IETF Activity since last IETF Meeting -------------------- IETF Activity since last IETF Meeting (Beijing) 83 New I-Ds (3 of which were updated, some (0) more than once) 128 I-Ds were updated (Some more than once) 37 I-Ds Last Called 23 I-Ds approved for publication In the final 4 weeks before meeting 169 New I-Ds were received - 20% of total newbies since last meeting 83 I-Ds were updated - 64% of total updated since last meeting Week1 252 % Week2 0 % Week3 0 % Week4 0 % The IESG Secretary. IETF Progress Report 1-Dec-10 to 31-Dec-10 1) 23 IESG Protocol and Document Actions this period Requirements for a Protocol to Replace AppleTalk NBP (Informational) Mobile Ad Hoc Network (MANET) Neighborhood Discovery Protocol (NHDP) (Proposed Standard) Media Description for IKE in the Session Description Protocol (SDP) (Informational) IPFIX Mediation: Framework (Informational) Interactions between PMIPv6 and MIPv6: scenarios and related issues (Informational) RTP Payload Format for H.264 Video (Proposed Standard) DHCPv4 Lease Query by Relay Agent Remote ID (None) The Remote Framebuffer Protocol (Informational) An Alternative Connection Model for the Message Session Relay Protocol (MSRP) (None) With-defaults capability for NETCONF (Proposed Standard) DHCPv4 and DHCPv6 Options for Access Network Discovery and Selection Function (ANDSF) Discovery (None) Session-Specific Explicit Diameter Request Routing (Informational) Use of Device Identity in HTTP-Enabled Location Delivery (HELD) (Proposed Standard) The Babel Routing Protocol (Experimental) Fundamental Elliptic Curve Cryptography Algorithms (None) Extending YANG with Language Abstractions (Experimental) Re-INVITE and Target-Refresh Request Handling in the Session Initiation Protocol (SIP) (None) IMAP LIST Extension for Special-Use Mailboxes (None) Definition of IETF Working Group Document States (Informational) Protecting The Router Control Plane (Informational) Requirements to Extend the Datatracker for IETF WG Chairs and Authors (Informational) Sieve Notification Using Presence Information (Proposed Standard) Prohibiting SSL Version 2.0 (Proposed Standard) 2) 37 IESG Last Calls issued to the IETF this period PCC-PCE Communication and PCE Discovery Requirements for Inter-Layer Traffic Engineering (Informational) MPLS Upstream Label Assignment for LDP (Proposed Standard) The use of AES-192 and AES-256 in Secure RTP (Proposed Standard) SIP (Session Initiation Protocol) Usage of the Offer/Answer Model (Informational) Extensible Markup Language Evidence Record Syntax (Proposed Standard) Generalized Labels for Lambda-Switching Capable Label Switching Routers (Proposed Standard) A Uniform Resource Name (URN) Namespace for CableLabs (Informational) Security Concerns With IP Tunneling (Informational) Compression Format for IPv6 Datagrams in Low Power and Lossy Networks (6LoWPAN) (Proposed Standard) Suite B Cryptographic Suites for Secure Shell (Informational) PIM Group-to-RP Mapping (Proposed Standard) Negotiation of Generic Image Attributes in SDP (Proposed Standard) Indication of support for keep-alive (Proposed Standard) Experiment: Hash functions with parameters in CMS and S/MIME (Experimental) Cryptographic Messages Syntax (CMS) Algorithm Identifier Protection Attribute (Proposed Standard) Routing Metrics used for Path Calculation in Low Power and Lossy Networks (Proposed Standard) Internet Protocols for the Smart Grid (Informational) MPLS Transport Profile User-to-Network and Network-to-Network Interfaces (Informational) Threat Analysis for TCP Extensions for Multi-path Operation with Multiple Addresses (Informational) A Security Framework for Routing over Low Power and Lossy Networks (Informational) Architectural Guidelines for Multipath TCP Development (Informational) Base Deployment for Multicast Listener Support in PMIPv6 Domains (Informational) IMAP LIST Extension for Special-Use Mailboxes (None) Elliptic Curve-based Certificate-less Signatures for Identifier Based Encryption (ECCSI) (Informational) Sakai-Kasahara Key Establishment (SAKKE) (Informational) Security Considerations for the SHA-0 and SHA-1 Message-Digest Algorithms (Informational) Additional New ASN.1 Modules for the Cryptographic Message Syntax (CMS) and the Public Key Infrastructure Using X.509 (PKIX) (Proposed Standard) MIKEY-SAKKE: Sakai-Kasahara Key Exchange in Multimedia Internet KEYing (MIKEY) (Informational) MD4 to Historic Status (None) IPv4 and IPv6 Infrastructure Addresses in Multicast-VPN Routes (Proposed Standard) Prohibiting SSL Version 2.0 (Proposed Standard) Routing Loop Attack using IPv6 Automatic Tunnels: Problem Statement and Proposed Mitigations (Informational) Algorithms for Cryptographic Message Syntax (CMS) Protection of Symmetric Key Package Content Types (Proposed Standard) Using 127-bit IPv6 Prefixes on Inter-Router Links (Proposed Standard) Authentication-Results Registration For Vouch By Reference Results (Proposed Standard) Domain Name System (DNS) IANA Considerations (BCP) HTTP 'Headers-Not-Recognized' Header Field (Experimental) 3) 1 New Working Group(s) formed this period DNS-based Authentication of Named Entities (dane) 4) 2 Working Group(s) concluded this period Calendaring and Scheduling Standards Simplification (calsify) Provisioning of Symmetric Keys (keyprov) 5) 180 new or revised Internet-Drafts this period (o - Revised Internet-Draft; + - New Internet-Draft) WG I-D Title ------- ------------------------------------------ (none) o Stream Control Transmission Protocol (SCTP) Packet Drop Reporting (none) o An IPv4 - IPv6 multicast translator (none) o XML Media Types (none) o IANA Registry for IPv4 Options Classes (none) o Certificate Exchange Messaging for EDIINT (salud) + Alert-Info URNs for the Session Initiation Protocol (SIP) (pce) o PCC-PCE Communication and PCE Discovery Requirements for Inter-Layer Traffic Engineering (none) o The Atom "deleted-entry" Element (mpls) o Requirements for Point-To-Multipoint Extensions to the Label Distribution Protocol (sidr) o A Profile for X.509 PKIX Resource Certificates (manet) o Mobile Ad Hoc Network (MANET) Neighborhood Discovery Protocol (NHDP) (dnsext) o Update to DNAME Redirection in the DNS (sidr) o Certificate Policy (CP) for the Resource PKI (RPKI (krb-wg) o Kerberos Version 5 GSS-API Channel Binding Hash Agility (none) o Requirements for the XCON-DCON Synchronization Protocol (none) o Requirements for Distributed Conferencing (none) o A Framework for Distributed Conferencing (none) o Saratoga: A Scalable File Transfer Protocol (mboned) o Multicast Ping Protocol (6man) o IPv6 Node Requirements RFC 4294-bis (bliss) o Call Completion for Session Initiation Protocol (SIP) (none) o Session Initiation Protocol Service Example -- Music on Hold (emu) o Requirements for a Tunnel Based EAP Method (none) o The Tao of IETF: A Novice's Guide to the Internet Engineering Task Force (tsvwg) o Applicability of Keying Methods for RSVP Security (vcarddav) o vCard Format Specification (mext) o DHCPv6 Prefix Delegation for NEMO (none) o FTP Extension for Internationalized Text (behave) o Stream Control Transmission Protocol (SCTP) Network Address Translation (payload) o RTP Payload Format for G.718 Speech/Audio (fecframe) o Raptor FEC Schemes for FECFRAME (dhc) o DHCPv4 lease query by Relay Agent Remote ID (none) o Mesh Structured Hierarchical Networking and IPv6 (6lowpan) o Neighbor Discovery Optimization for Low-power and Lossy Networks (grow) o BGP Monitoring Protocol (mpls) o Label Edge Router Forwarding of IPv4 Option Packets (none) o Bidirectional Forwarding Detection (BFD) with Graceful Restart (ecrit) o LoST Service List Boundary Extension (simple) o An Alternative Connection Model for the Message Session Relay Protocol (MSRP) (none) o IPv6 AAAA DNS Whitelisting Implications (none) o Long Term Archive Storage Protocol (none) o Advice on When It is Safe to Start Sending Data on Label Switched Paths Established Using RSVP-TE (v6ops) o Basic Requirements for IPv6 Customer Edge Routers (none) o The Network Trouble Ticket Data Model (xmpp) o Extensible Messaging and Presence Protocol (XMPP): Core (none) o The Media Types application/mods+xml, application/mads+xml, application/ mets+xml, application/marcxml+xml, application/sru+xml (forces) o ForCES Logical Function Block (LFB) Library (none) o Framework for IPv4/IPv6 Multicast Translation (none) o MPLS-TP Ring Protection (none) o Recommendations for the Remediation of Bots in ISP Networks (none) o Fundamental Elliptic Curve Cryptography Algorithms (none) o Session Recording for Conferences using SMIL (none) o Extending YANG with Language Abstractions (none) o Elliptic Curve DSA for DNSSEC (pcn) o PCN Boundary Node Behaviour for the Controlled Load (CL) Mode of Operation (pcn) o PCN Boundary Node Behaviour for the Single Marking (SM) Mode of Operation (yam) o Preliminary Evaluation of RFC XXX "[PLACEHOLDER: INSERT TITLE HERE]", for advancement from Draft Standard to Full Standard by the YAM Working Group (vcarddav) o vCard XML Representation (none) o MIKEY-IBAKE: Identity-Based Mode of Key Distribution in Multimedia Internet KEYing (MIKEY) (none) o OSPF Extensions for Wavelength Switched Optical Networks (WSON) with Impairments (none) + EA-HD: A Novel Link State Update Mechanism for ASON (none) o Secure PSK Authentication for IKE (simple) o Session Matching Update for the Message Session Relay Protocol (MSRP) (none) o A Generic Cognitive Adaptive Module (CAM) for MANETs (none) o IPv6 Multihoming without Network Address Translation (dhc) o Secure DHCPv6 Using CGAs (6man) o An uniform format for IPv6 extension headers (none) o A RELOAD Usage for Distributed Conference Control (DisCo) (none) + Proactive Channel Handoff in wireless cognitive networks (none) + Ethics Search Protocol (ESP) for Internet Search Engines (none) o Quick Failover Algorithm in SCTP (none) o A RSVP-TE Reservation Protocol Based on Priority in Multi-Domain Optical Network (sipcore) o Re-INVITE and Target-refresh Request Handling in the Session Initiation Protocol (SIP) (eman) + Energy Management Framework (none) o A set-key attribute for symmetric-key packages (multimob) o Base Deployment for Multicast Listener Support in PMIPv6 Domains (morg) o IMAP LIST extension for special-use mailboxes (eman) + Requirements for Power Monitoring (none) o Commentary on the Design of the Authenticated Encrypted Data Content Type (bmwg) o Device Reset Characterization (tcpm) o Computing TCP's Retransmission Timer (avt) o RTP Control Protocol (RTCP) Port for Source-Specific Multicast (SSM) Sessions (opsec) o Protecting The Router Control Plane (none) o RTCP Extension for Feedback Suppression Indication (none) o Guidelines for Using IPv6 Transition Mechanisms during IPv6 Deployment (none) o Metadata Query Protocol (none) o Framework for IP Version Transition Scenarios (none) o Inter-Area P2MP Segmented LSPs (none) o Most Efficient Augmented Password-Only Authentication and Key Exchange for IKEv2 (ccamp) o General Network Element Constraint Encoding for GMPLS Controlled Networks (none) o Simple and Efficient Read Support for Sparse Files (none) o A Solution Approach for AS Relationships-aware Overlay Routing (sidr) o Use Cases and interpretation of RPKI objects for issuers and relying parties (siprec) o Requirements for SIP-based Media Recording (SIPREC) (none) o A Mechanism for Session Initiation Protocol (SIP) Avalanche Restart Overload Control (none) o A Session Initiation Protocol (SIP) Load Control Event Package (none) o OAuth 2.0 support for the Kerberos V5 Authentication Protocol (none) o MD2 to Historic Status (none) o Reverse Routing Header (none) o The ARIA Algorithm and Its Use with the Secure Real-time Transport Protocol(SRTP) (none) o A Basic Guideline for Listing ISPs that Run IPv6 (payload) o RTP Payload Format for Bluetooth's SBC audio codec (sieve) o Sieve Notification Using Presence Information (none) o Load Sharing for the Stream Control Transmission Protocol (SCTP) (soc) o Design Considerations for Session Initiation Protocol (SIP) Overload Control (none) o Automated (DNSSEC) Child Parent Synchronization using DNS UPDATE (ippm) o Loss Episode Metrics for IPPM (geopriv) o A Location Dereferencing Protocol Using HELD (none) + Pay It Proper Protocol -- PIPP (none) o Updated Security Considerations for the MD5 Message-Digest and the HMAC-MD5 Algorithms (none) o 'Informational' Class for IPv4 Options (tls) o Prohibiting SSL Version 2.0 (none) o Specifying Civic Address Extensions in PIDF-LO (grow) o MRT BGP routing information export format with geo-location extensions (none) o A Mechanism for Transporting User to User Call Control Information in SIP (none) o Deprecation of ICMP Source Quench messages (none) o Indication of features supported by proxy (none) o A Generalized PAC for Kerberos V5 (none) o Addition of the ARIA Cipher Suites to Transport Layer Security (TLS) (none) o "Gateway-Initiated" 6rd (6man) o Using 127-bit IPv6 Prefixes on Inter-Router Links (none) o FTP extension for IPv4/IPv6 transition (none) o Application Bridging for Federated Access Beyond Web (ABFAB) Architecture (core) o CoRE Link Format (precis) o Stringprep Revision Problem Statement (none) o Pinhole Control Protocol (PCP) (none) o The Unencrypted Form Of Kerberos 5 KRB-CRED Message (cuss) o Problem Statement and Requirements for Transporting User to User Call Control Information in SIP (none) + Practice of Extensible Provisioning Protocol (EPP)extension mapping for Chinese Domain Name (none) o A URN Namespace for the Open Grid Forum (OGF) (pkix) o S/MIME Capabilities for Public Key Definitions (none) o Support for hosts in MANETs (none) o Textual Conventions for the Representation of Floating-Point Numbers (none) + Name Based API (none) + Definition of a secondary routing structure (none) + Measuring the Quality of an Internet Interactive Audio Codec (none) + Recommendations for Transport Port Uses (none) + TIE: Two-Party Selection of TCP Initial Congestion Window Estimate (none) o Wrapping Last-Hop DNS for Traffic Protection (v6ops) + IPv6 Multihoming without Network Address Translation (none) + A WebSocket handshake proposal using Upgrade and CONNECT masking (l2vpn) + MAC Flush Loop Detection in VPLS (none) o Authenticated Middlebox Traversal with the Pickle Packet (6man) + Distributing Address Selection Policy using DHCPv6 (none) + PingPong IdP Discovery Protocol (none) + Adding Extended Authentication Names to the Bos Super User list (none) + SIP Interconnect Guidelines (none) + Packet Loss and Delay Measurement for MPLS Networks (none) + A YANG Data Model for Interface Configuration (ftpext2) + FTP extension for IPv4/IPv6 transition (none) + An XMPP Sub-protocol for WebSocket (mpls) + Configuration of pro-active MPLS-TP Operations, Administration, and Maintenance (OAM) Functions Using LSP Ping (bmwg) + IP Flow Information Accounting and Export Benchmarking Methodology (none) + WebSocket Upgrade+Hello Handshake (none) + A Packet Loss and Delay Measurement Profile for MPLS-based Transport Networks (urnbis) + Uniform Resource Name (URN) Namespace Definition Mechanisms (none) + Motivations for Recommendations (6man) + The Line Identification Destination Option (none) + A Novel Inter-domain Routing Algorithm in Distributed Multi-Domain Optical Network (none) + Topology-based aggregation (urnbis) + Using International Standard Book Numbers as Uniform Resource Names (none) o An efficient method to publish ranges of IP addresses in the DNS (none) + TCP and SCTP RTO Restart (urnbis) + Using National Bibliography Numbers as Uniform Resource Names (eman) + Energy-aware Networks and Devices MIB (none) + Definition of Managed Objects for SAVI Protocol (none) + Extended Electronic Signature Policies (none) + Automating the Initial Window in TCP (none) + Virtual Networks Problem Statement (none) + Host Initiation for Flow Mobility in PMIPv6 (none) + A Wireless Channel Model Based Rate Control (WMRC) Scheme in RTP/UDP for Real Time Multimedia Transmissions over Wired-Wireless Networks(WMRC- RTP/UDP) (none) + Additional protocol requirements on DECADE (none) + Extending the Virtual Router Redundancy Protocol for Graceful Restart (websec) + The Web Origin Concept (none) + TESF Based on True IPv6 Address Access (none) + Detection Event Description Language (DEDL) (none) + Cloud SDO Activities Survey and Analysis (none) + Cloud Industry Workitem Survey Results (none) + Cloud Reference Framework (sidr) + The RPKI Ghostbusters Record 6) 10 RFC produced this period S - Standard; PS - Proposed Standard; DS - Draft Standard; B - Best Current Practices; E - Experimental; I - Informational RFC Stat WG Published Title ------- -- -------- ---------- ----------------------------------------- RFC6057 I (none) Dec 2010 Comcast's Protocol-Agnostic Congestion Management System RFC6067 I (none) Dec 2010 BCP 47 Extension U RFC6047 PS (calsify) Dec 2010 iCalendar Message-Based Interoperability Protocol (iMIP) RFC6065 PS (isms) Dec 2010 Using Authentication, Authorization, and Accounting Services to Dynamically Provision View-based Access Control Model User-to-Group Mappings RFC6031 PS (keyprov) Dec 2010 Cryptographic Message Syntax (CMS) Symmetric Key Package Content Type RFC6032 PS (none) Dec 2010 Cryptographic Message Syntax (CMS) Encrypted Key Package Content Type RFC6033 PS (none) Dec 2010 Algorithms for Cryptographic Message Syntax (CMS) Encrypted Key Package Content Type RFC6063 PS (keyprov) Dec 2010 Dynamic Symmetric Key Provisioning Protocol (DSKPP) RFC6069 E (tcpm) Dec 2010 Making TCP More Robust to Long Connectivity Disruptions (TCP-LCD) RFC6075 PS (none) Dec 2010 The Internet Assigned Number Authority (IANA) Application Configuration Access Protocol (ACAP) Vendor Subtrees Registry 7 Standards Track; 0 BCP; 1 Experimental; 2 Informational List Usage Report 2010-12-01 2010-12-31 16ng 0 3gv6 0 66attendees 0 67attendees 0 68attendees 0 69attendees 0 6lowapp 0 6lowpan 13 70attendees 0 71attendees 0 72attendees 0 73all 0 73attendees 0 73attendess 0 74all 0 74attendees 0 75all 0 75attendees 0 76all 0 76attendees 0 77all 0 77attendees 0 78all 0 78attendees 1 79all 0 79attendees 9 80all 0 80attendees 0 CCAMP 0 MAVS 0 aaa 0 aaa-doctors 3 aaa-implementers 0 abfab 65 acap 0 addr-select-dt 0 addr-select-dt-web 0 adslmib 8 aft 0 agentx 0 alto 2 ancp 8 ans-research 0 apex 0 apps-discuss 149 apps-review 32 architecture-discuss 0 armd 22 arp222 0 ason-routing 0 asrg 57 asrg-announce 0 atommib 0 atompub 0 aulli 0 autoconf 4 avt 215 avtext 0 beep 1 behave 23 bgmp 0 bliss 6 bmwg 14 bofchairs 28 bridge 0 bridge-mib 0 btns 0 caldav 1 call-home 0 calsch 0 calsify 10 capwap 1 carddav 0 cat 0 cats 0 ccamp 30 cdi 0 cdni 22 certid 55 cfrg 0 cga-ext 1 cgasec 0 channel-binding 0 charter-tool 3 cicm 0 clouds 2 clue 48 cna 0 cnrp 0 codec 11 codesprints 3 collation 0 conex 3 conneg 0 core 70 cosmogol 0 crisp 0 csky-idsubmit 0 cso 4 cuss 35 dasl 0 datatracker-rqmts 19 dccp 19 dcp 0 dcpel 0 dea-dir 0 decade 25 deltav 0 dhc 0 dhcipv6 0 dhcwg 55 diffserv 0 diffserv-interest 0 dime 14 directory 0 discuss 0 disman 0 dispatch 63 dix 0 dlswmib 0 dmm 0 dmsp 0 dna 0 dns-dir 14 dns-rrtype-applications 1 dns-security 0 dnsext 167 dnsind 0 dnsop 20 dnssec 0 domainrep 0 drinks 2 drums 0 e2md 0 eai 0 eap 1 eapext 0 early_warning 0 earlywarning 2 ecm 0 ecrit 11 ediint 0 edu-discuss 6 edu-team 22 email-notifications 0 eman 5 eme 0 emu 10 enroll 0 entmib 0 enum 0 eos 0 esds 0 fax 0 fecframe 57 fecframe-proto 0 forces 5 forces-protocol 0 forces.old 0 frnetmib 0 ftpext 33 fyiup 0 gen-art 142 geopriv 72 grip 0 grobj 0 grow 42 gsmp 0 hash 0 hasmat 0 hiccup 0 hip 0 hiprg 1 hipsec 17 hokey 0 homegate 5 homesec-dt 0 http 0 http-auth 153 http-state 15 httpbisa 0 httpmail 0 httpstreaming 0 hubmib 0 humanresolvers 0 hybi 698 i-d-announce 388 iab-wireless-workshop 0 iab-wireless-workshop-interest 0 iaoc-scribes 0 icar 0 icar-announce 0 idmr 0 idn 0 idr 11 idwg 0 ieprep 0 iesg-agenda-dist 2 ietf 238 ietf-62 0 ietf-announce 92 ietf-announce-old 0 ietf-dkim 5 ietf-iana 0 ietf-message-headers 1 ietf-nomcom 0 ietf-nomcom.SAVE 0 ietf-outcomes 0 ietf-privacy 1 ietf-runners 0 ietf-sailors 0 ietf-types 10 ietf72-1st-timers 0 ietf74-1st-timers 0 ietf74-team 0 ietf75-1st-timers 0 ietf75-team 0 ietf76-1st-timers 0 ietf77-1st-timers 0 ietf79-1st-timers 0 ietfmibs 0 ifmib 0 ima 147 imap5 0 imapext 0 impp 0 imrg 0 imss 0 inch 0 independent 0 int-area 38 intersecs 0 intserv 0 ion 0 ip1394 0 ipcdn 0 ipdir 1 ipdvb 0 ipfc 0 ipfix 25 ipngwg 0 ipo 0 ipoib 0 iporpr 0 ipoverib 0 ipp 19 ippm 21 ipr-announce 17 ipr-wg 0 ips 0 ipsec 20 ipseckey 0 ipsp 0 ipsra 0 iptel 0 ipv6 72 ipv6-dir 0 ipvbi 0 ire 0 irtf-announce 0 irtf-discuss 5 irtf-mobility-charter 0 ischedule 0 isis 0 isis-update 0 isis-wg 38 isms 29 issll 0 itrace 0 itu+ietf 0 iucg 14 kaml 0 karp 16 keyassure 360 keyprov 9 kink 0 kitten 92 kmart 0 krb-wg 52 l1vpn 0 l2cp 0 l2tpext 0 l2vpn 20 l3vpn 8 ldap-dir 0 ldapbis 0 ldapext 1 ldup 0 ledbat 6 lemonade 0 link-relations 13 lisp 26 listname 0 lsd 0 lsma 0 ltans 1 ltru 0 lwip 0 madman 0 magma 0 maitai 43 malloc 0 manet 7 manet-dt 0 marf 0 marid 0 martini 3 mboned 13 mead 0 media-feature-tags 0 media-feature-tags-archive 0 mediactrl 5 megaco 7 messaging 0 meta-model 0 mext 5 mib-doctors 19 mib2rdml 0 midcom 0 middisc 0 mif 9 mip4 7 mip6 0 mipshop 0 mipshop-mih-dt 0 mmox 0 mmusic 38 mobike 0 mobileip 0 mobopts 1 monami6 0 morg 18 mospf 0 mpls 187 mpls-interop 0 mpls-tp 184 mpowr 0 msdp 0 msec 1 msgtrk 0 mter 0 mtg-guests 0 multi6 0 multimob 6 multimobsec-api 0 multipathtcp 48 namedroppers 167 nasreq 0 nat 0 nat66 32 nbs 42 nea 5 nemo 1 netconf 64 netext 2 netlmm 0 netmod 30 new-work 0 newprep 0 newtrk 0 nfsv4 47 ngo 0 ngtrans 0 nntpext 0 nomcom 0 nomcom2000 0 notifications 0 nscp 0 nsis 49 nsis-imp 0 ntdp 0 ntp 0 oam 0 oauth 105 off-path-bof 0 ogpx 0 omcast 0 oncrpc 0 openpgp 0 opes 0 ops-area 1 ops-nm 0 opsawg 68 opsec 6 ospf 17 ospf-manet 0 ospf-wireless-design 0 otp 0 oud 0 p2pi 0 p2prg 1 p2psip 24 pana 8 paws 0 payload 0 pce 9 pcn 51 pcp 269 peppermint 0 pesci-discuss 0 pilc 0 pim 22 pint 0 pki4ipsec 0 pkix 38 pkng 1 plasma 0 pmol 3 pmtud 0 policy 0 port-srv-reg 23 pppext 1 ppsp 5 ppvpn 0 precis 17 prim 0 printmib 0 privacydir 3 problem 0 proto-team 0 provreg 0 proxies 0 psamp 0 psamp-text 0 pso-discuss 0 ptomaine 0 ptopomib 0 pwe3 82 pwot 0 qos_inband 0 radext 0 radir 0 radius 0 rai 26 rai-discuss 0 ram 0 ranger 0 rap 0 raven 0 rddp 0 re-ecn 0 recipe 0 remoteui 0 renum 48 rescap 0 research-funding 0 rfc-editor-rfi 0 rfced-ietf 0 rfid 0 rgchairs 0 rip 0 rir-ietf 0 rmonmib 0 rmt 0 roamops 0 rohc 0 roll 73 routing-discussion 4 rps 0 rpsec 0 rrg 17 rserpool 0 rsn 0 rsvp 0 rsvp-dir 0 rtfm 0 rtg-bfd 11 rtg-dir 17 rtg-mibs 0 rtg-rdd 0 rtgwg 8 rucus 0 run 0 saad 0 saag 66 sacred 0 safe 0 salud 4 sam 4 sasl 2 savi 4 scap_interest 3 schema 0 sctp-impl 0 seamoby 0 secdir 118 secmech 0 secsh 0 send 0 shara 0 shim6 0 sidr 77 sieve 14 sigtran 0 simple 58 sip 2 sip-clf 9 sip-http-events 0 sip-ops 0 sip-overload 43 sip-security 0 sipcore 37 sipping 17 sipping-emergency 0 sipping-tispan 0 siprec 131 sixpac 5 smartpower-interest 1 smartpowerdir 12 smf-discussion 0 smime 15 sming 0 snadlc 0 snmpconf 0 snmpv3 0 softwires 15 spam 0 spb-isis 0 speechsc 0 speermint 5 spirits 0 spki 0 spkm 0 splices 0 ssm 0 stevey 0 stime 0 storm 4 stun 0 svrloc 0 swmp 0 syslog 0 systers 0 tae 0 tana 0 tap 0 tcpimpl 0 tcplw 0 tcpm 47 tcpsat 0 techspec 0 ternli 0 test 0 testlist 0 tewg 0 tictoc 9 tlp-interest 0 tls 28 tmrg 1 tn3270e 0 tools-development 13 tools-discuss 28 tools-team 0 trade 0 trigtran 0 trill 10 tsv-area 1 tsvwg 73 udlr 0 uri-review 2 urlreg 0 urn 23 urn-nid 3 usefor 0 uswg 0 v4tov6transition 0 v4v6interim 0 v6ops 582 v6tc 0 vcarddav 87 videomgmt 0 vmeet 0 vnrg 2 vpim 0 vpn-dir 0 vrrp 1 vwrap 36 w3c-policy 7 wax 0 web 0 webdav 0 webi 0 websec 95 weird 0 wellknown-uri-review 0 wgchairs 12 widex 0 woes 0 wrec 0 wts 0 xcon 15 xml-dir 0 xml2rfc 0 xml2rfc-dev 0 xmldsig 0 xmpp 105 xrblock 0 yaco-idsubmit-tool 0 yaco-liaison-tool 0 yaco-wgchair-tracker 0 yam 1 yang 0 zeroconf 0 List Subscriber Report 2010-12 Aggregate Total is 110899 /tmp/z9 Unique Total is 44738 16ng 397 25years 4 3gv6 261 6lowapp 269 6lowpan 694 72onsite 1150 78all 1258 78attendees 838 79all 1353 79attendees 925 80all 759 80attendees 566 80companions 16 aaa-doctors 50 aaa-implementers 24 abfab 160 acef 9 addr-select-dt 19 adslmib 174 agentx 135 alto 486 ancp 214 apps-discuss 371 apps-review 35 architecture-discuss 481 armd 147 arp222 93 ason-routing 1 asrg 624 asrg-announce 285 autoconf 348 avt 1232 avtext 84 behave 634 bliss 355 bmwg 391 bofchairs 9 bridge-mib 142 btns 196 caldav 151 calsify 163 carddav 7 ccamp 681 cdni 202 certid 105 cfrg 489 cga-ext 102 cgasec 60 channel-binding 18 charter-tool 21 cicm 89 clouds 283 clue 112 codec 296 codesprints 33 collation 5 conex 261 core 445 cosmogol 39 crisp 153 csky-idsubmit 8 cso 85 cuss 52 datatracker-rqmts 28 dccp 354 dcpel 85 decade 191 dhcwg 613 diffserv-interest 438 dime 356 directory 43 disman 159 dispatch 433 dix 225 django-project 1 dmm 119 dna 151 dns-dir 18 dns-rrtype-applications 5 dnsext 694 dnsop 782 domainrep 68 drinks 170 e2md 88 eapext 47 earlywarning 128 ecrit 307 edu-discuss 102 edu-team 10 eman 212 eme 127 emu 178 enum 583 esds 114 execd 1 fecframe 130 fecframe-proto 13 first-timers 154 forces 213 forces-protocol 14 ftpext 44 gen-art 38 gen-art-private 30 geopriv 322 grobj 60 grow 416 gsmp 230 hasmat 115 hiccup 47 hiprg 201 hipsec 313 hokey 181 homegate 408 homesec-dt 17 http-auth 73 http-state 113 httpmail 34 httpstreaming 218 hubmib 170 humanresolvers 27 hybi 381 i-d-announce 2142 iab 22 iad-eval 7 iaoc 12 iaoc-scribes 4 icalendar 20 idr 1036 ieprep 254 iesg 27 iesg-agenda-dist 220 iesg-confirm 15 iesg-negotiation 22 iesg-only 19 iesg-scribes 5 ietf 2040 ietf-64 15 ietf-67 13 ietf-68 13 ietf-69 11 ietf-70 9 ietf-announce 3157 ietf-iana 15 ietf-liaisons 27 ietf-meetings 14 ietf-message-headers 61 ietf-nomcom 76 ietf-outcomes 21 ietf-privacy 157 ietf-runners 46 ietf-sailors 45 ietf-trust 1 ietf-types 140 ietf-vols 10 ietf72-team 11 ietf73-1st-timers 169 ietf73-team 11 ietf76-team 15 ietf77-team 13 ietf78-1st-timers 255 ietf78-team 16 ietf79-1st-timers 433 ietf79-team 16 ietf80-1st-timers 148 ietf80-team 19 ietf81-team 3 ietf82-team 3 ietf83-team 3 ietfmibs 118 ilnp 6 ima 194 imap5 79 imrg 387 imss 49 independent 134 int-area 473 intersecs 0 iola-iesg-tracker 9 ipcdn 250 ipdir 16 ipfix 307 ipoverib 243 ippm 602 ipr-announce 135 ipr-wg 177 ips 506 ipsec 1060 iptel 431 ipv6 2067 ipv6-adoption 11 ire 99 irtf-announce 621 irtf-discuss 114 ischedule 39 isis-update 118 isis-wg 440 isms 122 itu-t-liaisons 16 iucg 48 kaml 73 karp 136 keyassure 257 keyprov 131 kitten 266 kmart 49 l1vpn 242 l2tpext 279 l2vpn 1035 l3vpn 982 ldap-dir 13 ldapext 170 ledbat 277 lemonade 198 link-relations 15 link-relations-announce 7 lisp 365 loi-requests 91 lsd 38 ltans 158 ltru 89 lwip 81 magma 349 mailman 0 maitai 71 malloc 161 manet 2979 manet-dt 39 marf 90 martini 117 mavs 66 mboned 334 media-feature-tags 14 mediactrl 272 meeting-invite 3587 megaco 690 mext 968 mib-doctors 21 mib2rdml 63 midcom 458 middisc 16 mif 280 mip4 428 mip6 627 mipshop 482 mipshop-mih-dt 11 mmox 180 mmusic 753 mobopts 404 monami6 301 morg 73 mpls 1693 mpls-interop 0 mpls-tp 827 mpls-tp-manage 23 msec 388 mtg-guests 68 multimob 278 multimobsec-api 33 multipathtcp 322 namedroppers 0 nat66 231 nbs 69 nea 310 nemo 667 netconf 321 netext 233 netlmm 465 netmod 114 new-work 60 newprep 27 newtrk 97 nfsv4 449 ngo 149 nomcom-design-team 12 nomcom06 12 nomcom07 15 nomcom07-toolbounces 14 nomcom08 16 nomcom09 18 nomcom10 18 notifications 89 nscp 63 nsis 423 nsis-imp 49 ntdp 98 numbers 8 oam 80 oauth 620 off-path-bof 61 ogpx 131 omcast 49 ops-area 234 ops-chairs 29 ops-dir 46 ops-nm 194 opsawg 201 opsec 264 ospf 766 ospf-manet 119 ospf-wireless-design 13 oud 29 p2pi 361 p2pi-com 6 p2prg 849 p2psip 714 pana 243 paws 128 payload 75 pce 431 pcn 176 pcp 128 peppermint 119 pim 562 pkix 720 pkng 67 plasma 33 pmol 113 port-srv-reg 22 pppext 537 ppsp 316 precis 41 privacy 13 privacydir 20 proxies 229 psamp 163 pwe3 1107 qos_inband 51 radir 8 rai 257 rai-discuss 113 ranger 41 rddp 173 re-ecn 215 recipe 89 renum 86 rfc-editor-rfi 19 rfced-ietf 12 rip 26 rir-ietf 7 rmonmib 337 rmt 440 rohc 355 roll 612 routing-discussion 887 rps 294 rpsec 431 rrg 534 rserpool 148 rsvp-dir 10 rtg-bfd 436 rtg-dir 30 rtg-mibs 0 rtg-rdd 76 rtgwg 394 rucus 111 saad 95 saag 537 safe 57 salud 42 sam 206 sasl 190 savi 176 scap_interest 98 secdir 69 shara 101 shim6 221 sidr 307 sidr-migrate 6 sieve 163 sigtran 873 simple 779 sip 1816 sip-clf 90 sip-http-events 35 sip-ops 137 sip-overload 127 sipapis 8 sipcore 432 sipping 1494 siprec 104 sitescope-list 1 sixpac 100 smartpower-interest 309 smartpowerdir 20 smime 267 softwires 484 spam 12 spam-discussion 14 spb-isis 49 speechsc 278 speermint 375 spkm 31 splices 55 ssm 565 storm 108 swmp 36 syslog 189 systers 30 tae 107 tana 121 tap 49 tcp-auth-dt 13 tcpao-security 0 tcpm 452 testlist 2 tictoc 269 tlp-interest 62 tls 513 tmc 5 tmrg 220 tools-development 19 tools-discuss 109 tools-team 6 trustees 13 tsv-area 372 tsv-dir 33 tsvwg 755 uri-review 91 urn 80 urn-nid 79 v4tov6transition 233 v4v6interim 180 v6ops 1080 vcarddav 127 videomgmt 3 vmeet 69 vnrg 312 vpim 127 vpn-dir 9 vrrp 421 vwrap 162 w3c-policy 23 wax 24 websec 172 webtools 3 wellknown-uri-review 13 wgchairs 297 woes 76 xcon 324 xml-dir 14 xml2rfc 137 xml2rfc-dev 11 xmpp 203 xrblock 62 yaco-idsubmit-tool 8 yaco-liaison-tool 15 yaco-wgchair-tracker 14 yam 73 yang 90 yang-doctors 12