression-algorithm = 1 suit-compression-algorithm = 1
suit-compression-parameters = 2
suit-unpack-algorithm = 1 suit-unpack-algorithm = 1
suit-unpack-parameters = 2
suit-text-manifest-description = 1 suit-text-manifest-description = 1
suit-text-update-description = 2 suit-text-update-description = 2
suit-text-manifest-json-source = 3 suit-text-manifest-json-source = 3
suit-text-manifest-yaml-source = 4 suit-text-manifest-yaml-source = 4
suit-text-vendor-name = 1 suit-text-vendor-name = 1
suit-text-model-name = 2 suit-text-model-name = 2
suit-text-vendor-domain = 3 suit-text-vendor-domain = 3
suit-text-model-info = 4 suit-text-model-info = 4
suit-text-component-description = 5 suit-text-component-description = 5
suit-text-component-version = 6 suit-text-component-version = 6
suit-text-version-required = 7 suit-text-version-required = 7
B. Examples Appendix B. B. Examples
The following examples demonstrate a small subset of the The following examples demonstrate a small subset of the
functionality of the manifest. However, despite this, even a simple functionality of the manifest. Even a simple manifest processor can
manifest processor can execute most of these manifests. execute most of these manifests.
The examples are signed using the following ECDSA secp256r1 key: The examples are signed using the following ECDSA secp256r1 key:
-----BEGIN PRIVATE KEY----- -----BEGIN PRIVATE KEY-----
MIGHAgEAMBMGByqGSM49AgEGCCqGSM49AwEHBG0wawIBAQQgApZYjZCUGLM50VBC MIGHAgEAMBMGByqGSM49AgEGCCqGSM49AwEHBG0wawIBAQQgApZYjZCUGLM50VBC
CjYStX+09jGmnyJPrpDLTz/hiXOhRANCAASEloEarguqq9JhVxie7NomvqqL8Rtv CjYStX+09jGmnyJPrpDLTz/hiXOhRANCAASEloEarguqq9JhVxie7NomvqqL8Rtv
P+bitWWchdvArTsfKktsCYExwKNtrNHXi9OB3N+wnAUtszmR23M4tKiW P+bitWWchdvArTsfKktsCYExwKNtrNHXi9OB3N+wnAUtszmR23M4tKiW
-----END PRIVATE KEY----- -----END PRIVATE KEY-----
The corresponding public key can be used to verify these examples: The corresponding public key can be used to verify these examples:
skipping to change at page 83, line 38 skipping to change at page 88, line 50
This example covers the following templates: This example covers the following templates:
- Compatibility Check (Section 7.1) - Compatibility Check (Section 7.1)
- Secure Boot (Section 7.2) - Secure Boot (Section 7.2)
It also serves as the minimum example. It also serves as the minimum example.
{ {
/ authentication-wrapper / 2:h'81588fd28443a10126a0584482025840356 / authentication-wrapper / 2:bstr .cbor ({ digest: bstr
3303937656636346266336262396234393465373165316632343138656566386434363 .cbor ([
6636339303266363339613835356563396166336539656464623939584093347ceebc1 / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
209a2d660bfbbe78e461079f1952c614e1ae8f734ff0ea438110d056c1a0cce6b0599d / digest-bytes /
b54e6704847de49efe60e9a7b821215d83368a2c8c7c088' / [ h'5c097ef64bf3bb9b494e71e1f2418eef8d466cc902f639a855ec9af3e9eddb99'
h'd28443a10126a05844820258403563303937656636346266336262396234 ]) signatures: [
3934653731653166323431386565663864343636636339303266363339613835356563 bstr .cbor (18([
396166336539656464623939584093347ceebc1209a2d660bfbbe78e461079f1952c61 / protected / bstr .cbor ({
4e1ae8f734ff0ea438110d056c1a0cce6b0599db54e6704847de49efe60e9a7b821215 / alg / 1:-7 / "ES256" /,
d83368a2c8c7c088' / 18([ }),
/ protected / h'a10126' / { / unprotected / {
/ alg / 1:-7 / "ES256" /, },
} /, / payload / bstr .cbor ([
/ unprotected / { / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
}, / digest-bytes /
/ payload / h'8202584035633039376566363462663362623962 h'5c097ef64bf3bb9b494e71e1f2418eef8d466cc902f639a855ec9af3e9eddb99'
3439346537316531663234313865656638643436366363393032663633396138353565 ]),
63396166336539656464623939' / [ / signature / h'60f5c3d03a3aa759bfef2ef0f5f97a93b1
/ algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /, f5e741f7463f4385af88513a5c2957bea2d6c4cfddd03392a267aab0fc0fd515560ed5
/ digest-bytes / h'3563303937656636346266336262396 8e33fad26ac32a024c5a7143'
2343934653731653166323431386565663864343636636339303266363339613835356 ]))
563396166336539656464623939' ]
] /, }),
/ signature / h'93347ceebc1209a2d660bfbbe78e461079f195 / manifest / 3:bstr .cbor ({
2c614e1ae8f734ff0ea438110d056c1a0cce6b0599db54e6704847de49efe60e9a7b82
1215d83368a2c8c7c088'
]) /
] /,
/ manifest / 3:h'a50101020003585fa202818141000458568614a40150fa6b4
a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab450358248
202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba987654321
00e1987d0010f020f0a4382030f0c43821702' / {
/ manifest-version / 1:1, / manifest-version / 1:1,
/ manifest-sequence-number / 2:0, / manifest-sequence-number / 2:0,
/ common / 3:h'a202818141000458568614a40150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9 / common / 3:bstr .cbor ({
de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45035824820258200011223
3445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f0
20f' / {
/ components / 2:[ / components / 2:[
[h'00'] [h'00']
], ],
/ common-sequence / 4:h'8614a40150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663 / common-sequence / 4:bstr .cbor ([
e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab4503582482025820001122334455
66778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f'
/ [
/ directive-override-parameters / 20,{ / directive-override-parameters / 20,{
/ vendor-id / / vendor-id /
1:h'"fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe"' / fa6b4a53-d5ad-5fdf- 1:h'fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe' / fa6b4a53-d5ad-5fdf-
be9d-e663e4d41ffe /, be9d-e663e4d41ffe /,
/ class-id / / class-id / 2:h'1492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45'
2:h'"1492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45"' / / 1492af14-2569-5e48-bf42-9b2d51f2ab45 /,
1492af14-2569-5e48-bf42-9b2d51f2ab45 /, / image-digest / 3:bstr .cbor ([
/ image-digest / 3:h'8202582000112233445566778899a
abbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210' / [
/ algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /, / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
/ digest-bytes / / digest-bytes /
h'00112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210' h'00112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210'
] /, ]),
/ image-size / 14:34768, / image-size / 14:34768,
} , } ,
/ condition-vendor-identifier / 1,15 , / condition-vendor-identifier / 1,15 ,
/ condition-class-identifier / 2,15 / condition-class-identifier / 2,15
] /, ]),
}),
} /, / validate / 10:bstr .cbor ([
/ validate / 10:h'82030f' / [
/ condition-image-match / 3,15 / condition-image-match / 3,15
] /, ]),
/ run / 12:h'821702' / [ / run / 12:bstr .cbor ([
/ directive-run / 23,2 / directive-run / 23,2
] /, ]),
} /, }),
} }
Total size of Envelope without COSE authentication object: 117 Total size of Envelope without COSE authentication object: 159
Envelope: Envelope:
a1035871a50101020003585fa202818141000458568614a40150fa6b4a53 a2025827815824820258205c097ef64bf3bb9b494e71e1f2418eef8d466c
d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45 c902f639a855ec9af3e9eddb99035871a50101020003585fa20281814100
0358248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcd 0458568614a40150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af14
effedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f0a4382030f0c43821702 25695e48bf429b2d51f2ab450358248202582000112233445566778899aa
bbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f0a
4382030f0c43821702
Total size of Envelope with COSE authentication object: 266 Total size of Envelope with COSE authentication object: 272
Envelope with COSE authentication object: Envelope with COSE authentication object:
a202589281588fd28443a10126a058448202584035633039376566363462 a2025898825824820258205c097ef64bf3bb9b494e71e1f2418eef8d466c
663362623962343934653731653166323431386565663864343636636339 c902f639a855ec9af3e9eddb99586fd28443a10126a05824820258205c09
303266363339613835356563396166336539656464623939584093347cee 7ef64bf3bb9b494e71e1f2418eef8d466cc902f639a855ec9af3e9eddb99
bc1209a2d660bfbbe78e461079f1952c614e1ae8f734ff0ea438110d056c 584060f5c3d03a3aa759bfef2ef0f5f97a93b1f5e741f7463f4385af8851
1a0cce6b0599db54e6704847de49efe60e9a7b821215d83368a2c8c7c088 3a5c2957bea2d6c4cfddd03392a267aab0fc0fd515560ed58e33fad26ac3
035871a50101020003585fa202818141000458568614a40150fa6b4a53d5 2a024c5a7143035871a50101020003585fa202818141000458568614a401
ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab4503 50fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b
58248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdef 2d51f2ab450358248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123
fedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f0a4382030f0c43821702 456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f0a4382030f0c4382
1702
B.2. Example 1: Simultaneous Download and Installation of Payload B.2. Example 1: Simultaneous Download and Installation of Payload
This example covers the following templates: This example covers the following templates:
- Compatibility Check (Section 7.1) - Compatibility Check (Section 7.1)
- Firmware Download (Section 7.3) - Firmware Download (Section 7.3)
Simultaneous download and installation of payload. No secure boot is Simultaneous download and installation of payload. No secure boot is
present in this example to demonstrate a download-only manifest. present in this example to demonstrate a download-only manifest.
{ {
/ authentication-wrapper / 2:h'81588fd28443a10126a0584482025840393 / authentication-wrapper / 2:bstr .cbor ({ digest: bstr
8376565633835666139396664333164333332333831623938313066393062303563326 .cbor ([
530643466323834613666343231313230376564303066666637353058404931df82e15 / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
3bf1e3af5a59800216d8a47c33a37839e7d63d9f526fd369aa8359daae18f7619c9591 / digest-bytes /
23e7f7f928ee92a9893afedd35d06a936d6ed3d5843bf2a' / [
h'd28443a10126a05844820258403938376565633835666139396664333164 h'987eec85fa99fd31d332381b9810f90b05c2e0d4f284a6f4211207ed00fff750'
3333323338316239383130663930623035633265306434663238346136663432313132 ]) signatures: [
30376564303066666637353058404931df82e153bf1e3af5a59800216d8a47c33a3783 bstr .cbor (18([
9e7d63d9f526fd369aa8359daae18f7619c959123e7f7f928ee92a9893afedd35d06a9 / protected / bstr .cbor ({
36d6ed3d5843bf2a' / 18([ / alg / 1:-7 / "ES256" /,
/ protected / h'a10126' / { }),
/ alg / 1:-7 / "ES256" /, / unprotected / {
} /, },
/ unprotected / { / payload / bstr .cbor ([
}, / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
/ payload / h'8202584039383765656338356661393966643331 / digest-bytes /
6433333233383162393831306639306230356332653064346632383461366634323131 h'987eec85fa99fd31d332381b9810f90b05c2e0d4f284a6f4211207ed00fff750'
32303765643030666666373530' / [ ]),
/ algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /, / signature / h'750141d65b4f20a88dc70c6785a67e0f4f
/ digest-bytes / h'3938376565633835666139396664333 085aead83ba2289d6e37271508cc91e0a0592f5c940c2257c9c0b26403c0ba4477f2ce
1643333323338316239383130663930623035633265306434663238346136663432313 37b60089fe02cde7911d1c15'
132303765643030666666373530' ]))
] /, ]
/ signature / h'4931df82e153bf1e3af5a59800216d8a47c33a }),
37839e7d63d9f526fd369aa8359daae18f7619c959123e7f7f928ee92a9893afedd35d / manifest / 3:bstr .cbor ({
06a936d6ed3d5843bf2a'
]) /
] /,
/ manifest / 3:h'a50101020103585fa202818141000458568614a40150fa6b4
a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab450358248
202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba987654321
00e1987d0010f020f0958258613a115781b687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6
d2f66696c652e62696e1502030f0a4382030f' / {
/ manifest-version / 1:1, / manifest-version / 1:1,
/ manifest-sequence-number / 2:1, / manifest-sequence-number / 2:1,
/ common / 3:h'a202818141000458568614a40150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9 / common / 3:bstr .cbor ({
de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45035824820258200011223
3445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f0
20f' / {
/ components / 2:[ / components / 2:[
[h'00'] [h'00']
], ],
/ common-sequence / 4:h'8614a40150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663 / common-sequence / 4:bstr .cbor ([
e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab4503582482025820001122334455
66778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f'
/ [
/ directive-override-parameters / 20,{ / directive-override-parameters / 20,{
/ vendor-id / / vendor-id /
1:h'"fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe"' / fa6b4a53-d5ad-5fdf- 1:h'fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe' / fa6b4a53-d5ad-5fdf-
be9d-e663e4d41ffe /, be9d-e663e4d41ffe /,
/ class-id / / class-id / 2:h'1492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45'
/ 1492af14-2569-5e48-bf42-9b2d51f2ab45 /,
2:h'"1492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45"' / / image-digest / 3:bstr .cbor ([
1492af14-2569-5e48-bf42-9b2d51f2ab45 /,
/ image-digest / 3:h'8202582000112233445566778899a
abbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210' / [
/ algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /, / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
/ digest-bytes / / digest-bytes /
h'00112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210' h'00112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210'
] /, ]),
/ image-size / 14:34768, / image-size / 14:34768,
} , } ,
/ condition-vendor-identifier / 1,15 , / condition-vendor-identifier / 1,15 ,
/ condition-class-identifier / 2,15 / condition-class-identifier / 2,15
] /, ]),
} /, }),
/ install / 9:h'8613a115781b687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f / install / 9:bstr .cbor ([
6d2f66696c652e62696e1502030f' / [
/ directive-set-parameters / 19,{ / directive-set-parameters / 19,{
/ uri / 21:'http://example.com/file.bin', / uri / 21:'http://example.com/file.bin',
} , } ,
/ directive-fetch / 21,2 , / directive-fetch / 21,2 ,
/ condition-image-match / 3,15 / condition-image-match / 3,15
] /, ]),
/ validate / 10:h'82030f' / [ / validate / 10:bstr .cbor ([
/ condition-image-match / 3,15 / condition-image-match / 3,15
] /, ]),
} /, }),
} }
Total size of Envelope without COSE authentication object: 152 Total size of Envelope without COSE authentication object: 194
Envelope: Envelope:
a1035894a50101020103585fa202818141000458568614a40150fa6b4a53 a202582781582482025820987eec85fa99fd31d332381b9810f90b05c2e0
d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45 d4f284a6f4211207ed00fff750035894a50101020103585fa20281814100
0358248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcd 0458568614a40150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af14
effedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f0958258613a115781b68747470 25695e48bf429b2d51f2ab450358248202582000112233445566778899aa
3a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c652e62696e1502030f0a4382 bbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f09
030f 58258613a115781b687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c
652e62696e1502030f0a4382030f
Total size of Envelope with COSE authentication object: 301 Total size of Envelope with COSE authentication object: 307
Envelope with COSE authentication object: Envelope with COSE authentication object:
a202589281588fd28443a10126a058448202584039383765656338356661 a202589882582482025820987eec85fa99fd31d332381b9810f90b05c2e0
393966643331643333323338316239383130663930623035633265306434 d4f284a6f4211207ed00fff750586fd28443a10126a0582482025820987e
66323834613666343231313230376564303066666637353058404931df82 ec85fa99fd31d332381b9810f90b05c2e0d4f284a6f4211207ed00fff750
e153bf1e3af5a59800216d8a47c33a37839e7d63d9f526fd369aa8359daa 5840750141d65b4f20a88dc70c6785a67e0f4f085aead83ba2289d6e3727
e18f7619c959123e7f7f928ee92a9893afedd35d06a936d6ed3d5843bf2a 1508cc91e0a0592f5c940c2257c9c0b26403c0ba4477f2ce37b60089fe02
035894a50101020103585fa202818141000458568614a40150fa6b4a53d5 cde7911d1c15035894a50101020103585fa202818141000458568614a401
ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab4503 50fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b
58248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdef 2d51f2ab450358248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123
fedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f0958258613a115781b687474703a 456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f0958258613a11578
2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c652e62696e1502030f0a438203 1b687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c652e62696e1502
0f 030f0a4382030f
B.3. Example 2: Simultaneous Download, Installation, Secure Boot, B.3. Example 2: Simultaneous Download, Installation, Secure Boot,
Severed Fields Severed Fields
This example covers the following templates: This example covers the following templates:
- Compatibility Check (Section 7.1) - Compatibility Check (Section 7.1)
- Secure Boot (Section 7.2) - Secure Boot (Section 7.2)
skipping to change at page 88, line 27 skipping to change at page 93, line 4
B.3. Example 2: Simultaneous Download, Installation, Secure Boot, B.3. Example 2: Simultaneous Download, Installation, Secure Boot,
Severed Fields Severed Fields
This example covers the following templates: This example covers the following templates:
- Compatibility Check (Section 7.1) - Compatibility Check (Section 7.1)
- Secure Boot (Section 7.2) - Secure Boot (Section 7.2)
- Firmware Download (Section 7.3) - Firmware Download (Section 7.3)
This example also demonstrates severable elements (Section 5.5), and This example also demonstrates severable elements (Section 5.5), and
text (Section 8.6.4). text (Section 8.6.4).
{ {
/ authentication-wrapper / 2:h'81588fd28443a10126a0584482025840373 / authentication-wrapper / 2:bstr .cbor ({ digest: bstr
5363835353739613833626162643731656338656632326661343961633837336637386 .cbor ([
13730386134336136373465373832616433306236353938643137615840faca70796c3 / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
19ce6dae69690a64ced3ab91b9bb7f3e9a5004122d629d2816216a870448424ce4410d / digest-bytes /
658b80215185e32d8ec6feb15c7275d64437c36418463e4' / [ h'75685579a83babd71ec8ef22fa49ac873f78a708a43a674e782ad30b6598d17a'
h'd28443a10126a05844820258403735363835353739613833626162643731 ]) signatures: [
6563386566323266613439616338373366373861373038613433613637346537383261 bstr .cbor (18([
6433306236353938643137615840faca70796c319ce6dae69690a64ced3ab91b9bb7f3 / protected / bstr .cbor ({
e9a5004122d629d2816216a870448424ce4410d658b80215185e32d8ec6feb15c7275d / alg / 1:-7 / "ES256" /,
64437c36418463e4' / 18([ }),
/ protected / h'a10126' / { / unprotected / {
/ alg / 1:-7 / "ES256" /, },
} /, / payload / bstr .cbor ([
/ unprotected / { / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
}, / digest-bytes /
/ payload / h'8202584037353638353537396138336261626437 h'75685579a83babd71ec8ef22fa49ac873f78a708a43a674e782ad30b6598d17a'
3165633865663232666134396163383733663738613730386134336136373465373832 ]),
61643330623635393864313761' / [ / signature / h'861b9bfb449125742baa648bc9d148cba4
/ algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /, 5519cca8efecf705c2165ecdecaeba8b6ce2131284e66708788d741e8779d5973fa8e2
/ digest-bytes / h'3735363835353739613833626162643 5da49eb203c81920719da949'
7316563386566323266613439616338373366373861373038613433613637346537383 ]))
261643330623635393864313761' ]
] /, }),
/ signature / h'faca70796c319ce6dae69690a64ced3ab91b9b / manifest / 3:bstr .cbor ({
b7f3e9a5004122d629d2816216a870448424ce4410d658b80215185e32d8ec6feb15c7
275d64437c36418463e4'
]) /
] /,
/ manifest / 3:h'a70101020203585fa202818141000458568614a40150fa6b4
a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab450358248
202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba987654321
00e1987d0010f020f09820258203ee96dc79641970ae46b929ccf0b72ba9536dd84602
0dbdc9f949d84ea0e18d20a4382030f0c438217020d8202582023f48b2e2838650f43c
144234aee18401ffe3cce4733b23881c3a8ae2d2b66e8' / {
/ manifest-version / 1:1, / manifest-version / 1:1,
/ manifest-sequence-number / 2:2, / manifest-sequence-number / 2:2,
/ common / 3:h'a202818141000458568614a40150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9 / common / 3:bstr .cbor ({
de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45035824820258200011223
3445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f0
20f' / {
/ components / 2:[ / components / 2:[
[h'00'] [h'00']
], ],
/ common-sequence / 4:h'8614a40150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663 / common-sequence / 4:bstr .cbor ([
e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab4503582482025820001122334455
66778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f'
/ [
/ directive-override-parameters / 20,{ / directive-override-parameters / 20,{
/ vendor-id / / vendor-id /
1:h'"fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe"' / fa6b4a53-d5ad-5fdf- 1:h'fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe' / fa6b4a53-d5ad-5fdf-
be9d-e663e4d41ffe /, be9d-e663e4d41ffe /,
/ class-id / / class-id / 2:h'1492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45'
2:h'"1492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45"' / / 1492af14-2569-5e48-bf42-9b2d51f2ab45 /,
1492af14-2569-5e48-bf42-9b2d51f2ab45 /, / image-digest / 3:bstr .cbor ([
/ image-digest / 3:h'8202582000112233445566778899a
abbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210' / [
/ algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /, / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
/ digest-bytes / / digest-bytes /
h'00112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210' h'00112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210'
] /, ]),
/ image-size / 14:34768, / image-size / 14:34768,
} , } ,
/ condition-vendor-identifier / 1,15 , / condition-vendor-identifier / 1,15 ,
/ condition-class-identifier / 2,15 / condition-class-identifier / 2,15
] /, ]),
} /, }),
/ install / 9:[ / install / 9:[
/ algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /, / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
/ digest-bytes / / digest-bytes /
h'3ee96dc79641970ae46b929ccf0b72ba9536dd846020dbdc9f949d84ea0e18d2' h'3ee96dc79641970ae46b929ccf0b72ba9536dd846020dbdc9f949d84ea0e18d2'
], ],
/ validate / 10:h'82030f' / [ / validate / 10:bstr .cbor ([
/ condition-image-match / 3,15 / condition-image-match / 3,15
] /, ]),
/ run / 12:h'821702' / [ / run / 12:bstr .cbor ([
/ directive-run / 23,2 / directive-run / 23,2
] /, ]),
/ text / 13:[ / text / 13:[
/ algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /, / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
/ digest-bytes / / digest-bytes /
h'23f48b2e2838650f43c144234aee18401ffe3cce4733b23881c3a8ae2d2b66e8' h'23f48b2e2838650f43c144234aee18401ffe3cce4733b23881c3a8ae2d2b66e8'
], ],
} /, }),
/ install / 9:h'8613a1157832687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f / install / 9:bstr .cbor ([
766572792f6c6f6e672f706174682f746f2f66696c652f66696c652e62696e1502030f
' / [
/ directive-set-parameters / 19,{ / directive-set-parameters / 19,{
/ uri / / uri /
21:'http://example.com/very/long/path/to/file/file.bin', 21:'http://example.com/very/long/path/to/file/file.bin',
} , } ,
/ directive-fetch / 21,2 , / directive-fetch / 21,2 ,
/ condition-image-match / 3,15 / condition-image-match / 3,15
] /, ]),
/ text / 13:h'a1814100a2036761726d2e636f6d0578525468697320636f6d70 / text / 13:bstr .cbor ({
6f6e656e7420697320612064656d6f6e7374726174696f6e2e20546865206469676573
7420697320612073616d706c65207061747465726e2c206e6f742061207265616c206f
6e652e' / {
[h'00']:{ [h'00']:{
/ vendor-domain / 3:'arm.com', / vendor-domain / 3:'arm.com',
/ component-description / 5:'This component is a / component-description / 5:'This component is a
demonstration. The digest is a sample pattern, not a real one.', demonstration. The digest is a sample pattern, not a real one.',
} }
} /, }),
} }
Total size of the Envelope without COSE authentication object or Total size of the Envelope without COSE authentication object or
Severable Elements: 191 Severable Elements: 233
Envelope: Envelope:
a10358bba70101020203585fa202818141000458568614a40150fa6b4a53 a20258278158248202582075685579a83babd71ec8ef22fa49ac873f78a7
d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45 08a43a674e782ad30b6598d17a0358bba70101020203585fa20281814100
0358248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcd 0458568614a40150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af14
effedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f09820258203ee96dc79641970a 25695e48bf429b2d51f2ab450358248202582000112233445566778899aa
e46b929ccf0b72ba9536dd846020dbdc9f949d84ea0e18d20a4382030f0c bbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f09
438217020d8202582023f48b2e2838650f43c144234aee18401ffe3cce47 820258203ee96dc79641970ae46b929ccf0b72ba9536dd846020dbdc9f94
33b23881c3a8ae2d2b66e8 9d84ea0e18d20a4382030f0c438217020d8202582023f48b2e2838650f43
c144234aee18401ffe3cce4733b23881c3a8ae2d2b66e8
Total size of the Envelope with COSE authentication object but Total size of the Envelope with COSE authentication object but
without Severable Elements: 340 without Severable Elements: 346
Envelope: Envelope:
a202589281588fd28443a10126a058448202584037353638353537396138 a20258988258248202582075685579a83babd71ec8ef22fa49ac873f78a7
336261626437316563386566323266613439616338373366373861373038 08a43a674e782ad30b6598d17a586fd28443a10126a05824820258207568
6134336136373465373832616433306236353938643137615840faca7079 5579a83babd71ec8ef22fa49ac873f78a708a43a674e782ad30b6598d17a
6c319ce6dae69690a64ced3ab91b9bb7f3e9a5004122d629d2816216a870 5840861b9bfb449125742baa648bc9d148cba45519cca8efecf705c2165e
448424ce4410d658b80215185e32d8ec6feb15c7275d64437c36418463e4 cdecaeba8b6ce2131284e66708788d741e8779d5973fa8e25da49eb203c8
0358bba70101020203585fa202818141000458568614a40150fa6b4a53d5 1920719da9490358bba70101020203585fa202818141000458568614a401
ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab4503 50fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b
58248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdef 2d51f2ab450358248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123
fedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f09820258203ee96dc79641970ae4 456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f09820258203ee96d
6b929ccf0b72ba9536dd846020dbdc9f949d84ea0e18d20a4382030f0c43 c79641970ae46b929ccf0b72ba9536dd846020dbdc9f949d84ea0e18d20a
8217020d8202582023f48b2e2838650f43c144234aee18401ffe3cce4733 4382030f0c438217020d8202582023f48b2e2838650f43c144234aee1840
b23881c3a8ae2d2b66e8 1ffe3cce4733b23881c3a8ae2d2b66e8
Total size of Envelope with COSE authentication object: 923 Total size of Envelope with COSE authentication object: 929
Envelope with COSE authentication object: Envelope with COSE authentication object:
a402589281588fd28443a10126a058448202584037353638353537396138 a40258988258248202582075685579a83babd71ec8ef22fa49ac873f78a7
336261626437316563386566323266613439616338373366373861373038 08a43a674e782ad30b6598d17a586fd28443a10126a05824820258207568
6134336136373465373832616433306236353938643137615840faca7079 5579a83babd71ec8ef22fa49ac873f78a708a43a674e782ad30b6598d17a
6c319ce6dae69690a64ced3ab91b9bb7f3e9a5004122d629d2816216a870 5840861b9bfb449125742baa648bc9d148cba45519cca8efecf705c2165e
448424ce4410d658b80215185e32d8ec6feb15c7275d64437c36418463e4 cdecaeba8b6ce2131284e66708788d741e8779d5973fa8e25da49eb203c8
0358bba70101020203585fa202818141000458568614a40150fa6b4a53d5 1920719da9490358bba70101020203585fa202818141000458568614a401
ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab4503 50fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b
58248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdef 2d51f2ab450358248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123
fedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f09820258203ee96dc79641970ae4 456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f09820258203ee96d
6b929ccf0b72ba9536dd846020dbdc9f949d84ea0e18d20a4382030f0c43 c79641970ae46b929ccf0b72ba9536dd846020dbdc9f949d84ea0e18d20a
8217020d8202582023f48b2e2838650f43c144234aee18401ffe3cce4733 4382030f0c438217020d8202582023f48b2e2838650f43c144234aee1840
b23881c3a8ae2d2b66e809583c8613a1157832687474703a2f2f6578616d 1ffe3cce4733b23881c3a8ae2d2b66e809583c8613a1157832687474703a
706c652e636f6d2f766572792f6c6f6e672f706174682f746f2f66696c65 2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f766572792f6c6f6e672f706174682f74
2f66696c652e62696e1502030f0d590204a20179019d2323204578616d70 6f2f66696c652f66696c652e62696e1502030f0d590204a20179019d2323
6c6520323a2053696d756c74616e656f757320446f776e6c6f61642c2049 204578616d706c6520323a2053696d756c74616e656f757320446f776e6c
6e7374616c6c6174696f6e2c2053656375726520426f6f742c2053657665 6f61642c20496e7374616c6c6174696f6e2c2053656375726520426f6f74
726564204669656c64730a0a2020202054686973206578616d706c652063 2c2053657665726564204669656c64730a0a202020205468697320657861
6f766572732074686520666f6c6c6f77696e672074656d706c617465733a 6d706c6520636f766572732074686520666f6c6c6f77696e672074656d70
0a202020200a202020202a20436f6d7061746962696c6974792043686563 6c617465733a0a202020200a202020202a20436f6d7061746962696c6974
6b20287b7b74656d706c6174652d636f6d7061746962696c6974792d6368 7920436865636b20287b7b74656d706c6174652d636f6d7061746962696c
65636b7d7d290a202020202a2053656375726520426f6f7420287b7b7465 6974792d636865636b7d7d290a202020202a2053656375726520426f6f74
6d706c6174652d7365637572652d626f6f747d7d290a202020202a204669 20287b7b74656d706c6174652d7365637572652d626f6f747d7d290a2020
726d7761726520446f776e6c6f616420287b7b6669726d776172652d646f 20202a204669726d7761726520446f776e6c6f616420287b7b6669726d77
776e6c6f61642d74656d706c6174657d7d290a202020200a202020205468 6172652d646f776e6c6f61642d74656d706c6174657d7d290a202020200a
6973206578616d706c6520616c736f2064656d6f6e737472617465732073 2020202054686973206578616d706c6520616c736f2064656d6f6e737472
6576657261626c6520656c656d656e747320287b7b6f76722d7365766572 6174657320736576657261626c6520656c656d656e747320287b7b6f7672
61626c657d7d292c20616e64207465787420287b7b6d616e69666573742d 2d736576657261626c657d7d292c20616e64207465787420287b7b6d616e
6469676573742d746578747d7d292e814100a2036761726d2e636f6d0578 69666573742d6469676573742d746578747d7d292e814100a2036761726d
525468697320636f6d706f6e656e7420697320612064656d6f6e73747261 2e636f6d0578525468697320636f6d706f6e656e7420697320612064656d
74696f6e2e205468652064696765737420697320612073616d706c652070 6f6e7374726174696f6e2e20546865206469676573742069732061207361
61747465726e2c206e6f742061207265616c206f6e652e 6d706c65207061747465726e2c206e6f742061207265616c206f6e652e
B.4. Example 3: A/B images B.4. Example 3: A/B images
This example covers the following templates: This example covers the following templates:
- Compatibility Check (Section 7.1) - Compatibility Check (Section 7.1)
- Secure Boot (Section 7.2) - Secure Boot (Section 7.2)
- Firmware Download (Section 7.3) - Firmware Download (Section 7.3)
- A/B Image Template (Section 7.10) - A/B Image Template (Section 7.11)
{ {
/ authentication-wrapper / 2:h'81588fd28443a10126a0584482025840616 / authentication-wrapper / 2:bstr .cbor ({ digest: bstr
5306331656136383963393830306138343335353066333837393662366664626435326 .cbor ([
1306337386265356432363031316438653738346461343364343763584010222ddbce4 / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
e82a85f6ec7b72db34d7c5be8d2e822e4b2d099a4cf1d08aa2174c56c2e93bf20c785b / digest-bytes /
ca298900208d92d352faf86e6cddc902a726bbc443c21ff' / [ h'ae0c1ea689c9800a843550f38796b6fdbd52a0c78be5d26011d8e784da43d47c'
h'd28443a10126a05844820258406165306331656136383963393830306138 ]) signatures: [
3433353530663338373936623666646264353261306337386265356432363031316438 bstr .cbor (18([
653738346461343364343763584010222ddbce4e82a85f6ec7b72db34d7c5be8d2e822 / protected / bstr .cbor ({
e4b2d099a4cf1d08aa2174c56c2e93bf20c785bca298900208d92d352faf86e6cddc90 / alg / 1:-7 / "ES256" /,
2a726bbc443c21ff' / 18([ }),
/ protected / h'a10126' / { / unprotected / {
/ alg / 1:-7 / "ES256" /, },
} /, / payload / bstr .cbor ([
/ unprotected / { / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
}, / digest-bytes /
/ payload / h'8202584061653063316561363839633938303061 h'ae0c1ea689c9800a843550f38796b6fdbd52a0c78be5d26011d8e784da43d47c'
3834333535306633383739366236666462643532613063373862653564323630313164 ]),
38653738346461343364343763' / [ / signature / h'359960bae5a7de2457c8f48d3250d96d1a
/ algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /, f2d36e08764b62d76f8a3f3041774b150b2c835bb1b2d7b1b2e629e1f08cc3b1b48fce
/ digest-bytes / h'6165306331656136383963393830306 bb8fb38182c116161e02b33f'
1383433353530663338373936623666646264353261306337386265356432363031316 ]))
438653738346461343364343763' ]
] /, }),
/ signature / h'10222ddbce4e82a85f6ec7b72db34d7c5be8d2 / manifest / 3:bstr .cbor ({
e822e4b2d099a4cf1d08aa2174c56c2e93bf20c785bca298900208d92d352faf86e6cd
dc902a726bbc443c21ff'
]) /
] /,
/ manifest / 3:h'a5010102030358aaa202818141000458a18814a20150fa6b4
a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab450f82583
68614a105198400050514a20358248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0
123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0583a8614a1051a00084400050514a20
35824820258200123456789abcdeffedcba987654321000112233445566778899aabbc
cddeeff0e1a00012c22010f020f095861860f82582a8613a105198400050513a115781
c687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c65312e62696e582c8613a1051
a00084400050513a115781c687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c653
22e62696e1502030f0a4382030f' / {
/ manifest-version / 1:1, / manifest-version / 1:1,
/ manifest-sequence-number / 2:3, / manifest-sequence-number / 2:3,
/ common / 3:h'a202818141000458a18814a20150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9 / common / 3:bstr .cbor ({
de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab450f8258368614a10519840
0050514a20358248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcde
ffedcba98765432100e1987d0583a8614a1051a00084400050514a2035824820258200
123456789abcdeffedcba987654321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0e1a000
12c22010f020f' / {
/ components / 2:[ / components / 2:[
[h'00'] [h'00']
], ],
/ common-sequence / 4:h'8814a20150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663 / common-sequence / 4:bstr .cbor ([
e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab450f8258368614a1051984000505
14a20358248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedc
ba98765432100e1987d0583a8614a1051a00084400050514a203582482025820012345
6789abcdeffedcba987654321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0e1a00012c22
010f020f' / [
/ directive-override-parameters / 20,{ / directive-override-parameters / 20,{
/ vendor-id / / vendor-id /
1:h'"fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe"' / fa6b4a53-d5ad-5fdf- 1:h'fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe' / fa6b4a53-d5ad-5fdf-
be9d-e663e4d41ffe /, be9d-e663e4d41ffe /,
/ class-id / / class-id / 2:h'1492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45'
2:h'"1492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45"' / / 1492af14-2569-5e48-bf42-9b2d51f2ab45 /,
1492af14-2569-5e48-bf42-9b2d51f2ab45 /,
} , } ,
/ directive-try-each / 15,[ / directive-try-each / 15,[
h'8614a105198400050514a203582482025820001122334455 bstr .cbor ([
66778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0' / [
/ directive-override-parameters / 20,{ / directive-override-parameters / 20,{
/ offset / 5:33792, / offset / 5:33792,
} , } ,
/ condition-component-offset / 5,5 , / condition-component-offset / 5,5 ,
/ directive-override-parameters / 20,{ / directive-override-parameters / 20,{
/ image-digest / 3:h'820258200011223344556 / image-digest / 3:bstr .cbor ([
6778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210' / [
/ algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /, / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
/ digest-bytes / / digest-bytes /
h'00112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210' h'00112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210'
] /, ]),
/ image-size / 14:34768, / image-size / 14:34768,
} }
] / , ]) ,
h'8614a1051a00084400050514a20358248202582001234567 bstr .cbor ([
89abcdeffedcba987654321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0e1a00012c22'
/ [
/ directive-override-parameters / 20,{ / directive-override-parameters / 20,{
/ offset / 5:541696, / offset / 5:541696,
} , } ,
/ condition-component-offset / 5,5 , / condition-component-offset / 5,5 ,
/ directive-override-parameters / 20,{ / directive-override-parameters / 20,{
/ image-digest / 3:h'820258200123456789abc / image-digest / 3:bstr .cbor ([
deffedcba987654321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff' / [
/ algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /, / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
/ digest-bytes / / digest-bytes /
h'0123456789abcdeffedcba987654321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff' h'0123456789abcdeffedcba987654321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff'
] /, ]),
/ image-size / 14:76834, / image-size / 14:76834,
} }
] / ])
] , ] ,
/ condition-vendor-identifier / 1,15 , / condition-vendor-identifier / 1,15 ,
/ condition-class-identifier / 2,15 / condition-class-identifier / 2,15
]),
] /, }),
} /, / install / 9:bstr .cbor ([
/ install / 9:h'860f82582a8613a105198400050513a115781c68747470
3a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c65312e62696e582c8613a1051a00084400
050513a115781c687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c65322e62696e
1502030f' / [
/ directive-try-each / 15,[ / directive-try-each / 15,[
h'8613a105198400050513a115781c687474703a2f2f6578616d70 bstr .cbor ([
6c652e636f6d2f66696c65312e62696e' / [
/ directive-set-parameters / 19,{ / directive-set-parameters / 19,{
/ offset / 5:33792, / offset / 5:33792,
} , } ,
/ condition-component-offset / 5,5 , / condition-component-offset / 5,5 ,
/ directive-set-parameters / 19,{ / directive-set-parameters / 19,{
/ uri / 21:'http://example.com/file1.bin', / uri / 21:'http://example.com/file1.bin',
} }
] / , ]) ,
h'8613a1051a00084400050513a115781c687474703a2f2f657861 bstr .cbor ([
6d706c652e636f6d2f66696c65322e62696e' / [
/ directive-set-parameters / 19,{ / directive-set-parameters / 19,{
/ offset / 5:541696, / offset / 5:541696,
} , } ,
/ condition-component-offset / 5,5 , / condition-component-offset / 5,5 ,
/ directive-set-parameters / 19,{ / directive-set-parameters / 19,{
/ uri / 21:'http://example.com/file2.bin', / uri / 21:'http://example.com/file2.bin',
} }
] / ])
] , ] ,
/ directive-fetch / 21,2 , / directive-fetch / 21,2 ,
/ condition-image-match / 3,15 / condition-image-match / 3,15
] /, ]),
/ validate / 10:h'82030f' / [ / validate / 10:bstr .cbor ([
/ condition-image-match / 3,15 / condition-image-match / 3,15
] /, ]),
} /,
}),
} }
Total size of Envelope without COSE authentication object: 288 Total size of Envelope without COSE authentication object: 330
Envelope: Envelope:
a10359011ba5010102030358aaa202818141000458a18814a20150fa6b4a a202582781582482025820ae0c1ea689c9800a843550f38796b6fdbd52a0
53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab c78be5d26011d8e784da43d47c0359011ba5010102030358aaa202818141
450f8258368614a105198400050514a20358248202582000112233445566 000458a18814a20150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af
778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d058 1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab450f8258368614a105198400050514a20358
3a8614a1051a00084400050514a2035824820258200123456789abcdeffe 248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffe
dcba987654321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0e1a00012c2201 dcba98765432100e1987d0583a8614a1051a00084400050514a203582482
0f020f095861860f82582a8613a105198400050513a115781c687474703a 0258200123456789abcdeffedcba987654321000112233445566778899aa
2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c65312e62696e582c8613a1051a bbccddeeff0e1a00012c22010f020f095861860f82582a8613a105198400
00084400050513a115781c687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f 050513a115781c687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c65
66696c65322e62696e1502030f0a4382030f 312e62696e582c8613a1051a00084400050513a115781c687474703a2f2f
6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c65322e62696e1502030f0a4382030f
Total size of Envelope with COSE authentication object: 437 Total size of Envelope with COSE authentication object: 443
Envelope with COSE authentication object: Envelope with COSE authentication object:
a202589281588fd28443a10126a058448202584061653063316561363839 a202589882582482025820ae0c1ea689c9800a843550f38796b6fdbd52a0
633938303061383433353530663338373936623666646264353261306337 c78be5d26011d8e784da43d47c586fd28443a10126a0582482025820ae0c
386265356432363031316438653738346461343364343763584010222ddb 1ea689c9800a843550f38796b6fdbd52a0c78be5d26011d8e784da43d47c
ce4e82a85f6ec7b72db34d7c5be8d2e822e4b2d099a4cf1d08aa2174c56c 5840359960bae5a7de2457c8f48d3250d96d1af2d36e08764b62d76f8a3f
2e93bf20c785bca298900208d92d352faf86e6cddc902a726bbc443c21ff 3041774b150b2c835bb1b2d7b1b2e629e1f08cc3b1b48fcebb8fb38182c1
0359011ba5010102030358aaa202818141000458a18814a20150fa6b4a53 16161e02b33f0359011ba5010102030358aaa202818141000458a18814a2
d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45 0150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf42
0f8258368614a105198400050514a2035824820258200011223344556677 9b2d51f2ab450f8258368614a105198400050514a2035824820258200011
8899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0583a 2233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210
8614a1051a00084400050514a2035824820258200123456789abcdeffedc 0e1987d0583a8614a1051a00084400050514a20358248202582001234567
ba987654321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0e1a00012c22010f 89abcdeffedcba987654321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0e1a
020f095861860f82582a8613a105198400050513a115781c687474703a2f 00012c22010f020f095861860f82582a8613a105198400050513a115781c
2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c65312e62696e582c8613a1051a00 687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c65312e62696e582c
084400050513a115781c687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66 8613a1051a00084400050513a115781c687474703a2f2f6578616d706c65
696c65322e62696e1502030f0a4382030f 2e636f6d2f66696c65322e62696e1502030f0a4382030f
B.5. Example 4: Load and Decompress from External Storage B.5. Example 4: Load and Decompress from External Storage
This example covers the following templates: This example covers the following templates:
- Compatibility Check (Section 7.1) - Compatibility Check (Section 7.1)
- Secure Boot (Section 7.2) - Secure Boot (Section 7.2)
- Firmware Download (Section 7.3) - Firmware Download (Section 7.3)
skipping to change at page 96, line 45 skipping to change at page 100, line 4
B.5. Example 4: Load and Decompress from External Storage B.5. Example 4: Load and Decompress from External Storage
This example covers the following templates: This example covers the following templates:
- Compatibility Check (Section 7.1) - Compatibility Check (Section 7.1)
- Secure Boot (Section 7.2) - Secure Boot (Section 7.2)
- Firmware Download (Section 7.3) - Firmware Download (Section 7.3)
- Install (Section 7.4) - Install (Section 7.4)
- Load & Decompress (Section 7.7) - Load & Decompress (Section 7.8)
{ {
/ authentication-wrapper / 2:h'81588fd28443a10126a0584482025840346 / authentication-wrapper / 2:bstr .cbor ({ digest: bstr
2346337633863306664613736633963393539316139646231363039313865326233633 .cbor ([
93661353862306135653439383466643465386639333539613932385840d7063361f65 / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
3d57e63691e1bd9c856058c773b94e488bff58d599c45277788e90eb92fbef666f584e / digest-bytes /
8d35b3b20ceef50a69b94dcff12beee92e426a06ea31320' / [ h'4b4c7c8c0fda76c9c9591a9db160918e2b3c96a58b0a5e4984fd4e8f9359a928'
h'd28443a10126a05844820258403462346337633863306664613736633963 ]) signatures: [
3935393161396462313630393138653262336339366135386230613565343938346664 bstr .cbor (18([
3465386639333539613932385840d7063361f653d57e63691e1bd9c856058c773b94e4 / protected / bstr .cbor ({
88bff58d599c45277788e90eb92fbef666f584e8d35b3b20ceef50a69b94dcff12beee / alg / 1:-7 / "ES256" /,
92e426a06ea31320' / 18([ }),
/ protected / h'a10126' / { / unprotected / {
/ alg / 1:-7 / "ES256" /, },
} /, / payload / bstr .cbor ([
/ unprotected / { / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
}, / digest-bytes /
/ payload / h'8202584034623463376338633066646137366339 h'4b4c7c8c0fda76c9c9591a9db160918e2b3c96a58b0a5e4984fd4e8f9359a928'
6339353931613964623136303931386532623363393661353862306135653439383466 ]),
64346538663933353961393238' / [ / signature / h'd721cb3415f27cfeb8ef066bb6312ba758
/ algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /, 32b57410a0c700de71cf8004ea23b9dd3c912a99fab111e9b8f2cc55c7dffcc37012de
/ digest-bytes / h'3462346337633863306664613736633 cf72e44f69b3d3db8cc98cb6'
9633935393161396462313630393138653262336339366135386230613565343938346 ]))
664346538663933353961393238' ]
] /, }),
/ signature / h'd7063361f653d57e63691e1bd9c856058c773b / manifest / 3:bstr .cbor ({
94e488bff58d599c45277788e90eb92fbef666f584e8d35b3b20ceef50a69b94dcff12
beee92e426a06ea31320'
]) /
] /,
/ manifest / 3:h'a801010204035867a20283814100814102814101045858880
c0014a40150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2
d51f2ab450358248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcde
ffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f085827880c0113a115781b687474703a2f2f6
578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c652e62696e1502030f094b880c0013a1160116020
30f0a45840c00030f0b583a880c0213a4035824820258200123456789abcdeffedcba9
87654321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0e1a00012c22130116001602030f0
c45840c021702' / {
/ manifest-version / 1:1, / manifest-version / 1:1,
/ manifest-sequence-number / 2:4, / manifest-sequence-number / 2:4,
/ common / 3:h'a20283814100814102814101045858880c0014a40150fa6 / common / 3:bstr .cbor ({
b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab4503582
48202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543
2100e1987d0010f020f' / {
/ components / 2:[ / components / 2:[
[h'00'] , [h'00'] ,
[h'02'] , [h'02'] ,
[h'01'] [h'01']
], ],
/ common-sequence / 4:h'880c0014a40150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9d / common-sequence / 4:bstr .cbor ([
e663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab450358248202582000112233
445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f02
0f' / [
/ directive-set-component-index / 12,0 , / directive-set-component-index / 12,0 ,
/ directive-override-parameters / 20,{ / directive-override-parameters / 20,{
/ vendor-id / / vendor-id /
1:h'"fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe"' / fa6b4a53-d5ad-5fdf- 1:h'fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe' / fa6b4a53-d5ad-5fdf-
be9d-e663e4d41ffe /, be9d-e663e4d41ffe /,
/ class-id / / class-id / 2:h'1492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45'
2:h'"1492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45"' / / 1492af14-2569-5e48-bf42-9b2d51f2ab45 /,
1492af14-2569-5e48-bf42-9b2d51f2ab45 /, / image-digest / 3:bstr .cbor ([
/ image-digest / 3:h'8202582000112233445566778899a
abbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210' / [
/ algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /, / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
/ digest-bytes / / digest-bytes /
h'00112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210' h'00112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210'
] /, ]),
/ image-size / 14:34768, / image-size / 14:34768,
} , } ,
/ condition-vendor-identifier / 1,15 , / condition-vendor-identifier / 1,15 ,
/ condition-class-identifier / 2,15 / condition-class-identifier / 2,15
] /, ]),
} /, }),
/ payload-fetch / 8:h'880c0113a115781b687474703a2f2f6578616d70 / payload-fetch / 8:bstr .cbor ([
6c652e636f6d2f66696c652e62696e1502030f' / [
/ directive-set-component-index / 12,1 , / directive-set-component-index / 12,1 ,
/ directive-set-parameters / 19,{ / directive-set-parameters / 19,{
/ uri / 21:'http://example.com/file.bin', / uri / 21:'http://example.com/file.bin',
} , } ,
/ directive-fetch / 21,2 , / directive-fetch / 21,2 ,
/ condition-image-match / 3,15 / condition-image-match / 3,15
] /, ]),
/ install / 9:h'880c0013a116011602030f' / [ / install / 9:bstr .cbor ([
/ directive-set-component-index / 12,0 , / directive-set-component-index / 12,0 ,
/ directive-set-parameters / 19,{ / directive-set-parameters / 19,{
/ source-component / 22:1 / [h'02'] /, / source-component / 22:1 / [h'02'] /,
} , } ,
/ directive-copy / 22,2 , / directive-copy / 22,2 ,
/ condition-image-match / 3,15 / condition-image-match / 3,15
] /, ]),
/ validate / 10:h'840c00030f' / [ / validate / 10:bstr .cbor ([
/ directive-set-component-index / 12,0 , / directive-set-component-index / 12,0 ,
/ condition-image-match / 3,15 / condition-image-match / 3,15
] /, ]),
/ load / 11:h'880c0213a4035824820258200123456789abcdeffedcba98 / load / 11:bstr .cbor ([
7654321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0e1a00012c22130116001602030f'
/ [
/ directive-set-component-index / 12,2 , / directive-set-component-index / 12,2 ,
/ directive-set-parameters / 19,{ / directive-set-parameters / 19,{
/ image-digest / 3:h'820258200123456789abcdeffedcba987 / image-digest / 3:bstr .cbor ([
654321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff' / [
/ algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /, / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
/ digest-bytes / / digest-bytes /
h'0123456789abcdeffedcba987654321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff' h'0123456789abcdeffedcba987654321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff'
] /, ]),
/ image-size / 14:76834, / image-size / 14:76834,
/ source-component / 22:0 / [h'00'] /, / source-component / 22:0 / [h'00'] /,
/ compression-info / 19:1 / "gzip" /, / compression-info / 19:1 / "gzip" /,
} , } ,
/ directive-copy / 22,2 , / directive-copy / 22,2 ,
/ condition-image-match / 3,15 / condition-image-match / 3,15
] /, ]),
/ run / 12:h'840c021702' / [ / run / 12:bstr .cbor ([
/ directive-set-component-index / 12,2 , / directive-set-component-index / 12,2 ,
/ directive-run / 23,2 / directive-run / 23,2
] /, ]),
} /, }),
} }
Total size of Envelope without COSE authentication object: 245 Total size of Envelope without COSE authentication object: 287
Envelope: Envelope:
a10358f1a801010204035867a20283814100814102814101045858880c00 a2025827815824820258204b4c7c8c0fda76c9c9591a9db160918e2b3c96
14a40150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48 a58b0a5e4984fd4e8f9359a9280358f1a801010204035867a20283814100
bf429b2d51f2ab450358248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddee 814102814101045858880c0014a40150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d4
ff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f085827880c 1ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab4503582482025820001122
0113a115781b687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c652e 33445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e
62696e1502030f094b880c0013a116011602030f0a45840c00030f0b583a 1987d0010f020f085827880c0113a115781b687474703a2f2f6578616d70
880c0213a4035824820258200123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100011 6c652e636f6d2f66696c652e62696e1502030f094b880c0013a116011602
2233445566778899aabbccddeeff0e1a00012c22130116001602030f0c45 030f0a45840c00030f0b583a880c0213a4035824820258200123456789ab
840c021702 cdeffedcba987654321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0e1a0001
2c22130116001602030f0c45840c021702
Total size of Envelope with COSE authentication object: 394 Total size of Envelope with COSE authentication object: 400
Envelope with COSE authentication object: Envelope with COSE authentication object:
a202589281588fd28443a10126a058448202584034623463376338633066 a2025898825824820258204b4c7c8c0fda76c9c9591a9db160918e2b3c96
646137366339633935393161396462313630393138653262336339366135 a58b0a5e4984fd4e8f9359a928586fd28443a10126a05824820258204b4c
3862306135653439383466643465386639333539613932385840d7063361 7c8c0fda76c9c9591a9db160918e2b3c96a58b0a5e4984fd4e8f9359a928
f653d57e63691e1bd9c856058c773b94e488bff58d599c45277788e90eb9 5840d721cb3415f27cfeb8ef066bb6312ba75832b57410a0c700de71cf80
2fbef666f584e8d35b3b20ceef50a69b94dcff12beee92e426a06ea31320 04ea23b9dd3c912a99fab111e9b8f2cc55c7dffcc37012decf72e44f69b3
0358f1a801010204035867a20283814100814102814101045858880c0014 d3db8cc98cb60358f1a801010204035867a2028381410081410281410104
a40150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf 5858880c0014a40150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af
429b2d51f2ab450358248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff 1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab450358248202582000112233445566778899
0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f085827880c01 aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f
13a115781b687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c652e62 085827880c0113a115781b687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f
696e1502030f094b880c0013a116011602030f0a45840c00030f0b583a88 66696c652e62696e1502030f094b880c0013a116011602030f0a45840c00
0c0213a4035824820258200123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210001122 030f0b583a880c0213a4035824820258200123456789abcdeffedcba9876
33445566778899aabbccddeeff0e1a00012c22130116001602030f0c4584 54321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0e1a00012c221301160016
0c021702 02030f0c45840c021702
B.6. Example 5: Two Images B.6. Example 5: Two Images
This example covers the following templates: This example covers the following templates:
- Compatibility Check (Section 7.1) - Compatibility Check (Section 7.1)
- Secure Boot (Section 7.2) - Secure Boot (Section 7.2)
- Firmware Download (Section 7.3) - Firmware Download (Section 7.3)
Furthermore, it shows using these templates with two images. Furthermore, it shows using these templates with two images.
{ {
/ authentication-wrapper / 2:h'81588fd28443a10126a0584482025840323 / authentication-wrapper / 2:bstr .cbor ({ digest: bstr
1306231323835306332333930393164386538326330653965393130363632623638616 .cbor ([
33834323435386136343138653333663637303165643538333432635840b5b8cb30c2b / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
bb646c4d32426d72768668d6d6af54c26ac46c4020ca37ada47b9468340b4d0b2ddd15 / digest-bytes /
db824a7e6b0bc233e753940dfb7131fa145ddc456da3cf6' / [ h'de7c7927a15bd2eda59cab1512875f17c9f1e9e23885ce1ac6d671eefcefa37a'
h'd28443a10126a05844820258403231306231323835306332333930393164 ]) signatures: [
3865383263306539653931303636326236386163383432343538613634313865333366 bstr .cbor (18([
3637303165643538333432635840b5b8cb30c2bbb646c4d32426d72768668d6d6af54c / protected / bstr .cbor ({
26ac46c4020ca37ada47b9468340b4d0b2ddd15db824a7e6b0bc233e753940dfb7131f / alg / 1:-7 / "ES256" /,
a145ddc456da3cf6' / 18([ }),
/ protected / h'a10126' / { / unprotected / {
/ alg / 1:-7 / "ES256" /, },
} /, / payload / bstr .cbor ([
/ unprotected / { / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
}, / digest-bytes /
/ payload / h'8202584032313062313238353063323339303931 h'de7c7927a15bd2eda59cab1512875f17c9f1e9e23885ce1ac6d671eefcefa37a'
6438653832633065396539313036363262363861633834323435386136343138653333 ]),
66363730316564353833343263' / [ / signature / h'e71e332c985fb0479f296685669d05348b
/ algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /, cdba8e186f25a5418f4682ea168df61661f54bf48f964577225ed455b22d277dd94de8
/ digest-bytes / h'3231306231323835306332333930393 7c57f1baceedd6719f3d56ec'
]))
1643865383263306539653931303636326236386163383432343538613634313865333 ]
366363730316564353833343263' }),
] /, / manifest / 3:bstr .cbor ({
/ signature / h'b5b8cb30c2bbb646c4d32426d72768668d6d6a
f54c26ac46c4020ca37ada47b9468340b4d0b2ddd15db824a7e6b0bc233e753940dfb7
131fa145ddc456da3cf6'
]) /
] /,
/ manifest / 3:h'a601010205035895a202828141008141010458898c0c0014a
40150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2a
b450358248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcb
a98765432100e1987d0010f020f0c0114a2035824820258200123456789abcdeffedcb
a987654321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0e1a00012c2209584f900c0013a
115781c687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c65312e62696e1502030
f0c0113a115781c687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c65322e62696
e1502030f0a49880c00030f0c01030f0c47860c0017021702' / {
/ manifest-version / 1:1, / manifest-version / 1:1,
/ manifest-sequence-number / 2:5, / manifest-sequence-number / 2:5,
/ common / 3:h'a202828141008141010458898c0c0014a40150fa6b4a53d / common / 3:bstr .cbor ({
5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab4503582482025
82000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1
987d0010f020f0c0114a2035824820258200123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210001
12233445566778899aabbccddeeff0e1a00012c22' / {
/ components / 2:[ / components / 2:[
[h'00'] , [h'00'] ,
[h'01'] [h'01']
], ],
/ common-sequence / 4:h'8c0c0014a40150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9d / common-sequence / 4:bstr .cbor ([
e663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab450358248202582000112233
445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f02
0f0c0114a2035824820258200123456789abcdeffedcba987654321000112233445566
778899aabbccddeeff0e1a00012c22' / [
/ directive-set-component-index / 12,0 , / directive-set-component-index / 12,0 ,
/ directive-override-parameters / 20,{ / directive-override-parameters / 20,{
/ vendor-id / / vendor-id /
1:h'"fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe"' / fa6b4a53-d5ad-5fdf- 1:h'fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe' / fa6b4a53-d5ad-5fdf-
be9d-e663e4d41ffe /, be9d-e663e4d41ffe /,
/ class-id / / class-id / 2:h'1492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45'
2:h'"1492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45"' / / 1492af14-2569-5e48-bf42-9b2d51f2ab45 /,
1492af14-2569-5e48-bf42-9b2d51f2ab45 /, / image-digest / 3:bstr .cbor ([
/ image-digest / 3:h'8202582000112233445566778899a
abbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210' / [
/ algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /, / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
/ digest-bytes / / digest-bytes /
h'00112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210' h'00112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba9876543210'
] /, ]),
/ image-size / 14:34768, / image-size / 14:34768,
} , } ,
/ condition-vendor-identifier / 1,15 , / condition-vendor-identifier / 1,15 ,
/ condition-class-identifier / 2,15 , / condition-class-identifier / 2,15 ,
/ directive-set-component-index / 12,1 , / directive-set-component-index / 12,1 ,
/ directive-override-parameters / 20,{ / directive-override-parameters / 20,{
/ image-digest / 3:h'820258200123456789abcdeffedcb / image-digest / 3:bstr .cbor ([
a987654321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff' / [
/ algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /, / algorithm-id / 2 / "sha256" /,
/ digest-bytes / / digest-bytes /
h'0123456789abcdeffedcba987654321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff' h'0123456789abcdeffedcba987654321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff'
] /, ]),
/ image-size / 14:76834, / image-size / 14:76834,
} }
] /, ]),
} /, }),
/ install / 9:h'900c0013a115781c687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e / install / 9:bstr .cbor ([
636f6d2f66696c65312e62696e1502030f0c0113a115781c687474703a2f2f6578616d
706c652e636f6d2f66696c65322e62696e1502030f' / [
/ directive-set-component-index / 12,0 , / directive-set-component-index / 12,0 ,
/ directive-set-parameters / 19,{ / directive-set-parameters / 19,{
/ uri / 21:'http://example.com/file1.bin', / uri / 21:'http://example.com/file1.bin',
} , } ,
/ directive-fetch / 21,2 , / directive-fetch / 21,2 ,
/ condition-image-match / 3,15 , / condition-image-match / 3,15 ,
/ directive-set-component-index / 12,1 , / directive-set-component-index / 12,1 ,
/ directive-set-parameters / 19,{ / directive-set-parameters / 19,{
/ uri / 21:'http://example.com/file2.bin', / uri / 21:'http://example.com/file2.bin',
} , } ,
/ directive-fetch / 21,2 , / directive-fetch / 21,2 ,
/ condition-image-match / 3,15 / condition-image-match / 3,15
] /, ]),
/ validate / 10:h'880c00030f0c01030f' / [ / validate / 10:bstr .cbor ([
/ directive-set-component-index / 12,0 , / directive-set-component-index / 12,0 ,
/ condition-image-match / 3,15 , / condition-image-match / 3,15 ,
/ directive-set-component-index / 12,1 , / directive-set-component-index / 12,1 ,
/ condition-image-match / 3,15 / condition-image-match / 3,15
] /, ]),
/ run / 12:h'860c0017021702' / [ / run / 12:bstr .cbor ([
/ directive-set-component-index / 12,0 , / directive-set-component-index / 12,0 ,
/ directive-run / 23,2 ,
/ directive-run / 23,2 / directive-run / 23,2
] /, ]),
} /, }),
} }
Total size of Envelope without COSE authentication object: 264 Total size of Envelope without COSE authentication object: 304
Envelope: Envelope:
a103590103a601010205035895a202828141008141010458898c0c0014a4 a202582781582482025820de7c7927a15bd2eda59cab1512875f17c9f1e9
0150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf42 e23885ce1ac6d671eefcefa37a03590101a601010205035895a202828141
9b2d51f2ab450358248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff01 008141010458898c0c0014a40150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe
23456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f0c0114a2035824 02501492af1425695e48bf429b2d51f2ab45035824820258200011223344
820258200123456789abcdeffedcba987654321000112233445566778899 5566778899aabbccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987
aabbccddeeff0e1a00012c2209584f900c0013a115781c687474703a2f2f d0010f020f0c0114a2035824820258200123456789abcdeffedcba987654
6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c65312e62696e1502030f0c0113a115 321000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0e1a00012c2209584f900c00
781c687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c65322e62696e 13a115781c687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c65312e
1502030f0a49880c00030f0c01030f0c47860c0017021702 62696e1502030f0c0113a115781c687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e63
6f6d2f66696c65322e62696e1502030f0a49880c00030f0c01030f0c4584
0c001702
Total size of Envelope with COSE authentication object: 413 Total size of Envelope with COSE authentication object: 417
Envelope with COSE authentication object: Envelope with COSE authentication object:
a202589281588fd28443a10126a058448202584032313062313238353063 a202589882582482025820de7c7927a15bd2eda59cab1512875f17c9f1e9
323339303931643865383263306539653931303636326236386163383432 e23885ce1ac6d671eefcefa37a586fd28443a10126a0582482025820de7c
3435386136343138653333663637303165643538333432635840b5b8cb30 7927a15bd2eda59cab1512875f17c9f1e9e23885ce1ac6d671eefcefa37a
c2bbb646c4d32426d72768668d6d6af54c26ac46c4020ca37ada47b94683 5840e71e332c985fb0479f296685669d05348bcdba8e186f25a5418f4682
40b4d0b2ddd15db824a7e6b0bc233e753940dfb7131fa145ddc456da3cf6 ea168df61661f54bf48f964577225ed455b22d277dd94de87c57f1baceed
03590103a601010205035895a202828141008141010458898c0c0014a401 d6719f3d56ec03590101a601010205035895a20282814100814101045889
50fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425695e48bf429b 8c0c0014a40150fa6b4a53d5ad5fdfbe9de663e4d41ffe02501492af1425
2d51f2ab450358248202582000112233445566778899aabbccddeeff0123 695e48bf429b2d51f2ab450358248202582000112233445566778899aabb
456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f0c0114a203582482 ccddeeff0123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100e1987d0010f020f0c01
0258200123456789abcdeffedcba987654321000112233445566778899aa 14a2035824820258200123456789abcdeffedcba98765432100011223344
bbccddeeff0e1a00012c2209584f900c0013a115781c687474703a2f2f65 5566778899aabbccddeeff0e1a00012c2209584f900c0013a115781c6874
78616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c65312e62696e1502030f0c0113a11578 74703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c65312e62696e1502030f
1c687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c65322e62696e15 0c0113a115781c687474703a2f2f6578616d706c652e636f6d2f66696c65
02030f0a49880c00030f0c01030f0c47860c0017021702 322e62696e1502030f0a49880c00030f0c01030f0c45840c001702
C. Design Rational Appendix C. C. Design Rational
In order to provide flexible behavior to constrained devices, while In order to provide flexible behavior to constrained devices, while
still allowing more powerful devices to use their full capabilities, still allowing more powerful devices to use their full capabilities,
the SUIT manifest encodes the required behavior of a Recipient the SUIT manifest encodes the required behavior of a Recipient
device. Behavior is encoded as a specialized byte code, contained in device. Behavior is encoded as a specialized byte code, contained in
a CBOR list. This promotes a flat encoding, which simplifies the a CBOR list. This promotes a flat encoding, which simplifies the
parser. The information encoded by this byte code closely matches parser. The information encoded by this byte code closely matches
the operations that a device will perform, which promotes ease of the operations that a device will perform, which promotes ease of
processing. The core operations used by most update and trusted processing. The core operations used by most update and trusted
execution operations are represented in the byte code. The byte code invocation operations are represented in the byte code. The byte
can be extended by registering new operations. code can be extended by registering new operations.
The specialized byte code approach gives benefits equivalent to those The specialized byte code approach gives benefits equivalent to those
provided by a scripting language or conventional byte code, with two provided by a scripting language or conventional byte code, with two
substantial differences. First, the language is extremely high substantial differences. First, the language is extremely high
level, consisting of only the operations that a device may perform level, consisting of only the operations that a device may perform
during update and trusted execution of a firmware image. Second, the during update and trusted invocation of a firmware image. Second,
language specifies linear behavior, without reverse branches. the language specifies linear behavior, without reverse branches.
Conditional processing is supported, and parallel and out-of-order Conditional processing is supported, and parallel and out-of-order
processing may be performed by sufficiently capable devices. processing may be performed by sufficiently capable devices.
By structuring the data in this way, the manifest processor becomes a By structuring the data in this way, the manifest processor becomes a
very simple engine that uses a pull parser to interpret the manifest. very simple engine that uses a pull parser to interpret the manifest.
This pull parser invokes a series of command handlers that evaluate a This pull parser invokes a series of command handlers that evaluate a
Condition or execute a Directive. Most data is structured in a Condition or execute a Directive. Most data is structured in a
highly regular pattern, which simplifies the parser. highly regular pattern, which simplifies the parser.
The results of this allow a Recipient to implement a very small The results of this allow a Recipient to implement a very small
skipping to change at page 106, line 13 skipping to change at page 108, line 17
command sequences are also wrapped in the manifest. This also allows command sequences are also wrapped in the manifest. This also allows
the parser to discern the difference between a command sequence and a the parser to discern the difference between a command sequence and a
SUIT_Digest. SUIT_Digest.
Parameters that are structured types (arrays and maps) are also Parameters that are structured types (arrays and maps) are also
wrapped in a bstr. This is so that parser extents can be set wrapped in a bstr. This is so that parser extents can be set
correctly using only a reference to the beginning of the parameter. correctly using only a reference to the beginning of the parameter.
This enables a parser to store a simple list of references to This enables a parser to store a simple list of references to
parameters that can be retrieved when needed. parameters that can be retrieved when needed.
D. Implementation Conformance Matrix Appendix D. D. Implementation Conformance Matrix
This section summarizes the functionality a minimal implementation This section summarizes the functionality a minimal implementation
needs to offer to claim conformance to this specification, in the needs to offer to claim conformance to this specification, in the
absence of an application profile standard specifying otherwise. absence of an application profile standard specifying otherwise.
The subsequent table shows the conditions. The subsequent table shows the conditions.
+-------------------+-----------------+----------------+ +-------------------+------------------+----------------+
| Name | Reference | Implementation | | Name | Reference | Implementation |
+-------------------+-----------------+----------------+ +-------------------+------------------+----------------+
| Vendor Identifier | Section 8.7.5.1 | REQUIRED | | Vendor Identifier | Section 8.7.5.2 | REQUIRED |
| | | | | | | |
| Class Identifier | Section 8.7.5.1 | REQUIRED | | Class Identifier | Section 8.7.5.2 | REQUIRED |
| | | | | | | |
| Device Identifier | Section 8.7.5.1 | OPTIONAL | | Device Identifier | Section 8.7.5.2 | OPTIONAL |
| | | | | | | |
| Image Match | Section 8.7.6.2 | REQUIRED | | Image Match | Section 8.7.6.2 | REQUIRED |
| | | | | | | |
| Image Not Match | Section 8.7.6.3 | OPTIONAL | | Image Not Match | Section 8.7.6.3 | OPTIONAL |
| | | | | | | |
| Use Before | Section 8.7.6.4 | OPTIONAL | | Use Before | Section 8.7.6.4 | OPTIONAL |
| | | | | | | |
| Component Offset | Section 8.7.6.5 | OPTIONAL | | Component Offset | Section 8.7.6.5 | OPTIONAL |
| | | | | | | |
| Minimum Battery | Section 8.7.6.6 | OPTIONAL | | Abort | Section 8.7.6.9 | OPTIONAL |
| | | | | | | |
| Update Authorized | Section 8.7.6.7 | OPTIONAL | | Minimum Battery | Section 8.7.6.6 | OPTIONAL |
| | | | | | | |
| Version | Section 8.7.6.8 | OPTIONAL | | Update Authorized | Section 8.7.6.7 | OPTIONAL |
| | | | | | | |
| Custom Condition | Section 8.7.6.9 | OPTIONAL | | Version | Section 8.7.6.8 | OPTIONAL |
+-------------------+-----------------+----------------+ | | | |
| Custom Condition | Section 8.7.6.10 | OPTIONAL |
+-------------------+------------------+----------------+
The subsequent table shows the directives. The subsequent table shows the directives.
+-------------------+----------------+------------------------------+ +-------------------+----------------+------------------------------+
| Name | Reference | Implementation | | Name | Reference | Implementation |
+-------------------+----------------+------------------------------+ +-------------------+----------------+------------------------------+
| Set Component | Section 8.7.7. | REQUIRED if more than one | | Set Component | Section 8.7.7. | REQUIRED if more than one |
| Index | 1 | component | | Index | 1 | component |
| | | | | | | |
| Set Dependency | Section 8.7.7. | REQUIRED if dependencies | | Set Dependency | Section 8.7.7. | REQUIRED if dependencies |
| Index | 2 | used | | Index | 2 | used |
| | | | | | | |
| Abort | Section 8.7.7. | OPTIONAL |
| | 3 | |
| | | |
| Try Each | Section 8.7.7. | OPTIONAL | | Try Each | Section 8.7.7. | OPTIONAL |
| | 4 | | | | 3 | |
| | | | | | | |
| Process | Section 8.7.7. | OPTIONAL | | Process | Section 8.7.7. | OPTIONAL |
| Dependency | 5 | | | Dependency | 4 | |
| | | | | | | |
| Set Parameters | Section 8.7.7. | OPTIONAL | | Set Parameters | Section 8.7.7. | OPTIONAL |
| | 6 | | | | 5 | |
| | | | | | | |
| Override | Section 8.7.7. | REQUIRED | | Override | Section 8.7.7. | REQUIRED |
| Parameters | 7 | | | Parameters | 6 | |
| | | | | | | |
| Fetch | Section 8.7.7. | REQUIRED for Updater | | Fetch | Section 8.7.7. | REQUIRED for Updater |
| | 8 | | | | 7 | |
| | | | | | | |
| Copy | Section 8.7.7. | OPTIONAL | | Copy | Section 8.7.7. | OPTIONAL |
| | 10 | | | | 9 | |
| | | | | | | |
| Run | Section 8.7.7. | REQUIRED for Bootloader | | Run | Section 8.7.7. | REQUIRED for Bootloader |
| | 11 | | | | 10 | |
| | | | | | | |
| Wait For Event | Section 8.7.7. | OPTIONAL | | Wait For Event | Section 8.7.7. | OPTIONAL |
| | 12 | | | | 11 | |
| | | | | | | |
| Run Sequence | Section 8.7.7. | OPTIONAL | | Run Sequence | Section 8.7.7. | OPTIONAL |
| | 13 | | | | 12 | |
| | | | | | | |
| Swap | Section 8.7.7. | OPTIONAL | | Swap | Section 8.7.7. | OPTIONAL |
| | 14 | | | | 13 | |
| | | | | | | |
| Fetch URI List | Section 8.7.7. | OPTIONAL | | Fetch URI List | Section 8.7.7. | OPTIONAL |
| | 9 | | | | 8 | |
+-------------------+----------------+------------------------------+ +-------------------+----------------+------------------------------+
The subsequent table shows the parameters. The subsequent table shows the parameters.
+------------------+------------------+----------------------+ +------------------+------------------+----------------------+
| Name | Reference | Implementation | | Name | Reference | Implementation |
+------------------+------------------+----------------------+ +------------------+------------------+----------------------+
| Vendor ID | Section 8.7.5.2 | REQUIRED | | Vendor ID | Section 8.7.5.3 | REQUIRED |
| | | | | | | |
| Class ID | Section 8.7.5.3 | REQUIRED | | Class ID | Section 8.7.5.4 | REQUIRED |
| | | | | | | |
| Image Digest | Section 8.7.5.5 | REQUIRED | | Image Digest | Section 8.7.5.6 | REQUIRED |
| | | | | | | |
| Image Size | Section 8.7.5.6 | REQUIRED | | Image Size | Section 8.7.5.7 | REQUIRED |
| | | | | | | |
| Use Before | Section 8.7.5.7 | RECOMMENDED | | Use Before | Section 8.7.5.8 | RECOMMENDED |
| | | | | | | |
| Component Offset | Section 8.7.5.8 | OPTIONAL | | Component Offset | Section 8.7.5.9 | OPTIONAL |
| | | | | | | |
| Encryption Info | Section 8.7.5.9 | RECOMMENDED | | Encryption Info | Section 8.7.5.10 | RECOMMENDED |
| | | | | | | |
| Compression Info | Section 8.7.5.10 | RECOMMENDED | | Compression Info | Section 8.7.5.11 | RECOMMENDED |
| | | | | | | |
| Unpack Info | Section 8.7.5.11 | RECOMMENDED | | Unpack Info | Section 8.7.5.12 | RECOMMENDED |
| | | | | | | |
| URI | Section 8.7.5.12 | REQUIRED for Updater | | URI | Section 8.7.5.13 | REQUIRED for Updater |
| | | | | | | |
| Source Component | Section 8.7.5.13 | OPTIONAL | | Source Component | Section 8.7.5.14 | OPTIONAL |
| | | | | | | |
| Run Args | Section 8.7.5.14 | OPTIONAL | | Run Args | Section 8.7.5.15 | OPTIONAL |
| | | | | | | |
| Device ID | Section 8.7.5.4 | OPTIONAL | | Device ID | Section 8.7.5.5 | OPTIONAL |
| | | | | | | |
| Minimum Battery | Section 8.7.5.15 | OPTIONAL | | Minimum Battery | Section 8.7.5.16 | OPTIONAL |
| | | | | | | |
| Update Priority | Section 8.7.5.16 | OPTIONAL | | Update Priority | Section 8.7.5.17 | OPTIONAL |
| | | | | | | |
| Version Match | Section 8.7.5.17 | OPTIONAL | | Version Match | Section 8.7.5.18 | OPTIONAL |
| | | | | | | |
| Wait Info | Section 8.7.5.18 | OPTIONAL | | Wait Info | Section 8.7.5.19 | OPTIONAL |
| | | | | | | |
| URI List | Section 8.7.5.19 | OPTIONAL | | URI List | Section 8.7.5.20 | OPTIONAL |
| | | | | | | |
| Strict Order | Section 8.7.5.21 | OPTIONAL | | Strict Order | Section 8.7.5.22 | OPTIONAL |
| | | | | | | |
| Soft Failure | Section 8.7.5.22 | OPTIONAL | | Soft Failure | Section 8.7.5.23 | OPTIONAL |
| | | | | | | |
| Custom | Section 8.7.5.23 | OPTIONAL | | Custom | Section 8.7.5.24 | OPTIONAL |
+------------------+------------------+----------------------+ +------------------+------------------+----------------------+
Authors' Addresses Authors' Addresses
Brendan Moran Brendan Moran
Arm Limited Arm Limited
EMail: Brendan.Moran@arm.com EMail: Brendan.Moran@arm.com
Hannes Tschofenig Hannes Tschofenig
 End of changes. 519 change blocks. 
1738 lines changed or deleted 1860 lines changed or added

This html diff was produced by rfcdiff 1.48. The latest version is available from http://tools.ietf.org/tools/rfcdiff/