IETF
netmod
netmod@jabber.ietf.org
Monday, March 23, 2015< ^ >
benoit.claise has set the subject to: NETMOD WG Meeting, IETF 89
Room Configuration
Room Occupants

GMT+0
[13:25:06] dezsoke.anonim joins the room
[13:41:35] dezsoke.anonim joins the room
[13:42:40] dezsoke.anonim leaves the room
[13:52:35] Bert Wijnen joins the room
[13:55:05] Bert Wijnen leaves the room
[13:55:20] Jürgen Schönwälder joins the room
[13:56:09] Bert Wijnen joins the room
[13:56:39] Meetecho joins the room
[13:56:56] Radek Krejci joins the room
[13:58:03] Christian OFlaherty joins the room
[13:58:05] dezsoke.anonim leaves the room
[13:59:15] KY joins the room
[14:00:11] Nick DelRegno joins the room
[14:00:40] Lisa Huang joins the room
[14:00:49] Andres Lucas joins the room
[14:02:07] dezsoke.anonim joins the room
[14:02:43] <Bert Wijnen> What is the audio channel?
[14:02:52] Balazs Lengyel joins the room
[14:03:10] <Bert Wijnen> I see audio from gold in the agenda, but when cionnection, I see channels 1-6 or some such
[14:03:11] ladislav.lhotka@nic.cz joins the room
[14:03:35] Balazs Lengyel leaves the room
[14:03:45] Bert Wijnen_8727 joins the room
[14:03:47] <Lisa Huang> I could hear from Jabber
[14:04:30] Balazs Lengyel joins the room
[14:04:48] balint.uveges joins the room
[14:04:48] balint.uveges leaves the room
[14:05:33] Balazs Lengyel leaves the room
[14:05:37] Balazs Lengyel joins the room
[14:05:44] <Bert Wijnen> i now have neetecho working. with video and audio
[14:05:59] <Meetecho> Bert the m3u link may be wrong, try this: http://icecast-ietf.conf.meetecho.com:8000/gold.mp3
[14:06:02] <Meetecho> which works
[14:06:13] joel jaeggli joins the room
[14:06:38] <Bert Wijnen_8727> tx. i now use meetecho instead
[14:07:01] Balazs Lengyel leaves the room
[14:07:03] <Nick DelRegno> There was an extra "/" in the URL in the m3u file.
[14:07:03] Balazs Lengyel joins the room
[14:07:18] joel jaeggli has set the subject to: IETF 92 netmod
[14:07:24] <ladislav.lhotka@nic.cz> Juergen’s slide #3
[14:07:30] <ladislav.lhotka@nic.cz> slide 4
[14:07:59] <ladislav.lhotka@nic.cz> slide 5
[14:08:00] <Bert Wijnen_8727> Mic: sorry
[14:08:15] Nick DelRegno leaves the room
[14:08:31] <Bert Wijnen_8727> learning to use meetecho. first time that i am remote
[14:08:41] Nick Del Regno joins the room
[14:08:57] Shawn Morris joins the room
[14:09:02] balint.uveges joins the room
[14:09:07] <ladislav.lhotka@nic.cz> slide 6
[14:09:40] bartosz.balazinski joins the room
[14:10:15] Andres Lucas leaves the room
[14:11:52] <ladislav.lhotka@nic.cz> YANG 1.1 by Martin
[14:11:58] Don OConnor joins the room
[14:13:02] <ladislav.lhotka@nic.cz> Please open the list of issues on the web, I will refer to them.
[14:13:10] KY Hong joins the room
[14:13:26] <ladislav.lhotka@nic.cz> Issue Y34
[14:13:34] Rakesh Gandhi joins the room
[14:14:44] Balazs Lengyel leaves the room
[14:15:09] Balazs Lengyel joins the room
[14:15:51] <ladislav.lhotka@nic.cz> Issue Y45
[14:15:54] Andres Lucas joins the room
[14:17:17] Don OConnor leaves the room
[14:17:30] giovanni martinelli joins the room
[14:18:07] Senthil Sivakumar joins the room
[14:18:12] Rakesh Gandhi leaves the room
[14:19:54] mjethanandani joins the room
[14:20:35] Shawn Morris leaves the room
[14:20:55] Balazs Lengyel leaves the room
[14:21:28] <mjethanandani> Joining as Jabber scriber for netmod.
[14:22:12] Mikael Abrahamsson joins the room
[14:22:14] Balazs Lengyel joins the room
[14:23:06] Andres Lucas leaves the room
[14:23:19] t t joins the room
[14:25:34] Todd Tolbert joins the room
[14:27:08] benoit.claise joins the room
[14:27:40] Balazs Lengyel leaves the room
[14:28:09] Balazs L joins the room
[14:29:01] Andres Lucas joins the room
[14:29:27] Simon Dredge joins the room
[14:29:29] <mjethanandani> Still discussing YANG 1.1 issue. Martin presenting. Issue being discussed is conformance framework.
[14:29:40] Todd Tolbert leaves the room
[14:30:47] Andy Veitch joins the room
[14:30:50] a a joins the room
[14:32:58] <mjethanandani> Discussing open issue in YANG 1.1
[14:33:21] <mjethanandani> Madatory nodes in augment.
[14:34:25] Balazs L leaves the room
[14:34:53] balazs l joins the room
[14:35:59] Don OConnor joins the room
[14:37:26] <mjethanandani> Relaxing the rule on mandatory nodes can lead to mandtory nodes being defined that systems cannot support. This is one proposal. The second proposal is to surround the mandatory node with a presence statement.
[14:40:03] <mjethanandani> Andy Bierman favors wrapping it with a presence statement.
[14:42:38] Andres Lucas leaves the room
[14:43:07] <mjethanandani> The second solution does require creation of an additional container.
[14:44:04] t t leaves the room
[14:44:14] <mjethanandani> Asking for vote on first option.
[14:44:36] <mjethanandani> Now asking for vote on second option.
[14:44:49] <Radek Krejci> hummmmm
[14:45:04] a a leaves the room
[14:45:06] a a joins the room
[14:45:38] <mjethanandani> More votes for second option.
[14:45:44] mhartley.cisco joins the room
[14:46:02] <mjethanandani> Y36 being discussed. Associate a notification with a data node.
[14:47:03] Qin Wang joins the room
[14:47:50] <mjethanandani> Y36-01 suggests a path-stmt to be present as a sub-statement.
[14:48:40] <mjethanandani> Y36-02 allows "inline" notificaiton statement.
[14:50:05] andres lucas joins the room
[14:51:21] <balazs l> is this only for symentry, then I don't support it
[14:52:00] alessandro amirante joins the room
[14:52:52] <mjethanandani> Last open issue is Y5: non-unique leaf list.
[14:53:01] <mjethanandani> Sorry Y57
[14:53:23] <balazs l> SOlution 3 is really an updated version erging 1 and 2
[14:54:16] alessandro amirante leaves the room
[14:56:07] <balazs l> Yes  leaf-level access control is a bad idea, dont use it forbid it
[14:56:34] <balazs l> I tried to clarify the rules, no one came up with problems  lately
[14:57:23] <balazs l> I can live with the restriction
[14:57:47] <balazs l> yes
[14:59:12] <mjethanandani> Juergen is asking how many people have read it. Do folks want this feature?
[15:00:52] <balazs l> hummmmm
[15:01:18] <mjethanandani> 1 vote for yes, and 2 for no. Not a strong vote.
[15:01:33] <mjethanandani> Chairs not sure how to proceed.
[15:01:42] <ladislav.lhotka@nic.cz> 2 votes were for yes
[15:03:12] <Bert Wijnen_8727> tome it seems 2-2 vote. so no strong position to add. And I hear it CAN BE DONE with existing language so I would say do not adopt it
[15:04:23] Amy ZHAO joins the room
[15:04:36] <balazs l> Already today we have no way to handling leaf-list as a unit. I didnt want to change it. It could be done
[15:05:08] giovanni martinelli leaves the room
[15:06:10] <Bert Wijnen_8727> so for a big or not so simple change, I would thinbk you need more than 2 people in favor
[15:07:02] Don OConnor2 joins the room
[15:08:49] balazs l leaves the room
[15:09:26] Balazs Lengyel joins the room
[15:11:16] giovanni martinelli joins the room
[15:12:16] andres lucas leaves the room
[15:12:20] Andres Lucas joins the room
[15:13:13] Andres Lucas leaves the room
[15:14:07] Andres Lucas joins the room
[15:16:08] Amy ZHAO leaves the room
[15:17:20] Andres Lucas leaves the room
[15:17:25] Andres Lucas joins the room
[15:19:53] Andres Lucas leaves the room
[15:21:40] Andres Lucas joins the room
[15:22:07] Balazs Lengyel leaves the room
[15:22:36] joel jaeggli joins the room
[15:22:45] brian.bnsmith joins the room
[15:22:51] <mjethanandani> Andy is on slide 5 of his YANG Guidelines presentation.
[15:23:19] x x joins the room
[15:23:48] joel jaeggli leaves the room
[15:26:35] <mjethanandani> Now on slide 7
[15:28:45] <mjethanandani> Slide 8
[15:28:52] KY leaves the room
[15:29:35] Amy Zhao joins the room
[15:29:37] x x leaves the room
[15:30:16] f f joins the room
[15:32:55] <Bert Wijnen_8727> an example does not have to be a complete module. so it may not comp[ile clean, right?
[15:35:43] f f leaves the room
[15:35:59] b b joins the room
[15:37:18] <mjethanandani> Lada presenting JSON Encoding of YANG data. Slide 2.
[15:41:59] b b leaves the room
[15:42:15] b b joins the room
[15:42:42] mhartley.cisco joins the room
[15:43:06] mhartley.cisco leaves the room
[15:43:36] mhartley.cisco joins the room
[15:44:13] mhartley.cisco leaves the room
[15:45:55] Amy Zhao leaves the room
[15:49:48] Mikael Abrahamsson leaves the room
[15:51:49] Christian OFlaherty leaves the room
[15:54:45] b b leaves the room
[15:55:07] b b joins the room
[15:56:21] Simon Romano joins the room
[15:59:16] <Radek Krejci> hummmmm
[15:59:49] Qin Wang leaves the room
[16:00:09] <mjethanandani> Please indicate what you are humming for.
[16:00:43] <Radek Krejci> hum for option 2, keep the document only for 1.0
[16:01:39] <mjethanandani> Lada presenting Defining and Using Metadata with YANG. Slide 2
[16:02:44] b b leaves the room
[16:03:27] dezsoke.anonim leaves the room
[16:05:52] <mjethanandani> 4 yes and 1 no.
[16:09:27] Simon Dredge leaves the room
[16:10:12] <Bert Wijnen_8727> can someone post the webpage where we can find that?
[16:10:19] Andres Lucas leaves the room
[16:10:37] Rakesh Gandhi joins the room
[16:11:03] Andres Lucas joins the room
[16:11:29] Nick Del Regno leaves the room
[16:12:14] <Bert Wijnen_8727> rtfm?
[16:13:43] giovanni martinelli leaves the room
[16:14:17] <mjethanandani> Clyde presenting SYSLOG Data Model.
[16:15:24] <mjethanandani> Bert, I missed your comment. Could you expand on what webpage you are referring to?
[16:16:55] joel jaeggli leaves the room
[16:18:43] Andres Lucas leaves the room
[16:19:04] <Bert Wijnen_8727> nice
[16:19:18] Lucas Andres joins the room
[16:24:55] balint.uveges leaves the room: Disconnected: closed
[16:25:29] <mjethanandani> Jimmy presenting Inventory Data Model.
[16:30:26] Lucas Andres leaves the room
[16:32:35] bartosz.balazinski leaves the room
[16:32:40] Meetecho leaves the room
[16:34:00] mhartley.cisco leaves the room
[16:34:05] Andy Veitch leaves the room
[16:34:07] <Bert Wijnen_8727> thanks Juergen
[16:34:12] Jürgen Schönwälder leaves the room
[16:34:24] <mjethanandani> Meetiang ended.
[16:34:27] KY Hong leaves the room
[16:34:30] mjethanandani leaves the room
[16:34:31] ladislav.lhotka@nic.cz leaves the room
[16:34:38] Bert Wijnen_8727 leaves the room
[16:35:04] Rakesh Gandhi leaves the room
[16:35:06] Andy Veitch joins the room
[16:35:33] Don OConnor2 leaves the room
[16:39:03] Andy Veitch leaves the room
[16:39:59] a a leaves the room
[16:51:16] benoit.claise leaves the room
[16:51:17] benoit.claise joins the room
[16:51:17] benoit.claise leaves the room
[16:55:56] Andy Veitch joins the room
[16:56:15] joel jaeggli joins the room
[17:03:21] Andy Veitch leaves the room
[17:25:46] benoit.claise joins the room
[17:26:41] benoit.claise joins the room
[17:27:17] benoit.claise leaves the room
[17:38:08] Andy Veitch joins the room
[17:38:18] Andy Veitch leaves the room
[17:46:15] joel jaeggli leaves the room
[17:53:06] balint.uveges joins the room
[17:53:06] balint.uveges leaves the room
[17:56:36] joel jaeggli joins the room
[17:56:49] benoit.claise leaves the room
[18:01:46] benoit.claise joins the room
[18:02:42] Andy Veitch joins the room
[18:03:36] benoit.claise joins the room
[18:04:30] benoit.claise leaves the room
[18:38:59] benoit.claise leaves the room
[19:27:31] Andy Veitch leaves the room
[19:31:31] Andy Veitch joins the room
[19:40:18] Andy Veitch leaves the room
[19:40:50] Andy Veitch joins the room
[19:57:47] Andy Veitch leaves the room
[19:59:27] Andy Veitch joins the room
[20:02:06] Andy Veitch leaves the room
[20:05:30] joel jaeggli leaves the room
[20:08:53] Senthil Sivakumar leaves the room
[20:08:53] Don OConnor leaves the room
[20:08:53] Simon Romano leaves the room
[20:08:53] Radek Krejci leaves the room
[20:08:53] Lisa Huang leaves the room
[20:21:50] Bert Wijnen leaves the room
[20:21:50] Bert Wijnen joins the room
[20:29:56] Andy Veitch joins the room
[20:48:07] joel jaeggli joins the room
[20:48:59] joel jaeggli leaves the room
[20:49:02] joel jaeggli joins the room
[20:50:10] Andy Veitch leaves the room
[20:58:46] Andy Veitch joins the room
[21:26:06] Andy Veitch leaves the room
[21:36:41] Andy Veitch joins the room
[21:40:00] joel jaeggli leaves the room
[21:42:36] Andy Veitch leaves the room
[21:53:29] joel jaeggli joins the room
[21:54:21] joel jaeggli leaves the room
[21:54:22] joel jaeggli joins the room
[22:04:54] joel jaeggli leaves the room
[22:11:32] joel jaeggli joins the room
[22:30:43] Andy Veitch joins the room
[22:56:03] Andy Veitch leaves the room
[23:11:28] joel jaeggli joins the room
[23:11:29] joel jaeggli leaves the room
[23:28:52] Andy Veitch joins the room
Powered by ejabberd Powered by Erlang Valid XHTML 1.0 Transitional Valid CSS!